Vote_Crisler_1937

September 25th, 2022 at 7:51 PM ^

after looking at this pic it’s clear. Were he ever in earshot of me, I would say, “I’d ask how you feel about all that Jaguars stuff. But I can see you’ve eaten all those feelings already.”  
 

Then find a hundred other ways to to say emasculating things around the fact that he’s clearly put on belly fat. 

DetroitDan

September 25th, 2022 at 5:43 PM ^

Urban is still upset that they didn't overturn DJ Turner's first half interception. I think Turner's int deserved to stand.  The ball hit the ground, but DJ controlled it all the way.  Sometimes best to leave the call on the field if there's not clear cut evidence to overturn.

goblu330

September 25th, 2022 at 6:13 PM ^

It was the most “in the spirit of an interception” play ever.  If you looked at it under a legit microscope my guess is the ground helped it but not reviewing it was the right move.  Frankly I wish they would let plays like that stand more often all around instead of reviewing every play where there is a chance of reversal.  If Maryland had made that play I would have been like “yeah that was nice.”

FB Dive

September 25th, 2022 at 6:51 PM ^

It should have been reviewed, but it also should have stood as called. Replay showed him with firm control of the ball both going to the ground and immediately after hitting the ground. His left hand/forearm was underneath the ball and we didn't have an angle clearly showing if/how the ball moved off the left hand/arm when he hit the ground. The fact the ball touches the ground is meaningless, what matters is whether he lost control of it when the ball hits the ground.

If it's a de novo review, then fine, I'm probably overturning it. But it's not, and you can only overturn if the replay clearly and indisputably shows the call was wrong. A single, fuzzy angle of his left hand's fingers slightly moving off the ball while his palm and forearm are still underneath it is not sufficient to reverse under that standard of review -- especially when you have to replay it in slow-mo to even notice it. 

goblu330

September 25th, 2022 at 8:01 PM ^

They do review it de novo though.  That isn’t how they are supposed to, but in practice that is what they do.  That is why it is better if they just don’t call down for the review on plays like that.  And they would have called it incomplete even though there was not even close to indisputable visual evidence either way. 

joegeo

September 25th, 2022 at 10:41 PM ^

His right wrist is on the ball. The left hand is fully visible with empty palm and fingers. Maybe it’s hard for you to visualize from this one screen grab, but it’s even more clear if you watch the frame or two before and after.

Yeah I think it’s indisputable and the refs blew the call. At the very least, their choice to not review it - this wasn’t a random spot or something, it was a major play, a turnover - was clearly a mistake.

To be clear, Im glad they made the mistake!

Durham Blue

September 26th, 2022 at 12:45 PM ^

But did the ball ever contact the ground even though it slipped from his hands and appeared to move to between his left forearm and right wrist?  That's really tough to see on replay.  The call on the field was INT and I think would've stood as called had they reviewed it.  Plus, Michigan is the home team and should get the benefit of the doubt on something that is so close to 50/50.

mitchewr

September 26th, 2022 at 9:57 AM ^

"Sometimes"? Lol, that's literally what the rule is supposed to be ALL the time. You ONLY overturn the call on the field if there's undeniable, undisputable video evidence. That means, no hemming or hawing, no "I dunno...it kinda", no "well from this angle it sorta"...none of that.

How on earth replay officials get this wrong so many times is mind boggling. We ought to see (across college football in general) far less overturning the call on the field than we actually do...because there just isn't that much "indisputable" video evidence on most plays.

Indy Pete - Go Blue

September 25th, 2022 at 6:16 PM ^

urban M still has a huge Michigan complex despite his success against our program at osu. It’s amazing how insecure Ohio state people are about Michigan - even when they owned us for two decades. It’s great to be a Michigan Wolverine - and it is miserable to be  the worst NFL coach of all time. 

mitchewr

September 26th, 2022 at 9:59 AM ^

That's an interesting thought experiment...what if Urban had come here instead of Ohio State and we became the program that won a national championship and almost never lost a conference game for his whole duration and then subsequently would have Ryan Day as our current head coach...

What would the fanbase think if that alternate reality had happened?

Blinkin

September 25th, 2022 at 6:47 PM ^

This is why urban shouldn't be allowed to do broadcast. He can't hide his bias. I understand everyone has a viewpoint or a preference, but real pros can hide it from the general public.