Top Ten Post-1968 Michigan Football Games

Submitted by DennisFranklinDaMan on January 17th, 2024 at 5:21 PM

I was reflecting this morning on my all-time favorite Michigan football games (starting in 1969), based on an absolutely subjective combination of ranking-significance, atmosphere, personal meaning, game experience, entertainment value, and whatever else you want to include. Here's my list, but I'm sure I'm forgetting some. What are everybody else's?

(Honorable Mention: 1991 Desmond vs Notre Dame; 1977 Michigan/Ohio State; 2022 at Penn State; 1995 Biakabatuka vs. Ohio State)

10. 2011 vs Notre Dame (Under the Lights) 

9.1997 at Penn State

8. 1996 vs. Iowa (an often-forgotten instance of pure delirium)

7. 2022 at Ohio State

6. 2024 vs. Washington (Natl. Championship)

5. 1997 vs. Ohio State

4. 1998 vs. Washington State (Natl. Championship) Rose Bowl)

3. 2024 vs. Alabama (Rose Bowl)

2. 2021 vs. Ohio State 

1. 1969 vs. Ohio State

 

LLG

January 17th, 2024 at 5:28 PM ^

I think you are underestimating how big that Penn State game was in 1997. It was called "Judgment Day" and we went there and destroyed them.  Those three games were hyped all week.  We obliterated Penn State in an away game.  Happy Valley is a hard place to win in, and it was stunning how much we mauled them.  We jumped from #4 to #1.

After that we were favored in the remaining games.  I just remember it felt like a really, really big win.

Watch the introductions to the game.  Among other things, it was called the "Big Ten Game of the Year."

https://youtu.be/MitFlHNpcbY?si=FBEkQc5laL4AotTD&t=1

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3YFOcfwWgqc

 

mfan_in_ohio

January 17th, 2024 at 5:42 PM ^

This. That was the game that vaulted Michigan to #1 for the first time that year and was a major part of the argument for Michigan over Nebraska. It was absolute domination from start to finish. Penn State’s 8 points were the last score of the game in the last few minutes. The saddest TD I can remember a top 5 team ever scoring. 

mfan_in_ohio

January 17th, 2024 at 5:49 PM ^

I think he means the 1997 Iowa game in which we came back from down 21-7 at half after the Tim Dwight punt return. We scored the winning TD with a pass to Jerame Tuman with about 2 minutes left, and then Sam Sword picked off a pass to seal it as Iowa tried to drive for the win. In the crowd, it felt at halftime like “well, we always blow a game, every year. I guess it’s this one.” And then we didn’t.


I like it on this list, but the Penn State win from 1997 should be above it.

Ray

January 17th, 2024 at 6:05 PM ^

That clutch Tuman catch saved the season.  I looked on YouTube for Keith Jackson’s call but couldn’t find it—but that moment was absolutely electric.  

While the PSU, MSU and Colorado games were just good old fashioned curb-stompings, that Iowa game as well as the OSU game had moments where the season really hung in the balance.  

L'Carpetron Do…

January 17th, 2024 at 6:12 PM ^

That was when I was becoming truly obsessed w / college football.  I remember that weekend because those other games were hyped so much too.  That was a great UNC team and the infamous Nebraska-Missouri game was that day too. The best weekend in one of the all-time greatest seasons. As Jackson said: if that doesn't whet your whistle, you're watching the wrong channel. 

 

MMBbones

January 17th, 2024 at 6:56 PM ^

I too was at the 97 Iowa-M game. At halftime, my brother-in-law turned to me and said, "You know we're going to lose this game, don't you?" I engaged in some shut-up.

I confess to since having made much more play out of his prognostication than a kind person would.

Griese's turnaround at halftime may have been his finest moment.

three_honks

January 17th, 2024 at 7:14 PM ^

The 24 points surrendered to Iowa in 97 included

  • Tim Dwight's punt return for a TD
  • A one yard drive following a Griese near pick-six
  • A FG following a Tim Dwight kickoff return to the Mich 26 in which Mich did not surrender a 1st down.

Other than that, the most points Michigan surrendered was 16 to both Wiscy & Wash St.

BKBlue94

January 17th, 2024 at 7:25 PM ^

I was at at that comeback 1997 Iowa game as a kid and remember watching the Penn State one on that year TV. Both great memories. As a 9 year old though, it was the home game against Notre Dame that year that cemented in my mind that we had an unbeatable defense and gave me total, probably unreasonable confidence in the season. If I'm remembering correctly, we turned it over three times in our own half up 7 in the fourth quarter, and still gave up no points.

goblue2121

January 17th, 2024 at 5:29 PM ^

1. 2021 Ohio St

2. 1996 Ohio St

3. 2022 Ohio St

4. 1997 Ohio St

5. 2023 Ohio St

6. 2023 Bama 

7. 1998 Wash St

8. 2023 Washington 

9. 1997 PSU

10. 2006 ND

S.D. Jones

January 17th, 2024 at 5:29 PM ^

A great selection and I love them all. While I decline to rank the games, I'd like to add these three to the mix:

  • AC vs IU
  • Touchdown Billy Taylor
  • And a personal favorite, John of Navarre overcomes the Gophs at the Homerdome. 

WesternWolverine96

January 17th, 2024 at 5:31 PM ^

good list.... I would put OSU 2023 on the list but I don't know which game to remove

 

I haven't seen the '69 game, but I keep hearing about it

 

I am in no way thinking this is a top game.... but I was recently remembering that our comeback vs. Rutgers in the covid year was actually a very important game prior to our 3 BIG titles.  I think that game was the first sign of our team starting to turn a corner and cemented Cade as a starter.

Dunder

January 17th, 2024 at 5:37 PM ^

Need some distance from this season before I could order a list. Others to consider: 89 Rose Bowl, 93 Rose Bowl, 2000 Orange Bowl, 93 at PSU, 2006 at PSU, 1986 Fiesta, 78 at Notre Dame, 96 at OSU, 

michengin87

January 18th, 2024 at 1:57 AM ^

I was at the 89 Rose Bowl and the 96 at OSU.  Glad you included the latter in your top 10.  A complete domination by the defense on both sides with one play being the difference - Griese to Streets.  I remember walking out of the Shoe and the OSU fans were just stunned and speechless.  What a wonderful feeling.

The 95-96-97 games are right up there with 21-22-23 and both culminating in a National Championship.

 

caup

January 17th, 2024 at 5:40 PM ^

My top 10, just off the top of my head. (I may want to change some of these.)

1. 1969 vs. Ohio State

2. 2024 Rose Bowl vs Bama

3. 1998 Rose Bowl vs WSU

4. 2024 National Championship Game

5. 2023 vs. Ohio State

6. 1997 vs Ohio State

7. 2021 vs. Ohio State

8. 1997 at Penn State

9. 2016 at Michigan State

10. 2011 vs Notre Dame (UTL)

 

snarling wolverine

January 17th, 2024 at 6:29 PM ^

With the storyline, the Zinter injury, and the fact that it went down to a defensive stand in the last 30 seconds, yeah, I think it belongs.

If we're evaluating these games without taking any larger context into consideration, and just looking at how the two teams played that day, 1969 OSU probably wouldn't belong in the top 10.  All the scoring happened in the first half.  In the second half OSU threw a bunch of interceptions while M sat on the ball.  But obviously the context makes it an easy choice.  2023 OSU is too.

stephenrjking

January 17th, 2024 at 6:35 PM ^

Dude, it wasn’t the most aesthetically pleasing game, but we’re talking about the sign gate revenge game, undefeated teams, winner wins the national title. Michigan has to win to validate the entire three-year run because OSU tried to decapitate our coach. Came down to the last minutes, won with a legendary Blake play. Not top ten? That’s insane. It may have been the biggest UM-OSU game of all time.