Cam

December 31st, 2022 at 8:50 PM ^

Arrogance is the best description for what happened today, and it's the single biggest problem plaguing Michigan's football program. For decades, there's been an institutional belief that Michigan doesn't have to adapt its personnel and gameplan to the other teams strengths. This is why we see things like handoffs to a back up TE, throws from a freshman TE on a trick play from the two, a backup linebacker taking goal line carries in a national semifinal, repeatedly running man schemes against a program designed to beat it, etc. The coaches have always believed they can just show up. It's why Michigan has been terrible in bowl games for 50 years. They have no respect for opponents, which prevents them from adequately preparing and adapting to the situation on the field.

Michigan lost today because of arrogance, and they will continue to do so under Harbaugh in big games.

Ham

December 31st, 2022 at 8:20 PM ^

Jim seriously needs to do something about his clock management issues. Losing 2.5 minutes like this at the end of a tight game is fatally stupid. Just imagine if Michigan had 3.5 minutes to work on the last drive instead of 1.

MRunner73

December 31st, 2022 at 8:20 PM ^

The first what should have ended in a TD had bad play calling near the End Zone. Defense really didn't make good adjustments in the 2nd half, they gave up 30 points. Credit TCU, but I had higher expectations to adjust and limit TCU more.

Harbaugh should have called a TO with 1:30 to go on TCU's first play.

TheJuiceman

December 31st, 2022 at 9:00 PM ^

That was the one thing he did right. Had he called timeout before their 1st down play, we would've got the ball back with less than a minute. Saved us probably 20 seconds.  They also may have been more likely to be aggressive on 3rd down in that case too to seal the win, because we would've been out of timeouts going into 3rd Down. 

Jordan2323

December 31st, 2022 at 8:20 PM ^

I give them an F. Bad decision on the goal like after the official screw job, bad decision prior to that on the first drive for an ignorant play call from the 2, Minter’s blitzing got burned all night, clock management down two scores even had Jack Harbaugh asking what the fuck, got gashed in the interior all night with no adjustments, etc etc etc 

zggolfer

December 31st, 2022 at 8:21 PM ^

Ah that greatest o line in the country shit has to produce or you know what?  Maybe not, TCU had lbs and dbs way more physical and willing to tackle then OSU.  Really good season overall.

WayOfTheRoad

December 31st, 2022 at 8:39 PM ^

This is something I try to explain to people but they think I'm crapping on them. I'm not. However, they aren't a "smash" OL. They're good at the immediate collection and movement but they don't move DLs in an elite fashion. This is ideal with a Corum running and it can lead to some long Edwards runs but a back like Edwards isn't going to get those consistent yards against any front 7 with a pulse because the OL actually isn't 'smash'. They're more technical than the old UM lines that just bashed a defense back 3 yards at the snap.

TCU? They just sent their second level forward with a running start and UM kept running into it. Also, the right side specifically had an awful game.

WayOfTheRoad

December 31st, 2022 at 8:22 PM ^

I'm not wildly angry or anything. However, the coaches absolutely shit the bed. Just outsmarting themselves in the way they made every other staff do this year. That BS inside the 2 both times was stunningly dumb.

The team didn't really appear to be ready or they bought their own hype about muscling them with ease. 

TCU clearly scouted UM. Both pick 6s were due to purely scouting JJ specifically and the limited routes UM runs.

UM had a month off and just did what they've always done. Nothing felt specially prepared or unique and they kept running into a team blitzing the gaps like a high school team would.

The team fought late and a lot are upset with the refs but it was so much more on the team than refs. Sure, some trash calls but this team beat themselves. They are better than TCU but absolutely weren't today. TCU is a very good squad so nothing taken away from them! UM just played probably their second worst game of the year today and did it in the playoff.

chatster

December 31st, 2022 at 8:26 PM ^

This has been said elsewhere. The story of this game was 14 points for TCU on two pick-sixes and 14 points lost by Michigan while failing to score likely touchdowns TWICE when the Wolverines had the ball with first and goal. Take 14 points from TCU, add 14 points to Michigan and Michigan wins 59-37.

When you have CO-offensive coordinators, you have NO offensive coordinator.

WayOfTheRoad

December 31st, 2022 at 8:43 PM ^

It's the belief (that I also hold) that calling a game has a feel to it. When you're only responsible for one part of the offense it creates a disjointed feel for the game. It's like subbing QBs or RBs.

Further, this has been a constant under Jim and a total lack of a consistent passing game has followed. Maybe connected and maybe not but I'm of the belief that you have one OC like you have one DC.

Phaedrus

December 31st, 2022 at 8:27 PM ^

Holy shit everyone here has lost their mind. The coaching was fine. We had bad luck throughout the entire game, we had 2 pick sixes, and we were still in position to go on a game winning drive.

We have one of the best coaching staffs in the country. When you get into the playoffs anything can happen. We have a coaching staff that can get us to the playoffs, which is better than what we've had since Lloyd Carr war our coach.

UnkleBuck

December 31st, 2022 at 8:27 PM ^

From top to bottom the coaching was nothing short of appalling.  With 4 weeks to prepare, the players deserved better.  Getting manhandled by TCU was almost laughable.  Georgia will stomp TCU, making U-M's loss look even worse.

brad

December 31st, 2022 at 8:28 PM ^

Also, where was the fucking jet motion that Vance fucking Bedford announced to the whole damn world earlier this week? It's kryptonite to TCU linebackers, and even I fucking knew.  They finally came around with 15 minutes left in the damn game.  Coaching malpractice.  And yet, we can't expect to ever have better coaching than this.

Ashgeauxbleaux

December 31st, 2022 at 8:28 PM ^

Terrible clock management,terrible play calls in first qtr at goal line.Left 14 pts on field.Never tried to big boy them with heavy package.They are making big money for that crap.

alum96

December 31st, 2022 at 8:29 PM ^

Imagine JJ running in the first half like he did in the 2nd

No worries - we were saving him for the title game

Imagine doing a battering ram 4x in a row 2 yards off the end zone like v Rutgers.  No, let's have a freshman TE throw shit. 

Imagine... oh nevermind it never changes,  At least we can beat OSU.

As everyone says it takes YEARS to learn how to win the playoffs.  Like TCU.

Optimism Attache

December 31st, 2022 at 8:30 PM ^

I think the too cute stuff on O is Weiss. Went away from what’s worked all year way too soon. Minter did not have a great game, but he’s been money all season, plus D just missed a lot of assignments/coverages. It didn’t seem like they schemed anything for Johnson—why?

UM_Ftown

December 31st, 2022 at 8:30 PM ^

Harbaugh gonna want out again just like last year I bet. 
 

The “we’re not going to change anything about our gameplan regardless of the opponent and run this 1970s offense” sure does get old when they run up against a team who’s equally athletic but runs a more modern offense to fit their players better. 

Imagine what kind of numbers JJ would have at say USC running and throwing the ball. 

bronxblue

December 31st, 2022 at 8:42 PM ^

Michigan put up 527 yards of total offense and McCarthy accounted for nearly 400 himself.  They were down Corum and it really hurt their overall flow but I'm tired of this "Michigan is running some archaic offense" bullshit.  It's not prehistoric but even if it was they are 25-3 running it over the past 2 years and averaged 38-ish points per game doing it. 

They got beat today and it sucks but TCU's "modern offense" scored 37 points.

J. Redux

December 31st, 2022 at 8:31 PM ^

Leaving this game feels so much worse than leaving Miami last year.

TCU reminded me of those awful Dantonio teams that would get insanely lucky and think it was skill. Dugan was awful. If they play this game 100 times, Michigan wins 95. It just sucks that today was one of the other 5. (Last year, if Michigan played Georgia 100 times, Michigan might have won 5. Or 1).

MgoBlueprint

December 31st, 2022 at 8:32 PM ^

The playcalling and clock management was atrocious. 3 drives inside the 5 and only 3 points. That was the difference.

Offense taking using like 3 minutes in plus territory on the second to last drive was a killer.

on the other hand they coached these boys up. The resolve was insane.

shawnducati

December 31st, 2022 at 8:34 PM ^

This is not on the players. 

1st half: horrible ply calls inside the 5. 

2nd half: horrible blitzing on D. We are not a blitzing team and we are doing what OSU did against us. Changed our identity. We are a base D that keeps everything in front of us. 

NOT ON THE PLAYERS. 

TheJuiceman

December 31st, 2022 at 8:46 PM ^

Kind of had to, seeing as how Morris was either still banged up or essentially invisible, while Mazi looked like he's been worrying about fucking court all month cough cough. The d kept us in it all first half while the offense thumb fucked their own asses for 30 minutes.  Then they broke. We looked out of shape in a bowl game yet again, why is that?? Fuck this shit 

bronxblue

December 31st, 2022 at 8:35 PM ^

Lots of bad playcalls but at the same time they weren't the ones who threw two pick-6s on bad reads or overturned a clear TD and then subsequently fumble the ball.  I don't blame players (I will blame the refs) because they're human but this was a holistic ball dropping by the UM program. 

I am interested to see how this staff looks next year when they aren't (outside of Moore) first-time lead coordinators.  This game felt like one where they might have out-smarted themselves a bit.