"Michigan is a spiritual team." Jim Harbaugh

Submitted by StephenRKass on November 29th, 2022 at 5:37 PM

I found it interesting that a number of the leaders on the team made a point to give credit to God, and to praise the spiritual atmosphere on the team. Here are several quotes, and links:

The coaches, they’re incredible. It's a happy locker room as you can imagine, but they're down there giving thanks to God. I told you this: It’s a spiritual team. And they're happy. They’re celebrating but they’re giving thanks. 

LINK:  Harbaugh postgame interview, Nov. 26

This isn't anything new. Harbaugh regularly used personal time to go on service trips to Peru. When the team went to Italy, including the Vatican in Rome, Harbaugh said:

"The role that (faith) plays in my life is in the priorities that I have," he said April 26, "faith, then family, then football."

LINK:  Jim Harbaugh, Catholic News Agency, Apr. 26, 2017

This came in the time he was able to personally present some Michigan shoes to Pope Francis.

Harbaugh humbly wanted to give all the credit to the team. He left the immediate field interviewer with JJ McCarthy to go fetch Donovan Edwards. When Edwards was asked about his performance, his first words were:

First and foremost, all praises to the Lord,” he said. “He blessed us to be able to come play in this game. All of us who played in the game, we came out healthy and we got the victory. So all praises to the Lord.”

LINK:  Donovan Edwards, Sports Spectrum, Nov. 28, 2022

Edwards had a lot more to say, with Detroit WXYZ-TV and in the postgame conference:

“The Lord has blessed us to be capable of a lot,” he said. “We trust in God, we trust in each other; we have love for the Lord and we have love for each other. … We give glory to the Lord at the end of the game. . . . The reason I was able to do what I did is because of the Lord. I pray all the time and I talk to God all the time. He told me this is going to be our game for us, that I was going to have a breakout game.”

JJ McCarthy, as many of you know, is very generous with NIL money. Among other things:

JJ For the Kids supports a number of children’s hospitals across the country. Originally started after an interaction with a young fan, McCarthy’s foundation was founded “as a way to make a difference in the lives of kids in my communities, in the Chicagoland area and in Ann Arbor.” The foundation has branched out to also support the ChadTough and Oxford Strong foundations.

LINK:  JJ McCarthy donates NIL Money to O-Line and to Charity

But more than that, JJ is an incredibly centered young man, who spends 40 minutes a day in meditation, and 10 minutes before every game.

Somewhere between leading Michigan's offense, being a college student, navigating a handful of NIL projects, and attending various events, the 19-year-old finds 40 minutes daily to close his eyes and meditate.

"I (meditate) every single day, twice a day," McCarthy said following Michigan's 59-0 win over UConn. "Before the game, it's about getting into that present moment and finding that flow. I wake up, and I'll meditate for 30 minutes. And as everyone sees out by the field goal post, I'll meditate for 10 more minutes before the game."

LINK:  JJ McCarthy's X-Factor is daily meditation

The star of the team, Blake Corum, is also spiritual. As a boy, working for his Dad's landscaping business, his father shared:

Blake always wanted to put some of his money that he earned in the church offering,” his father, James Corum, said in a telephone interview Monday. “Everything he does on and off the field, it just makes me proud to have him as my son.”

This continues with using NIL money to help the local Ypsi Community:

A day after hurting his left knee in a win over Illinois, he used funds from name, image and likeness deals to donate 300 turkeys, green beans, apple sauce, milk, a winter hat and hand sanitizer to families in Superior Township and Ypsilanti, Michigan.

Corum is humble, and not looking for credit, or just for good PR:

“The impressive part is, he’s not just out here as a volunteer doing the work, he’s writing the check,” said Bilal Saeed, who assists Corum on community service initiatives and NIL deals.

Corum, who also donated hundreds of turkeys last year, had to be convinced that publicly sharing what he does in the community served a greater good than worrying some people may think he’s trying to get credit for his charitable efforts.

LINK:  Michigan RB Blake Corum gives thanks during Ohio State week

Of course, as fans, we're going to focus on the X's and the O's out on the field. We will see the 2nd win in two years against OSU. But on the team, particularly with the leaders, their focus is on the strength they get from God, and in being humble, working together as a team.

There has been a lot of talk about the "culture" of the team. And about the culture elsewhere. I'll just say that in their interviews and comments, Jim Harbaugh, JJ McCarthy, Blake Corum, Donovan Edwards and many others are happy to spell out what that culture is.

Bo Harbaugh

November 29th, 2022 at 6:11 PM ^

Meyer and Tressell sold their souls to Satan.  
 

Not a godly man here, but I’d assume the benevolent spirit wouldn’t choose favorites amongst quality people.

satan on the other hand…can help

explains a lot about the osu success

/s

Regarding faith and or religion, I think the team should do what they feel best as a group and are hopefully respectful of all faiths and beliefs.  I’d rather we not become Like Dabo’s super church/ evangelical summer camp of a program

NittanyFan

November 29th, 2022 at 6:20 PM ^

Yeah ---- I am a (fairly strong) believer myself, but it is easy to quote the verse "God works all things together for the good of those who love Him" when things are going your way.

It is more challenging to say "we just lost 42-23, and the other team just ran for a bunch of yards over my teammates and I, my National Title dreams are now dead, and on top of all that my girlfriend dumped me a few days ago.  But God still loves me and good things are ahead."

But for those who can and do say that, I respect their faith.

rym

November 29th, 2022 at 5:58 PM ^

As an atheist who was a high school and college athlete, I found injections of Christianity (or even generic monotheism) into my sporting events to be tiresome and alienating. I’m sure that in any athletic program at a public school like UM, there is a significant minority of players and staff on the team who are non-Christian and who feel equally uncomfortable. Team bonding and solidarity should not be linked to religion. Michigan football is its own religion.

WeimyWoodson

November 29th, 2022 at 6:47 PM ^

I'm in a similar boat and like a few others mentioned, I just find it cringy, awkward, and strange to bring up. I wonder if these people think that God actually changed the outcome for them to win the game but doesn't feel like curing the kid with cancer. 

If one of my coworkers ever stood up after some praise from my boss and started thanking God for getting that praise, I'd find that super strange. Wouldn't you?

Phaedrus

November 29th, 2022 at 9:41 PM ^

I think it's important to respect secular institutions as secular. Part of respecting the secular nature of a secular institution is not having a prayer circle on the field after a game.

As much as I like Edwards as a player, I find his persistent evangelism strange and in poor taste. God doesn't need a shout out on TV.

The one quote I really liked was the one about Corum shying away from publicizing his charity. That's how you know he was doing it for the right reasons—and there's no reason to assume he was doing it for religious/spiritual purposes. Even if it were for religious/spiritual purposes, it's something I can respect.

If you want to express your religion publicly, do so by adhering to the morals of your religion. Public displays of religious rituals, praise, and prayer are frequently done by the most immoral scumbags. The proof is in the pudding, and you should not boast about your charity or piousness.

For Christians, I think Kant did an excellent job of breaking down the moral framework with his "categorical imperative." This was pretty much "the golden rule" expressed in many different ways. Here is my favorite:

Act in such a way that you treat humanity, whether in your own person or in the person of any other, never merely as a means to an end, but always at the same time as an end.

When you evangelize, you treat others as a mere means to your end. You dismiss their agency and rationality.

Wendyk5

November 30th, 2022 at 12:08 AM ^

I'm more comfortable with the players expressing their individual views than I am with Harbaugh's comments. That's because Harbaugh is the leader and face of the team and represents the university in those roles. He's not really acting, at that point, as an individual. If a player says something about god and faith, I have no problem with that. I can usually tell that player is a follower of Christianity. He's speaking for himself, and I'm cool with that. But when it seems like the program is embracing a particular religion, it feels exclusive. If Harbaugh says, "I'm a Catholic and this is how I worship on my days off," I have no problem with that, either. The issue for me is when the team seems to embrace a Christian theology as a whole. I'd feel the same if it embraced a Jewish theology or atheism.  

UMfan21

November 29th, 2022 at 6:17 PM ^

Thank you for saying this.  The number of posts that were implying a link between "spirituality" and "culture" here made me raise an eye brow.

 

We have a great culture and close team.  Many are open about their spirituality.  These two are not necessarily correlated.   I know plenty of bad Christians and plenty of good Atheists.

samsoccer7

November 29th, 2022 at 8:16 PM ^

I find it a bit odd as well. If a player is Muslim or Hindu or Jewish or something else, would they feel that comfortable saying it on TV and in front of other team members? Why isn’t there a multi-denominational prayer? Doesn’t sit well with me bc there’s no real equality in it.

BooKooBlue

November 29th, 2022 at 6:04 PM ^

Darrius Clemons posted a 6 minute instagram video of the locker room celebration after the game. Including the entire team saying the Lord's prayer. That was cool. 

JamieH

November 29th, 2022 at 6:09 PM ^

I mean, is it?  Look I have no problem with anyone practicing whatever religion they want.

Having the entire team obviously forced to embrace Christianity exclusively is, IMO, really really wrong and has absolutely no place at a public University.  If you want that kind of thing, go to Notre Dame or BYU.

I love Harbaugh as a coach but I disagree with him on this point.

EDIT:  I did not watch the clip.  Is it the whole team or some subset of the team?  Obviously if there is some subset of the team that wants to all pray together after the game, then go for it.  I'm all for that.

If this is some sort of forced team activity or even semi-forced (ie you are self-selecting yourself out of the group if you don't comply) then it is wrong.

JamieH

November 29th, 2022 at 6:15 PM ^

Well you said the entire team was saying the Lord's prayer.  As I said, I didn't watch the video.  But if the entire team is saying an exclusively Christian prayer, then yes, that is forcing everyone to embrace Christianity or single themselves out as being "not in the group"

If its some subset of kids on the team that all pray together after games, then go for it.  

Michigan is not a Christian institution.  No one should ever be made to feel on the "outside" of a sports team: because they won't say an exclusively Christian prayer.

JamieH

November 29th, 2022 at 6:27 PM ^

Depends on how it is presented, and I didn't watch the video.

But please remember, "optional" displays of religion are quite often not actually optional when the coaching staff holds your entire career in their hands.  

I just hope it is being done with care and is not singling out those that don't care to participate. 

Michael

November 29th, 2022 at 6:43 PM ^

Agree with this 100p. As someone on the atheism-agnosticism spectrum and growing up in the bible belt, I did not enjoy team prayer. I did not feel like I had any choice but to go along with it and while it was not explicitly "forced," I didn't feel like I could just opt out without any sort of consequence, real or imagined. I doubt I was the only one who felt that way, too, but I'd never know because everyone just did what the coaches want. 

UMfan21

November 29th, 2022 at 6:28 PM ^

"Force" can be implicit as with the recent court case of a high school coach who "forced" his players to say Christian prayers.   

At least in that instance "force" can be in the form of higher position on depth charts, inclusion in "cliques" and social events, etc.  By not participating, players are at best left out and at worst, playing time/career impacted.

 

Not saying it is happening at UofM, but generally that's what "forced" means in this context.  Nobody is saying they are holding a gun to the players head and making them recite it.

Michael

November 29th, 2022 at 6:49 PM ^

He may not intend do impose it, but that doesn't mean he isn't doing so in practice. I'd ask all the Christians here if they would be comfortable playing on a team who are overwhelmingly Muslim, and having "optional" prayers in that faith. Or pick any other religion, for that matter, no matter how widely practiced or seemingly absurd (Scientology, Zoroastrianism, Pastafarianism, whatever else.)

For many of us non-religious folk, there isn't really a discernible difference between many religions. 

BooKooBlue

November 29th, 2022 at 8:01 PM ^

I do understand. But what Im saying is Harbaugh is smart enough not to do that. He seems very informed on todays social issues. You apparently think it's a fact that Jim Harbaugh told the team not to leave until he makes them say a christian prayer. How do you know what the team policy on prayer is? You're assuming a lot.

UMfan21

November 29th, 2022 at 9:47 PM ^

Just going by what is posted here.  Harbaugh is a devout Catholic who took his team to the Vatican to meet the Pope.  He has a very Catholic view on abortion which he has been public about.   He has led the team in reciting the Lord's prayer.   

I do not see him taking the team to a Mosque or Sihk temple.   I do not see him quoting the Torah.  

Again, he may not be forcing/limiting what others do, but he clearly makes his beliefs known and his position of authority can (and I would argue likely) creates a perception of a "preferred" religion for the team to follow.

MJ14

November 29th, 2022 at 10:48 PM ^

Good thing players aren’t forced to come play for Coach Harbaugh then. He isn’t afraid to tell you who he is and what he believes. Which clearly this post shows. What’s really cool is that if a player doesn’t want to be involved in playing for a head coach like that, they can choose over 100 other schools. Again, it’s not like Jim hides this and then says on the first day of training camp that everyone must recite the Lord’s Prayer or you don’t play. It’s not like that at all. You will be surprised to learn a few guys don’t participate. No one on the team holds any ill will towards them and a couple of those guys are prominent players on the team. You guys are making stuff up that doesn’t happen. Creating scenarios that don’t exist. 

grumbler

November 29th, 2022 at 11:01 PM ^

So you are okay with Michigan losing excellent potential recruits who might feel uncomfortable coming to a school where the coach openly professes a specific religion the recruit doesn't share, and praises explicitly those players who do share the coach's particular religious beliefs?  

I'd rather win at football and leave the religion for individual observance.  Secular football teams are going to appeal to religious people more than religious football teams are going to appeal to secular people.

MJ14

November 29th, 2022 at 11:50 PM ^

I have bad news for you if you think a coach openly professing a religion is a hindrance to recruiting. Because Nick Saban is a devout Catholic. And there are often times that Alabama prays as a team. 

Lincoln Riley goes to a southern baptist church in California. Obviously everyone knows about Dabo Swinney. Brian Kelly? Devout Catholic. Luke Fickell, devout Catholic. Sonny Dukes, probably obviously, is a Christian. Jimbo Fisher has a chaplain on staff and pushes Christianity just as much as Dabo. Auburn just hired Hugh Freeze, who was coaching at a Christian university, and is a Christian. Kirby Smart? You guessed it a Christian and opened his first press conference talking about it and his wife raising their kids in a Christian home. Marcus Freeman? Catholic. 

Anyways I could go on and on but I was just trying to think of coaches in the top 15, 3/4 of these coaches have a chaplain and a lot of them have team prayer. I’m not saying it’s right or wrong or saying all of them even follow the same religion. I’ve venture to say 40% are Catholic, 30% are what would be considered evangelical and then a lower percent are a mix of Baptist/Methodist/non-denominational. Point being though that it’s actually harder to find a coach in the top 15 that doesn’t have something similar or even more extreme than what Michigan has. And as far as I can tell from staff members, Michigan is very respectful to guys who aren’t Christian. Some coaches(Dabo/Jimbo/Freeze) try to convert all their players. I don’t think that’s what you’re seeing out of Harbaugh here. And again, staff members say they are very respectful of others. Michigan has a Jewish player, a handful of Muslim players  and a few other religions or non-religious guys. 

Wendyk5

November 29th, 2022 at 10:35 PM ^

I'm the proud Jewish parent of a 6'2" pitcher. Though my husband is not Jewish, my son considers himself Jewish because of me. Even more striking is that his team (he graduated from college last year) had 13 Jewish players and they were a good team! One or two were around 6'4". No team prayer but they did try to have a seder in the dorm. 

StephenRKass

November 29th, 2022 at 9:33 PM ^

Thanks very much for sharing this. Fascinating and good read. It reminded me of another non-Christian on the team, Mormon OT Andrew Gentry. Harbaugh met him while he was serving on his 2 year mission, in the process of him choosing Michigan instead of Virginia.

Regarding Gelb, I think it is great that he can be there during a prayer, but respectfully abstain, since these are not his beliefs.

Ernis

November 29th, 2022 at 7:39 PM ^

That’s definitely a concern I share, but I see the fact that no one seems to have a problem with JJ meditating, which is, based on his descriptions of using it to center himself/find flow/clear his mind, rooted not in the Christian tradition of meditation strictly as contemplation of Biblical scripture, so is thus rooted in non-Christian traditions and therefore Satanic according to Western Christian cosmology… I think that shows a fair degree of tolerance. Or naïveté.