OT: Michigan Stadium - Is it loud? What are your thoughts about the atmosphere?

Submitted by Amazinblu on December 12th, 2023 at 12:57 PM

Comments in another thread triggered a thought - which is - What's the atmosphere like in Michigan Stadium?

I'm old school and remember the time before the boxes were added to the east and west sides of the stadium.   There were a couple of thoughts back then - and, one was - the noise level on the field was "not so loud" - so, Michigan was a "wine and cheese" crowd.   Part of the answer reflected the shape of the bowl - which is parabolic.   One view (before the addition) was - the noise from one side of the stadium bounced off the opposing side and reflected "upward" (because of the parabolic shape) - the result being - at the focal point - a hundred or more yards above the playing surface, it was incredibly loud - but, the playing surface didn't capture that.

Then, of course - the boxes were added - the facade / face of the boxes are at an angle facing downward toward the field - which results in the sound from the east and west sides hitting the facades and reflecting downward to the playing surface.

I recall one of the UTL games.   A friend of mine was on the ND staff - and, after the game, one of his comments was - I've never been in a stadium that loud.

The UTL games were great environments - and, the past two OSU games in Ann Arbor were quite special too.   I think the Michigan v OSU game in '21 was the best environment for a sporting event that I've ever attended.

My question is:  What do you think of Michigan Stadium and the environment?   Is it loud - when it needs to be?   Can you tell a difference?  (Especially if you go back a few years to "before" the boxes were added.)

Prospects who visited The Game have also commented on the atmosphere.   Do you think it can impact their decision?

I love the look of the stadium - and, the noise level against key opponents.   I especially enjoyed the procedural infractions on the Buckeyes in '21 - which, I think were indicative of just how loud Michigan Stadium can be.

Go Blue!

goblu330

December 12th, 2023 at 1:26 PM ^

Michigan stadium is not particularly loud, but it has a unique sound.  For big games, the stadium has a hummmmm that lasts for the entire game.  Sometimes it revs up, sometimes it revs down, but it never turns off.  It is a marathon crowd, not a sprint. I have ran out of metaphors but people who have spent a lot of time there understand.

antidaily

December 12th, 2023 at 1:31 PM ^

UTL was definitely rockin. I just don't think the construction even with boxes traps the sound like other places. And perhaps the crowd isn't as wild either. But its loud enough. It makes a difference.

TruBluMich

December 12th, 2023 at 1:34 PM ^

I know what my watch recorded for sound (I have no idea how accurate that it is) during the Ohio State game and anyone who thinks 120db isn't loud needs to stop standing next to the speakers at rock concerts. It was at or around 100db+ the entire game when Michigan did not have the ball.  The Big House gets really loud when it needs to.

S.D. Jones

December 12th, 2023 at 1:45 PM ^

I've always thought part of the difference in sound level between the Big House and, say, Beaver Stadium or Camp-Randall was harmonics. That is, the metal from those two free-standing erector sets resonates sound while the dirt surrounding UM's in-ground bowl tends to dampen the volume. Of course, as an LS&A guy, my knowledge of structural engineering is vast. 

BoCanHam15

December 12th, 2023 at 1:54 PM ^

Ask,"Joel Klatt!"  Also it's obvious that we're loud on an as needed basis!  We're no ice cream social.  Beaver stadium is only,"loud" when they have a chance.  From my experience there's nothing better than a tamed lion.  Meow!!!

Baugh So Har

December 12th, 2023 at 2:01 PM ^

We need a full, elliptical awning over all the fans (at least the part of the bowl that’s above ground, to minimize on-field shadows) - like the Allianz Arena - to really bounce the sound back down on to the field

BornInA2

December 12th, 2023 at 2:06 PM ^

Last time I attended a game I pretty much hated the experience.

Blaring music, endless ad timeouts, and even then the 'scoreboard' was a distraction.

All that crap isn't about the game and, for me, makes attending the games in person less fun than watching at home where the beer is cheap and good, I have three games going at once, and I sit in a comfortable chair with no bathroom or food line.

goblu330

December 12th, 2023 at 2:14 PM ^

Yeah, going to a game has to be a different mindset.  When I go to a football game I never drink, that would suck.  Grab something to eat as I get in before I head down to seats and then I am in there for the long haul.  It appears that some people are willing to miss an entire game or experience to wait in a refreshment line.  Can't do that.

AppleFritters4Life

December 12th, 2023 at 2:46 PM ^

I was at the Washington night game a couple years back and then the following week I got tickets to the Penn State/Auburn white out. While Penn State was a little bit louder, (not much) the Michigan atmosphere was better, and a lot less repetitive. 

The in-game atmosphere at Beaver feels like a soundboard with 4 different songs/clips that they play on a loop all game long at every break in play. It gets old fast. At Michigan games, there is some of that but it's much better coordinated with what is actually happening in the flow of the game. 

 

I've been to 3 whiteouts and 3 Michigan night games and Michigan has done a good job of closing the gap in crowd noise, and is arguably the top atmosphere in the big ten. 

 

 

mackbru

December 12th, 2023 at 2:48 PM ^

I've been to a bunch of rival stadiums and the Big House at full tilt is actually among the loudest. PSU is the only one that gets consistently louder. Iowa gets as a loud. But Wisconsin and the toilet in Columbus are NOT as loud as their reputations suggest. Wisconsin does get rowdy, tho. 

shoes

December 12th, 2023 at 2:51 PM ^

The wine and cheese narrative was always false. It was purely a function of acoustics. A probably unintended consequence of the luxury seating was that sound is held in much better. The stadium is now (fairly) loud and it is an excellent atmosphere. It will nevr be Autzen stadium in Oregon or Tiger Stadium in baton Rouge at night, but it is pretty good.

BlueGoM

December 12th, 2023 at 3:33 PM ^

yes it's loud.  Much louder once they put in the new structures.

The new gigantic scoreboards w/equally large speakers are also very loud.  Don't buy seats next to them you won't be able to hear yourself think.

 

 

JacquesStrappe

December 12th, 2023 at 3:39 PM ^

Penn State and The Columbus Crapper are loud as are Camp Randall and Kinnick at times. But in my experience none of those are as loud as Neyland Stadium (Tennessee’s Fighting Fulmers)

The two Death Valleys (LSU and Clemson) are apparently deafening as is Bama, Georgia, Texas A&M . Can’t say myself as I haven’t been to either of those five.

uminks

December 12th, 2023 at 6:34 PM ^

I attended the OSU game this season and it was the loudest game I ever remember attending. Every time OSU had the ball it got loud.  I attended many games in the 80s and then only one home game every other year. In the 90s, up to present time., When I was young it seem like a lot of older people (over 50) always liked to sit. Now that I'm older, I stood the entre game and cheered my ass off.

WolverineHistorian

December 12th, 2023 at 6:56 PM ^

Beaver Stadium having all those decks really helps their crowd noise.  But the stadium is ugly as hell both inside and out.  We don't have the ugly factor at the big house, which I appreciate.  

We're not the loudest but we were never the wine and cheese crowd either.  There were plenty of non-rivalry games where I remember the crowd being incredible.  I was at the game when Henne threw the pass to Manningham on the last play against Penn State.  I was at the Northwestern game in Harbaugh's first season when the crowd did the "Defense!" chants.  

This is going back some years but remember when Henson threw the over the shoulder touchdown pass to David Terrell against Wisconsin?  At the time, I thought that was the loudest the big house had ever been for a non-rivalry game.  That entire game, the crowd was on fire despite the fact it was so low scoring (we won 13-10).  

ezmoney

December 12th, 2023 at 7:00 PM ^

It’s been many years since I’ve sat in the stands at Michigan Stadium but being on the sidelines I’ve always thought crowd noise is not that big of a deal. It certainly gets quieter as you move towards midfield on the home or west sidelines. At times you “feel” the crowd when in the end zones but it’s nothing like Columbus. When on the field in Columbus and the stadium is completely empty you can clearly hear someone in a very soft voice speaking from all way the across to the far end zone. Really amazing acoustics.

Buffalowing Blue

December 13th, 2023 at 7:58 AM ^

I heard it was really loud for the osu games but TV does it no justice IMO. Even the noise reduction on cell phones by fans doesn't give you an idea how loud it is.

I've seen one video vs osu this year (which was yesterday) that was down on the field near the student section where it was the closest I felt to hearing and feeling how loud it was on Blakes first TD run.  It was a bar stool camera following Taylor Lewan.

I think if they enclosed the two ends around the scoreboards a bit more it would hold in more noise but a lot of it has to do with the older crowd as many have mentioned.

dragonchild

December 13th, 2023 at 10:55 AM ^

Correct, the stadium reflects sound upward.  Probably deafening for those banner planes.

Michigan Stadium can get loud on the field, but mostly due to sheer volume - it has one of the, if not the highest seating capacity in the country.

The parabolic bowl is actually better for the band.  There's little echo to smear out notes, so the band sounds crisp.  That said, everyone's moving to piped music so we might outlive the MMB.