Michigan State 27, Michigan 24 Comment Count

Ace October 31st, 2020 at 4:07 PM

"Disconcerting signals," indeed.

That was a penalty drawn by Cam McGrone before he exited this cursed game with an injury. It fairly describes the entire contest for Michigan.

Michigan State's offense could do one thing with any consistency: chuck the ball long against press man coverage. The Wolverines had no answers in terms of personnel and seemingly didn't try to come up with any schematically. The five Spartan scoring drives featured long passes covering 30, 53, 50, 19, and 31 yards. The coaches pulled starting corner Vincent Gray for Jalen Perry in the second half; Perry managed to stay closer to MSU's receivers but couldn't do any better at playing the ball.

Michigan's offense, meanwhile, failed to come up with a downfield passing game of their own, and much of their success on the ground came outside the tackles. State piled up six tackles for loss and held M to 4.7 yards per carry (sacks removed). Joe Milton's accuracy waxed and waned as he mustered 300 scoreless yards on 51 attempts. Jalen Mayfield went down late and, while he walked off the field, he was taken into the tunnel by the cart.

The coaches will come under heavy, deserved criticism for the most surprising—and perhaps most bitterly disappointing—defeat of the Jim Harbaugh era. The Wolverines were poised to tie the game at 14 heading into halftime before Josh Gattis dialed up second and third-and-goal plays with Hassan Haskins as a wildcat quarterback; the run was stuffed, the surprise pass underthrown and tipped incomplete by Ann Arbor native Antjuan Simmons, who had a standout game at linebacker for MSU.

Don Brown rarely deviated from calling press man coverage even though the defense was getting eviscerated by the vaunted Rocky Lombardi to Ricky White connection, which tallied eight completions on ten targets for 196 yards and a touchdown. Lombardi averaged 19 yards on his 17 completions and his total was deflated by numerous flags on the Michigan secondary.

In other Big Ten games, Minnesota lost to Maryland, which got pasted last week by Northwestern, which is losing by two scores early against Iowa, which lost last week against Purdue. I guess the silver lining is that this is an incredibly stupid year.

Comments

stephenrjking

October 31st, 2020 at 4:17 PM ^

In a game that was nothing but disastrous for the defense, Michigan only actually gave up 27 points. As was argued, sometimes defenses give up points.

The offense simply wasn’t good.

And the defense never, ever looked competent.

It’s a make or break year for Brown, and it’s looking like “break.”

I regret plugging back in to the team so much, honestly. Who needs the aggravation?

Cheers. 

HAIL-YEA

October 31st, 2020 at 4:53 PM ^

I don't even know anymore. I was completely checked out until I saw the performance last week, got suckered back into this shit.  Don Brown has been nothing but fools gold, He more than anyone is responsible for why this team can't achieve shit.. I'm out until we have new coaches. Not wasting anymore more of my life on this shit program.

Glennsta

October 31st, 2020 at 5:37 PM ^

Jansen made a good point pre-game, i.e. that MSU put up 27 last week, even with 7 turnovers, which suggested that their offense might not be that bad. That being said, us getting flagged for multiple PI penalties helped them out a ton.

I agree, the offense wasn't as efficient as it should be given the talent on the roster. Harbaugh's teams have been marked by plenty of talented players whose talent gets wasted.

I put aside my chronic BPONE after last week (it doesn't take much), but it's back and probably worse than ever.  I looked at the schedule after today's game and I think we'll be lucky to end up a .500 team. I unplugged the Lions years ago and only being an alum is keeping my interest in this program. 

murderwolflives

October 31st, 2020 at 4:17 PM ^

The "JT Barrett was short" debacle effectively killed Harbaugh. His fire and passion have disappeared in greater and greater amounts since then. Now he barely reacts to bad calls like that drop they called a completion on 3rd and forever. He should have been fighting for a review and was complacent.

The End is Nigh

BlueTuesday

October 31st, 2020 at 4:25 PM ^

Harbaugh lost his passion years ago though I’m not sure it’s because of the Barrett was short play.

Im hoping Harbaugh sees the writing on the wall and bows out at the end of the year while helping Michigan keep their recruits and helping the administration work towards finding a suitable replacement.

jmblue

October 31st, 2020 at 4:18 PM ^

Brown seemingly is what he is at this point.  I'm ready for a new DC.  I no longer have confidence in him.  Every 3rd down today was terrifying.

Gattis was disappointing. As the game went on we seemed to fall more and more into the old trap of trying to protect a young QB with "safe" playcalls on 1st and 2nd down that went nowhere, forcing said young QB to then be a hero on 3rd down.  No matter the staff, it seems like we can't shake that mindset.

jmblue

October 31st, 2020 at 4:56 PM ^

He'll make mistakes, you have to accept that if you're the OC.  But you're probably setting him up to make more of them when you're falling behind the sticks all the time.  We finished 7-17 on 3rd down, which is solid considering that our average distance was like 9 yards. 

Michigan4Life

November 1st, 2020 at 12:43 AM ^

I thought MSU schemed well against Milton and he made a lot of bad decision against coverage that he got away with quite a few times only bc he has a strong arm. He won't get away with it against OSU since they have superior athletes. Milton should've thrown at least 3 INTs bc of his inability to process coverage.

MgofanNC

November 1st, 2020 at 1:18 PM ^

For sure, Brown is what he is and he's clearly never going to change. Missing on some good corners the last few cycles and Ambry's early departure has put us in this really tough spot. BUT, I believe that if you are going to win college football games in today's game (especially if they are calling PI on those plays early) you have to score at least 1 touchdown a quarter (end with 28+ points). That would have given us a win in this one. I don't see how this falls on the defense (which granted did play well below expectations) when the defense only gave up 27 points. 

Blake Forum

October 31st, 2020 at 4:19 PM ^

Not sure what to say. In terms of the stakes of the game combined with the advantage Michigan should’ve had, this is the worst loss of the Harbaugh Era. Can’t put any spin on it 

socalwolverine1

October 31st, 2020 at 5:54 PM ^

Nah, first let's dispell the notion that we are as good as the hype generated by the win over the 0-2 Gophers, especially after their loss to Maryland. Second, give Sparty credit for being motivated and ready to play, and give them additional credit for their play on both sides of the ball. They won the battle in the trenches and had a great scheme on defense that we simply couldn't solve. Especially when our OL was pretty much dominated. No, for me the last two OSU games stick out way above this loss as our worst in the Jim Harbaugh/ Don Brown era.

YoOoBoMoLloRoHo

October 31st, 2020 at 4:20 PM ^

Wow, that coaching job was appalling. All the PR power & expertise in the AD cannot hide the tire fire in Schembechler Hall because that was the worst outing by a Harbaugh team in his 6 years.

MgoBlueDevil

October 31st, 2020 at 4:24 PM ^

Ace... after your "They really thought" article this place got so hyped. It just took one extra week for the hype to die. If Tucker literally goes on to do nothing else at Michigan State... he should be remembered for causing Jim to get fired. I'm not so sure he will get fired though. Everyone seems to have excuses and anyone that questions things should be mocked with impunity (a fewyear old reference for those that have been here a few years). That article about the Minnesota game aged like milk Ace. He needs to be shown the door.

DonAZ

October 31st, 2020 at 4:27 PM ^

Am I correct in understanding Harbaugh's contract end-date is approaching without an extension yet granted?  I wonder if there's an understanding between Emmanuel and Harbaugh, and at this point he's just mailing it in.

Glennsta

October 31st, 2020 at 6:04 PM ^

His contract is up at the end of 2021. If he gets fired before that, his buyout is $10M. 

I'd understood that an extension probably would have already been done but for the precarious state of university finances due to Covid. It's hard to justify visibly spending millions of dollars on football when the state is cutting university funding, revenues are slacking, positions are being eliminated, and tuition is increasing.

BigMeech82

October 31st, 2020 at 4:29 PM ^

Defensive failures aside (there are too many to list) what I found concerning on offense was what seemed like a lack of preparing the QB for what he would be facing in MSU's defensive schemes.  Milton seemed to make a lot of poor pre snap judgements with the football.  There were several times when other receivers were open, but he rarely seemed to look off his first read. 

To me, I think that's a bit more of an indictment on Harbaugh and McDaniels and should make the AD rather nervous in following through on an extension with coach.

surlyman

October 31st, 2020 at 4:32 PM ^

Agreed.  Also, lack of adjustment in the running game.  Between the tackles was not working.  State was selling out there, but the edges were open.  We did not run wide nearly enough.  The whole offensive plan was maddening.  Up the middle after a first down pass was incomplete left us in 3rd and 8 or 9 about a million times.  Terrible plan coming into the game and terrible lack of adjustments during the game on both sides of the ball.

njvictor

October 31st, 2020 at 4:30 PM ^

Paye and Hutchinson might be the most overrated players I've ever seen play for Michigan. Both considered 1st round picks and grade out well on PFF but yet are non-existent most games. Zero sacks between the both of them against a terrible OL. It feels like everyone just pretends they're good

The Oracle 2

October 31st, 2020 at 4:31 PM ^

The idiotic play calling at the goal line might have been the difference in the game. I got the impression that those calls, as well as some others, were Gattis saying “look at me!” It also looked like Don Brown stubbornly refused to alter his plan, even after being repeatedly burned in the same way. Those things are on the coaches. But the o-line’s inability to create daylight in the running game and the lack of any pressure on Lombardi are on the players. Truly a team loss.