pin & pull variations

Neck Sharpies: Oh No You Fed Pin and Pull After Midnight Comment Count

Seth June 29th, 2020 at 9:51 AM

HTTV NOTE: Our kickstarter ends TOMORROW for HTTV. We plan on having at least two live, socially distanced pickup events in August. One at…

image

Five Shores Brewing up north in Beulah, Michigan. Neck Sharpies/HTTV sponsor Matt Demorest didn't pick the best year to open a brewery, but he did pick the best brewer, and also a location that has lots of outdoor space so you can lawn it this year. If you're in the Traverse area this summer stop in and try it. Watch this space for updates on the pickup events and how those are going to work while keeping the safety of our readers foremost.

-----------------------------------------------

Someone not yet very practiced at the art of explaining things once described to me why Pokemon is so popular. Forgive me if I get any of this wrong but as I understand it you capture a basal creature with some kind of elemental property. Then you train it. After a certain point your creature gains access to more of its baked-in power, and then with more training it reaches a level of maturity where it can use that same basic elemental ability to deal with all situations. To reach its final iteration you have to add some kind of outside element, at which point your Pokemon is a spiky, accoutrement-covered bad-ass.

image

And I thought that's a lot like how football plays work. You've got your basic play, and as you get better at it you can run it from different looks and adapt it on the fly to whatever the defense is doing to it. #SpeedInSpace is that added item, which one determining the thing's ultimate form.

The offensive gameplan for the Citrus Bowl was really the culmination of a season in which Michigan steadily tweaked and improved their base Pin & Pull running game. One of the ways they did this was to toy with motions, personnel, and formations to create the matchups they desired on the outside. Observe this beauty:

I call it Pin & Pullazord.

image

There's a LOT going on with this play, too much to unpack with one graphic. I expect you already know how to play Pin & Pull, and its intermediate forms so we can go right to Level 64 and beyond.

[After THE JUMP: add Held Item BenchMasonite]

THE BACKSIDE IS A TRIPLE-OPTION

image

Score covered Nico so I added him back

Hearkening back to the 2017 Ohio State game when Michigan first unleashed its Pin & Pull stuff, the backside of this play has two quarterback options baked in. One is a zone read of the Jack (Alabama's weakside OLB). The other is a pitch option to Mike Sainristil, who came across on orbit motion, versus the free safety.

image

HAVE DOWNBLOCK, WILL TRAVEL

Those dudes taken care of, let's return to the actual Pin & Pull. We'll start with the pin, which is a bit unusual. You can't really see those blocks well from that angle so here's another from the all-22 a coach sent me:

As in any P&P the offense will attempt to block down on the non-edge DL and the frontside linebacker. Those are typically advantageous blocks but here they're trusting Mayfield, Ruiz, and Runyan to block guys more or less lined up directly over them. It'll become even more difficult when those DL step playside right before the snap when they see motion.

image

Fortunately there's room to account for that. Note where Ruiz is snapping it above and where he is when Charbonnet is making his cut for the hole:

image

That isn't power blocking but stretch zone. Even if those backside pin blocks are in their gaps, it's fine so long as they don't get into the backfield. The key block is Mayfield's because he actually has to set the inside of the intended gap. When you talk about plays that made the NFL take notice of the guy not yet in the NFL, I bet this was one of them. It's one step to head off the DE, arms out to gain control, and then he swings the other leg around and anchors before the DE can push back. McKeon also sealed his guy far inside but the design of the defense allowed for that: the DL's playside shift is made good by the linebackers' taking inside gaps and that's all the hesitation McKeon needed.

image

Was this the playcall? Probably not. That's why this is an evolution of Pin & Pull: they're so used to running it they can adjust on the fly. Didn't get your downblock? Don't panic—zone block your guy and we'll get to it further outside.

SENIOR GUARDS ARE NICE

I would be remiss if I addressed this play without discussing why this became the base in the first place: Pin & Pull asks the guards to make very good split-second decisions and win those decisions with their size and agility. Emphasizing guard play was a good move for a team with fourth-year seniors Bredeson and Onwenu.

image

Mike Onwenu's job as the first puller is to set the right side of the run play. That means he has to get out there as quickly as he can, find the defender setting the edge of the defense, and deal with him. Ideally the play calls for Onwenu to kick out that defender, thus setting a gap between himself and Mayfield's "down" block. In this case he got the guy he expected—the SAM—trying to set a hard edge and force everything back inside. But you never know. Defenses like to swap out edge defenders to make this complicated, and even when you get the guy you expected in the spot you expected him, he might set a soft edge instead, diving inside of you and "playing to spill," trusting another defender to sweep around and string the play out to the edge or the next defended gap.

Onwenu has to do more than that, however. Remember this play isn't just a simple Pin and Pull but a Stretch Pin and Pull. The gap Charbonnet has to run through isn't on the hashmark where the SAM began but yards outside of it. The difference is how much Onwenu can move the guy.

image

Ben Bredeson as the second puller gets to do a different complicated thing. You can see WLB #8 giving chase from behind in the second frame above. That's the guy who would normally be flowing unmolested to the tap. Why is he in the backfield, and more importantly why is he so far behind Charbonnet it's not even worth his best effort to keep up anymore? Well, that's like Bredeson's concern, man.

The second puller's job, broadly defined, is to hit the first defender to appear in the hole. All this pinning and pulling takes time, and that's time every non-Rutger defense will use to get anyone available to the hole. There should be at least one available defender who relates to the running back, and then another defender who relates to the puller. Alabama believes they've got a way to get one of those guys, the WLB, to the ball against Pin & Pull without having to deal with the puller while covering all their gaps in case it's not: have the WLB blitz to where the second puller is vacating.

image

This is why I said the second puller's job is defined broadly. He's the only one who can catch the WLB, whom Bredeson must have been expecting to come across the formation and need to be dealt with later down the line. Bredeson cuts off his pull and gets enough on this very troublesome athlete to push #8's momentum away from the ball.

image

I'll save you a scroll if you want to watch these two blocks again.

Mmmmm seniors.

CHOOSE YOUR MATCHUPS

The last piece I want to talk about is what they're doing with BEN MASON. Typically when they've run Pin & Pull in the past they would just have another receiver out in a half-assed pattern to occupy a defender. That's a cheap way to get where you're going, sure, though it leaves the defense a few more options. What they can't undo is a good block.

Remember, a fullback is going to draw attention to where he's going, since that's usually where the ballcarrier is going as well. To make this worthwhile we don't want to just have Mason crash into any old linebacker or even a safety. Let's find him a maximum squishy cornerback perhaps?

That's accomplished by motioning Mike Sainristil across the formation right before the snap. Michigan is familiar with Alabama's base defense and that the reaction to this will be to rotate the safeties and the Rip/Liz call. Now they've got the safeties all moving away from the play they're ultimately going to have to stop.

image

The rotation also makes the SAM the curl/flat defender so he's not going to be blitzing into the run anymore. The cornerback becomes the overhang and has responsibility for the new #1 receiver to his side, which resolves into Mason. So he can't really scream into this either, else he leaves Mason out there all alone for a pass (come to think of it, they should teach an RB to look for a pop pass off this look next year).

Clearly this isn't the matchup Alabama wants—transfer cornerback Josh Jobe versus Ben Mason. But that's the tradeoff for the design of their defense so their cornerbacks can focus on #1 receivers, safeties and outside linebackers can play the curl/flat zones, and one safety is always the deep guy.

Initially of course the matchup is the SAM versus Mason, and you can see that because the SAM initially sets up for the fullback, after using his outside arm to fend off a false release step from McKeon. All of this creates confusion for that guy so Onwenu can make the play's key block. Now it's just up to Mason to take out the cornerback and all that green space—which might otherwise have been occupied by a receiver and cornerback dancing around downfield.

Why does this matter? Because…

image

I think my favorite part is as Charbonnet's being tackled, when Josh Jobe finds himself two yards past the numbers, and mistakenly believes Ben Mason's Ride to Hell is over before he gets an Oh-No-You-Don't yank right out of the frame.

image

The end.

Comments

lsjtre

June 29th, 2020 at 11:11 AM ^

Watching highlights of games like this one and the Game from 2017 make me cringe because the win was there if not for the only position on the field that failed so miserably to take the opportunities given them.

Let's hope the winner of the race for QB between Milton and McCaffrey yields the player to be able to finally do that

S.G. Rice

June 29th, 2020 at 10:32 AM ^

Motion from Giles Jackson causing reaction from the defense must have really been impressive, since he wasn't on the field, right?  Or was it Jackson and not Sanristil?

blueday

June 29th, 2020 at 10:59 AM ^

Was just at Five Shores. Great beer. Bike ride there from Frankfort for a beer treat and cans to for the return trip.

imafreak1

June 29th, 2020 at 11:33 AM ^

Michigan ran for 3.8 YPC and scored 16 points in this game.

It will be so neat when all of this great blocking and play calling turns into a successful run game, scoring points, and winning games.

I have to wonder if Gattis can scheme up some neat plays but still struggles to turn that into an effective game plan. The plan this game seemed to be taking advantage of the one on one coverage of the WR down the field. Which totally failed. Weird bad day by the QB or a plan that asked the QB to do something he couldn't do? Who can say?

On a positive note, this was more promising than the Army game.

username03

June 29th, 2020 at 11:54 AM ^

At this point I believe it's more of a game management problem than a scheme problem, which is probably out of Gattis's hands. Purposely slowing the game to a crawl, way overvaluing controlling the clocking, pre-settling for FGs, and the variety of other things we do as if it's 1960 are more detrimental than play-calling. Yes QB play could be better but taking the training wheels off might help there.

cbutter

June 29th, 2020 at 12:11 PM ^

If you take out Shea's total yards and carries, they ran for 4.5 per play. If you are over 4 per carry against Alabama, you are doing something right. Shea Patterson completed less than 50% of his passes and missed a couple of big ones that should be simple throws for a good college QB. 

I think that the offensive struggles in the second half of the season revolved mostly around him. Now whether or not the next guy is an upgrade, who knows?

NeverPunt

June 29th, 2020 at 12:49 PM ^

worth noting as well that Shea's misses here were - in general - uncharacteristic for him. Granted he had some bad moments in the OSU game as well but for his career at Michigan he was generally very accurate and threw catchable deep balls. Can't blame Gattis for asking Shea to make throws he's made the majority of his career. 

Seems we just often haven't had the combination of accurate QB and strong WR play at the same time in big games when we needed it most. 

Wolverine In Exile

June 29th, 2020 at 2:38 PM ^

That's one of the things I think a lot of people miss on when desiring "speed in space" and spread offense OMG. If you have a good FB, putting him in a coherent offensive scheme where he can accentuate bad matchup blocking assignments (FB v. Deion Sanders like CBs; FB vs. OLB who's not looking for him; FB crashing on a counter against a blind sided DE) can be amplified in a spread out system. Think RichRod's "Old beer truck" FB at West Virginia. Most of the time people still cling to the notion of a FB being this I-formation telegraph of where a running play is going. A modern day FB in a spread and speed based system can be a huge decisive advantage if deployed properly. Loving the thought of a slimmed down and remotivated Mason within a Gattis offense.

AC1997

June 29th, 2020 at 1:41 PM ^

I think in year-1 of speed-in-space you're seeing a little of the challenge RichRod had.  You can create creative, effective plays but against elite teams you have to have those next-level variations ready to go and also have to have players execute and MAKE PLAYS sometimes.  Gattis got better as the year went on, but ultimately against two of the top-five teams in the country he was only going to be able to do so much unless we caught some breaks or had players execute.

The question will be if he can continue his upward trajectory as an OC with a new QB and OL.

AC1997

June 29th, 2020 at 1:42 PM ^

Seth - 

I'm a novice at this level of detail, but I was wondering a couple of future opportunities.  Do you actually think they were prepared to read the left side of the play on this or was it just a decoy?  

Also, I like the idea of a pop-pass to Mason as a future variation.  What about an RPO pass to Nico on the left side once everyone is focused on the triple-option?  

Magnus

June 29th, 2020 at 7:05 PM ^

My two cents:

I think Michigan was prepared to read the backside, but Patterson didn't keep very often last year. (Not that he should have kept the ball on this play.)

Coverage determines whether an RPO will be effective. If Collins is facing press man, there's really no one to "read" on the RPO unless you just want to toss up a 50/50 ball. RPOs are typically reserved for zone coverage, or you can scheme up some fun RPOs on crossing/switch routes.

Michigan did run a couple RPOs against man coverage when the defender came up to stop the run. For example, they ran one for a TD to Cornelius Johnson against MSU. But those are tough to run because the QB needs to keep the ball, really sell the run, and possibly take a hit while throwing a ball from an awkward angle. It's kind of a high risk, high reward concept.

Seth

June 29th, 2020 at 9:45 PM ^

They never tested the backside option but they ran it like it was live so I (and the defense) have to assume it was. Michigan had to know that Saban was aware of Patterson's tendency to hand off. I don't think they would have bet a play they practiced this hard against it. So yeah, the backside option was live. 

Unsalted

June 29th, 2020 at 3:06 PM ^

Great Sharpie Session Seth!

I hope we get some real football this fall with many more great Sharpie Sessions to follow. This really shows how to create favorable match-ups with formation and motion, Ben Mason vs CB. And the importance of reading the defense, Bredeson nicking the WLB shooting the gap.

Speed in space with a fullback, and a TE with his hand in the dirt. Bo is smiling.

4th phase

June 29th, 2020 at 3:07 PM ^

I’m all for getting Mason out there more next year and having him execute those blocks. Two back shotgun and h back arcs. His tenacity can break the will of the defenders.

Impressed by Mayfields strength. He looks like he’s in a bad spot with bad leverage and still holds his own. 

uminks

June 29th, 2020 at 9:59 PM ^

Michigan always seems to play well for about 3 QTRs, then things get sloppy and the offense bogs down with mistakes. Then the defense will often get burned with the long passes. I thought we were going to win this game until things started falling apart. 

707oxford

June 30th, 2020 at 12:34 AM ^

Was just Up North last week and went to Five Shores. Didn’t realize Demo was affiliated with it though.  All three beers I had were fantastic - a rare feat for a new brewery. Sat out at the picnic tables and the kids snacked from the food truck. Had a great time, and yes, the whole setup was extremely sanitary. 
 

One quibble: I liked the pint glasses so much I asked to buy a couple to bring home with me...until I found out they cost several dollars more than the beer itself. Maybe once they stock up, they’ll be more reasonably priced. 

Mongo

June 30th, 2020 at 10:02 AM ^

More Ben Mason, please.  That play design works the way it was run and also as a decoy into pull/pitch to Giles around end ... make that one man miss and Giles turns it up the sideline. 

McCaffrey running this play would be killer on the pull/pitch as it adds another solid run option into the backside depending on how the WDE plays it.