This picture encapsulates all of us [Patrick Barron]

Michigan 30, East Carolina 3 Comment Count

Alex.Drain September 2nd, 2023 at 4:48 PM

The B1G on Peacock Era opened with a brilliant first 35 minutes from JJ McCarthy, followed by a comatose 25 minutes that begged the question "what's the point?" before culminating in the saddest field goal of all Sad Field Goals. East Carolina snapped the shutout to preserve whatever pride they had left but head back to Greenville soundly defeated, the 30-3 score perhaps not even the best reflection of the lopsided nature of the game when both starting units were in. Michigan taking their foot off the gas is all that prevented the Big House turf from flowing red with Pirate blood. 

East Carolina got the ball to begin the game and went three and out, with Michigan safety Keon Sabb, in his first career college start, getting a PBU to end the drive. Michigan was indeed short-handed with injuries but not quite as severe as perhaps anticipated. Makari Paige did play, while Will Johnson warmed up but did not appear in the contest. ECU punted it deep and Jake Thaw did not catch it, instead letting it roll down to the two. Backed up in the shadow of their own goal line, Michigan was as conservative as it gets, running three times into run blitzes and then punting. 

ECU's next drive didn't go any better, two run plays that were stuffed before QB Mason Garcia fired under pressure from Kenneth Grant, short-arming the ball and leaving it off target, plucked out of the air for an INT by Mike Sainristil. Michigan's ensuing drive was the first of five straight that would end in points and the beginning of the fireworks display from JJ McCarthy. But first was a play that will make headlines: the return of the train play from 2016, a tribute to the suspended Jim Harbaugh (several players including McCarthy wore "Free Harbaugh" shirts to the game). 

[Bryan Fuller]

But once the luster of the train wore off, it was a beautiful showing of offense. McCarthy zipped a ball in to Roman Wilson on an out route to get it going. Blake Corum galloped for 21 down to the 15 and two plays later, McCarthy sidestepped pressure, rolled, and just as he was crossing the line of scrimmage, fired a dart to Wilson in the end zone for a TD. McCarthy appeared to be across the line of scrimmage, but the referees ruled that just enough of his back foot was on the line to leave the call on the field and uphold the TD. 7-0 Michigan. 

The Pirates picked up their first first down on the next drive, a QB sneak from Mason Garcia, but punted on the next series after pressure on 3rd & 11 forced Garcia to abandon the designed passing play and scramble short of the line to gain. Back on offense, the Wolverines went down and scored again. JJ McCarthy started it with a 20 yard bullet to Cornelius Johnson and then hooked up with Roman Wilson on a 3rd & 7. Blake Corum's long run down the sideline went for 37 yards and got the Wolverines to the goal line. Corum punched it in from two yards out, his first TD since last year's knee injury against Illinois. 14-0. 

East Carolina's fourth drive was their longest of the game, going for 32 yards, and it was led by a new QB: Alex Flinn. The veteran seemed to calm the Pirate offense down and got them moving, but then fired a seeming interception to Michigan corner Josh Wallace. It appeared to your author that Wallace secured the catch with both feet in bounds, but after review, the call was overturned. Peacock never showed us comprehensive replays or explained why it was overturned, so your guess is as good as mine. Nevertheless, Sainristil broke up a fade and Michigan forced another punt. 

[Patrick Barron]

McCarthy was right back on his game on Michigan's next possession. On four consecutive plays McCarthy converted a 3rd & 11 with a strike to Cornelius Johnson, hit Colston Loveland on play-action for 24, found Loveland on a 15 yard out, and then scrambled and uncorked a laser to Roman Wilson in the end zone for a TD. Yowza! Transfer kicker James Turner shanked the extra point and Michigan led 20-0 with 5:32 remaining in the first half. 

On the next possession, for the first time all game, East Carolina drove into Michigan territory and got a chance to score points. Sloppy tackling from the Wolverines allowed ECU to pick up a pair of third-and-short/mediums and sail their way inside the Wolverine 35 as time ticked under 90 seconds remaining. However, Michigan's LBs stuffed the first down run, Kris Jenkins forced Flinn to throw the ball away, and then a throw for Jaylon Johnson (defended by Sabb) was ruled incomplete after a review (seemed obvious at the time). Curiously, Michigan seemed to have 12 players on the field and a flag was thrown but after the review, the penalty was never enforced and instead ECU faced a 51 yard FG. Coach Mike Houston sent Andrew Conrad out there, who pushed the kick wide. 

Michigan now had a shorter field and time to drive for a field goal of their own, with 48 seconds remaining in the half. McCarthy short-armed his first couple throws but overall had little problem directing the offense into field goal range. A 12 yard pass to Wilson and then a 9 yard delivery to Frederick Moore, the true freshman's first NCAA catch, set Turner up for a 50 yard FG. The grad student kicker banged it right down the middle (would've been good from 60) and Michigan led 23-0 at halftime. 

[AFTER THE JUMP: second half, takes, box score]

[Bryan Fuller]

The second half began just as the first half had ended with JJ McCarthy swashbucklin', slicing and dicing the Pirate defense en route to another scoring play. Blake Corum and Donovan Edwards picked up chunks on the ground in between great throws by McCarthy. His best was the one that concluded the drive, a dime to Roman Wilson in the corner of the end zone, perfectly placed between the coverage. Wilson's third TD catch of the game and McCarthy's third TD pass of the game. 30-0. 

East Carolina went three-and-out on their first possession of the second half and Michigan was right back at it on offense. McCarthy's surgical precision was still present: seven yard pass to Edwards followed by 14 yards to Loveland. Edwards rushed Michigan into Pirate territory and a couple plays later, McCarthy scrambled and threw seconds before getting blasted up high, a roughing the passer with targeting that made all of us say "why is JJ still in the game?". Don't worry, this would be his last drive. McCarthy's final pass of the day went for 15 yards to Johnson and after an unnecessary roughness penalty on ECU, Michigan had 1st & G at the six.

This situation led to a profoundly stupid sequence, where interim coach Jesse Minter and playcaller Kirk Campbell displayed appalling stubbornness in trying to get Donovan Edwards a TD. They got five shots at it (one play was initially ruled a TD, then marked short after replay but an offsides penalty was accepted to replay the down), five run plays all designed for Edwards inside the six yard line, and Michigan did not score. East Carolina was doing what they'd done all day, packing the box and telling Michigan to do something else. This time, Michigan declined. It probably would've helped to use a short yardage back like Corum or Kalel Mullings too, but Michigan needed to get Edwards a TD like humans need oxygen. Instead, it burned them with a stupid result capped off by a 4th down play (McCarthy fumbled the snap) that had fans writhing with TCU flashbacks. 

[Bryan Fuller]

Michigan wouldn't score again, pulling the starters and phoning it in on offense, slamming into a wall against an ECU defense that was dead set to stop the run. They didn't let Davis Warren off the leash and when Warren threw, he didn't look particularly special. Sloppy discipline leading to pre-snap penalties set some of these drives back and the closest they got to scoring was a Turner 52-yard FG attempt, which was hooked way wide.

Defensively, an ever-increasing hodgepodge of players off the depth chart let the Pirates drive, but had a shutout going until the final play of the game. ECU got down to the 14 with just over 6 minutes to go and chose not to attempt a Sad Field Goal, Mason Garcia (who had re-entered the game) scrambling short of the line to gain and turning it over on downs. On their second trip into Michigan territory of the half, Mike Houston changed his mind. Down to the 16 with five seconds left, he lined up Andrew Conrad for a 33 yard attempt and this time, Conrad fit it through. Shutout no more, the clock operator mercifully letting two additional seconds run off the clock and the game was over. 30-3. 

There's only so much you can say about this kind of game and a re-watch will be more illuminating for the most intriguing parts of this game, the offensive tackles and the DBs. Michigan's running game lacked the luster of last year, RBs gaining 132 yards on 29 carries (4.6 YPC) but on the initial review, this seemed to be very much a strategic decision by ECU. As for pass protection, to ECU's credit, they tried all kinds of funky blitzes and some of them had success. McCarthy was just too slippery and the coverage not tight enough to stop Michigan's blazing passing game. 

[Patrick Barron]

McCarthy will undoubtedly be the story of this game, should there be any story that lasts in the popular memory for more than 15 minutes. #9 was a maestro in this contest, 26/30 for 280 yards (9.3 Y/A), 3 TD, 0 INT. His throws were right on the money all day long, some of them into tight windows. McCarthy's arm strength was apparent, save for a couple throws late in the first half. The balls were launched from a cannon, crisp accuracy and decision-making gusto that provides encouraging evidence in support of the sort of junior-year leap that feels so essential for Michigan's quest to end a 26-year national title drought. 

Defensively I don't have too many notes, as Michigan was switching out defensive players frequently. ECU's offensive line was totally overwhelmed, as expected in my preview, but again, they were well prepared for that reality, a credit to the coaching of Houston's staff. They got the ball out in a hurry to nerf the pass rush and tried to spread it out on the ground east to west to prevent Michigan from detonating their offense as much as possible. Michigan's young and inexperienced secondary seemed fine on first watch, but again, UFR will be much more useful for this analysis. If I had one stand-out hero on defense, it was NT Kenneth Grant, a regularly disruptive presence up the middle swatting Pirate linemen aside like flies. 

Special teams saw Turner have a bumpy Michigan debut, the two 50+ yard FG attempts with extremely different results and a disconcerting 3/4 day on PAT's. Tommy Doman looked fine as Michigan's punter, 2 punts for 89 yards. Michigan used Jake Thaw twice as a punt returner and Karmello English once. No sign of Kalel Mullings or of Alex Orji on kick return. Alas. 

Michigan has now won their season opener for the fifth straight season and is 7-2 in week one in the Jim Harbaugh Era. Next up is UNLV a week from today, a contest which doesn't project to be any more competitive. Sherrone Moore will be back as offensive coordinator but Jim Harbaugh will still be suspended. That game is scheduled for 3:30 pm EST and will be broadcast on CBS. 

Comments

MGoBlue96

September 2nd, 2023 at 7:32 PM ^

I mean Minter had to do some funky things to generate pressure last year because they struggled at generating pass rush organically. I am going to withhold judgement based on the grand total sample size of one game and ECU getting the ball out quick,  but there is no way they win the NC they want this year without getting more individual organic pressure from the edges. So it didn't really get fixed last year, it was just schemed around by Minter and quite frankly the lack of organic pressure and getting caught in blitzes was part of the loss to TCU.

leftrare

September 2nd, 2023 at 5:17 PM ^

Alex, please tell us you had your tongue firmly planted to your cheek when you used the phrase about the shadow of the goal line. Please. 
 

It might be the most annoying adage that announcers make. The goal POST casts a shadow.  The goal line, since it’s on the ground, can only cast a shadow on the dirt beneath it. 

MMBbones

September 2nd, 2023 at 8:31 PM ^

"It might be the most annoying adage that announcers make. The goal POST casts a shadow.  The goal line, since it’s on the ground, can only cast a shadow on the dirt beneath it. "

Eh. I'm as pro-grammar-nazi as the next guy. But some euphemisms are so widely used that to criticize them is a bit pedantic. Like "begs the question" being used incorrectly most of the time. At a certain point, you just accept it as an alternative use of English, which continues to be a very fluid language.

“This is the type of arrant pedantry up with which I will not put.” -- Churchill

leftrare

September 2nd, 2023 at 9:19 PM ^

Just to be clear, let me just say I very much appreciate what Alex does and yes, I’m picking a nit here because it bugs me. 
 

but this is not a grammar thing. It’s a malaprop. Some play by play guy, presumably many decades ago, referred to the shadow of the goal post. And that was fine. When the goal posts got moved from the goal line to the end line, it lost some of its meaning. And then at some point, somebody like Brent Musberger gaffed his way into referring to the goal line and it’s shadow. And it stuck. This won’t keep me from calling it out. 
 

 

soniktoothe

September 2nd, 2023 at 10:19 PM ^

If you want to pick nits then don't call it a malaprop. That would be if someone called the goal line a gold mine. It would be similar to one of my malaprop pet peeves where I live, *chester drawers*. 

Does it defy the logic of of the things that it describes? Definitely. It is simply an idiom that has gained traction. There are a many idioms that don't make sense. Language is fluid and you can't control its evolution over time. 

grumbler

September 3rd, 2023 at 1:33 PM ^

A malaprop would be like someone saying "goal line" instead of "goal post."  Similar-sounding phrases but very different meanings.  No one would consciously refer to the shadow of a line.

Malaprops can turn into idioms, for sure, but this isn't one of them.  It's just a common mistake.

UMfan21

September 2nd, 2023 at 5:22 PM ^

I may be wrong, but I'm pretty sure Mullings was in for the kick return to open the 2nd half.  It went deep into the end zone for no return, but he was the closest player.

outsidethebox

September 2nd, 2023 at 5:22 PM ^

Could not watch the game live. Reviewing the roster of who made defensive tackles is rather stunning-showing that at least 10 players who were not on the team last year or played a very limited number of snaps were significant contributors in this game. 

East Carolina is a well-coached team and this and the number of players Michigan used mitigated the final score. 

The highlights show JJ to be incredibly talented-for those who are wandering. 

aiglick

September 2nd, 2023 at 5:26 PM ^

First 35 minutes fantastic and then some bleh with the starters out. Got some backups some valuable minutes. Overall solid work. Go Blue onto UNLV.

Quailman

September 2nd, 2023 at 5:29 PM ^

"Peacock never showed us comprehensive replays or explained why it was overturned, so your guess is as good as mine"

I don't mean this with snark, but I thought in the couple replays we got it was kinda obvious they thought the receiver touched it while oob, making it incomplete

 

DennisFranklinDaMan

September 2nd, 2023 at 5:44 PM ^

Nice write-up (with the unfortunate (but increasingly common) misuse of the phrase "begging the question"). That's a fairly familiar Michigan early-season win against a cupcake, with a meaningless second half played as if it were a formality, which it was.

A friend asked me if he should take Michigan and the points, yesterday, and I advised him not to, pointing out that we're not really the kind of program that usually runs up the score in these games, often because we bring in the second team and then focus on running the ball. Sure enough ...

Anyway, the first half certainly showed our dominance, and I'm pleased. Though our first TD was an absolute gift, and a perfect rejoinder to those Michigan fans who scream that we never get a break. JJ was 100% over the line of scrimmage when he let that ball go. Bizarre.

Still, dominance. I wonder, if Harbaugh had been there, would we have been as quick to go to the passing game, in the first half? 

MGoCarolinaBlue

September 2nd, 2023 at 7:07 PM ^

Came here to say the same thing: "begging the question" does not mean "motivating or suggesting or prompting the question"; it refers instead to the specific informal logical fallacy of assuming the conclusion, AKA circular reasoning.

It's easy to see why this misunderstanding of the phrase is so common, and I'm not one to rag on somebody for this kind of mistake. I just want to let people know, because if it were me using the term wrong, I would want to be informed about it, and then I would be delighted to have learned something new.

Hannibal.

September 2nd, 2023 at 5:47 PM ^

OL had their worst game run blocking since at least 2019.  Way too much reliance on JJ McCarthy to convert 3rd and 10s.  If the officials get that illegal forward pass call right and we maybe miss one or two of those 3rd and 10s and 3rd and 11s, this game feels a lot worse.

Failing to run the ball against a cream puff like ECU has historically been very ill tidings for Michigan. ECU might have been packing the box but that's because we had an extra tackle and two tight ends out there a lot of the time.  Guys were getting whipped one on one and if an O-lineman got a second level block all day, I missed it.

Worst game for special teams that I can remember in quite some time too. 

But the Marcus Hall double bird moment definitely belongs to the moment that the B1G signed this shitass TV deal that put the game on Peacock.  Their game coverage was absolutely shitty and you still had to sit through commercials.  They missed a full Michigan play because they showed the replay of Kalel Mullings's pass from last year three times.  And Chris Simms offered nothing of value commentary-wise.  Just banal crap and no virtually no breakdowns of plays. I wholeheartedly endorse piracy at this point. 

And I'm so glad that the NCAA has eliminated 10% of the plays from scrimmage this year.  If there's anything we college football fans hate, it's plays from scrimmage.  Fortunately, tickets are 10% cheaper to account for it, amirite?

stephenrjking

September 2nd, 2023 at 7:48 PM ^

Guys were getting whipped one on one

Just did a rewatch and this is not true, at least of the OL; Loveland and Bredeson had a miss or two each.

ECU was firing into gaps and charging LBs and a safety to the LOS. That can definitely stymie runs, even with an effective OL. The counter to this is to throw the ball into the empty space behind them. 

Which Michigan did. Over and over and over. From the first real drive on. 

 

rcgoblue

September 2nd, 2023 at 11:00 PM ^

I am a bit confused by the O line breakdown. I know they are probably testing different starters next week, but the run blocking was certainly a concern. I wouldnt be surpised at all if the concepts work a lot better as with Sherrone Moore on the sidelines next week. I wonder if the adjustments were lacking today. Going to be more of a growth process than I was anticipating. 

1VaBlue1

September 3rd, 2023 at 8:33 AM ^

So I guess you're unable to count and to notice when LBs and safeties come up for run support at the snap.  We are all very familiar with continuing to run into stacked boxes (8-9 in the box) - we complain about it all year long every season because it never works!  Yet, here you are, complaining about a bad running game simply because you can't see what's actually happening. 

Newsflash: they were running into stacked boxes all day long.

However, they also threw over the top early and often to negate the stacking, except that ECU never backed off.  Instead of finding something to complain about, how about paying attention to what was actually happening on the field?

djmagic

September 3rd, 2023 at 3:46 PM ^

I agree with your Sims sentiment.  More than a few times I got the impression that he watched a 20minute highlight reel in his hotel room before reading a single page scouting sheet while being driven to the Big House, and beyond that, didn't really know anything about the team; nor was his "analysis" very insightful.  I get it - not everyone can be Joel Klatt, but, c'mon.

and Peacock broadcast/coverage was, forgive me, for the birds.

J.W. Wells Co.

September 2nd, 2023 at 5:57 PM ^

Goal lines are flat on the ground. They don’t have shadows. The correct saying is, “in the shadow of their own goalPOSTS.”

Just like some moron at some point idiotically started referring to a hook-and-lateral play as “hook and ladder.” There are no ladders out there. Just laterals after the guy running the hook route catches the ball.

rc90

September 2nd, 2023 at 9:44 PM ^

I'm pretty sure I've heard it called "hook and ladder" since 1982, the Kellen Winslow game. That is an old, old mistake, and at this point it's kinda accepted, like using 'fun' as an adjective or saying 'most unique' or (groan) using 'I' instead of 'me' as the object of a preposition ('between you and I, this one is the most unique of fun times.')

Ick.

AlbanyBlue

September 2nd, 2023 at 6:00 PM ^

Big picture stuff:

On offense -- JJ not hesitant today and right on his game. No ball patting or confusion I could see. OL is a work in progress as compared to the last two seasons, but I think that's by design (the "Michigan Method" stuff).

On defense -- Looks like a viable CB2 in Wallace. Interior D seemed excellent but edge-setting might need some attention. LB play seemed improved, but I'll wait for UFR on that.

Special teams -- Punting fine. The shank XP is worrisome. Turner could have missed the first long one and made the second, that would have been fine (since I had ECU +21.5 1st half). 

Coaching -- Roster management and play calling seemed fine when it mattered. Obviously everything got shut down in the second half.

Just fine overall against a tomato can. Get healthy. Onto UNLV.

mi93

September 2nd, 2023 at 6:14 PM ^

On the Wallace INT, the ECU WR had a hand on the ball while being clearly OOB.  I'm pretty sure that's why it was overturned seeing as the play is immediately dead at that point.

Fan from TTDS

September 3rd, 2023 at 8:08 AM ^

Did you see CJ Stroud play against MN in his first start after Justin Fields went to the NFL?  At that time there were fans who wanted Stroud benched and McCord to take over.  This year McCord and Devin Brown are neck and neck in practice and Day decided to start McCord yesterday.  The QB battle will continue over the next two weeks and I think Day will find his guy when we play ND on 9/23.  MI last year had a QB battle between McCarthy and McNamara and McCarthy is still not a finished product.

I trust Ryan Day with the QB room given the fact that his last three guys Justin Fields, Dwayne Haskins (RIP), and CJ Stroud were all invited to New York City as Heisman Finalists and were all drafted in the 1st rounds of the NFL draft.  Will McCord or Brown be invited to NY and be drafted in the 1st round?  At this time we don't have enough stats to even make an educated guess.

Go Blue Beat T…

September 3rd, 2023 at 2:56 PM ^

Your conversion rate on third and fourth and short continues a multi year trend toward atrocious. 
don’t need stats sometimes to see some guys just don’t have … it. MHJ looked so frustrated all day. 
 

hard to judge your D against IU. A lot more looked open and vulnerable that better teams will take advantage of. Looks like losses to ND, Penn St., Wisconsin, probably Maryland, and of course on 11/25. 
with the AD retiring whoever is coming in is going to have to find their coach…no way you get “urbz” back. The dethroning is nearing completion. Frickin finally. Nearly twenty damn year run. NIL levels the recruiting field. Your program is no longer what it was.  

The FannMan

September 2nd, 2023 at 8:09 PM ^

Nice write-up.  JJ is That Dude. He was making NFL throws for fun.  Other than that, I’m already forgetting this game. 

By the way, I don’t recall the ref at the game explaining why the INT was overturned either.