Where Did Jim Harbaugh Go??

Submitted by JWG Wolverine on

Disclaimer: To be completely clear, I think anyone even thinking about Jim Harbaugh's job status is beyond insane. He is our coach, and no one could be better than him. This is just a post with a small concern that I think is emotionally hindering this team and need to be solved.

In December 2014, when rebuilding our program from an absolutely catostrophic scenario, our interim Athletic Director Jim Hackett did the impossible and made IT H4PPEN.

What followed that was the reignition of our program by the wildest and gif-yiest head coach in College Football who attacked each day with an enthusiasm unknown to mankind, and certainly showed that every week on the sideline.

I could go on forever, you should get the point by now.

I don't know if you guys have noticed, but this version of Jim Harbaugh that we've known and loved has become almost non-existant this year. Instead, we find him pacing the sidelines, with a very stable amount of enthusiasm, not even close to enthusiasm unknown to mankind.

Michigan players have always (and sincerely) loved playing under such a coach, and I think that his activity on the sideline keeps a spark under the team and is a factor in their performance, as well as their positive opinion on him.

So where has he gone? Where is this Jim Harbaugh that we love? Where is the QB that guaranteed a win over OSU? Where is the coach who has a more honest and meaningful press conference, unlike his Hoke-like bland coachspeak we saw out of him last night? Where is his attacking of each day with an enthusiasm unkown to mankind?

I thought that this loss would be a breaking point and a huge wake-up call for him, where he realizes (and says) that this game was unacceptable, that at Michigan, you can't have such a losing record to your rivals. Followed by improvement back to the old, active, enthusistic sideline Harbaugh. Amazingly, we didn't see this. Instead, we heard the infamous "We're on to Cincinnati" approach.

Now, I've realized that he has still kept up his enthusiasm on the recruiting trail, and from what we've seen in practice, and that this seems to be strictly a sideline problem.

I have two ideas what the cause of this may be:

Number One: Tim Drevno needs to be on the sideline. Having a coaches in the press box decreases the ability to manage your team on a personal level. Our offense has sucked, and Drevno has been in the press box, our defense has flourished, and Don Brown has not only been on the sideline, but has looked more Harbaugh-like than Harbaugh has.

Number Two: Fear that the refs may call less favorably due to his antics. After the "technical in basketball" incident at OSU last year, I think he may have a fear that if he reacts too much to bad calls, the refs will tend to have calls go Michigan's way less.

Obviously, we have other problems that should be on our mind, and this isn't a direct factor to winning and losing games, but I think it does have an affect on how these guys play on the field, and if they show energy, passion, hope and care or not. With Don Brown pumping up the defense, they have stepped up, faced adversity, and delivered. With Harbaugh pacing the sideline and talking to Drevno up in the box, our offense has showed less emotion, and as a result, less success.

Has anyone else noticed this? Any thoughts? What needs to be done?

blueday

October 8th, 2017 at 4:31 PM ^

In the middle of the field? Spaety filled the box all night. Little street ball .. get one of our tall TE running 10 yards down the field and jump toss it to him. Just one try. No ... more fade.

NateVolk

October 8th, 2017 at 4:01 PM ^

The league is populated with great coaches and schools now spending money on football. It's tougher now to get wins with a young team.

 

He's the best of the best in his field. I am sure if you asked observers who watch practice, the fire burns hotter than ever.

 

The off the field stuff is who he is. If the media finds him interesting, it's not his problem. He'd do all that stuff even if no one was watching.

Tuebor

October 8th, 2017 at 5:17 PM ^

And yet Harbaugh has failed to finish higher than 3rd in the divison and is looking like we will be 4th in the division this year, behind Meyer, Franklin, and Dantonio.  Nothing says 2nd best coach in the league like 3rd place finishes in the division.  Not to mention that Franklin now has a better Big Ten record than Harbaugh since 2015.

 

Big ten record since Harbaugh took over at Michigan:

OSU 18-2
PSU 15-5
UM  14-5

Looks like 3rd place to me.

 

He definitely isn't better than Dantonio.  1-2 against him.  And the fact that Dantonio took MSU from laughing stock to winning 65 games and 3 conference titles from 2010-2015.  You don't just throw that away because they had issues in 2016.  The last time Michigan had anything remotely close to that level of success was when we won 5 conference titles in 8 years from 1997 through 2004.  Since then Michigan has basically been Iowa, except even Iowa won a division title in 2015.

 

He has losing records against both Meyer and Dantonio, and while he is 2-0 against Franklin, Franklin won a big ten championship in year 3.  Hopefully I'm wrong, but we don't look like we are going to win a big ten championship this year.

 

Yeah MSU had a bad year in 2016, but they look better than us in the first half.  Can't blame the rain for that.

Tuebor

October 8th, 2017 at 6:21 PM ^

If you prefer a simpler metric I propose head to head record amongst the four coaches.  

Meyer 7-3
Dantonio 6-5
Harbaugh 3-4
Franklin 2-6

 

What do you know, Harbaugh is 3rd.

 

 

We might feel like Harbaugh is better than Dantonio, but the results don't back that up.

snarling wolverine

October 8th, 2017 at 7:44 PM ^

We were literally an inch or so from winning the division last year.   Hell, in Ann Arbor we probably get the 4th-down spot our way.  

I get you're trying to be a cool negative guy, but this is tiresome.  He's one of the best coaches in the country (100+ NCAA schools and probably 25 NFL teams would die to hire him) and you sound like you're trying to run him out of town.

 

bcnihao

October 8th, 2017 at 8:27 PM ^

Talk about moving the goal posts . . . .  Harbaugh is third-best in the division because of overall conference record.  Oh, but wait, he's not better than Dantonio because of head-to-head record.  But you're ignoring head-to-head record when comparing Harbaugh to Franklin.  Huh???

Maynard

October 8th, 2017 at 4:50 PM ^

Not bad. Not bad. But let's see, there is the 1-4 against rivals which is likely to fall to 1-5. There is the fact that MSU played in the playoff and Penn St. has a Big 10 title. And I don't have to even get into the difference between OSU and MIchigan records since then. So again, how is he not 4th in this division as far as coaching is concerned?

Woodstock Wolverine

October 8th, 2017 at 4:05 PM ^

What do you expect him to do? Yell and throw things at his young players?! I'm sure if we're in position to win a close game and refs fuck up he will show that fire. This thread is ridiculous and your assumptions are bad and you should feel bad.

JWG Wolverine

October 8th, 2017 at 5:47 PM ^

I expected him to talk to his players and fire them up. Not just pace around. Obviously his actions toward refs should NEVER be toward the team, that’s what Brian Kelly does, and it’s not good. JH knows that he shouldn’t do that, which is why he never has. Your assumptions of my thoughts are bad and you should feel bad.

kb

October 8th, 2017 at 4:03 PM ^

A couple Michigan players start shit with the MSU players even if it is a penalty. They sat there when MSU players were cheap shotting them.

jmblue

October 8th, 2017 at 4:04 PM ^

It feels like fans are searching for every alternative to the most straightforward explanation for our team's play, which is that the team just isn't that good this year.

We knew (or should have) that 2017 was going to be challenging: not only were we going to lose a crazy number of starters from the '16 team, but we weren't going to have as many upperclass contributors as usual, as both our '14 and '15 recruiting classes were small and underheralded.   And now we've lost our starting QB and top outside WR for the season.  We just have to hold down the fort as well as possible this year and then hopefully get back to business next year.

 

 

JWG Wolverine

October 8th, 2017 at 5:36 PM ^

This isn’t an excuse or why we lost the game. The team (well really the offense) is not good this year. That’s certainly our problem. I’m just saying that this is an interesting issue that could be affecting the confidence and passion of these players. Not at all a main factor, but a possible small (and controllable) issue that should be addressed.

bamf16

October 8th, 2017 at 5:42 PM ^

Compounding the tough to swallow pill that our favorite team isn't the best team us that the offensive coaches who should be doing things to help mitigate weaknesses and problems are inexplicably making them worse with a murky chain of command and an unwillingness to make changes that fools on a blog can diagnose. Tim Drevno as an OC is as in over his head as Brady Hole as a Head Coach.

Charmandar

October 8th, 2017 at 4:05 PM ^

Well Harbaugh was coaching on the sidelines last night. I am pretty sure he was Schembechler Hall today at some point. I don't have a GPS on the guy. 

Sambojangles

October 8th, 2017 at 5:11 PM ^

I was thinking that too. I don't really believe it as an explanation but it is possible that the baby, born premature in January, has had a bigger effect than anyone thought he would have. JH has played and coached through six other births, but maybe this one is different.

BIGBLUEWORLD

October 8th, 2017 at 4:10 PM ^

That's a very good post, both in thoughtful content and video presentation.

To answer your question: Ever since that Ohio State debacle with the cheeting skunk referees, he has been more subdued.

That game cost us a lot, both in terms of momentum and recruiting.

I think the turnaround is going to come with beating OSU in the Big House, and having a quarterback recruited by Harbaugh running the team.

Also, give Frey the line and get our offensive coaches working on the same page. Now.