It Goes Over Your Nose Comment Count

Brian November 16th, 2020 at 11:11 AM

11/14/2020 – Michigan 11, Wisconsin 49 – 1-3 Big Ten

I'm at the point where literally everything that happens with Michigan football is shoveled into my confirmation bias. No matter the specific configuration of any failure, it's Jim Harbaugh's responsibility because he presides over a hellish, roiling chaos.

The cornerbacks have 5.5 limbs between them? Well, Michigan's recruiting operation is infamously disorganized. Try to block a punt and give Wisconsin the equivalent of a turnover? Chris Partridge left Michigan so he could work under Lane Kiffin and DJ Durkin. DJ Durkin! (Who Jim Harbaugh hired before his incompetence got a kid killed; instead his incompetence only led to one of three complete ass-beatings Harbaugh has suffered at OSU's hands.) Starting quarterback has turned into a pumpkin? Dylan McCaffrey is still at Michigan. Instead of staying on a football team and having a very good chance to get significant playing time before a transfer he decided to leave the team but not the school.

This culminated in what I admit is a silly fury indeed. What is the Harbaugh equivalent of the camera cutting to Brady Hoke clapping uselessly after several ogres have dismembered our one true prince? Well, it's above: mask boner. I have reached the point where any shot of a Michigan coach engenders eyerolling because not one of them is ever wearing a mask correctly.

image

image

image

It goes over your nose! And if you put a headset mic under it you may as well not wear one at all!

The head coach of the team that just missed two games because of COVID understands that sound will pass through fabric. He's also addressed the fogging issue:

image

To me, everything must be brought back to the point that this program is failed and will not recover and we must start over again, so the mask is a symbol, man, of why Wisconsin methodically atomized Michigan on Saturday.

You could pick many other symbols, like Michigan going to the shotgun from the half-yard line and getting stuffed, immediately followed by Wisconsin getting off their one-yard-line with a four-yard QB sneak. That would also be a good symbol of why Michigan is bad at football and all the coaches must be put on a mission to Alpha Centauri. (Warde: it's not a firing! It's a promotion.)

You could pick a flailing cornerback trying to play man coverage he could not. You could pick a run game that is coming off consecutive rushing rutgers. You could pick the five offsides against Indiana, or losing to an MSU team that's headed for 1-7, or the various damning records starting with 0 and ending with a number between 6 and 12. These are all good.

I'm sticking with the masks. This is my symbol. There are many like it, but this one is mine.

[After THE JUMP: no points are awarded]

AWARDS

Known Friends and Trusted Agents Of The Week

you aren't the man now, dog

-2535ac8789d1b499[1]#1: Nobody. This isn't a stunt to express dissatisfaction. This was a football game in which Michigan was immediately down 14-0 and never looked even vaguely competitive. No one is statistically notable in a good way except maybe Ronnie Bell, and four catches for 56 yards showing up as the #1 in this category is sadder than awarding no points at all.

KFaTAotW Standings. (Scoring: 8 points for first, 5 for second, 3 for third, 1 for HM. Points from ties adjudicated by an ankylosaur named Sharon.)

14: Joe Milton (#1 Minnesota, #3 MSU, #3 Indiana)
10: Dax Hill (#2 MSU, #2 Indiana)
9: Ronnie Bell (HM Minnesota, #1 Indiana)
8: Giles Jackson(#1 MSU)
5: Kwity Paye(T2 Minnesota, HM MSU, HM Indiana)
3: Aidan Hutchinson(T2 Minnesota), Michael Barrett(#3 Minnesota)
2: Hassan Haskins(HM Minnesota, HM MSU)
1: Ben Mason (HM Minnesota), Jaylen Mayfield (HM Minnesota), Roman Wilson (HM MSU), Brad Robbins(HM Indiana), Cornelius Johnson(HM Indiana)

Who's Got It Better Than Us(?) Of The Week

Nothing.

Honorable mention: No.

image​MARCUS HALL EPIC DOUBLE BIRD OF THE WEEK.

Michigan's first offensive play was a ball into Nick Eubanks's face mask that ended up being intercepted, and that rather set the tone.

Honorable mention: The rest of the game.

OFFENSE

There goes that. Joe Milton imploded, with the assistance of his OL and WR, sure. But his second throw was directly into a linebacker's chest. He averaged 5 yards an attempt before being replaced by Cade McNamara. Whatever flickers of hope existed for the rest of the season depended on steady improvement from a guy with a high ceiling.

I'm not saying that's totally out the window since young players oscillate wildly, but it looks a lot further away today. And there's clearly no help coming from anyone else. As mentioned above, it looks incredibly bad that your #2 QB isn't playing football anywhere this fall because he doesn't want to be on your team.

At least they tried it. Running Joe Milton didn't help, because Michigan OL were getting dumped in the backfield. Evening numbers up in the box is only effective if you can actually block the numbers. Michigan got sat on. Nothing helps when your OL is getting whipped.

I don't think running Milton if and only if Ben Mason was in the backfield helped much.

You've seen this, right? Gun from the half yard line. FFS.

We've got an offense that doesn't do sensible manball things at sensible manball times and also is completely ineffective at getting to the perimeter.

404 takes not found. What else is there to say?

DEFENSE

Nobody knows what to do. Here is a veteran linebacker taking on a block and not funneling to his help:

Ross stops entirely so he can take on a block, and then gets sealed inside. This is a violation of Linebacker 101 from a guy with a season's worth of snaps under his belt, a week after he came in with a –5.5 in UFR. Ross and McGrone should be amongst your steadiest players. Instead they're running out of gaps and vacating zones on the regular.

Add it to the pile of evidence that this team is a holistically disorganized mess.

No, we shan't set an edge. Another game against a good running outfit, and another blizzard of easy yards off tackle when Michigan does not bother to contain the ball. This happened last year against Wisconsin—remember Jonathan Taylor zipping 75 yards untouched—and then against Ohio State; Mo Ibrahim did it in the Minnesota game.

This no doubt would have been better with Michigan's starting defensive ends, but those guys were around last year and trying to make up for interior issues. Michigan's original sin remains recruiting at DT and CB, all of which is entirely the staff's fault. They've failed to recruit sufficient numbers of DTs of any ranking.

SPECIAL TEAMS

Mmm. I suppose trying to block a punt was Michigan's best bet to make the score look respectable. It naturally ended with a penalty that extended Wisconsin's drive.

ELSEWHERE

Spencer Hall has written some items. One is a similar mask riff, proving that I am not alone in my insanity.

https___bucketeer-e05bbc84-baa3-437e-9518-adb32be77984.s3.amazonaws.com_public_images_5fc6ed22-b505-418f-9ad7-1cc5235cd49c_1027x609

That is Michigan coach Jim Harbaugh’s mask protocol on Saturday night. Harbaugh has put on his headset first, then attempted to stretch the mask over the mouthpiece of that headset. The internet roundly agreed that Harbaugh’s approach made it look like his mask had a boner, and that putting the headset mic under the mask was incredibly dumb, given how other coaches have managed to communicate through masks. Harbaugh’s team had just 47 yards rushing on the night.

Across the field, Paul Chryst TAPED HIS MASK TO HIS FREAKING FACE.

He also talks about the whole Harbaugh thing later:

Harbaugh had done his job everywhere he’d been. He made Stanford great. He got the 49ers to a Super Bowl with a first-year starter at QB before he and San Francisco’s owners bickered into a separation. Harbaugh came to Michigan as nothing less than a guaranteed savior.

Then ... none of the good things happened. Michigan failed to appear in the Big Ten Championship, let alone the Playoff. They pulled good-to-great recruiting classes, but failed to capitalize. Michigan is 3-3 against Michigan State in Harbaugh’s tenure. They are 10-14 against ranked teams. Worst of all, they are 0-5 against Ohio State, and barring a miracle, will hit 0-6 with a thunderous noise of wailing and breaking glass. 

Comments

Ed Shuttlesworth

November 16th, 2020 at 2:06 PM ^

The ridiculous DT thing bespeaks a lack of attention to detail -- as lol do the masks!!! -- and that's exactly what you were always going to get with Harbaugh.  

Quick culture jolt makes him look good compared to the incompetent he replaced, then he has to and can't build and maintain his own program, and then he disassociates and pisses all his co-workers off, and the thing spirals completely out of control.  Was well on the way to happening in SF, and would have if he'd stayed around.

mgoO

November 16th, 2020 at 2:29 PM ^

Wearing masks on the sideline is for the TV cameras or just abject stupidity considering most of the people (players) on the sideline don't have to wear masks.

That said, Harbaugh is usually good at doing things for show and not so good at doing things like winning football games so it's surprising that they're so bad at wearing masks.

As for Partridge and the punt block...we have run into/roughed the kicker multiple times for no reason since Harbaugh has been around.  Blaming it on Partridge leaving is STRETCH.

Don

November 16th, 2020 at 6:03 PM ^

"we have run into/roughed the kicker multiple times for no reason since Harbaugh has been around."

We did that in Harbaugh's first OSU game in 2015.

The score was still 0-0 late in the first quarter; we'd stopped OSU on downs on their first possession, and had just stopped their second drive on the OSU 9 yard line, so they were basically punting from their own endzone. I was sitting in the bar by myself, but I distinctly remember saying out loud to myself "Now don't try to get smart and go for the block—just take the fucking punt and the field position."

Sure enough, the Michigan coaching geniuses (Baxter? Durkin? Harbaugh?) decide to try to block the punt and Kinnel gets a flag for roughing the kicker, giving new life to OSU. Two plays later Elliott runs 66 yards down to the Michigan 10, and soon Barrett was in the end zone.

Would we have won the game if we hadn't roughed the kicker? Probably not, but a coaching staff that knows what it's doing wouldn't be taking entirely unnecessary chances after their defense has just done its job at the stage in the game when the game is still competitive.

That special teams fuckup against OSU wasn't the only idiot decision that season—sending gunners against an MSU team that didn't have a returner to field the coming punt was even worse, given the game situation. Ultimately, these things are on Harbaugh.

oldhackman

November 16th, 2020 at 2:47 PM ^

The mask commentary works, but I found my own metaphor on Sunday.  My block M flag was flying proudly on gameday as it always does.  When I got up on Sunday morning, the flag was on the ground as sometimes happens on windy nights. Except this time was different.  This time the flagpole hadn't just wriggled out of the socket; it was bent and broken in half.  There is no fixing it.  It needs to be replaced.  The sooner the better.

 

 

Hab

November 16th, 2020 at 3:51 PM ^

Worst of all, they are 0-5 against Ohio State, and barring a miracle, will hit 0-6 with a thunderous noise of wailing and breaking glass. 

That thundering noise of wailing and breaking glass will be from OSU fans angry that they don't break the all-time scoring mark set by Ga Tech at 222-0.  You'll likely get nothing but apathetic, disinterested silence from Michigan fans.

ca_prophet

November 16th, 2020 at 5:57 PM ^

The team has three large problems, over which varying degrees of control can be exercised.

We really have no control over the OSU Death Star.  If that was the only problem we had and we were taking care of our end, we might have more patience.

We have only some control over recruiting and player retention.  It does not matter if the staff pursues all the right people, hits all the right notes, and gives all the time and effort humanly possible; sometimes the 18-year-old man-child is going to go somewhere else.  Sometimes it will even happen for nonsensical reasons.  What the staff does have control over is the overall shape, and this is where they've fallen down - we just don't have bodies at DT.

The staff has (as much as possible; sometimes things just don't work) control over player development and game planning.  The player development has actually been good(?!) - we've turned a fair number of low ranked recruits into good players, and have not had more than our share of high-ranked busts.  A few key injuries/transfers have hurt us on this front, which mostly speaks to lack of elite depth - a characteristic shared by everyone except Clemson/Alabama/OSU.

Where we have really fallen short is the game planning.  Even last year, we had papered over our lack of DTs by leaning on the things we did have - playing everything to spill, using our DEs to help inside, and using McGrone/Hudson to make up for that.  It didn't work against OSU/Alabama, but it was a response that played to our strengths and put people in a position to succeed.  On offense, we grew into our speed-in-space gameplan and the offense looked like it was cohering.  Then we opened this year with a flare screen and it looked like it was all coming together.

Then something happened.  I have no idea what it could have been, but the offensive game plan seemingly got chucked out the window, and the defensive plan shows no knowledge of our strengths and weaknesses.  Wisconsin was always going to be a pasting with our four best linemen out, but good coaching would have shown signs of trying to compensate for our thin DL and non-elite corners, and doing something to attack the weaknesses with our offensive strengths.  I didn't see any of that.

I don't think they've forgotten how to coach.  I don't think they've forgotten how to appraise strengths and weaknesses.  I have no idea why we don't see signs of it on the field ... but we don't, and that's not something we should tolerate.

Blue_third

November 16th, 2020 at 6:27 PM ^

Jim Harbaugh has tested negative for COVID probably innumerable times. If his mask is loose, it only means he puts himself at risk. You can't spread what you don't have. That being said our best defense against Ohio State this year is COVID so maybe loose masks are necessary around the Penn State game. I would have liked to have seen Dylan have a chance this year. His brother is one of the best players in the NFL and his dad was a baller. Bummer. 

Amaznbluedoc

November 16th, 2020 at 7:21 PM ^

Rather than a mask, a better metaphor would be the fan with the paper bag, except JH’ s would have no holes.  The program is stuck in dumb and dumber mode and it’s time to wake up JH and tell him he’s not doing a cameo on Bill and Ted’s excellent Adventure.

WalmartWolve

November 16th, 2020 at 7:51 PM ^

 This is Brian pissed off. The mask issue (symbol) is more than a mere tipping point, it's basically an insult in retribution for the perps obvious negligence in everything he does at Michigan. This is such a sad fucking situation. 

Double-D

November 17th, 2020 at 12:46 AM ^

Josh Ross is a cyan.

He has regressed and might be the biggest weakness in the defense. He is slow to react and behind on every coverage assignment. He can’t fill a gap and is always out of position. 

He should be replaced so a freshman with potential can get some experience.