SWFLWolverine

January 5th, 2021 at 9:29 AM ^

 

https://www.sports-reference.com/cfb/coaches/nick-saban-1.html

Saban's dynamic run did not really begin until 2008. At MSU he was 6-5-1, 6-6, 7-5, 6-6, 9-2 (34-24-1). At LSU he went 8-4, 10-3, 8-5, 13-1, 9-3 (48-16). Overall he ranks #17 for all time win % at .799. Meyer is the #3 all time win % at .854 behind Rockne and Leahy and he has the highest bowl win% at .800. 

My conclusion is that Meyer is more an Xs and Os coach and Saban is a Jimmyies and Joes coach. Obviously you need some of each to be a successful as both men are, but on a level playing field, I take Meyer over Saban.

Phaedrus

January 5th, 2021 at 12:09 PM ^

My understanding is that they are both Xs and Os guys, just on opposite sides of the ball.

Personally, I would take Saban over Meyer. Both win, both cheat, but Saban isn’t a sanctimonious ass about it and he doesn’t protect murderers and wife beaters from legal repercussions (that we know of). Meyer is a dirtbag human being whose competitiveness stresses him out to the point of being unhealthy for both him and those around him. One could argue that Saban has had more success because he doesn’t let the job overwhelm him. 

1VaBlue1

January 5th, 2021 at 8:55 AM ^

His recruiting at BGSU and Utah was also pretty darn good - for the levels those schools were at.  He out-crooted the MAC when he was winning at BGSU, and he was recruiting a step below PAC 10 level when coaching at Mountain West member Utah.  Those schools are not going to regionally out-croot Michigan, OSU, USC, and UW, let alone do so nationally.  He was still recruiting above his level at those schools, though...

Glennsta

January 5th, 2021 at 8:51 AM ^

Ridiculous request?  He might as well ask for $20M. If someone is dumb enough to pay him, why begrudge him taking it?

A lawyer buddy of mine hated doing bankruptcy cases, just hated them. But he still had former clients referring him new clients who would be asking if he could handle their case. Finally, he decided, screw it and he more than doubled his fee.

His rationale was that reference to the old analogy of life being like a shit sandwich; the more bread you got, the less you taste the shit.

Parenthetically, it didn't work. He got more referrals than ever; it seemed like these new clients were thinking that he must have been the best bankruptcy attorney ever: just LOOK at how much he charges.

Navy Wolverine

January 5th, 2021 at 6:17 AM ^

Carson Wentz makes an average of $32M per year. Kirk Cousins $33M.

I guess $12M seems like a relative bargain compared to that when you get someone who could be a game changing coach like Meyer. Plus he doesn't even count against the salary cap.

M-GO-Beek

January 5th, 2021 at 9:10 AM ^

Yeah, if Gruden is making $10mil/year and hasn't won anything since he has been back (and after not being a coach for 10 years). If he can get $10, then I certainly think it is reasonable for Urbs to argue for $12. Plus those NFL make money hand over fist with a hard salary cap on players. The owners can and will splurge.

UofM Die Hard …

January 5th, 2021 at 4:30 PM ^

ha you said it best...if he is asking for that much for never coaching a down in teh NFL, he doesnt care if he does or doesn't.  Why wouldnt you ask for that much...he knows he would take a lot of losses to his stellar career so I would do the same. 

I dont see it happening if this is the price, be paid more that arguably the greatest coach in history (Bill B.)...uh yeah, not sure about that. 

A Lot of Milk

January 5th, 2021 at 7:51 AM ^

He wants more money than any current NFL coach, despite never coaching a single down in the NFL at any level, and with a track record of prematurely leaving his last two jobs because of cheating/scandal/health reasons, meaning he's a huge flight risk if anything goes badly which is more likely than the alternative. Honestly he sounds perfect for the cowboys

ih8losing

January 5th, 2021 at 7:52 AM ^

Good on him. Use your leverage, ask high when negotiating, bet on yourself. All things we do when getting a new job, especially when being recruited! 

1VaBlue1

January 5th, 2021 at 8:28 AM ^

Well now, there's no need for me to make an original comment...  LOL!!  But yeah, he's proven himself at multiple locations and levels of football.  If you think it translates to the NFL, then pay the money for a great coach.  If you don't, he still has a cushy TV job...

Personally, I don't think his brand of football translates well, at all.  His offense is fairly basic and relies on superior athleticism and talent - advantages that can be obtained via recruiting in college, but don't really exist in the NFL.  His defense is mainly a backstop against a shootout - get a few stops and his offense will beat you - and also relies, to a lesser degree, on athleticism and talent.  Both units run fairly simple schemes.  He'll score some points in the NFL, but won't be able to out-athlete other teams.  I see a mediocre performance in the NFL for him.  His biggest asset as a coach, IMO, is that he is a fantastic identifier and recruiter of talent.