Xavier Worthy's mom on why he left Michigan for Texas

Submitted by Communist Football on September 8th, 2023 at 11:14 PM

The Athletic's Max Olson wrote a piece about Xavier Worthy, which details why he left Michigan. According to her, the Michigan admissions department was the culprit:

Unfortunately, as his recruiting process heated up, a pandemic was going on. Worthy couldn’t take official visits and had to build relationships over video chats. He became a big believer in Michigan offensive coordinator Josh Gattis and his “Speed in Space” mantra, and that connection persuaded him to commit to Michigan in July 2020.

Sarkisian, Alabama’s offensive coordinator at the time, never backed off. Worthy and Jones took a November trip to Alabama to attend an Iron Bowl win over Auburn and do a self-guided campus tour, sparking rumors that a flip was incoming. But Worthy stuck with Michigan and signed in December. Coach Jim Harbaugh called him “one of the top players in the country.”

“I felt like that was where home was at,” Worthy said.

When he first picked Michigan, Worthy planned to be an early enrollee. His school district didn’t allow seniors to graduate early. Jones got creative. She got him enrolled in Apex Learning Virtual School, an online program, for the fall of 2020. It wasn’t easy to get that plan lined up without guidance counselors, but Jones ensured his class schedule met all graduation and NCAA initial eligibility requirements.

But that's not good enough for Michigan admissions, as we've learned over and over again:

In early January 2021, two weeks before Worthy would move to Ann Arbor with J.J. McCarthyDonovan Edwards and the Wolverines’ freshman enrollees, a problem emerged. Michigan has strict admissions standards for midyear enrollees, one former staffer said, and wasn’t able to get Worthy admitted into school. He was told that based on his academic profile, it would be better to enroll in June for U-M’s summer bridge program. His mother was stunned.

“For me, that didn’t fly,” she said. “I turned in all of his academic paperwork and applications in September. As far as I had been told, up until two weeks before, he was on track to enroll early. There was nothing missing, nothing short, they’d waived the SATs. It didn’t make sense. Something wasn’t right. What’s the problem and why am I finding out about this now?”

Worthy wanted to stay at Michigan, but he wasn't allowed to join the team since he wasn't enrolled.

Worthy still wanted to honor his commitment. He moved to Ann Arbor and got an apartment. When Michigan posted a video of midyear move-in day on Jan. 16, Worthy was missing. Two days later, he announced on Twitter that “to end all the drama and speculations I am not enrolling early.” But he was in town. Since he wasn’t enrolled, he wasn’t allowed to work out in the football facility. All he could do was join Zoom meetings. After a strange month of trying to make it work, he moved back home.

“Michigan messed that up,” Jones said. “The trust wasn’t there. For us, trust is so big in everything. We just never felt like we were getting the truth about what happened. It was just a lot of, ‘We’re sorry.’”

The 17-year-old returned to Fresno to rethink his future. It didn’t make him feel any better that Central East was playing a five-game spring season and he couldn’t participate. During a loss to rival Buchanan, Biggs looked to Worthy on the sideline and told him, “Sure could use you right now.”

If he wasn’t going to Michigan, Worthy knew where he needed to be.

“I was going wherever Sark went,” he said.

When is Santa Ono going to get this fixed?

OneEyedMooseSm…

September 9th, 2023 at 12:22 AM ^

I don't believe this shit for a moment.  Sounds like a single mom ret-conning her past activities (after a piece of time had passed) and then found a beta-male amplifier for it.

Now trying to throw her sobbing salt in our pot just because her boy is at a soft program that can't even manage their own scene vs we're playing for prizes.

lilpenny1316

September 9th, 2023 at 1:15 AM ^

Umm, is this true?

They’d waived the SATs.

Was this in place in 2020? I know COVID changed a lot of things, but I was kinda surprised to see they "waived" it in his case.

Amazinblu

September 9th, 2023 at 8:19 AM ^

During Covid many colleges went “test score optional”.

I cannot recall Michigan’s position.   

I believe Michigan’s current stance is - take either the ACT or SAT, and - super scoring of the ACT is allowed.

The public schools in California do not currently consider or even (to my knowledge) accept standardized test scores.

ShadowStorm33

September 9th, 2023 at 1:18 AM ^

If we're being honest, even had admissions let him enroll early, I'd say it's pretty likely he would have transferred after his first year given some combination of (1) how we use WRs, (2) NIL, and (3) Gattis leaving...

Humen

September 9th, 2023 at 2:13 AM ^

It’s terrible to imagine him stuck in AA and not able to do anything. Looking at him as an individual, regardless of slant, it’s clear this was a horrible experience for him. At 17/18 and alone in a new place. That sucks.

The number of stories (many of which cannot be confirmed) about admissions is a large number. If there’s enough smoke, there’s probably fire. 

Worthy will be fine. So will Michigan. Just another bad look.

cbs650

September 9th, 2023 at 6:27 AM ^

“For me, that didn’t fly,” she said. “I turned in all of his academic paperwork and applications in September. As far as I had been told, up until two weeks before, he was on track to enroll early. There was nothing missing, nothing short, they’d waived the SATs. It didn’t make sense. Something wasn’t right. What’s the problem and why am I finding out about this now?”

This part of the story seems odd and doesn't vibe. Why would Michigan admit him waving the SAT score and then say he can't enroll early because of his academic profile? 

cbs650

September 9th, 2023 at 6:31 AM ^

For those in the thread pointing out he went to Texas so its just admissions being admissions, lets not forget that he wasn't denied admissions to Michigan. He just couldn't enroll early. And he didn't enroll early at Texas either I don't believe. 

His mom also said she submitted everything in September. Schools do have the right after admitting you to rethink their decision once they get your final HS transcript. 

Cam

September 9th, 2023 at 6:48 AM ^

Plenty about her description of events doesn’t make sense, but it’s also clear Michigan didn’t handle this well to say the least. Whatever man. Have fun losing to Alabama tonight.

SlickNick

September 9th, 2023 at 7:08 AM ^

I'm all for these articles of recruits and some of our transfers going public. Shine the spot light on how ridiculous and seemingly unorganized Michigan's admission process is. I actually feel bad that this seems like it caused lots of stress for him and his family.

Optimism Attache

September 9th, 2023 at 7:16 AM ^

Either the mom is intentionally omitting important facts or Michigan, at the very least, screwed up the communication on this. We know there is less flexibility in admissions standards than some of us would like, but I'm not really surprised someone transferring to an online school wasn't granted early admission. If you look up Apex Learning Virtual School, the stories are not great. I doubt he was getting something comparable to a senior year of high school in one semester online. 

bronxblue

September 9th, 2023 at 8:49 AM ^

Yeah, I suspect the mom may be omitting some details here or conflating different statements.  There's probably also a lot of confusion in general - this was all during the pandemic and schools were scrambling.  But I also suspect there was a lot of "we'll need to review your transcript before final admissions" type of caveat communicated and that can oftentimes be missed or forgotten.  But UM allows guys to attend early pretty commonly - McCarthy was in his class and did so, for example - but there are expectations and maybe this school just didn't meet those standards and the admissions department made the call about the bridge courses and Worthy's parents were just unhappy about it all.

Perkis-Size Me

September 9th, 2023 at 7:51 AM ^

If Worthy’s family had this cleared with UM Admissions before they enrolled him in this online school, then the Admissions Dept backtracked on their word and I don’t blame Xavier, his mom or his family an ounce for being pissed and losing trust. 

But if they just decided to do this without consulting the Admissions Department about it, then…..what can you do? 

Regardless, I think we can all agree that the admissions process here oftentimes seems incredibly antiquated and absurdly difficult to navigate for no real good reason. I wonder how much of this is a situation of certain people being in charge of things for no reason, or people who have no business being in charge of anything important. 

All I know is that I hate he couldn’t come here. Imagine him catching balls from McCarthy this season….that’s a passing combo that gets Michigan over the top against a Georgia or Alabama. 

 

njvictor

September 9th, 2023 at 8:09 AM ^

So basically she enrolled her son in a seemingly questionable online program at the last second to get around her son’s schools requirements and is shocked that there was admissions issues? Yeah, I’m not gonna blame this one on admissions

bronxblue

September 9th, 2023 at 8:45 AM ^

Yeah, I know this place immediately rushes to blame everything on admissions (and there are issues with it) but in my brief review of Apex Learning online it seemingly can be gamed pretty easily.  Also, Michigan didn't deny Worthy admissions to UM; they denied him early admissions and instead basically said he needed to catch up over the summer.  That's happened before with guys at this school and they just...do it.  Or go somewhere else.  Lots of schools have programs like that for kids transitioning from HS to college, especially if they were on the border in terms of admissions or class requirements.  

Wendyk5

September 9th, 2023 at 8:33 AM ^

I hate when we rehash this kind of stuff here, based on an interview with a former player's parent (see Cade McNamara) and then take what the parent says as gospel. I don't know what happened but you can bet if it was on the University, Harbaugh is trying to fix it in some way. No one knows better than him that Worthy transferring was a loss for us. He also wants to uphold academic standards, as well he should -- this is college, not the NFL. 

bronxblue

September 9th, 2023 at 8:41 AM ^

Most of this was already known when he left (he didn't enroll mid-year and that had been his goal, so everyone was aware of it at the time), but also not a total surprise.  I understand that guys want to enroll early so they'll have a better chance of seeing the field, but with Gattis seemingly being a lynchpin and a lot of this article being about wanting to "honor his commitment" I do wonder if he would have just transferred at some point once Gattis was gone.  Just feels a bit like the match wasn't as solid but Worthy had a sense of duty to honor a commitment. 

I also will say that while I'm all for bashing admissions this is also during the pandemic and Worthy apparently tried to graduate early via some online school that isn't without controversy.  Lots of guys coming from traditional HS graduations are able to enroll early; 3 other guys from Worthy's class, including JJ, enrolled early.  Why Worthy couldn't get this squared away via his HS is another issue but I do understand UM looking at his transcript and saying "yeah, you might need to fill in some holes here" especially during a pandemic when a bunch of things were askew.

EastCoast Esq.

September 9th, 2023 at 9:11 AM ^

Our admissions department is garbage. But question....are Ivy League schools as stingy with this kind of stuff? Or other high end schools like Duke and Vanderbilt?

Also, do non-athletes have such problems with transferring and mid-year enrollments? I thought I saw something recently about a Stanford athlete having difficulties?

Basically...if our department is just a bureaucratic nightmare, then it is directly harming the school and getting in the way of our ability to attract top talent. Being obstructive is not the same as being picky.

M-Dog

September 9th, 2023 at 9:13 AM ^

I guess I can root for Texas today with a clear conscious, because I always thought that Worthy flipped solely because of Sark's tampering.  Turns out not to be the case.

That this was self-inflicted by Michigan shouldn't surprise anybody.  Guess I should not have been so quick to judge,

GN1282

September 9th, 2023 at 9:36 AM ^

Seems like a pretty easy fix for this type of situation going forward is to have a Winter Bridge program, as well.  
 

There is zero reason why this is offered only once per year 

jdemille9

September 9th, 2023 at 9:51 AM ^

My only issue with this is her comment about the trust not being there. This wasn't a trust issue, it's an archaic and asinine admissions policy that caused all the problems, not anyone lying or misleading or even anything to do with the football program. 

Carcajou

September 9th, 2023 at 11:06 AM ^

Seems to me that the football program/athletic department should way in advance already have a package for any athlete who wants to early enroll, including a list of approved schools and courses, etc. and even a liason to make sure it all goes through instead of leaving it on the student-athlete and his family.

mackbru

September 9th, 2023 at 12:00 PM ^

I'd guess many of the folks who think it's embarrassing that M has higher academic standards than most schools probably didn't go to Michigan. It's ok to have higher standards. It's a university, not a football factory. Consider the bigger picture.

Michigan no doubt already lets in plenty of athletes who wouldn't otherwise be academically qualified. Its standards are lower than, say, Stanford's -- and probably equal to those of ND or UCLA. Michigan doesn't lack for talent. It has the 2nd ranked team in the nation -- which is evidence enough that it can have higher standards and still field highly competitive teams.

HabsFanUSA

September 9th, 2023 at 1:01 PM ^

The narcissism of this place knows no bounds - this is just another example.

(I say this as a UM faculty member, my wife is a faculty member, with multiple U-M degrees among us and our kids.)

This kind of nonsense is the product of decision making by unsupervised middle managers who wield unfettered power.

Happens all the time in this arrogant institution.