[Patrick Barron]

Frank Sinatra Takes Two Steps Comment Count

Brian September 26th, 2022 at 1:51 PM

9/24/2022 – Michigan 34, Maryland 27 – 4-0, 1-0 Big Ten

Blake Corum hopped outside because he had no choice. There he met a Maryland safety, who deposited his shoulder in Corum's midsection. A defensive end shed Luke Schoonmaker and jumped on Corum from the side. Corum was still a half-yard short of the first down. He wore one 260-pound Terrapin like a cape; the second was trying to break him in half.

Corum took a step. He took another step. Tilted forward at a 45-degree angle, he looked like an Scandinavian World's Strongest Man competitor who has been tasked with dragging a semi the length of a football field—minus 150 pounds, a foot, and a beard you could knit a suspension bridge out of. He took two more steps, each of of them a Xeno's paradox approaching the first down marker, until finally that impossible line was breached. Eventually the whole thing collapsed into a heap, and Michigan's offense got to keep playing football.

image

On the sideline, I imagine Mike Hart muttered something like "ok, son" to himself. Maybe he cocked an eyebrow. In the booth upstairs, Fred Jackson left the planet for several seconds, returning only so he could proclaim the prophecy had finally come true. The tether back to this world from the astral plane whispered "you told them so," and brooked no references to Avery Horn.

It is in this way scripture is written.

-----------------------------------------------------

This year's preview clucked about exactly one Blake Corum thing:

CORUM DOES LACK ONE HART TRAIT. That would be the ability to drive a ruck of Penn State defenders six yards at a time. This is a tradeoff we'll make for the ability to dust anybody in the country not named Nakobe Dean, but it is an important thing to note in the context of this year's team.

We spent an awful lot of time slotting linebackers and other large persons into a short-yardage role. Meanwhile Corum was silently squatting several times a day until his legs could be used to hold up buildings. Once after a WTKA podcast Sam mentioned that Corum was upset that people thought he could not handle the job on third and one. Message received. Doubts removed.

But of course, the above was not the only thing Corum did in short yardage situations.

He added another long bounce touchdown on third and four, and when Maryland did set the edge he went to work inside. He has the vision to pop outside, the discipline not to do it when it's not there, the long speed to dust safeties out of position, the jitter to dust safeties in position. He is also a very nice person.

On a day where Michigan faced an actual opponent and could have had things go the wrong way, Corum put them in front and then gave them breathing room in the fourth quarter. Several people on Twitter were complaining that Joel Klatt was saying things like "take away Blake Corum and this team would be struggling," and, well, yeah. Take away the Mona Lisa and the Louvre is just a collection of guys in silly hats. "Michigan has the best back in America is not a bug," it's a feature.

At some point opponents are going to freak out about Corum and weight will shift back to JJ McCarthy's shoulders, and that's fine. Saturday clarified exactly what is line 1 on the opposing scouting report. If McCarthy corrects from last week's wobble it's all on the table.

AWARDS

Known Friends and Trusted Agents Of The Week

52382066846_ecc86697e0_k

 

you're the man now, dog-2535ac8789d1b499[1]

#1 Blake Corum. See above. Numerically: 30 carries, 243 yards. That'll do.

#2(T) DJ Turner and Gemon Green. Stared down the second-best set of receivers they'll see this year and roundly defeated them. Rakim Jarrett and Dontay Demus totaled 24 yards between them. Jeshaun Jones had 48. Everything was contested. Turner had an absurd interception-type substance. Test: passed. Full points for both.

#3(T) Luke Schoonmaker, Joel Honigford, and Max Bredeson. This space speculated in the game preview that Maryland did not have the personnel to match up with Michigan heavy sets, and it appeared that the coaching staff came to the same conclusion. This resulted in a ton of two and three TE sets that sent Blake Corum off tackle as the tight ends neutralized the playside end and then dumptrucked the second level. Two points each.

Honorable mention: JJ McCarthy did complete 69% of his passes and this is the internet. Mike Sainristil just about got in the cornerback party at #2 but he did have a critical error on Maryland's second TD drive. Otherwise, exceeding all reasonable expectations and then some. Mazi Smith had a key TFL and came on late. RJ Moten had a key interception. Mike Morris was relatively effective as a rusher and had a sack and a thumping hit.

KFaTAotW Standings.

(points: #1: 8, #2: 5, #3: 3, HMs one each. Ties result in somewhat arbitrary assignments.)

18: Blake Corum (#2 CSU, #2 Hawaii, HM UConn, #1 Maryland)
14: JJ McCarthy (#1 Hawaii, #2 UConn, HM Maryland)
11: Mazi Smith (#1 CSU, T3 Hawaii, HM Maryland)
10: Ronnie Bell (HM CSU, HM Hawaii, #1 UConn)
6: Gemon Green (HM UConn, T2 Maryland)
5: DJ Turner (T2 Maryland), Kris Jenkins (#3 UConn, T3 Hawaii)
4: Junior Colson (#3 CSU, HM UConn)
3: Mike Morris (T3 Hawaii, HM Maryland)
2: Roman Wilson (HM CSU, HM Hawaii), Max Bredeson (T3 Maryland), Luke Schoonmaker (T3 Maryland), Joel Honigford (T3 Maryland)
1: Braiden McGregor (HM CSU), Eyabi Anoma (HM CSU), Derrick Moore (HM CSU), Jaylen Harrell (HM CSU), Rod Moore (HM CSU), Makari Paige (HM Hawaii), Rayshaun Benny (HM Hawaii), Mason Graham (HM Hawaii), Cornelius Johnson (HM Hawaii), Donovan Edwards (HM Hawaii), AJ Henning (HM UConn),  Caden Kolesar (HM UConn), Mike Morris (HM Maryland), Mike Sainristil (HM Maryland), RJ Moten (HM Maryland).

Who's Got It Better Than Us(?) Of The Week

Corum inserts the dagger on third and short.

Honorable mention: Corum inserts another dagger on fourth and short. McCarthy finally hits that deep ball to Bell. Turner and Moten pull off excellent interceptions, mostly. Smith consumes RB in backfield for TFL.

imageMARCUS HALL EPIC DOUBLE BIRD OF THE WEEK.

First drive of the third Q: McCarthy misses an RPO pull read on third and four, Isaiah Gash gets two yards, and Michigan punts on fourth and two in plus territory. An all-around recipe for frustration.

Honorable mention: Two Maryland fans six rows in front of me are wearing absurdly oversized baseball caps that make me irrationally upset. CJ Stokes fumbles his only carry. JJ McCarthy does a lot of running around inadvisably. Taulia Tagovailoa sits in the pocket and enjoys afternoon tea.

[After THE JUMP: bumps]

OFFENSE

52381462220_1c7578af1d_k

[Fuller]

Well, I mean, Zaphod's just this guy, you know? JJ McCarthy was not perfect and did a number of frustrating things. Also he was 18/26 for 220 yards and was one deep ball away from averaging 10 YPC. The duality of man, man.

I completely understand the rabbling here. There was a lot of alarming wandering around in the backfield, particularly two plays that were very Early Devin Gardner. One was the world's longest QB scramble and an important first down. One was an absurd Ishtar journey that resulted in a fumble (sort of*) and third and twenty-five. This is not ideal.

I don't know. McCarthy's first real bad play was another capital-j Journey on which he had Blake Corum on a wheel route against a defensive end and did not pull the trigger:

Blake Dang Corum

This turned me into Jesse Pinkman. BRO. BROOOOOOO. BRO. Whichever guy called that play was hopping up and down and eating his hat when McCarthy didn't throw that.

Decisions kind of snowballed from there. There were certain points where I was crabby in the stands because I thought Michigan's playcalling wasn't helping matters and then you hop to the tape and that run up the gut to Isaiah Gash is an RPO that sends AJ Henning into the flat against a corner blitz:

Hat is vomited up so someone else can eat hat. Wither the guy who pulled it against Hawaii and rifled in a touchdown to Ronnie Bell?

And then well whatever I just do this:

It's amazing how all that just melted away in the face of some bad decisions and missed deep balls. Yeah, this was probably a bad JJ McCarthy game. If this is a bad game, ok.

*[McCarthy was clearly in possession of the ball and throwing it forward. For review not to overturn that was absurd. That actually helped Michigan since the throw was intentional grounding and the fumble-type substance was a few yards closer to the sticks, but it was very wrong]

On the other hand. Maybe Cornelius Johnson should have caught that ball?

52382498530_efcc11d229_k

[Barron]

We never got a replay but it did not feel like the defensive back got a hand on it. I kind of feel like if you get sproingled in your motte and bailey that you should catch the ball. NFL types wanted to see some contested catches from him this year; this was a missed opportunity.

One frustrating item. Just last week we saw SMU's Rashee Rice repeatedly dunk on Maryland defensive backs. Rice is a big leapy guy in the vein of a couple of Michigan receivers and other than the unplanned chuck above we did not see Michigan test anyone on a back shoulder fade or other Nico Collins go-get-it special.

DEATH TO WING TIGHT END BLOCKS ON SHORT YARDAGE. I understand that you've got to do some things to preserve a bit of mystery when you're doing the football. But if you're just going to do the obvious thing, for the love of God let your inline tight end be in line. The whole reason the column leads off with Blake Corum heroically lifting two Terrapins six feet is because Michigan motioned Luke Schoonmaker across the formation and asked him to block a DE with an inherent disadvantage:

TE motioning to bottom

That not an L for Schoonmaker, it's a stalemate. If that stalemate is at the line of scrimmage Corum just burrows inside of it and doesn't have to clean out the stables. I cannot tell you how many times I have seen wing TEs asked to do things against DEs who are bigger and stronger than them and—since the TE is not actually inline—have an inbuilt ability to set the block in the backfield.

Your inline TE will have a tougher time pulling across the formation and may be covered up and unable to go downfield. On short yardage, so what? Argh!

52381523063_2a12aa5257_k

Preferred deep guy. Michigan has targeted all of their top three guys deep but it feels like Roman Wilson is the preferred option there, because he's super fast. Here he got three targets and was very open on two—the third saw a safety able to impede his path to the ball a little bit.

Making Wilson your preferred guy puts a premium on putting the ball right on your dude because his advantage is getting past the guys, not putting them on a poster on an underthrown ball. So your risk level is lower but the rate of downfield successes probably lower.

Totally fine. Gio El-Hadi got a start against a Big Ten team and that was just fine. Michigan is notably right handed on the ground, though, and when things did go over the left it was often one of those 3TE sets—El-Hadi and Hayes did not get a whole lot of gradable blocks.

The OL also gave up minimal pressure. That's necessary but not sufficient since Maryland does not have an edge guy of note and loves dropping eight.

DEFENSE

52382231554_e32b8603a2_k

uncommon [Fuller]

Call it even? Two main developments. One: the secondary got a stiff test and passed it with flying colors. Two: Michigan got very little pressure from its front four. Overall, a push? I would feel much better about this assertion if Michigan hadn't given up a ton of big chunk plays on Maryland's last, relatively futile drive. Before that you were looking at 300 yards and 20 points—six of them on 50+ yard field goals—for what looks like the second or third best offense in the league outside of Michigan.

DE measuring stick acquired. Mike Morris was about what we thought: reasonably good Wormley-esque rusher and very good run defender. He was Michigan's most effective DE in this game, which is good for him. It is less good for Michigan. Rivals's Trevor McCue notes that Morris generated six pressures, a hurry, and a sack in this game. Thumbs up. The rest of the cast did not keep pace:

Jaylen Harrell kind of disappeared in this one. He only won against his blocker 11% of the time against Maryland, bringing his season number down to 17%. … Taylor Upshaw continues to struggle at the other EDGE spot. … The only player with a lower pass rush grade than Upshaw is George Rooks.

Around these parts we were somewhat hopeful but mostly skeptical either of the veterans would turn the corner, metaphorically or literally, and while Harrell did blast the right tackle over on one play that was about his only impact. (The facemask flag is whatever; it happens.)

The guys in the "wildcard" section of the season preview are faring better, but in limited snaps. Okie has just 26 on the season; Moore and McGregor are flashing erratically but just not deployed enough to really get a read. It's like Uche got split across three guys. We just don't know what it looks like if one of them gets the bulk of snaps. Okie did flush Tagovailoa into his most Taulia moment of the day, the near INT to Sainristil. Speaking of…

52381461620_b9ede7d663_k

on you [Fuller]

Best late-career position switch ever? The only thing separating Mike Sainristil from the Known Friends section was the pass that set up Maryland's second touchdown:

You can see him go "oh crap" one second late.

Other than that, yow. He had the crucial stop that set up Michigan's two-minute drill touchdown when he thunked a TE and then tackled the Maryland Five Star WR Du Jour:

And even when Jarrett did get a majority of his receiving yards in this game this is how he did it:

If you told me that Rakim Jarrett would fare worse as a (mostly) slot receiver against Mike Sainristil than Dax Hill I would not have believed you. Draftable? Feels draftable.

52381920401_a502005e74_k

[Fuller]

Being in position is half the battle. Gemon Green spent much of his early career in Channing Stribling Hell where every time he was near a receiver he'd phase out of existence at the critical moment. This space has always advocated for cornerbacks who are right in the grill of their man, because "now hit the ball" is a much easier fix than "get three yards closer." Green did not exactly hit the ball in this game but he did enough to make Maryland deep balls nigh impossible. He's keeping Will Johnson on the bench.

Linebackers: oof. Junior Colson did not have a good game at first blush. He shot some gaps he shouldn't have, had some tackles run through, and his positive plays are unlikely to outdistance the negative ones. The most painful goof was the Tagovailoa scramble, where he passes his guy off to a cornerback and then stays super deep until it's almost too late, then gets beat when he does come up:

Shortly thereafter he was very passive on the goal line while unblocked and Maryland scored from the two.

Meanwhile Kalel Mullings got run over by the Maryland backup RB. That guy is a hoss, but so is Mullings. I was a little frustrated that we never saw anyone flash into the backfield despite Michigan holding up pretty well against doubles and keeping that linebacker level clean. Maybe Nikhai Hill-Green comes back next week and is a major upgrade; other than that I think we're stuck with a pretty meh group.

Young guys flash. Rayshaun Benny couldn't quite make this play but man is it encouraging all the same:

I'm not going to get on a guy for tackling up high when he's just swum past an OL and is not fully balanced. My man need some help, and the guy he needs help from is Eyabi Okie. Okie has a corner blitz outside of him and has no force responsibility. Shed at all costs, drive at all costs. Do something. Anything. Any bit of robbed momentum there is fourth down.

Not even mad. Love me a good shovel pass, particularly when paired with a jet sweep threat the other way:

Now, the formation tips this. But still, that's a counter step from the TE with that jet fake, and then a speed option threat. It's real nice.

SPECIAL TEAMS

52381276323_76924a8a73_k

not even momma is gonna love you after this one [Fuller]

Vestiges of Weird Maryland. Credit to the Terps for mostly not being Weird Maryland—maybe it's too early in the year for that—but doinking the opening kickoff off your facemask such that the opposing team actually recovers it is an all-timer.

We had an extensive discussion on the podcast about ways you could score a touchdown faster than Michigan did in this game; suffice it to say that we had hard time coming up with even outlandish scenarios that could top this. I'm surprised we haven't seen official recognition this was the fastest TD in Michigan history.

KEEP DOINKING HIM? Very disappointed that Michigan's next kickoff was deep in the endzone and Felton could just fling his hands in the air. Another muff is absurdly unlikely, but you've got to give them the chance. See above about Weird Maryland.

Not often Moody gets out-Moody'd. Two 50+ yarders from Maryland versus Moody hitting 2/3 with one 50+ and one miss from 43.

MISCELLANEOUS

Mary Sue U. FULL ALONZO HIGHSMITH FROM MARY SUE COLEMAN

52380111957_fb0351ab71_k

"please don't do anything rash, ma'am" –Ronnie Bell [Barron]

DEVASTATING.

What was with the weird QB substitution? Taulia Tagovailoa takes a big hit and briefly exits the game. He comes back. He plays fine. Corum inserts the dagger to give Michigan a two-score lead with a few minutes left. This game is mostly out of reach but not entirely. So why does Maryland put their backup in? I wonder if Tagovailoa had a borderline concussion.

Perspective. Here's some opponent-adjusted EPA/play for you:

 epa per play

Maryland might actually be pretty good, Michigan is 4th nationally based on (admittedly squiggly early-season) opponent-adjusted number crunching, and ye gods Iowa.

Dude. We had our first mind-bending fourth down decision in this game when Michigan punted on their first drive of the second half, in plus territory, on fourth and two, while Corum was on a heater. I can only assume that disappointment on the missed RPO read influenced that decision? I guess? I am stretching for something because otherwise that does not compute.

Obligatory officiating discussion. Maryland entered this game as the second-most penalized team in the nation and exited it with one call for five yards. The officials missed an egregious ineligible man downfield call and ignored holding both ways in a manner that facilitated offensive football but did not strike me as entirely fair. Also, I mean… the DJ Turner interception wasn't even worth a booth review? I have bad news for people who thought John O'Neill retiring was going to make things better.

HERE

GIFS:

Best and Worst:

So yeah, looking at the final score this was a 7-point game, but once Michigan pulled ahead in the 4th it never felt THAT close.  Before that last drive Maryland had 127 yards in the second half to Michigan’s 229, and Michigan was finally starting to get some pressure on Maryland’s QB and shutting down Maryland’s running game – they only had 33 yards rushing in the second half before that last drive.  Maryland didn’t really have an answer for Corum on the ground and had McCarthy just thrown the ball to his open receivers with a bit more consistency this game would have likely been the double-digit one we all expected.  That isn’t intended to take away from Maryland – they played really well and look improved on both sides of the ball compared to last year.  But this wasn’t even like the Rutgers game last year where the Scarlet Knights outgained Michigan and generally controlled the second half; this was more one of those games where a limited number of possessions led to a tightening at the end of the game that hopefully shook some of the rust off the team but doesn’t portend bad times ahead.

SP+ had a 94% win expectancy, FWIW.

State of our Open Threads:

It was a stark change from the UConn game - UConn saw all of nine fucks given and twelve shits given. Indeed, it was barely a thread at all. This week, we were a bit more stressed, as you might imagine. We gave 153 fucks and 118 shits. The parallel to last season's Rutgers game was fairly evident too - after giving a mere eighteen fucks and twelve shits against Northern Illinois, we jumped to 176 fucks and 76 shits for the Rutgers game. Like most seasons, the start of conference play brings hypertension and headaches in the Big Ten.

Anyway, here's the "fuck" / "shit" chart to date:

For a game like that, the "fire" talk was fairly restrained.

Comments

Double-D

September 26th, 2022 at 3:01 PM ^

Maryland called a good game all things considered and should beat MSU if they aren’t too beat up.

This was just not a clean game by UofM on either side of the ball.  JJs “interception” out of bounds was most concerning. I’m not sure what he was looking at. Throw that high and deep to the corner..he has the arm.

LSA Superstar

September 26th, 2022 at 3:15 PM ^

I agree completely that McCarthy was throwing a pass on that terrible 2nd down scramble where a Maryland DT ate his face and they called it a fumble.  But I actually don't think it would have been intentional grounding.  It's certainly close, but I'm pretty sure McCarthy leaves the 5-yard tackle box during one of his ill-fated soujourns to his right before doubling back to his left.  And although I don't dispute he was in the pocket when he got annihilated, the tackle box dissolves the moment the ball leaves it pursuant to Rule 2 Section 34.

J. Redux

September 26th, 2022 at 3:27 PM ^

The tackle box is only relevant if the ball makes it to the line of scrimmage.

I had some people on the game thread argue that it wasn't intentional grounding because he was being taken down, so you couldn't tell where he was throwing it, but if that were the case then there'd never be intentional grounding.  Few QBs will throw it away unless they're under duress...

Blue Middle

September 26th, 2022 at 3:29 PM ^

This is AMAZING writing and brilliant analysis.  I'm so glad you're back, Brian.

For the "rabble, rabble" crowd, I'd point out:

  • At this time last year we just survived a MUCH closer game against a much worse opponent (Rutgers).
  • At this time last year David Ojabo had not yet emerged and we were still shrugging about one of our DE positions (though we were clear that we had a special player on the other side).
  • This season, 'Bama struggled with a mediocre Texas team that just lost to Texas Tech.
  • Georgia gave up 22 points to Kent State this week.
  • Michigan State got routed by Minnesota (this does not relate to my message but is fun to repeat)
  • Maryland is very likely to be the 2nd-best offense we face; criticisms of the LBs and pass rush are legitimate but this game may also be the springboard to improvement.
  • We don't know how the players were coached this week--it's very possible (and likely if history is a guide) that JJ was coached not to run much this week; the pass rush may have been instructed to focus on containment first and pressure second.
  • This was the first challenge for our new coordinators

What I'm saying is that there are some legitimate concerns, but this team doesn't look behind last year's in totality and we know how that turned out.

On to Iowa.

M_Born M_Believer

September 26th, 2022 at 3:39 PM ^

Overall, I am not too concerned about the team and this game.  Maryland played like September Maryland and they do look very solid.  I fully expect them to blast Sparty next week and I will be laughing the whole time.  (FYI - I dont want to hear "But but you can't make fun of them until you beat them")  Screw that, Tuck is about to oversee a tire fire of a season.  Let them squirm with their pending disaster of a season.

Here are some points that I believe will not be relevant as the season progresses

1) Blake was the only reliable RB - Well we do have Edwards and as far as I know he should be returning so this was a one off.  Edwards most likely does not fumble and Michigan was shoving the ball right down Maryland's throat at that time.

2) JJ - This was only his 3rd career start (and first against a real team).  I have to believe that he will continue to progress and improve as the season goes along.  To me his biggest challenge right now is his decision making, particularly of when to tuck and run.  There were a few times (particularly with 7 and 8 men in coverage) that JJ was sitting back patting the ball looking for someone.  It should be 1...2...3... ok where is my running lane, I can pick up some positive yardage and live for another play.  Compared to 'Hey I can make every play spectacular!' (1 did and 1 didn't that contributed to the missed FG) 

3) JJ and long throws, I believe that he was just sped up ever so slightly in this game and that wasn't needed.  The more he relaxes I would expect a few more completions on those

4) Are we really concerned that Moody missed a FG?  Not likely to happen again...

5) Until that last drive (which appears that Michigan went into a Prevent Shell defense), the defense did alright especially in the 2nd half.  Good offenses will score points, Taulia has certainly matured and Maryland's game plan was very good.  Michigan adjusted and settled down in the 2nd half.

6) The unfortunate face mask on 3rd and long to open game.  Michigan D stood tall and made the plays.  This is another one off, not likely to happen....

7) Play calling, a couple of times it was 'What are they thinking'.  A WR Jet run to a throw was not the right call there when they were moving the ball consistently.  Particularly on 2nd and long.  Plus early on running vertical routes through zones is not effective.  It was nice to see the adjustment to more flood concepts and crossing patterns....

In the end, these are all minor points that are very correctable as the season goes along.  Last years team struggled against Rutgers for no reason, needed a late comeback to beat a bad Nebraska team and that other game.  My point is, every team will have challenges over the course of the season.  Particularly when the bar is set at 11 or 12 wins.  How they respond to each challenge will define the season.

This game?  A good win over a good team.  That is what I believe will be the tag line for this game at the end of the season when looking back on it in in review.....

Monkey House

September 26th, 2022 at 4:13 PM ^

I just watched the game for the first time right now. JJ was up and down but nothing that's not fixable and will be better with more more playing time. The number 1 problem I saw was the play calling was all over the place. With a solid game plan this would have been a 55-27 game easily. Again this is fixable and I HOPE is fixed by next week. If so then I have zero worries about the offense from here on out. The defense? That's another story 😬

AZBlue

September 26th, 2022 at 4:15 PM ^

Side Note:  Be sure to think of the Spartans in your life this week - whether it is holding your tongue toward a loved one or being particularly cruel toward that annoying coworker.

Spartan nation is so riled up right now that - for the first time in my memory - the "MGoBlog imploding" thread (for general "Walverines, September heisman, hur-hur-hur content) has been bumped off the front page at tRCMB for several days.

Leopards cannot change their spots completely though -- there are still threads noting how Maryland "gave" the game away vs. M and the unrealistic size of the Iowa - M betting line.  Not surprisingly the "Would you lock in 7-5 with a win over M right now?" thread has seen a recent resurgence in interest after a LOT of downvotes over the summer.

 

(Downvote if you must but I enjoy much of their OT discussions there <NEVER post> and find it refreshing when the negativity in a "game thread" actually makes me smile........)

4th phase

September 26th, 2022 at 4:19 PM ^

Anyone else think JJ seemed more likely to give on read options / rpos in this game now that Cade is out with injury? 

There's only 2 examples really, so who knows. But seemed like 2 missed give reads. 

 

Koop

September 28th, 2022 at 8:53 AM ^

Yes, this. I came here to offer two comments if they hadn't yet been offered:

  1. Yes, I suspect JJ was under instructions in this game to avoid running the ball himself to avoid injury, which could have contributed both to the questionable gives on the RPOs as well as the sandlot scrambles. Wishing Cade a full and speedy recovery.
     
  2. And I can't believe no one else has given Brian a hat tip for "Zaphod's just this guy." I mean, if we all can appreciate military history critiques over mottes and baileys and a solid history of Western philosophy reference in Zeno's paradox, can't we all get behind a Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy reference?

Everyone grab a Pan-Galactic Gargleblaster, sit back, and be froody.

Harlans Haze

September 26th, 2022 at 4:24 PM ^

It appeared the starters, particularly d-line was gassed the last MD TD drive. There were bound to be consequences of not being tested the first 3 games. But it's always good to get the W when you get smacked in the face. 

bronxblue

September 26th, 2022 at 5:03 PM ^

I don't want to be overly negative but I'm getting strong DPJ vibes around Johnson right now - a guy who sorta gator arms close balls and just can't quite put it all together.  My big prediction before the year was that Bell would be the leading receiver on this team and while Wilson remains a deep play threat it does feel like Bell has regained his top dog spot.

Glad to see I wasn't wrong in thinking Turner and Green had really good games.  Maryland's receivers looked mediocre in this game and I think we're going to see them not be mediocre next week against a depleted MSU defense.

I liked Maryland's play calls on 4th down and that little shovel pass was fun.  They came to play and had a good offensive gameplan.

I do expect an uptick in edge performance from the young guys as the season progresses but color me unsurprised that a lot of guys are just that.  Morris was the one consistent push at least.

I don't love Wilson as the designated deep threat because he's not going to fight for contested balls well and trying to hit a guy in stride 50 yards downfield is always a bit dicey.

I will defend McCarthy somewhat because I thought he generally handled Maryland's weird defensive scheme well but everyone who shat on McNamara should look at his stat line from this same game last year.  Football ain't easy.

AC1997

September 26th, 2022 at 5:57 PM ^

I'm okay with Wilson deep balls most of the time as long as you mix in throws to everyone.  However, I'm still not sure what sort of route runner Wilson is.  The knock last year was that he was a go-route guy and I think he's better this year but I still think he's limited in that area.  I need to see the replay & UFR, but I felt like there were passes where he hadn't done anything to win his route the way Bell or Johnson would.  All of the guys are solid and have their roles to play so it isn't a strong criticism, just a possible thing to monitor.

Same with CJ.  I like him and overall think he's a solid WR2.  But I never understood Brian's offseason NFL hype with him.  Nico Freaking Collins was a 3rd round pick so when Brian said he's going as high or higher than Nico I raised an eyebrow.  

bronxblue

September 26th, 2022 at 9:26 PM ^

Yeah, I watched a number of those deep throws on review of the game and Wilson had a step on the guys but he also wasn't blindingly wide open.  They were going to be tough catches and I think playing your Hawaii's and CSU's of the world gave McCarthy and Wilson a false sense that he'd just be running past secondaries like they're in quicksand.  That's not the case and compared to guys like Bell and All, for example, Wilson is still not quite there making himself the best target for these throws.  

Again, I don't want to rag on Johnson too much.  He's a talented guy and is good in the open field.  But yeah, when some of your issues is "struggles to catch the ball during contact" and "short-arms balls and sometimes catches them in your body" that's going to be big issues at the next level.  Still time for him to get there but the hype always felt a bit premature.

stephenrjking

September 26th, 2022 at 6:58 PM ^

I think Johnson is suffering from perhaps unreasonable expectations based upon his performances last year. That is, his performances were good, but he was never the next all-world receiver. Issues like contested-ball ability were known last year.

Granted, he could have improved in that area and hasn't appeared to so far. Improvement is reasonable. But transformation isn't.

Honestly, I'm just a bit meh on the receivers so far this year, and I think it's partly my own fault for projecting ideas of what they would be this year onto performances on the field that did not merit those high expectations. We have a great collection of good receivers, but none of the receivers appear to be individually dominant right now. Maaaaybe Bell proves to be more elite as the year goes on (and he certainly looks good). Maybe Andrel Anthony takes those steps to emerge that we've been ready to see since last year's MSU game. 

But so far we haven't seen it, and there *have* been some opportunities. They are definitely good. But each is missing just a bit that could take them to the next level. Contested-ball catching in particular seems to be in short supply, and that's disappointing because JJ could make a lot of yards if he could throw 50/50 passes and reasonably assume that his guy would get them. 

Roman is a good deep threat but I honestly wish his routes were a bit sharper, because he could absolutely smoke guys if they were. 

bronxblue

September 26th, 2022 at 9:19 PM ^

Yeah, I generally ratchet back my expectations for receivers compared to this site's takes because more often than not they do get needlessly overhyped about guys who are just okay.  Ronnie Bell is a very good college WR and is an A+ blocker who'll have a cup of coffee in the NFL most likely but the fact he's the most consistent performer on the team at that spot says what the current ceiling.

I agree a bit about Johnson being a victim of expectations; I just remember the DPJ years wherein I kept hearing about how amazing he was and then he finished his career with only 1 game of more than 1 TD reception and 1 game of more than 90 yards receiving and barely got drafted.  Johnson wasn't ever quite hyped to the moon but he's just sort of a guy at this point.  He's a good guy, but still just a guy.

I do think Michigan has shied away from contested catches for reasons that I don't quite get.  Maybe it's true, as you're saying, that nobody has really emerged as a downfield option in that respect so it's not in the playbook.  In that case I'd hope a guy like Anthony could take advantage but I guess it hasn't quite clicked yet.  My hope there is that as McCarthy gets more comfortable as the starting QB they integrate more of those plays in games.  I do think McCarthy has shown a willingness to throw into some degree of coverage downfield, for both good and bad reasons.

My biggest complaint about the receivers, honestly, is that McCarthy is trying to make "Wilson" happen.  Wilson is really good at being meep-meep gone but like you noted, his routes leave something to be desired.  It's been a couple of games now where he just locks onto him from the snap and come hell or high water he's throwing it to him downfield.  He's fast and I get it; he's open even if he's only got a step on a guy.  But my biggest fear about Iowa (and future good defensive opponents) is that they bait McCarthy into trying to make those throws when there are better ones available shorter.  I expect that to improve with more game reps but Wilson probably shouldn't be force-fed as many deep shots as he has these couple of games.

Koop

September 28th, 2022 at 8:59 AM ^

I'm inclined to give the edge rushers a pass this week because it felt like 90+% of Maryland's passes came out on a shotgun two-second read--contributing to the dink-and-dunk screen game and lack of downfield completions. OTOH, I was very concerned to see Maryland gaining 3-4 yards per carry on what appeared to be solid O-line surges. If Maryland's line is moving Smith, Jenkins, and company off their spots, that's ... not good.

And I, too, am not overly concerned about JJ's performance. Doubtful we'll see many more teams drop 8 and rush 3.

AC1997

September 26th, 2022 at 5:44 PM ^

I think so much of our "feelings" about the game, outcome, defense, margin, etc. was altered by that last stupid Maryland drive that it is hard to put it in context.  Here's what I mean...

I watched the game on delay.  While avoiding the internet I did get one text message that popped up saying "what an ugly game" from a buddy.  When I watched the recording I expected the worst.  After the Corum TD I was about to text that guy back saying we were a Moody miss away from covering a 17 point spread in a game where we missed every deep pass and penalties were turned off on the EA Sports Menu.  

As for that last drive, I think the defense assumed the game was won and sort of went thru the motions.  Specifically I thought they celebrated TFLs as if they ended the game while Maryland was setting up the next play and marching down the field.  That to me is a "first real game" problem that the coaches can yell at them about this week.  

Long way of saying that I was more encouraged than discouraged by all aspects of this game.  My only real concern was our pass rush, depth at RB, and getting Hill-Green back on the field at LB.

Richard75

September 26th, 2022 at 6:00 PM ^

The point about Roman Wilson is interesting. Using a receiver his size as your primary deep threat does indeed seem like a suboptimal approach…but then, 5-foot-10 Tyreek Hill is the best  there is.

Not saying Wilson is that caliber, but on this level he might very well be the fastest guy on the field whenever he’s out there. 

lhglrkwg

September 26th, 2022 at 6:01 PM ^

Between Cornelius' drop and this:

One frustrating item. Just last week we saw SMU's Rashee Rice repeatedly dunk on Maryland defensive backs. Rice is a big leapy guy in the vein of a couple of Michigan receivers and other than the unplanned chuck above we did not see Michigan test anyone on a back shoulder fade or other Nico Collins go-get-it special.

I guess I'm wondering when/if Andrel doesn't start to eat some of Johnson's snaps. I've got tons of smaller, route-artisan receivers. What we seem to need is a 'go up and get it' guy and Cornelius really hasn't flashed that. That ball Nico either would've gotten or would've drawn a DPI on. Andrel seems to have that skill and it would really make this offense killer if you had a guy who could do half of what Nico did 

ak47

September 26th, 2022 at 6:33 PM ^

On the one hand, I think you are being a little too easy on JJ given that he threw two passes that easily could have been interceptions and also fumbled the ball.

On the other hand I think you are being very harsh on the Gash RPO decision. Look where his eyes are, he's not reading that defensive back when making the give or keep decision because he's not the read man. Of course in an ideal world you'd like them to see the CB blitz coming pre-snap but really think that is actually just an RPS win for Maryland, they blitzed the CB and that changed who should have been the read guy in a way that JJ really can't switch to mid play because he can't read two guys at once. Once that blitz wasn't picked up on pre-snap JJ was just reading the line of scrimmage for a give pull decision, if he had chosen to pull it then becomes a does he keep and run or throw the pass. But its a sequential decision, he can't read the end of the line and the CB at the same time.

Brimley

September 26th, 2022 at 6:36 PM ^

In 1991, FSU and Bobby Bowden came into Michigan Stadium and hung 51 on us.  One big play: the around the world throw back to the QB with a convoy of blockers.  Michigan co-opted and made it our own.  I'd like to see the same with the option/shovel pass.

jsquigg

September 26th, 2022 at 7:34 PM ^

Great recap per usual. I could be wrong but on that Corum wheel route I'm pretty sure the safety was gunning that way. I'm not saying the throw shouldn't have been made, but the timing to make that throw was smaller and less obvious than it seemed.

Go Blue Beat T…

September 26th, 2022 at 10:45 PM ^

Left a comment after game one about Cade turfing some throws likely being a mechanical/footwork issue instead of nerves or whatever else it may have been and JJs sounds mechanics allowing him to deliver accurately thrown balls with great consistency, saying there’s no grade for footwork for the QB evaluation. Devin’s analysis shows that the deep balls missed Saturday were very fixable as his footwork seemed to throw off his accuracy on the deep ball. That said, 18/26 w no picks and a Td is a great floor. Can’t wait to see him break the ceiling against Sparty.

As an aside, QB1 against #TuckComin’ should be automatically DQed from consideration for B1G offensive POW honors. Blake was robbed of the spotlight. 

CFraser

September 27th, 2022 at 12:31 AM ^

I think the safety heading towards the sideline stopped JJ from throwing that wheel to Corum. He probably wasn’t going to get there, especially with JJ’s arm, but that’s probably why he tucked it. 

uminks

September 27th, 2022 at 2:11 AM ^

The defense played about the way I thought. The offense really should have scored 50+ on the MD defense. I think M offense could have scored on every position. If JJ would have hit 2 of those long passes in the first half the offense would have went on to win big. We need to score 30+ points every game. We need to keep up with OSU point drive by point drive. If it is 41-45 in the 4th in Columbus one good bounce of the ball Michigan's way could make the difference in winning in Columbus. I just hope the offense keeps improving and we don't get conservative on offense at Iowa. I would hate to see a low scoring game go Iowa's way. We need to score 30 points on the Iowa D.

mgobaran

September 27th, 2022 at 11:33 AM ^

Never felt the need to hmm and hawww during this game. It was an entertaining football game! 

At the end of the day this was the first start for McCarthy against real competition. And the first game for the OCs/DC against real competition. There were flaws. We overcame. Let's worry about this game more if this turns into a pattern. Otherwise it's just a somewhat off game against a decent team. Remember the 2021 Rutgers game? Shit happens

Don

September 28th, 2022 at 1:26 PM ^

This isn't the first time that Brian has made a passing reference to something that I have no clue about, but I don't get the reference to Sinatra.