The 2017 Schedule, Ranked Comment Count

Ace


Penn State is getting some dark horse playoff hype. [Bryan Fuller]

While we've entered the darkest days of the offseason, there's a beacon of hope: programs not named Michigan State now have a good idea of how their roster and depth chart will look this fall. Since I penned the opponent previews (save Ohio State, which was put in the ever-capable hands of Ross Fulton) for HTTV 2017, which you can preorder right here (or grab the digital version here), I figured I'd run down the 2017 schedule by expected difficulty.

This takes into account opponent quality, location of the game, time of the season (i.e. it's better to catch Florida early while Malik Zaire is still getting the offense down), and whatnot.

TIER I: THE EAST ELITES

1. Ohio State (home, Nov. 25)

While serious consideration was given to Penn State, The Game is The Game, and Ohio State's talent level remains ridiculous even after considerable turnover from last year's squad. The JT Barrett-Mike Weber backfield will be among the best in the country, and the offense will feature new wrinkles with former Indiana coach Kevin Wilson combining his light-speed approach with Urban Meyer's power spread.

Ohio State's defensive strength also happens to coincide with Michigan's greatest offensive concern. The Buckeyes boast four defensive ends who'd start—and star—on just about any team in the country: Tyquan Lewis, Sam Hubbard, Nick Bosa, and Jalyn Holmes. Hopefully, Michigan has figured out their right tackle situation by Thanksgiving.

2. Penn State (road, Oct. 21)

I understand the inclination to dismiss Penn State based on last year's 49-10 win. I really do. That said, PSU's offense took off last year under first-year coordinator Joe Moorhead, and I'd probably have them first on this list if top wideout Chris Godwin didn't move on to the NFL. Trace McSorley and Saquon Barkley may be as good, if not better, than the Barrett-Weber duo.

There are still reasons to doubt this team, chief among them an offensive line that remained awful at run-blocking last year and a defensive front seven that lacks star power. Also: James Franklin is still in charge of game management decisions. This offense is going to be tough to stop, though, and Michigan will have to do it in a road night game at Happy Valley.

[Hit THE JUMP for the rest of the schedule.]

----------------


Wisconsin needs more consistency from QB Alex Hornibrook. [Fuller]

TIER II: TALENTED BUT FLAWED

3. Wisconsin (road, Nov. 18)

The Badgers were a cut below the top of the Big Ten last year, losing to the top three teams in the East by seven points each. Their defense should once again be excellent despite the losses of TJ Watt and Vince Biegel; if last year's defense showed anything, it's that the Badgers have a seemingly endless stock of good linebackers, led by Jack Cichy. The D-line is stout and the secondary boasts a couple underrated talents in Derrick Tindal and D'Cota Dixon.

The offense, however, has been mediocre in two seasons under Paul Chryst, and they must replace their top two backs and first-round tackle Ryan Ramczyk from an uncharacteristically poor rushing attack. While there's talent in the receiving corps, QB Alex Hornibrook must show he can hold his own against elite defenses after struggling mightily against Michigan and OSU last year before losing the job to Bart Houston. It's telling that the Badgers made a play for Notre Dame grad transfer Malik Zaire, who instead wound up at...

4. Florida (neutral, Sep. 2)

If Zaire had more time to get comfortable in Florida's system, I'd probably have the Gators above the Badgers, but Michigan is fortunate to catch them early in the season—plus, Wisconsin is on the road while Florida is a neutral-site Jerryworld game. The two teams in this tier are quite similar; like the Badgers, UF has leaned on a talented defense while poor QB and O-line play hold back the offense.

Florida lost a lot of talent off last year's team, including early NFL Draft entrants at each level of the defense. Their best offensive player, playmaking receiver Antonio Callaway, could miss the Michigan game after an offseason marijuana citation. I'd like Michigan in this game regardless, but getting the Gators in the opener makes me like their chances even more.

----------------

I'll stop here to note there's a chasm between the top four teams on the schedule and the bottom eight. OSU and PSU are likely to be favored in those games, while upsets by Wisconsin and Florida are well within the realm of possbility. It'd take some weird stuff for Michigan to lose to the teams below. This is college football, of course, so weird stuff happens with alarming regularity, but four losses still looks to be the absolute floor unless M is hit with some catastrophic injuries.

----------------


Indiana's Richard Lagow needs to stop throwing to the other team. [Eric Upchurch]

TIER III: POTENTIALLY FRISKY

5. Indiana (road, Oct. 14)

Like I said: chasm. Indiana could be tricky; their defense took a huge leap under Tom Allen, who's now the head coach after Kevin Wilson was let go. That unit returns eight starters, including excellent linebacker Tegray Scales. It's beyond bizarre to type this, but Indiana should be able to rely on a solid defense this year.

While the offense could bounce back from a down year, they'll have to do so while replacing Kevin Wilson with Mike DeBord, who—I swear I'm not making this up—was brought in to continue running IU's up-tempo spread. They've got a pair of dangerous, big-bodied receivers in Simmie Cobbs Jr. and Nick Westbrook, and the passing game could be electric if Richard Lagow puts it together. Being in the East means the Hoosiers will lose more games than a couple of the teams below them, but if things break the right way they could be an upset threat on the road.

6. Maryland (road, Nov. 11)

While DJ Durkin had a pretty rough debut, there are some intriguing pieces in place for a potential year-two leap. After two years of terrible quarterback play, UNC transfer and former four-star recruit Caleb Henderson could provide stability to the position, and the run game was already dangerous last year with Ty Johnson and Lorenzo Harrison both cracking 7 YPC. The offensive line has plenty of young talent, most of which has some early playing experience.

The defense looks solid up front and potentially shaky in the secondary. That and lingering issues in the passing game—they're thin at receiver—will keep the Terps from competing with the top of the Big Ten East, but they'll battle with Indiana for fourth in the division and should look a good deal better than last year's team.

7. Minnesota (home, Nov. 4)

Replacing Tracy Claeys with PJ Fleck is a massive coaching upgrade, and while it may take a while for the total system overhaul to take hold, Michigan catches the Gophers relatively late in the year. With two quality running backs in Shannon Brooks and Rodney Smith, they have something to lean on while the rest of the team catches up. Fleck can't conjure a passing game out of thin air, though, so the Gophers project to be a limited offensive team this fall.

Last year's defense was good, but other than underrated DT Stephen Richardson, loses most of its top players. The secondary looks especially questionable after losing both starting corners and their top safety. Fleck started off slow at Western Michigan, and it's probably going to be a similar story at Minnesota, but he's working with more talent than before.

8. Michigan State (home, Oct. 7)

Even putting aside the legitimate, lingering questions about how this program will deal with a disastrous offseason, State has lost a good deal of its top-end talent and will be paper-thin at just about every position that isn't running back. The defense is down five of its top seven tacklers and could still lose its top returning D-lineman after Demetrious Cooper violated the terms of his plea deal. Brian Lewerke will be handed the keys to an offense that returns only one receiver with double-digit catches to his name. The O-line is a mess.

Honestly, MSU is only ranked this high because they'll treat the Michigan game like it's the Super Bowl. This team has significantly less talent and depth than last year's 3-9 squad, and a hopefully improved locker room culture can only go so far to make up for that.

----------------

TIER IV: NEVER SCHEDULE AIR FORCE

9. Air Force (home, Sep. 16)

Even by service academy standards, Air Force has a huge amount of turnover from last year's team; they return five starters on offense and just one on defense. On paper, Michigan should hardly break a sweat in this game.

But this is Air Force. They've spent decades refining a hurry-up option attack that best suits their personnel (and also endangers opposing defender's knees), and while they don't return much, they bring back two dangerous runners in QB Arion Worthman, whose insertion into the starting lineup turned last season around, and back Timothy McVey. Their chances of beating Michigan are slim; their chances of mounting a couple obnoxious scoring drives are high.

Oh wow I got through this section without mentioning this is another Dave Brandon scheduling special. Oh, crap, I'm still typing. Whatever.

----------------


Yep, still bad. [Patrick Barron]

TIER V: BODY BAGS

10. Cincinnati (home, Sep. 9)

Luke Fickell was a solid hire for Cinci; he's already recruiting at a level well above predecessor Tommy Tuberville. Tuberville let the team bottom out before his exit, however, and Fickell probably wishes he could add a couple of his 2018 commits to this year's team. The Bearcats were woeful on offense last year, especially on the ground, and I'm not sure they hit a home run with their hiring of Mike Denbrock, Notre Dame's primary playcaller the last two years, as offensive coordinator.

In a couple years, this program should be at a level where they put a scare into some high-level programs, but it's going to take some time.

11. Purdue (road, Sep. 23)

I'd probably have this game above Cincinnati if it came later in the year. Jeff Brohm is another huge coaching upgrade, and it didn't take him long to turn Western Kentucky into last year's best Group of Five team. There's a lot of new faces on offense, however, and the defense loses its linchpin in PFF All-American DT Jake Replogle. This is yet another game that'd be more worrisome if it occurred two or three years in the future.

12. Rutgers (home, Oct. 28)

Let's look at Rutgers' quarterback situation, from the HTTV preview:

Last year, Chris Laviano ceded the job midway through the year to Giovanni Rescigno, and the two posted equally terrible marks of 4.2 yards per attempt. When SBNation’s Bill Connelly created an overall percentile ranking for QBs in 2016 using weighted stats, both fell in the bottom eight out of 178 qualifying players.

While Laviano graduated, Rescigno exited the spring as the starter, but his hold on the job is tenuous. Ash said there will be a “complete, open competition” in the fall, and he’s adding plenty of competitors. Senior Zach Allen, the third-stringer last year, is rehabbing a torn ACL instead of undergoing surgery so he can play this year; three-star dual-threat true freshman Johnathan Lewis and Louisville grad transfer Kyle Bolin will make it a four-player race; Kill even added a walk-on transfer from Temple and a grad transfer from D-II Southern Connecticut State to bolster depth. The message is clear: Rutgers is trying anything they can to avoid even another half-season of Rescigno. Most alarmingly, it may not work.

Yup, still Rutgers.

Comments

Bodogblog

June 16th, 2017 at 1:04 PM ^

Does any other team run a hurry-up, power ground game?  That seems brutal for offensive lineman.  Yes perhaps more brutal on the D.  But I would assume OL have to be in better shape to run super up-tempo, which would seem to limit their roadgrader-ability.  Light vs. Heavy, so to speak.  And at some point you run out of time to do it all, or you confuse your identity.  I think Weber will be replaced by mid-year, and if Barrett still has trouble completing deep balls I'm not sure Wilson can do much. 

Bill Connelly gives Air Force a 2% chance of beating Michigan. 

Blue_In_Texas

June 16th, 2017 at 1:26 PM ^

Going to UF game in Dallas. Last two games I've been to in person were MSU at home when the thing happened and The Game at Ohio Stadium where that other bad thing happened. Really hoping these things don't come in threes. 

jimmyshi03

June 16th, 2017 at 1:31 PM ^

that Zaire didn't at least consider Minnesota. If he'd wanted to start, there was perhaps no more obvious school that could have used an experienced starter in the P5. 

Pepto Bismol

June 16th, 2017 at 2:41 PM ^

Zaire is the default starter at Florida already and I'm not sure he's even found the book store yet.  An argument about depth chart is probably the worst one you can make because he's already going to be the friggin' starter at the school he picked... which is a WAY better option than Minnesota in pretty much every conceivable way.

 

 

 

 

 

In reply to by Pepto Bismol

jimmyshi03

June 16th, 2017 at 5:58 PM ^

Even if he started, which I'm not sure about either. Franks may well be the guy, and, hell, I wouldn't be flabbergasted if Del Rio, as the ultimate know what you're getting guy, actually started.

Ty Butterfield

June 16th, 2017 at 1:56 PM ^

8-4 for sure. Interested to see if Harbaugh's seat gets a little warm after starting 0-3 against OSU.

Mongo

June 16th, 2017 at 2:12 PM ^

we need that win to set up a showdown with OSU. Personally, I think our defense is better suited this year to stop OSU especially with Samuel gone. JT's head will be on a swivel looking for Gary, Winovich, Bush and Hudson ... but he will end up on the ground with lot's of belly-rubbing afterwards.

MadMatt

June 16th, 2017 at 2:35 PM ^

Their offense is way over-rated.  Last year it was Barkley left, Barkley right, Barkley up the middle, then chuck an arm punt downfield in the hope the defense will put 9 guys in the box.  It worked often enough against inferior B1G teams that all they needed was a little voodoo magic against OSU, and voila!  A B1G Championship.

Michigan's defense (even with new starters) will be way too sound for PSU to try that same trick.  Michigan doesn't need 9 men in the box to stop Barkley (especially with that OL), hence the arm punt strategy will not work.

The PSU defense is exploitable.

They got lucky last year; regression to the mean will be our friend.

OSU, on the other hand, does scare me.  That much talent, and a head coach smart enough to know his preferred offense has gotten a little stale, that is trouble with a capital TROUBLE.

VintageBlue

June 16th, 2017 at 2:56 PM ^

Looking through Don Brown's history against service academies; there's not much and it's not good.  Two games against Navy; one at Maryland and another at UMass.  Navy put up 400 plus yards on 70+ (!!!) carries and 268 yards on 51 carries respectively.  Didn't look further back than 2008.  Expected to see more option-y offenses in his recent history.  Somehow his UConn, Maryland and Boston College teams never had Georgia Tech on the schedule.  Weird.

 

smwilliams

June 16th, 2017 at 3:13 PM ^

I think Ace's ranking is pretty much accurate. Road games are no joke in college (as opposed to the NFL/NBA). If Iowa is at Michigan Stadium last year, Michigan wins that game by 20+. If Ohio State is in Ann Arbor, Michigan wins that game by 10. If Wisconsin is at Camp Randall, Michigan loses that game. 

at Purdue, at Indiana, and at Maryland don't really scare me all that much namely because none of those crowds are at the same level of an Iowa or Wisconsin. 

So, it comes down to a night game in Happy Valley and playing in Madison. 

I think this young Michigan team drops both of those and wins the rest of their games (yes, including Ohio State). The opener against Florida will be the difference between a 9-3 or 10-2 season. If they beat Florida, they end up in a NY6 Bowl. If they lose, it's probably the Citrus. That said, it's not impossible for them to go 8-4, if Ohio State just has too much talent. 

BlueInWisconsin

June 16th, 2017 at 10:47 PM ^

You had me until you said Wisconsin would have beat Michigan in Madison. I was at that game. The only way Wisconsin was going to win was going to be a fluke. The Badgers had one successful offensive play all day long if memory serves. The only reason it was close was three missed field goals. Could they have replicated all that luck at home? Sure. Would their O been able to score? Not a chance in hell.

ST3

June 16th, 2017 at 3:17 PM ^

TheRinger has an interesting article up about tanking in the NFL and how it is worse than the other pro sports because of the compacted schedule and the 4 team divisions. But mainly, I mention this because of this hilarious comment from the article:

The NFL needs to evolve, or the competitive balance of the league is going to be threatened more so than it already is. Remember: The more teams tank, the more likely it is you’ll see Christian Hackenberg play at some point. And when Hackenberg is playing regular snaps, it means something has gone terribly wrong in the league.

bronxblue

June 16th, 2017 at 8:58 PM ^

This feels like an 8-9 win season. I'm not worried about Florida, and Michigan at home against OSU feels good. But Wisconsin and PSU are scary home teams and PSU has a really potent, if inconsistent, offense. It has been fun arguing with PSU fans about their offensive line and secondary. The line might be incrementally better, but they keep saying the team redshirted some awesome line and yet...I don't see it. And this was still a secondary that let Wisconsin throw on them and we all say the Rose Bowl. I'd put money on them disappointing compared to the pre season hype.

AJDrain

June 17th, 2017 at 12:27 AM ^

I think the season comes down to 4 games:

- Florida: Honestly this is the game I'm least worried about. They always have a tough defense, but I never get the sense they're actually good. They consistently beatdown the bad SEC teams, lose to the good SEC teams, and then get destroyed by the great teams to finsih like 9-4. Zaire doesn't scare me that much and the neutral environment helps M. I like our chances

- PSU: Unquestionably the toughest environment on this schedule, but environment doesn't win games. Football players do. And PSU is a tough team to figure out. The belief that "they got better as the season went on" is only so-so. They got in a lot of high scoring toss up games at the beginnning and end of season (Pitt, Temple, Minny, Indiana, Wiscy, USC). Their defense isn't good and so much of their offense was Godwin crazy catch Hail Maries. I could honestly see them at 9-3 this year. It will be tough, but I think M's offense could be good enough to win a shootout here. I see this as a tossup

- Wiscy: This is a tough one. It's kind of this year's Iowa game. Except, Camp-Randall doesn't terrify me like Kinnick does. It's tough to tell how good they actually were last year considering their noncoference wasn't great (they won a virtual home game against a blah LSU team). Got beaten soundly by M (damn missed FG's skewed margin). Blew winnable games against OSU/PSU and then had an easy bowl opponent. They were just typical Wisconsin. Mediocre QB, big RB, nice OLine, solid D, win 10 games. They have guys to replace and I agree with them being in the tier below. Will we beat them? Idk. It's another tossup. But winnable.

- OSU: Yeah, they're gonna be good. But they're replacing pieces in the secondary and WR. And we're home. If this were at OSU, I'd struggle to see us winning. But at home, I say it's 50/50. All depends on how we look. We outplayed them last year. Maybe third time's the charm for Harbaugh. 

All in all, I say probably 10-2. Maybe 11-1 and division title? Who knows. I struggle to see 8-4 though. As long as we can beat Florida, split Wiscy/PSU, then the season and a ticket to Indy, comes down to The Game. And boy wouldn't that be fun?

autodrip4-1968

June 17th, 2017 at 9:47 AM ^

Indiana playing with a good defensive unit and Mike DeBord coordinating a high tempo offense. Weird. That new offensive coordinator at Cincinnati might flourish without Brian Kelly looking over his shoulder. The expectations for myself in recent to Michigan football and their opponent's is every game is winnable. With talent being brought in and with the coaching staff in place the expected for me is talent and mental toughness and not to undermine health weather home or way I will like the chances of sweet victory. Of course you can't win them all by but they will not lie down unlike the previous two regime's.