Notre Dame Covid update

Submitted by Malarkey on August 18th, 2020 at 12:44 PM

Quick refresher: prior to matriculation, Notre dame tested 11k students to ensure no positive cases would arrive to campus  They found 33 positives of the entire Population tested  

First day of classes was last week August 10

Their plan lasted exactly 1 day before their first case. Yesterday (  7 days from the start of testing), they had 89 new daily cases, with a daily positive rate of around 20%. For perspective, the state of Indiana has 800-900 daily cases per rolling 7 day average  

 

https://here.nd.edu/our-approach/dashboard/

(Website under heavy demand at the moment)

 

 

 

 

bklein09

August 18th, 2020 at 12:57 PM ^

I’m guessing that tweet may be removed since it’s making several false, and potentially harmful, claims. 

I hope MGoBlog starts taking the same approach. Start deleting false and misleading posts that potentially spread misinformation that could cause real damage.

Edit: I know my request is likely unrealistic, but a man can dream.

mGrowOld

August 18th, 2020 at 1:08 PM ^

The Covid "truthers" (or deniers depending on your way of looking at things) are so freaking exhausting.  They show up in every thread to spout absolute nonsense which anyone with a triple digit IQ knows is wrong but they do it loudly, consistently and secure in their knowledge that they alone know the truth.

I guess I never fully appreciated how many Americans are complete fucking morons until Covid.  

1989 UM GRAD

August 18th, 2020 at 1:13 PM ^

MGrowOld, I've been referring to them as "Covid-19 Optimists," in an effort to try to be charitable to them.

Never has there been a group of people who are so unwavering in their wrongness.

It's driven me to do some reading on why some people are so susceptible to believing conspiracy theories or to be lured in to believing the .01% opinion rather than the 99.9% opinion.  

Your comment about feeling like they know something that everyone else doesn't know is spot on!

Bluesince89

August 18th, 2020 at 1:22 PM ^

My extended family have always been pretty conservative Catholics.  Your typical anti-abortion/anti-gay prejudices with a little bit of first generation immigrant racial prejudices sprinkled in for good measure.  I am decidedly the exact opposite in every respect.  But I could at least be around them the three or four times a year I had to be for holidays or functions (through the help of Mr. Johnny Walker).  After realizing they are all Trump loving, anti-mask, anti-vax, COVID/deep state conspiracy theorists, I've completely cut them out.  We've had family die of COVID and they still do not take it seriously and believe it's all bullshit to hurt Trump and bilk insurance companies.  

TomTerrific

August 18th, 2020 at 2:58 PM ^

As a conservative catholic and long time reader, I felt compelled to actually create an account and provide a response...  

What I don't understand is that people on the left tout acceptance for all and tolerance yet they are the primary people on this board bashing others that have thoughts different from their own.  Just in the recent posts the terms morons and idiots are being used. 

You mention completely cutting your extended family out because they have views different from yourself.  Are you being inclusive?

I am anti-abortion.  Why is this bad?  I believe that all life should be protected. In addition to unborn babies, it includes people in nursing homes, criminals on death row, etc.  

I am not anti-gay, but I do believe that marriage should be between a man and a woman.  The majority of issues in today's society is a result of the breakdown in family and not having a mother and father present when raising children.  Is this evil?

I am pro 2nd Amendment, not because I think guns are the only thing that can protect me from the bad guys, but because gun laws are only impacting those of us that follow the law.  The bad guys don't care about the laws and good guys don't kill people with guns.

Does this all make me an idiot, moron, or someone without an IQ of 3 digits? Or, does i make me someone that cares about life, family, and caring for others?

mGrowOld

August 18th, 2020 at 3:38 PM ^

A few points for you to consider as I'm assuming I'm one of the parties you're addressing in your response:

1. I'm a 61 year old conservative, Republican who owns both a business and several guns so we're aligned on that issue.

2. I believe in God although I dont go to church as often as I probably should

3. I'm neither pro nor anti abortion.  I do believe women should have the ability to make that choice even though my preference would be adoption rather than abortion

4. And my post had nothing to do with any of the things you mentioned.  NOTHING.  It was referring to idiots, morons and people with less than triple digit IQs who refuse to believe in science or math or anything else that runs counter to their precious belief system that denies Covid for reasons unknown.  If somehow you put yourself into that group of idiots, morons and people with low IQ because you are gun-owning Catholic who is anti-abortion I dont know what to tell you because my post mentioned NONE of those things.

None.

TomTerrific

August 18th, 2020 at 5:12 PM ^

Fair point.  I failed to go back through the comments to tie where the moron and IQ comments were coming from although I do feel, judging by the hugely negative response i received to my post, that most people on this board feel this way about conservative pro-life catholics.

My only counterpoint to #3 abortion in your post and the hatemongers below is that women (and men) do have a choice and its way before abortion comes into play.  I am not saying people can't have sex but pregnancy is a risk you have to be willing to take if you choose to have sex. 

An unborn child has no choice and should not pay the ultimate penalty of poor choices being made from others.

I guess my point is that there is a choice, people just refuse to consider that the choice is much earlier in the process.   

 

Bluesince89

August 18th, 2020 at 3:43 PM ^

You mention completely cutting your extended family out because they have views different from yourself.  Are you being inclusive?

Ah yes, the "you're not tolerant of my intolerance" bullshit.  No, I guess I'm not being inclusive and I don't feel too bad about it.  I've frankly seen enough of their racism, bigotry, and homophobia over the years, and now I don't need to here about how COVID is fake and a giant conspiracy, or how Bill Gates is trying to track us with vaccines and how my cousin's kids won't be vaccinated.  This is the level of stupid they're on.  I'm not really interested in having my children around them as they drop casual n-bombs other.  They're not missing me and I'm not missing them.

I am anti-abortion.  Why is this bad?  I believe that all life should be protected. In addition to unborn babies, it includes people in nursing homes, criminals on death row, etc.  

Never said it was.  I disagree with your position.  I was merely describing one of their beliefs.  I did not ascribe anything to it.  Good on you for being consistent.  Many are not.  

I am not anti-gay, but I do believe that marriage should be between a man and a woman.  The majority of issues in today's society is a result of the breakdown in family and not having a mother and father present when raising children.  Is this evil?

You are by definition anti-gay as you want to deny them the same rights, liberties, and privileges the state affords to others.  I don't care if the Catholic Church doesn't want to allow gays to get married.  Government doesn't get to discriminate in the privileges it gives to people.  

I am pro 2nd Amendment, not because I think guns are the only thing that can protect me from the bad guys, but because gun laws are only impacting those of us that follow the law.  The bad guys don't care about the laws and good guys don't kill people with guns.

I'm a gun owner (though I just own a single handgun for going to the range).  I have no problem with stricter gun laws or bans on certain types of weapons or ammunition.  

Does this all make me an idiot, moron, or someone without an IQ of 3 digits?

To be determined. 

Does this answer everything? 

Gameboy

August 18th, 2020 at 3:52 PM ^

As a flaming liberal, let me address one thing. Liberals do not tout acceptance "for all". We tout acceptance for who they are, meaning they are born that way (i.e. sexual preferences and race) because that is something they cannot change. We do not tout acceptance for something they are choosing to do, like spreading bat-shit conspiracies.

We do not care if you are anti-abortion. If you get pregnant and do not want to get an abortion, that is fantastic. What we do not like is you telling others that they cannot have abortions. It is their body, and unlike a mask, pregnancy is an unbelievable commitment and should be a personal choice. We just believe that you guys are bunch of hypocrites because you will not do one thing that is guaranteed to reduce abortions - wide spread and easy access to contraception. If you won't do one thing that WILL reduce abortions, you are not anti-abortion, you just don't like women having sexual freedom. That is why we really don't like you,

Again, we don't care if you are anti-gay. What we don't understand is why gay people getting married bothers you. It is their life, why do you have to butt in? They are just human beings who deserve to live a happy life like rest of us. Why do you want to stop them from being happy? That is why we don't like you.

Every other civilized country has much less death from the "bad guys" having guns, because they don't allow guns to roam freely in the society. I have felt far more safe in gun free countries than US. We don't want to ban them, but implementing reasonable regulation that 75% of citizens in this country support is not much to ask.

Bluesince89

August 18th, 2020 at 4:18 PM ^

Now, now.  When the big bad oppressive government was using unidentified border agents to arrest protestors and throwing them into unmarked cars and not telling them where they were going to be taken, I'm really glad the Second Amendment people (as 45 likes to call them) were there to serve as a check on the oppressive government who were violating their citizens' rights.  

gruden

August 18th, 2020 at 4:21 PM ^

Tom,

In case you haven't noticed, this board is pretty left-leaning.  Whether someone agrees or not, your post was very rational, yet they are negging you anyway.  There's no place for considerate reasoning here.

The fact is, there are doctors and immunologists who have pointed out the problems with masks and the approach we're taking, but that doesn't stop people here from leveling ad hominem attacks without any consideration whatsoever.  They've bought into the official position and if you have a different view they will attack you forthright.  There's only room for one message and any dissent is not tolerated.  This board is a microcosm for what we observe in society at large right now.

But then, this is a sports board and there isn't much sports now, so people have to get worked up about something I suppose.

Gobluegoblue2

August 19th, 2020 at 10:25 AM ^

I believe Norway will be releasing the first randomized control (no mask) vs variable (mask always when out in public) trial later this week that should show us.  On the CDC website, there are mask trials that show that non medical masks are ineffective... for the flu — as they are a couple of years old.  Nobody knows about this bug.  However, it seems that the primary author may have let the car out of the bag because he publicly stated that he hopes Norway doesn’t have a mask mandate on Monday.  I don’t not know the materials methods or any biases that may have been incorporated into study design at this point.  
 

I see over 150 pts per week in office and hospital and wear a properly fit-tested N95 for all encounters except elective surgery whereby every surgical pt is tested and quarantined the week before - then I just wear a standard surgical mask.  I do this because for the first 6 weeks of Covid-19, we had to in order to prevent mandatory 2 week quarantines if we came into contact without one.  Now I am used to it.  I wear a surgical mask when I’m stores.  Absolutely no way I will wear a mask while in an outdoor open area or at the beach etc - that makes no sense

Scout96

August 18th, 2020 at 4:28 PM ^

Hi,

Answer this, if you are anti abortion, which is your right to have that opinion, shouldn’t that make you someone that promotes wearing a mask.  Shouldn’t you then be appalled by those who refuse to take this simple safety precaution?  That would be very pro life.  If you refuse to wear a mask, then simply don’t complain about being denied the right to shop at places that require it, find a place that either doesn’t require it or have someone shop for you.  This is not a political issue, there are folks in all parties that won’t wear a mask because they are not worried about their risk or the risk to those that associate with them.

tigerd

August 18th, 2020 at 5:00 PM ^

Thank you for being a voice of reason. It really is crazy on this forum that if people don’t have the same beliefs as you they instantly feel the need to neg you. It’s a sad state of affairs that we’ve reached a point in society on both sides that has almost zero tolerance for differing thoughts and opinions. I used to wonder how in the world this country could have ever got to a point of a civil war where neighbors killed neighbors. Unfortunately it is becoming increasingly clearer that it is entirely possible that it may happen again some day simply because people are not open to differences in ideology. While this board used to be a welcome relief from the real world, lately it been like flipping the channels between CNN and FOX news. 

Littlefurrybuddha

August 18th, 2020 at 6:58 PM ^

Though I strongly disagree with your pro-life stance for many reasons, I can respect it as it seems to be consistent.  If you are against same sex marriage, you ARE anti-gay.  You are denying people a right/privilege/social construct because of who they are sexually attracted to.  Heterosexual divorce rate is hovering at 50%, so in half of all marriages the family as you see it ceases to exist.  Don't really care if you own guns, do care if you are a gun nut wacko that advocates for private citizens to own everything up to and including a fully-armed A-10.

BroadneckBlue21

August 18th, 2020 at 8:27 PM ^

Yes? If this is the first time you were compelled to post, then definitely yes. Have you lurked here? You aren’t asking questions genuinely, because you won’t like the answers or see them as changing you.

Intolerance not being tolerated is not being a hypocrite, nor is it okay just to accept people’s views simply because they have a lower care for others with regard to a pandemic virus.

When 20 colleges and k-12s close down in-person due to outbreaks and the response is to rationalize why the 21st college should still try to open campus—that view is moronic because it’s ignoring the empirical evidence and the basic logic we know about respiratory diseases.

As for cutting off family—that has nothing to do with being inclusive either, for the same damn reasons. Why do I have to hear my uncle use slurs against gays, women, Latinos, or blacks just for the sake of him having his own voice? I don’t. When what he says is exclusionary and highly prejudicial, wtf should I keep him in my circle? If I tell him to stop using prejudicial language and he shouts about his freedom, I am excluding him from my life because he’s a fucking exclusionary asshole.

We are not bound to our family for life just because we share some genetic code. If one of us ignores equality and equity, it isn’t a debate about freedom of choice or personal opinion.

Not every opinion is equal in validity or soundness. 

Let me put it this way: Jesus died on the cross so Uncle Bo could be an asshole who hates Muslims, but also so I could despise Uncle Bo for being an asshole. On the scale of righteousness, who gives a crap?

runandshoot

August 18th, 2020 at 2:59 PM ^

Anti-intellectualism at it's finest!

"There is a cult of ignorance in the United States, and there always has been. The strain of anti-intellectualism has been a constant thread winding its way through our political and cultural life, nurtured by the false notion that democracy means that "my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge." - Isaac Asimov, 1980.

The dude had issues, but he was right about this.

BernardC

August 18th, 2020 at 6:31 PM ^

Here’s the thing. Covid is real, and it’s concernable (sorry truthers).

The sky isn’t falling (sorry chicken littles). 
 

As always, the truth lies somewhere in between. I’m an antimasker (as in my rights), but am realistic enough to admit that they can’t hurt, and probably help to some degree. Not as much as some are pushing, but still can’t hurt. 
 

Good day mates. 

Gobluegoblue2

August 19th, 2020 at 10:55 AM ^

The problem is that a person or persons with inherent biases gets to be the arbiter of “harm”.   

free speech is free speech.  Canceling in antithetical to a free country. One can always politely disagree and present counter data and let open minded individuals decide for themselves. 

1VaBlue1

August 18th, 2020 at 2:19 PM ^

This is true.  And so then we must also mention Mr Charles Darwin.  His little evolution thingy upset some Catholics, as well...  Maybe moreso than Galileo's exploits did!

Science often falls on the wrong side of religious fervor...

TIMMMAAY

August 18th, 2020 at 6:44 PM ^

We're actually pretty similar in a lot of our thinking. I would typically describe myself (politically) as you have, but lately I'm leaning more to the left overall. Just a lot of different things I've come to believe over the past decade. 

Health care should be a basic right, and "free" (paid by our taxes, single payer). 

Money out of politics. Period. 

I'm very pro-gun, but I want to see some sort of regulation on who can/can't buy them (especially handguns and assault rifles). 

Our education system is a damn disgrace, top to bottom. Grade school through university. Compare our university rates against almost anywhere in Europe, it's pretty shameful. 

There's more, but those are my big things. 

Shop Smart Sho…

August 18th, 2020 at 7:50 PM ^

Sure, Republicans are great for boardrooms. They're just terrible for the financial well-being of a nation. 

Seriously, how is it that my entire life has been dominated by supply side economics despite it having been proven over and over that it actively damages all the but the richest of us?

And have you really never seen the graph that goes back to Reagan showing that deficits massively increase under GOP control?

Bo Harbaugh

August 18th, 2020 at 4:06 PM ^

Tyler, saying 2+2 = 3 is not an opinion, it's just wrong.  This is the problem with everyone thinking they are an expert or that their magical thinking should be as valued as scientific evidence.

Indeed, science can reach incorrect solutions to problems, but this is why it is always open for further examination and study and will change with new information.  Your opinions, though, are just that...your random thoughts, usually based on some experience and thought influence.

Science, like anything human, will never be perfect, but it is the best process we have. 

Deductive reasoning > Inductive reasoning