Anatomy of an Injury - High Ankle Sprain

Submitted by McLeft Shark on September 23rd, 2019 at 6:16 PM

Anatomy of an Injury – High Ankle Sprain

Since the board seems to be going a bit nuclear after the Wisconsin game, I felt it would be a good time for a productive diary that highlights what one of our players is going through. 

It seems that one of our receivers suffered a high ankle sprain towards the end of training camp.  If you don’t know what a high ankle sprain is, and how it differs from a regular ankle sprain it might be a bit frustrating watching him in the game on Saturday and trying to figure out exactly why he wasn’t utilized as much, or why he was still so limited.

 

Ankle sprain vs. high ankle sprain.

Take a look at the picture below, and you will see the ankle from 2 distinct views.  The top part of the picture is from the medial (inside) of the ankle and shows the Deltoid ligament, which is a very, very strong ligament in the ankle.  In fact this ligament rarely tears, and will instead cause other injuries to occur if it is overstressed (more on this in a bit).

 

The bottom part of the picture is the lateral ankle (outside view), which as you can see consists of 3 different ligaments, the Anterior Talofibular, Calcaneofibular, and Talofibular ligament.  These ligaments are easily stressed in what we will call a “standard ankle sprain”, also known as an inversion sprain. 

So to put it simply, an ankle sprain is an injury to the ligaments of the outside of the ankle by rolling onto the outside of the foot.   A high ankle sprain, on the other hand is an injury to the inside of the foot by rolling your ankle to the inside.  It’s much less common because of how strong the ligaments on the inside of the ankle are.

 

What happens during a high ankle sprain?

When you have a standard ankle sprain, any one (or a combination) of the three ankle ligaments on the outside of the ankle are stretched and injured.  This results in ankle swelling and pain that can vary depending on severity, but usually with a lower grade sprain you can be back in 1-3 weeks with a brace or tape because what your defending against is the general stability of the ankle.

 

High ankle sprains are not that.  In fact, because the inside ligaments of the ankle are so strong, an injury to that side of the ankle causes the top bone of the ankle to forcefully jam itself in between to two bones of the lower leg (the tibia and fibula). 

This isn’t going to feel good.  Imagine having a split piece of wood and hitting it at the split with a hammer.  The wood is going to split more and all that stuff in the middle is going to go everywhere.  It’s a mess. 

This is essentially what happens with a high ankle sprain.  By jamming to top bone (the talus) up into the lower leg, all the soft tissue and “stuff” between these two bones forcefully seperates and can tear, thus creating the injury. 

 

How long does a high ankle sprain take to heal?

4-6 weeks, depending on the demands of your position.  For lineman it’s less because there’s less cutting/change of direction involved.  For skill players like running backs and receivers its more.  Even coming back at 4 weeks they are likely to be limited in both A) cutting/change of direction ability and B) explosive athleticism.  

 

How does a high ankle sprain affect performance?

The ankle is critical to everything involved with explosive movements.  That’s because as you move to sprint, jump, and change direction you need that joint between the top ankle bone and lower leg to transfer force from the hips into the ground to push off.  If that joint is stiff or limited, then you lose power. 

So look, at 4 weeks your most likely looking at playing at or around 70%.  That would be like playing with a leg and a half.  Or sort of like replacing your Ferrari with the car from the Flinstones.

 

Conclusion

High ankle sprains are bad, and feel bad.  They limit performance in all things explosion, especially in changes of direction.  Your going to see any player that goes through this become progressively less limited in their duties as they heal, but you most likely won’t see things that require a large amount of explosive movements (such as returning kicks) until that player has returned to 100%.

 

Hope you all found this somewhat interesting.  Have a great day.  Cheers!

Comments

Maximum Effort

September 24th, 2019 at 2:17 AM ^

A high ankle sprain, on the other hand is an injury to the inside of the foot by rolling your ankle to the inside.  It’s much less common because of how strong the ligaments on the inside of the ankle are . . . High ankle sprains are not that.  In fact, because the inside ligaments of the ankle are so strong, an injury to that side of the ankle causes the top bone of the ankle to forcefully jam itself in between to two bones of the lower leg (the tibia and fibula). 

Um, sorry, but no. 

A high ankle sprain is an injury to the anterior tibiofibular ligament and/or the syndesmosis (aka, interosseous membrane) between the tibia and fibula.  The deltoid lig. is not involved and I would argue it has no role in the mechanism of injury. 

The mechanism is usually forceful external rotation of the foot relative to the lower leg (and thus the ellipsoidally-shaped talus rotates and cams the malleoli apart) or forceful hyperdorsiflexion of the foot.  Forced dorsiflexion forces the malleoli apart due to the fact that the talus is wider in the anterior and narrower in the posterior and acts like a wedge.

Click for a technical article with a good pic of the pertinent anatomy that was left out of OP:

https://www.oakortho.com/news/high-ankle-sprain-difficult-athletic-injury

Edit: defined syndesmosis, spelling

dcallen39

September 24th, 2019 at 12:55 PM ^

Maximum Effort is correct. A high ankle sprain is related to the syndesmotic membrane between the tibia and fibula as well as the anterior tibiofibular ligament. 

An injury to the deltoid ligament is usually referred to as a medial ankle sprain as opposed to the more common lateral ankle sprain. Though it is not uncommon to have a deltoid ligament sprain concurrently with a syndesmotic ankle sprain.

High ankle sprains can be complex from a management standpoint. If you do not allow the syndesmosis and/or the anterior tibiofibular to heal every time you move into a loaded dorsiflexed position, such as with the foot planted and the knee flexed, you are causing more potential trauma to the injured structures. If the patient does not manage well with conservative treatment then surgery may be necessary. 

I would think in the case of DPJ, due to the fact that he played on Saturday, the trainers are comfortable with the healing process, and are allowing him to play without restrictions.  

McLeft Shark

September 24th, 2019 at 7:39 PM ^

Welp, honestly I felt like it was best to explain this in regards of inversion vs. eversion sprains, as a high ankle sprain could happen either way, it's easier to explain it in regards to an eversion sprain. 

And yes, the deltoid ligament is involved in an eversion sprain, just not necessarily sprained.  The fact that it's tensile strength is so high is what creates the talus to forcefully move into the malleoli in forced dorsiflexion, causing the syndesmosis injury.  

Sorry if my verbage was confusing.  I attempted to utilize more laymans terms instead of pure medical speak.  I suppose it was poorly communicated (ala "rolling it to the inside should have been rolling it on the inside, or something of that sort.  I realty I should have used eversion vs. inversion I suppose).   I'll try to do better if I do this again. 

And yes.  Of course the medical staff has confidence in DPJ's healing process.  I just don't see him as 100% at this stage of his recovery based on healing time.  Again, I have no insider information on this, just using stages of healing as a benchmark.

 

Thanks

Sideways_Rain

September 27th, 2019 at 11:18 AM ^

Yes.

Would add to this that the syndesmosis and Ant Tib-Fib Ligament are essentially the structures that keep the distal (further from the center of the body) ends of the tibia and fibula from spreading apart, meaning that an injury to these structures can result in an unstable ankle (and often the inherent need for surgery). What you mentioned above and the potential ease with which further injury can cause a stable injury to become unstable is a major reason playing on a high ankle sprain too early can cause a much longer term issue.

Maximum Effort

September 27th, 2019 at 10:59 PM ^

Totally agree.  The other thing to consider is that as athletes heal and get close to return to play (RTP), you have to be way more conservative in when that happens. 

Problem is that you can tape up a regular sprain so that a guy can be at 90% ready as far as pain and function and you can tape up that last 10% of ankle stability and get him on the field safely w/o any major concerns.  You can't actually tape up a high ankle sprain to give it more stability because you literally need to lash 2 bones so they can't spread out without cutting off nerve/blood supply or impede Achilles function.

So your only option is to get the guy to 100% in function, pain, and stability before allowing him on the field.  Even then you're not 100% sure he's good to go for EVERYTHING he could see in game conditions since you can't replicate that in rehab.  So you end up allowing him to heal longer and testing in games a lot more sparingly to see how his ankle handles it.   Remember that any outward twisting of the foot relative to the leg or excessive flexing your foot to the shin can re-aggravate the injury and take you back several steps. 

These are the main reasons why I think high ankle sprains are a PITA.

leftrare

September 25th, 2019 at 2:27 PM ^

This is a great post.  I have had many "standard" ankle sprains.  A couple were excruciating.  As a result, an ankle injury replay on TV makes me nauseous.  Turns out, same with reading this.