If Jim Harbaugh can’t get Michigan to where it needs to be, who can?

Submitted by dmac24 on September 21st, 2019 at 10:19 PM

If Jim Harbaugh can’t get Michigan to where it needs to be, who can? The “Son” of Bo and a winner everywhere he has been; the quintessential Michigan Man, Harbaugh is underperforming five years in.  But if he can’t take us to the Promised Land, who out there legitimately can?  

 

Is there a deeper cultural problem that exists (Is Michigan too “Clean” to be able to keep up with the Alabama/Clemson/OSU’s of the world? Do we care too much about academics?)?

 

How do we escape BPONE?

 

Wolverine 73

September 21st, 2019 at 10:34 PM ^

Given that we couldn’t keep up with Wisconsin and barely could keep up with Army, I don’t think our concern should be with the suspected cheaters down south.  No one thinks Wisconsin and Army are paying guys under the table.

wetnoodle

September 21st, 2019 at 10:34 PM ^

Don't look for specifically a "Michigan Man"..sick of that

Throwing names out: Matt Campbell? Justin Fuente (hasnt done much at VT but who knows if change of scenery would work)?  Gundy?  Take a chance with Jedd Fisch since he knows the culture? Bob Stoops?

JamieH

September 21st, 2019 at 10:38 PM ^

C'mon.  Lloyd Carr was as clean as possible and he was able to compete just fine.  Did he dominate the way we would have liked over his last few seasons?  No, but even in 2006 we were one play away from going to the National Title game. 

I don't know what is wrong with Harbaugh's program, but cheating isn't the answer.

blueday

September 21st, 2019 at 10:38 PM ^

Creighton. Grab this guy before Sparty does. Jimmy is done. I think recruits that get it 

.. still pick Michigan. But the coach is not a selling point in year 5 while sinking the ship.

dcloren2121

September 21st, 2019 at 10:41 PM ^

Find someone whose teams are consistently well-organized and show the ability to adjust to their personnel and adjust to what the opponent does. 

Who consistently squeezes more out of less in terms of recruiting talent.

Start with someone like that and we're already better off. 

JBone4217

September 21st, 2019 at 10:41 PM ^

Kids playing a kids game. Everyone needs to back away from the ledge and stop giving so many fucks. If Michigan wins/losses affect your daily life perhaps it’s time to get a life. 

MichAtl85

September 21st, 2019 at 11:27 PM ^

This is not “kids playing a game”. These are semi professional athletes who receive compensation in the form of a scholarship education. If I want kids playing a game I attend my 7 year olds daughter”s soccer game. Those games are fun and  it’s great to see the kids having fun.

Michigan football is a product I spend money and time on. Like any other product I choose to consume there’s an expectation. The expectations haven’t been met. I won’t be spending money on this product until it improves.

ThorsHammer

September 22nd, 2019 at 6:13 AM ^

Michigan football is supposed to be entertainment. If it starts affecting your life in a negative way then you need to step back. These are kids playing a game. How this game end isn’t going to affect my taxes, my career, and my family. There are way bigger things happening in this country to get pissed about. 

brad

September 21st, 2019 at 10:43 PM ^

Jim Harbaugh of 2015 & 2016 could do it.  We don't have him anymore.  You get the impression that Harbaugh retired in the winter of 2017 and a collection of assistants is running everything.  The thing Michigan really needs to get at least close to where we want it to go is coherence.  They are totally incoherent.

L'Carpetron Do…

September 22nd, 2019 at 1:38 AM ^

For real. WTF happened? They used to be one of the most interesting teams to watch. Now they're insufferable. I've never seen a program go through such a drastic negative turn during  the prime years of a coach. It is bewildering.

The sad thing is that it doesn't look like a temporary thing - like they've had string of bad play or something. It looks like something in the program is broken - possibly irrevocably broken. And it looks all too familiar.

But God I hope I'm wrong. 

Anthony V

September 21st, 2019 at 10:52 PM ^

Jim and Don are too predictable with their script and very rarely make in game adjustments.  The offense when humming can still be stopped with ease when their limited formations and plays are all on film.  The defense when humming can be had (even by much lesser teams).  These guys can both coach, but I feel it’s their inability (or arrogance) to not adapt and make changes that make the team stagnant.  There isn’t a one man answer that can change it (i.e. Josh Gattis).  The whole concept of the glory days of BO needs to change.  You actually can have a different coaching mindset that adapts to current times and still embrace the past as the past.

Go Blue!

andrewgr

September 21st, 2019 at 10:55 PM ^

This questions is so mind-bogglingly misguided that I can't fathom how it seems to be a common meme on this site.

LSU hired Nick Saban away from MSU.  There wasn't a bidding war for his services.  Elite programs weren't tripping over themselves vying for his services.  He was just a solid coach they rolled the dice on.

Dabo Sweeney was an assistant who worked his way up.  There was never a time where other teams were thinking, "Wow, if we could only snap up Dabo from Clemson, we'd be set."  Until four years ago, when suddenly, he has his team playing at an elite level.

Jim Tressel was a I-AA coach.  He won 4 championships at that level.  After the 1st, and after the 2nd, and after the 3rd, any P5 team with a reasonable offer could have hired him.  Ohio State fans were underwhelmed when he was named head coach.

Lincoln Riley was a career assistant, with no head coaching experience.  Oklahoma fans were distraught that they didn't conduct a national search and hire a big name.  He's won his conference every year and made it to the playoffs twice.

"Who else would Michigan get?"  I don't know.  I don't need to know.  It's not my job to know.  I'm not getting paid a lot of money to be an athelectic director at one of the most desirable programs in the country.  What I do know is that there are, without any question, several coaches out there right now who are available to be hired that are going to wind up having great careers, and to suggest otherwise-- to claim that there are currently no home-run hires available anywhere, that ten years from now we'll look back and say, "Yeah, that was the worst dry spell in college football history, there was literally no coach that went on to become elite available anywhere", is just absurd.

andrewgr

September 22nd, 2019 at 12:07 AM ^

First of all, touting 10 wins like it means something is disingenuous.  10 wins hasn't meant much since 2006 when they moved to a 12 game regular season.  It's more meaningful to say that Harbaugh has UM at 3 loss seasons, and in fact has never had fewer than 3 losses.

I am not worried about finding a coach that can win 10 games a year, because it's not that impressive of an accomplishment.  A competent head coach that just recruits to Michigan's average level this century has 8 automatic wins a year.  Under even an average head coach, Michigan is 8-0 to start every season.  Michigan is always going to make a bowl and get that extra game, so the coach just needs to manage to go 2-3 in the 5 game schedule they play most years.

I think you could achieve that with like 10 out of the current head coaches in the Big10, no problem. 

Badkitty

September 22nd, 2019 at 4:36 AM ^

Just being afraid is no excuse for inaction.  You know things aren’t working.  There is something fundamentally wrong.  These past 3 games haven’t passed the eye test.  The fiery crazy obsessive coach we hired is gone. Nothing gets better if you’re not willing to change or take a chance.  

YoOoBoMoLloRoHo

September 21st, 2019 at 11:05 PM ^

It’s a deep, cultural issue to solve by key people like Warde.

The entitlement seems like it returned. JH infused a work ethic and competitiveness when he arrived with 4-hour practices and clear player rankings. Why is that fire gone? Why are guys almost assumed to depart (Ruiz, DPJ, Black, Collins, Hill last year) for the nfl with zilch in the productivity column? Why does the sideline look so sedate?

My 10-cent perspective: JH lost the competitive edge. He no longer goes ballistic on players and refs. He just exists on the sideline.

UMxWolverines

September 21st, 2019 at 11:05 PM ^

I think the Michigan Man culture needs to die. I really thought it needed to die after the Hoke disaster, but when it became more and more of a possibility of getting Harbaugh I figured he's the best we can get and he played here. But that ship has sailed, and I think someone outside needs to come in, and he needs full support. It's time to clean house, badly. 

uminks

September 22nd, 2019 at 3:10 AM ^

We tried that with RR and where did it get us, to the start of Michigan football decline. I thought Harbaugh was going to be the programs savior but it looks like the program is slipping back into a death spiral again and my thought is that Harbaugh will probably jump off this sinking ship. I'm very unhappy at the moment and hope we can find a future coach who will succeed. Of course, I'm still rooting for Harbaugh but he's got to kick this program back in gear. Or else we will finish below .500 and Harbaugh will always be on the hot seat for years to come. One sucky season will sink our recruiting.

WesternWolverine96

September 21st, 2019 at 11:07 PM ^

you escape BPONE by not feeling sorry for yourself and get off the couch

 

judge Harbaugh at the end of the year, I am open to a change if we don't finish strong

hell I think Harbaugh will want to fire himself if we don't play better..... my guess is he loves Michigan so much that he'd fire himself if he thought it would result in a championship

seasons not over, beat new jersey and then beat Iowa

they are better than this

 

BlueGoM

September 21st, 2019 at 11:08 PM ^

Back to what?  Winning 1 NC (split) in 40 years? 

We have the coach we all wanted.  I think we didn't realize how far we'd fallen and didn't realize how dominant Ohio had become.

Lastly I had a worry that we'd be in trouble this season.  how many starters on defense did we lose? lol like all of them?  Add in a change in OC, which IMO is a 50/50 chance of struggling first year while players learn the new O.