[David Wilcomes]

Michigan 31, Maryland 24 Comment Count

Alex.Drain November 18th, 2023 at 5:55 PM

On the day that Michigan Football got the 1,000th win in program history, the team won a contest that has to rank near the top of the list of most unsettling wins of the thousand. Michigan got out to an early 23-3 lead but uncharacteristic performances from both the offense and defense allowed the Terps back into the game. Timely plays from the Michigan defense to stifle the Maryland offense late closed the game out and secured a 31-24 victory, but no one can leave this viewing experience terribly reassured. As usual, the game before The Game was choppy. 

Michigan got the football first and went three-and-out, foreshadowing some of the struggles on offense that would pop up later in the game. They ran the football twice but JJ McCarthy threw behind the line to gain on 3rd & 5, Cornelius Johnson going out a yard short and forcing Michigan to punt. Maryland's first possession was a dink-and-dunk endeavor that marched them down into Michigan territory, but fizzled out once inside the red zone. Pressure got home to QB Taulia Tagovailoa on 3rd down, forcing a scramble out of bounds. Mike Locksley put his FG unit on the field and Maryland took a 3-0 lead. 

Michigan's second turn with the football was a display of the rushing dominance that has defined the program over the past few years. But before that, Michigan got it going with a strike down the seam to Roman Wilson that saw the receiver hit in the head at the end of the play. Targeting was initially called but repealed upon review. Wilson exited the game and did not return (he was seen in street clothes on the sideline). Without their top receiver, Michigan kept it on the ground and paved Maryland right into Baltimore. Donovan Edwards and Blake Corum each got to feast but it was Corum who punched it in from two yards out. After the Wilson injury, Michigan ran it seven times for 42 yards to finish the drive and get their first TD. 7-3. 

[David Wilcomes]

Maryland's next two drives were calamities that ultimately cost them the game. On a 3rd & 10 on the first drive, Tagovailoa was pressured by two Michigan defenders, hit by Michael Barrett who popped the ball free, which Derrick Moore scooped up and ran into the end zone for a touchdown. 14-3 Michigan. Maryland got the ball right back, gave up a sack to Jaylen Harrell (who was unblocked off the edge), and punted. That punt was blocked by Michigan's Christian Boivin, the ball winding up in the end zone and kicked out the back of the end zone by the punter Brenden Segovia for a safety. Michgian's lead had thus increased from four points to thirteen points without the Wolverine offense running a play. 

Maryland kicked the ball to Michigan as a result of the safety and the Wolverines drove down for another TD on a drive that at the time seemed to put the game firmly out of reach (even though it was still the first half). Michigan continued paving the Terps straight into Maryland territory, but ran into trouble when JJ McCarthy incorrectly pulled on a zone read and set the team up in a 3rd & 10. Michigan pitched the ball to Edwards for only two yards and were faced with a 4th & 8 at the Maryland 26. They decided to go for it and got bailed out when Maryland corner Tarheeb Still held AJ Barner for an obvious flag. The drive kept going, Michigan converted a 3rd & long to Colston Loveland and once inside the 5 it was Corum who finished it off again. 23-3.

[After THE JUMP: Where it gets annoying]

With 7:59 left in the first half, you would not have been crazy to think the game was already over with Michigan up 20 points. Everything seemed to be going well for the Maize & Blue, but then Maryland's offense began to get going. They responded to the large deficit by embarking on a 14 play, 75 yard drive to score their first touchdown, mostly through the air. Working at a moderately brisk pace, the Terps trusted the arm of their QB Tagovailoa and continued to mostly throw short passes on their way down the field, splicing runs in here-and-there. Michigan struggled in coverage underneath and Maryland was content to make them pay. A pass to TE Corey Dyches got Maryland down to the two and though it would take four plays to find paydirt, a Billy Edwards Jr. QB sneak chipped the lead down to 23-10. 

[David Wilcomes]

Michigan's next drive started with 1:59 left in the second quarter and the Wolverines looked for points before halftime to extend the lead. JJ McCarthy started the drive strong, hitting a quick out to Cornelius Johnson and a deep strike to Tyler Morris to get Michigan into Terrapin territory. Blake Corum survived a fumble (Trevor Keegan recovered) to pickup a 3rd & short but with time ticking down, McCarthy's passing was going to be needed to finish the drive. That's when things went haywire. McCarthy's 1st & Goal pass into the end zone was a dangerous, across-his-body throw that should've been intercepted but wasn't. His next pass was, misjudging the coverage on Colston Loveland pre-snap. McCarthy made up his mind he was throwing to Loveland and the ball was easily intercepted by LB Jaishawn Barham. Maryland got the huge stop they needed and went to halftime down 13. 

Michigan had been the better team in the first half but you got the sense that the second half would change quickly if Maryland could score on the opening possession of the third quarter. Indeed they did. Tagovailoa uncorked a beautiful ball to Kaiden Prather, who snagged an acrobatic catch over Josh Wallace for 34 yards and they'd net another 15 yards on a roughing the passer by Mason Graham only a few plays later. Like the hit on Wilson, there was a targeting review, but the booth officials opted not to enforce it. Regardless, the roughing call stood and Maryland was now inside Michigan's 20. Tagovailoa connected with Tai Felton on a 13 yard slant and now the Terps were down to Michigan's eight. Three rushing plays got Maryland another Edwards sneak TD. 23-17.  

With the game momentum shifting and an air of competitiveness swirling, the Michigan offense needed a response drive. They wouldn't get it. In a tribute to last week's playcalling, Michigan ran Blake Corum three times and punted on 4th & 1. Three-and-out. Maryland was poised to drive to take the lead and seemed prepared to do so, picking up yardage out past their 40 when another backbreaking turnover killed their offense, an interception by Mike Sainristil on a ball Tagovailoa intended for Prather. Sainristil thought he was not down and ran in for a pick-six, but upon further review he was down. 

 

[David Wilcomes]

Still, the interception set Michigan up with good field position and they decided to seize it. It was not the cleanest drive, some more clunky throws and not the same level of offensive line dominance as earlier, but it got the job done. After requiring another 4th down conversion, this one a pass to Colston Loveland, Michigan found the end zone via a Semaj Morgan run. Michigan went for two, calling a goal line fade for AJ Barner that was unsuccessful. The score sat at 29-17 but the two score lead was restored with 4:04 to go in the third quarter.

To the Terps' credit, they didn't go away and Tagovailoa had one of his best drives all season. As I outlined in FFFF, there are a few moments each week where Taulia looks like he could play on Sundays like his brother Tua, and most of those moments in this game came on this drive. The drive got going when Maryland picked up a 3rd & 10 on a screen (neat RPS+) and then Taulia started dropping dimes. On throws to Jeshaun Jones (wheel route vs. Sainristil) and Prather (deep vs. Will Johnson), the receivers had a step on the defenders, but only one step and the windows were not massive. In both cases, Taulia uncorked beauties, balls dropped into the perfect spots and suddenly Michigan's pass defense was being ripped apart. The Prather throw got Maryland to the one and Billy Edwards Jr.'s third QB sneak TD of the game finished things off. 29-24. 

Michigan's offense was slumping in this portion of the game. Their TD drives required 4th down conversions to complete and other drives were fizzling quickly. The next Michigan drive was one of those that fizzled quickly, one first down and then a punt (on a 4th & 2 from the Michigan 44). To add insult to injury, LT Myles Hinton (LaDarius Henderson missed the game with injury) went down with an ailment and had to be lifted from the game, Karsen Barnhart sliding out to left tackle and Trente Jones taking over at RT. With the punt, Maryland now had the ball with a chance to take the lead, a game that once seemed secure drifting into danger territory. 

 

[David Wilcomes]

Maryland picked up one first down thanks to a stellar run by Antwain Littleton II after initially being stuffed, but the drive hit a wall after a false start put the Terps behind the sicks and the combo of Mason Graham and Braiden McGregor sacked Tagovailoa on 3rd down. Michigan's next drive started at midfield with 8:37 to go, one touchdown likely putting the game out of reach. On the first play of that drive McCarthy had Cornelius Johnson running wide open deep for a possible TD that would've sealed it, but McCarthy's throw was behind Johnson, who couldn't haul it in. In response to the incomplete pass, Sherrone Moore turtled against the turtles, running the ball twice and punting on 4th & 3 from the plus-43. Tommy Doman pinned Maryland at the 10 and the Terps were hanging around. 

With Michigan's offense struggling, the defense rose to the occasion in this moment. Kenneth Grant stuffed a Roman Hemby run, sacked Tagovailoa on 2nd down, and then on 3rd & 18 from their own 2, Maryland jacked up a fade that Mike Sainristil intercepted. The ball was severely underthrown (may have been disrupted by the wind) and Sainristil tracked it well for the takeaway. Michigan was set up on the Maryland 39 but again couldn't get the points they needed to put the game away. A hold on Trente Jones backed the Wolverines up and strangely, it was in this moment that Sherrone Moore decided to get aggressive, letting JJ McCarthy throw amid collapsing pass protection, nearly being intercepted on 3rd & 19 after Karsen Barnhart was toasted. Michigan escaped that play and Doman's punt was downed at the 1 yard line. As it turned out, that punt had a sizable impact on the game. 

Maryland rushed once to give themselves some breathing room, but Tagovailoa was still standing in his own end zone when he fired a pass in the direction of a receiver. Unfortunately, the ball fell 10 yards short of the receiver and the referees felt it was not close enough to be "intended" for that receiver, which, when mixed with Tagovailoa in the tackle box, was an intentional grounding. Intentional grounding is a safety and Michigan now got two points tacked on. 31-24 and Michigan got the ball too. 

 

[David Wilcomes]

That grounding turned out to be the final time Maryland touched the ball. Their free kick was with just 3:36 on the clock and Maryland only had two timeouts. One first down would seal the game, which Michigan got thanks to four runs from Blake Corum. His final was on a 4th & 1.5 from just inside the Maryland 40, but Corum churned out the necessary yardage to convert the first down. The team kneeled it down and Michigan had their 1,000th win, 31-24. 

There are a few ways to view this game. On one hand, Michigan survived their game the week before The Game, which is habitually choppy. Last year it required a field goal on the final play of the game to win and both the 2016 and 2018 meetings with Indiana could be described as "uneasy". They survived it while outgaining the opponent (a bowl eligible opponent) in both total yardage and YPP. The team is 11-0 and you can never dismiss that achievement. 

On the other hand, Michigan's pass defense, so crucial for success in next week's meeting with Ohio State, looked subpar for a healthy stretch of this contest, which happened to be the first time all season Michigan faced a fully functional passing game. Taulia Tagovailoa was 21/31 for 247 yards (8.0 Y/A), stats that no doubt will frustrate Jesse Minter. They did bottle up the run, got some pressure, and forced three turnovers (the defense scored a winning nine points), but it was an uncomfortably wobbly showing, allowing long TD drives on 3 of 4 possessions.

[David Wilcomes]

Additionally, Michigan's offense did not look exceptional for the second week in a row. They punted five times and threw one interception against just three TD drives, needing those defensive points to win the game. In the second half, with a chance to dole out the final dagger multiple times, the team punted every possession before the kneel downs. Sherrone Moore's decision making was topsy-turvy, extremely aggressive early on, attempting multiple 4th downs instead of kicking field goals, but then cooled to extremely conservative late. The team again showed a firm commitment to the run and never got the passing attack in true rhythm. Moore is undefeated as an interim coach, but it is valid to have questions about the team's performance without Jim Harbaugh on the sideline during the game. 

Of course, a good chunk of this game can simply be chalked up to JJ McCarthy playing a poor game. He was 12/23 for 141 yards (6.1 Y/A), 0 TD to 1 INT, but he made more than just the one interceptable throw. He missed a handful of balls as well, with the deep miss to Cornelius Johnson standing out as the most painful. Combined with the zone read mistake, McCarthy was simply off-kilter, his worst showing since Bowling Green. Michigan will need their QB with NFL talent to perform like an NFL player to defeat Ohio State next week. 

Michigan is now 11-0 for the second consecutive season and The Game against Ohio State will feature two 11-0 teams for the second year in a row as well. They have not lost at home since 2020 and have not lost a B1G regular season game in over two calendar years. Both of those streaks are on the line against the Buckeyes, with a berth in the College Football Playoff also (essentially) on the line. That game is slated to be broadcast on Fox and as always (well, sans 2006) it will be at noon. 

Comments

GoBlueZ06

November 19th, 2023 at 12:00 AM ^

Get that insufferable moping pearl-clutching nonsense out of your system now and spare the rest of us. I particularly love the concern where Michigan isn't allowed to have fluctuations in performance without it being a harbinger of doom while every other elite program does... the EXACT same thing over the course of a season.

Could not care less about how the win was achieved, 11-0, 1000 wins overall, and now on to the The Game.

Beat Ohio.

lou apo

November 18th, 2023 at 6:15 PM ^

yeah for 1000!  However,

I say this a lot.  Don't go for 2 unless you are in the last half of the 4th qtr and the math says you must have it.  You just don't know what is going to happen and losing that sure point can bite you in the ass.  When we were up 29/24, we should have been up 30/24 where a field goal would have put the game away.  And then, a who could have predicted second safety only put us up by a touchdown instead of 8.  I was so paranoid Maryland was going to tie the game with a simple TD/PAT instead of needing a TD/2pt.  Take the easy points until the game is down to so little time that you just can't get combos of scores that make that 1 point forfeiture look like a really bad idea.

Hail to the Vi…

November 18th, 2023 at 6:15 PM ^

Win and advance, baby. Any road win in the league is a good win. It is a little concerning to evaluate the offensive play calling - especially in the second half - and how JJ has played without Jim on the sideline. It's plausible having Jim ruled out within 48 hours of kick off each of the past two weeks could be very disruptive short notice. Hard to know if that's grasping at straws or reality until next week when they've had a full week to prepare for his absence.

One thing is for sure, this team outta be pissed off even more than usual running out of the tunnel for next week's match up. It seems like almost insider common knowledge that Ohio State is responsible for breaking the news and fanning the flames of this PR circus that the UM players have had to play through the past month of the season. I know I would be out for blood against the culprit, and I have to imagine they will be.

OSU looks more beatable than they have in the past decade or so, but they also look a lot better than they did a month ago.

I anticipate a battle for the ages next week. Show no mercy next week BEAT OHIO!

BlueHills

November 18th, 2023 at 6:18 PM ^

Under bizarre circumstances without a head coach on the sidelines, and despite a ton of outside pressure and controversy that would have derailed many (if not most) of us, these young guys kept their heads and gutted out a tough win.

I give them credit. Credit also to Maryland who played well.

Go Blue! Beat Ohio State!

DennisFranklinDaMan

November 18th, 2023 at 6:20 PM ^

Man, if ever a game would disspell the nonsensical notion that referees (and the Big Ten) hate Michigan, this would seem to be it. Both the Intentional Grounding call and the fortuitous spot at the end may have been correct calls, but both easily could have gone the other way without anyone seriously complaining. 

I'm not saying the refs gave us the game, by any means — if you can tell me why that wasn't targeting on the Roman Wilson hit, I'd love to hear it — but they sure didn't hurt us, despite multiple opportunities to do so.

It won't end the conspiracy theorists' whining, of course, because nothing can. But man, I was so happy to get those calls. 

Whew!

bronxblue

November 18th, 2023 at 6:30 PM ^

The intentional grounding was blindingly obvious that they have to call that.  The spot is whatever because that's always a coin flip but we saw ID last week when Allar threw to nobody in that zip code and that was the same here.  I think refs are getting wiser to not wanting to bail out QBs who are under pressure.

Ghost of Fritz…

November 19th, 2023 at 8:43 AM ^

It actually is the correct call, and it is not really debatable. 

But...the fact is that some ref crews would keep the flag in the pocket because they don't want to 'decide the game.'   Some refs would not make that call and 'let the players decide the game on the field.'

Credit to the refs for making that call the same as they would have if it had been a meaningless moment in a total blowout.  

I also credit the refs for NOT calling targeting on the Maryland play and not calling on Mason Graham.  On both, helmet contacted helmet.  But no calls were the right way.

snarling wolverine

November 18th, 2023 at 6:32 PM ^

I agree that the officiating on the whole wasn't a big factor.  But the intentional grounding was obvious, and the spot was accurate - replay showed Corum got to the sticks.  There was nothing "fortuitous" about it, it was just correct. 

Otoh, they missed a safety earlier in the fourth quarter when Tua was definitely down in the endzone. 

Go Blue Beat T…

November 18th, 2023 at 11:16 PM ^

It’s not super obvious. I watched OSU convert a third down on a short hitch. The receiver is coming back to the ball and his momentum takes him backwards. The refs spot the ball where it is caught. My understanding is if the receiver is moving backwards then you don’t get forward progress. It was like a three yard difference. 

lou apo

November 19th, 2023 at 10:05 AM ^

I have noticed that if forward progress is briefly stopped by defenders and the runner is "flung" backwards, but then escapes the grasp of the defender, the forward progress is "undone" and the player will now be spotted at his next point of forward progress.  QB scrambles being the most common example.  The QB might roll out, be confronted with a couple defenders who slam into the QB who then spins out of their grasp going backwards and then might under their own power loop back even further.  Sometimes this results in a devastatingly huge sack and sometimes it results in a huge gain when the QB either loops around to the other side for a big run gain or finds a receiver for a big pass gain (and many times it results in a throw away).  This has made me consider whether there should be some defensive technique that attempts to do this on purpose (but not on the QB since the pass threat and throw away threat are so high).  Of course the great risk would be that the player gets away for a big gain. 

MaizeAndBlueWahoo

November 18th, 2023 at 6:59 PM ^

I'd be seriously complaining if they hadn't called that intentional grounding.  It was clear to anyone and everyone that Tagovailoa had no intention of completing that pass.  If there's debate about whether the receiver was "in the area" or not, then he was not, because Maryland clearly could not have argued the ball had any chance to be complete.  Their only case was that the ball traveled toward a receiver, in the sense that I travel toward Chicago on my daily commute - with no intention of ending up anywhere near it.  It's obvious they intentionally grounded the ball; the only argument they had was they were trying to do so legally.

KBLOW

November 18th, 2023 at 7:32 PM ^

Dude, those calls weren't close to being coin flips. And were obviously correct. That spot on Courm's run was marked short by at least a half-yard, 

And if I were a tin foil hat-wearing man (which I am this week) I'd argue that the ZERO holding calls on Maryland, completely ignoring several DPIs, that CJ most definitely reached for that 1st down on our 1st possession, and giving Maryland their 4th and goal TD that looked stopped, sure looked like the refs tilting the field. 

 

 

 

ole luther

November 18th, 2023 at 6:22 PM ^

I look forward to the team playing in their own house.

They've had to win without their main mentor on someone else's fields.

Next week, at home, hopefully helps all the players get sky high and focused.

Go Blue!

bronxblue

November 18th, 2023 at 6:28 PM ^

It's a game they had to win and they did.

I'd also add that being the HC and the OC has to be incredibly hard, and if there's one place where you'll definitely see that cost it'll be when the offense gets bogged down.  I'm sure Minter steps in more when UM's defense is on the field but usually Moore is able to just focus on the offense during those lapses while now he has to divide his attention and we saw how that played out.  I think if UM loses next week it'll be because of this lack of focus.

At the same time, this was a road game after yet another tumultuous week, and I honestly am not going to read as much into the passing issues.  Taulia has those throws in him and when he can make them he looks great.  But I also have a strong sense this wasn't a team UM focused too much on scheme wise and when they needed pressure they got it.  

Last year coming out of Illinois people worried if UM's rush defense had maybe been exposed a bit and there were concerns about McCarthy at QB.  Thy responded fine the next game against OSU and I'm sure they'll do the same again.  They may well lose next week; at some point the cumulative body blows of this year on and off the field wear you down.  But they're still perfect this year and I'm not quite ready to bury them because they've struggled a bit.

Clarence Beeks

November 18th, 2023 at 6:30 PM ^

the team won a contest that has to rank near the top of the list of most unsettling wins of the thousand. 

I can’t get there. Yes it was much closer than I would have liked, but so much of the flow of this game was about one thing: field direction. Maryland did everything and anything they did during the second and third quarters, when they had the wind. Without the wind, squat. If you don’t think that matters, just reference back to Klatt’s comment after the 4th quarter INT (the ball hit a wall of wind). This game felt like it had a big swing in the second and third, but from my seat it felt very much like as soon as the third quarter ended the only things Maryland had working wouldn’t anymore. And they didn’t. Beyond all that, a few other things. Somehow, also, Maryland is the Big Ten team that has scored the most points against Michigan each of the last two years. So there’s that. Trap game, yep. Outside controversy and distractions? That too. And Maryland very well could have beaten Ohio State. This was a game that beyond about a 5-10 stretch (real time, not game time) never really felt THAT close. I’ll gladly take a dose of adversity in a road game before The Game and come out with a win, when we haven’t seen any real on field adversity all year.

GoBlueZ06

November 19th, 2023 at 12:07 AM ^

Akron and UConn immediately leap to mind as well...

This was a road win against a team with nothing to lose whereas Michigan found themselves in unprecedented circumstances and oh by the way staring down the opportunity of back to back 11-0 starts for the first time since... 1901 and 1902, etc, etc, etc.

This wasn't unsettling, these are humans playing this game.

I remain incredibly excited for next week. We are the better football TEAM, period. Now go do the damn thing.

tubauberalles

November 19th, 2023 at 7:41 AM ^

Yeah, maybe I'm just calloused as an M fan, but "unsettling wins" is kind of our thing, IMO.  Anyone who thinks yesterday was anywhere near the top of the list of most unsettling wins probably hasn't seen many Bo or Carr games where the play calling just got shut down in the second half and many teams made their "unsettling" runs.

Ghost of Fritz…

November 19th, 2023 at 8:49 AM ^

Your point about the wind being a huge factor is solid.   We forget that watching on TV.  But it was a strong wind and it changed (1) offensive play calls, (2) the probability of pass plays working.  

Michigan had the wind in the 4th, right?  Moore should have used more short and intermediate passes in 1st and 2nd downs.  

 

waittilnextyear

November 18th, 2023 at 10:07 PM ^

While Moore didn’t update Mike Barrett’s injury, the sixth-year linebacker returned to the game after heading to the locker room. Barrett, who appeared in his postgame interview with an ice pack taped to his left shoulder, says that it isn’t much to worry about as far as his future prognosis is concerned.

“Just a little AC sprain on my shoulder,” Barrett said. “I kind of got hit on one of the plays as I was making a tackle — somebody came in and kind of hit my shoulder.

“Just kind of came in and got it looked at. Got it padded up and went back out there. Nothing a little Tylenol won’t fix.”

From: https://wolverineswire.usatoday.com/2023/11/18/injury-update-after-michigan-football-lost-multiple-players-at-maryland/

snarling wolverine

November 18th, 2023 at 6:36 PM ^

Two carries for 13 yards for Mullings.  He's quietly averaging over 6 YPC on the season.

If we're going to go really run-heavy, I'd like to see a little more of the big guy.  Don't love giving Corum 28 carries in a game like this.

MaynardST

November 18th, 2023 at 6:37 PM ^

Here are three obvious points:  1. JJ needs to find his inner Tom Brady and learn to pass accurately when he's banged up even on windy day. 2.  Mike Sainristil is at least as qualified to coach as Gattis now.  He may not be a great NFL caliber athlete, but he will make an incredible coach someday unless he decides to become an announcer. 3. The OSU game will be particularly tough if the offensive line isn't completely healthy. As it is, none of the defensive ends are as good as advertised before the season and Barnhart can't stop a topflight pass rusher.