Indiana People vs. Ohio People

Submitted by Firstbase on

SIAP, but here's an eyebrow-raising excerpt from Bob Wojnowski of The Detroit News comparing Indiana people to those from Ohio. 

"Wolverines-Boilermakers is merely the opener in a huge one-day clash between the neighboring states of Michigan and Indiana, a friendly, respectful border rivalry. It doesn’t quite garner the attention of the Michigan-Ohio spat, largely because Indiana people are proud, simple folk, while Ohio people are dolts with horrific behavioral issues."

Link

DMill2782

September 22nd, 2017 at 10:09 AM ^

Here's what is weird about Indiana and Trump. Back in 2011 Trump was picked to be the pace car driver for the 100th anniversary of the Indy 500. Indiana residents were not happy. Everyone hated Trump so much that he was viewed as an unacceptable choice for the 100th anniversary of the 500. 

People like me spearheaded a movement called Dump Trump to have him removed as the pace car driver. We did not talk to one single person who opposed our idea of removing him. We got the job done (writing letters, petitions, social media movement) and got him removed. Somehow, this state turned around and overwhelmingly voted for him to be President. Not good enough to drive a pace car, but good enough to run the country. Makes zero sense.

http://www.indystar.com/story/life/2016/05/23/time-donald-trump-nearly-…

billybrown

September 22nd, 2017 at 9:32 AM ^

Just recently moved to central indiana so my girlfriend can finish up school. Bought a nice big house but where we live is less than appealing. The people I've encountered have been mostly awful. People use mopeds as their main source of transportation. I haven't enjoyed it at all. Can't wait to return to ann arbor in about 5 years time. Still display our Michigan flag proudly on our front lawn. Haven't heard any football related smack talk yet.

jblaze

September 22nd, 2017 at 9:44 AM ^

I gotta be honest. The Cincinnati fans that I met at the game were all super nice and solid people. Maybe the jerks live in Cleveland/ Columbus thing.

Perkis-Size Me

September 22nd, 2017 at 9:50 AM ^

Cincinnatti is likely pretty well split between being an OSU town and a UK town. Lexington is only an hour and a half drive from there, about the same as it is from Cincy to Columbus. While they're definitely there, I don't think you're going to find as many rabid OSU fans in Cincinnatti as you will in Columbus (duh) or Cleveland.

Cincinnatti is also definitely much more of a pro town than it is a college town. 

UNCWolverine

September 22nd, 2017 at 10:01 AM ^

I never thought about this before. I know it's written mostly tongue and cheek like most of his material, but there is certainly some truth to it. I grew up in the area of Michigan that is close to both borders. I think it was 7 miles to Indiana and 15 to Ohio. My father is from Indiana and I spent a lot of time in both states growing up and around people from both states that had cottages on our lakes. Pretty good call by Wojo on this. Go blue.

SFBlue

September 22nd, 2017 at 10:02 AM ^

I dislike Ohio, but to me Indiana is far more of a backwater. Take away Bloomington and it's a flattened hellscape of strip malls, cheap beer, and chain restaurants.

LSAClassOf2000

September 22nd, 2017 at 10:15 AM ^

I really try to judge people on their individual merits regardless of where they are from. The only knock I'll put out there against Ohio (other than the Buckeyes and their fans) is that the northwest and west-central parts of the state going south to nearly Dayton produce some of the most dreadfully boring drives on the face of the Earth. There are no features to the land except a stray Mennonite now and again. The drive south on I-75 between Toledo and Dayton is a drive through a part of the country that we seem to have forgotten was there. 

Chuck

September 22nd, 2017 at 10:17 AM ^

Raised in Indiana. Michigan grad and current Michigan scientist. 1st time it’s become abundantly clear why everyone really fucking hates us outside of sports too...

Shop Smart Sho…

September 22nd, 2017 at 10:29 AM ^

For all of the Michigan residents shitting on Indiana and Ohio, I'd like to remind you that SE Michigan exists, and we know about it.

I'm from Indiana, and the only time I've seen parents pour Mt. Dew into their 2 year old's sippy cup was in Michigan. Your state also contains Lansing and all that it entails.

SpikeFan2016

September 22nd, 2017 at 11:14 AM ^

In general, these broad asides on a state scale are pretty dumb, as Michigan has more in common with IN/OH as an entire state than it does with many other states in the country (on a university/college town level, comparisons are more appropriate as the differences are much more drastic). 

 

However, there are, for better or worse, two distinct differences between Michigan and Ohio/Indiana.

1. Rural Culture:

  • In the rural parts of Michigan, the culture leans a little Canadian-esque, particularly in the northern half of the state. 
  • In Indiana and Ohio, the rural culture leans Southern/Appalachian, especially in the southern half of those states.
  • This all makes natural sense given MI's proximity to Canada and IN/OH's proximity to Kentucky/West Virginia.

2. Politics (Whether these are pros or cons is up to you, but they are facts; not trying to be normative about which is better!)

  • Michigan is far more politically moderate/liberal than Indiana, and to a lesser degree, than Ohio.
  • In terms of politics, Michigan is very similar to Wisconsin and Minnesota (Lean Democratic states that can be swing states depending on the cycle; Obama won all three by large margins twice; Trump won MI/WI by tiny margins, his two closest wins in the entire country, while Clinton held on in MN by a tiny, but slightly larger margin).
  • Ohio is most similar to Iowa politically (Swing States that decidedly Lean Republican; Obama won them both twice, but by thin margins, whereas Trump won them comfortably by large margins).
  • Indiana is by far the most socially and politically conservative state in the Midwest, and is the only solidly Republican state in the Midwest. Romney won Indiana by more than 10 points in a year when Obama swept the rest of the Great Lakes region by mostly large margins; in 2016 Trump won by nearly 20 points which is a landslide (I consider the Dakotas-Oklahoma "The Plains", which would be a separate region).
  • Indiana is most similar to Missouri politically, but Indiana is actually more Republican than several southern states (Georgia, South Carolina, North Carolina, Mississippi, although the difference among this group is primarily due to racial demographics). 

His Dudeness

September 22nd, 2017 at 10:59 AM ^

Neither state can effing drive.

It's KEEP RIGHT except to pass. My god, how hard is that ?

Anyway, from my experience the more loathesome creature is actually the Indiana native. It's the completely unexpected and seething racism that narrowly gives them the crown over Ohio for worst midwestern state.

Congrats Indiana. Don't let the meth hit you on the way out.