Fleck extended at Minnesota

Submitted by jimmyshi03 on November 3rd, 2021 at 3:34 PM

https://apnews.com/article/college-football-sports-football-minnesota-minnesota-golden-gophers-football-3d7f3c38961ffeac77af035fc547d0dc
 

Terms not yet available, but I’d imagine this includes a salary bump (piece above mentions he’s currently middle of the league pack), as well as buyout protection for the school. Fleck’s been mentioned as a potential second tier candidate for a couple of other jobs, like USC, so this looks like Minnesota heading anything off at the pass. 

TrueBlue2003

November 3rd, 2021 at 8:10 PM ^

Them being ranked by the CFP is mind boggling.  I can see Wisconsin given their schedule and the fact they crushed both Purdue and Iowa but what has Minnesota done?! 

Beat Purdue in a close game.  Is that impressive?  The committee seemed to totally ignore bad losses (Oregon, Miss St., Minn, Pitt) which is always infuriating to me.  If you lose to a good team, you get punished because the committee thinks you have to be behind them, but if you lose to a bad team, it gets ignored!

Newton Gimmick

November 4th, 2021 at 11:54 AM ^

The problem with Top 25 rankings is that you have to find 25 teams.  If it wasn't Minnesota, it would be a similarly flawed team.

Your last point is a good and underrated one.  Head-to-head and quality-of-loss are often conflicting criteria.  If A&M hadn't lost a close game to Mississippi St, they would have one loss instead of two and Alabama would have to be behind them in the rankings.  Yet the fact A&M lost to Miss St should make Alabama's loss to A&M a 'worse loss.' 

FB Dive

November 3rd, 2021 at 4:41 PM ^

His acceptance of the MSU job was exceedingly unenthusiastic, he doesn't deny interest in the LSU job when asked about it, and his success this season is built on the one-time transfer rule.

His stock is peaking right now, and if LSU offers him the job, I think he takes it. Taking the MSU job was a business decision, he has no emotional loyalty to them, and LSU job > MSU job in almost every possible way.

Robbie Moore

November 3rd, 2021 at 5:23 PM ^

If Tucker ends the season with one loss...to Ohio State...then LSU will pay whatever Tucker wants. The success Tucker has conjured up out of nothing may not be built to last but the accomplishment is a fact. Tucker knows the SEC. He's proven he can win. He would have talent rich Louisiana to himself. Makes all the sense in the world for both parties.

And then there is USC... 

Ezekiels Creatures

November 3rd, 2021 at 7:28 PM ^

I'm not so sure Tucker is as successful as you are portraying. His defense is ranked 103rd in the Nation, and the offense 34th. In 3 of his wins they have been outgained, and some fluky things have helped them win those 3 games. You have the 103rd defense in the SEC and you are road kill to half the teams.

Perkis-Size Me

November 3rd, 2021 at 5:12 PM ^

Its possible he stays. He has all the job security in the world (for now), and I believe MSU is building new football facilities so they have that going for them. But if I were him I would at least listen to what LSU's offer is. 

Saban may be at Alabama for the next few years but he's not going to be there forever. At the end of his current contract he'll be just about 75 years old. I doubt he has another extension in him. When he leaves, there is going to be a massive power vacuum in the SEC, especially in that division, and LSU is probably the best program to be able to seize on that opportunity. They usually recruit as well as Alabama in any given year, and with the right coach they should be competing with and beating Alabama on an at least somewhat regular basis, even while Saban is there.

Meanwhile, I feel like OSU is not going anywhere anytime soon. They've plugged and played coaches for years and just kept finding ways to get better. You really want to have to keep dealing with that every year? Because at MSU he's going to have to. You're not getting past that juggernaut more than once or twice in a decade. 

LSU is always going to be a better job than MSU, and the ceiling is certainly higher. It just is. That doesn't mean Tucker will take it necessarily, but again, I'd at least listen to what their offer is if I'm him. 

Blueblood80

November 3rd, 2021 at 8:03 PM ^

I can see this point as legit.  Aside from their running back, who is admittedly very very good, this MSU team has a smoke and mirrors feel to it.
Maybe we were just too used to the douchery of Dantonio but Tucker doesn’t seem to have the same passion of hatred towards U of M.  He seems more business like. 

jdib

November 4th, 2021 at 3:04 AM ^

You're operating under false pretenses on a few counts here:

 

1)  That money is the only considering factor to why he would go to LSU.  I think that the advantages of a rife recruiting ground in Louisiana makes it a much easier gig to be successful. 

2)  He's struck gold this year.  There's no guarantees next year after some of the Dantonio recruits leave that he even has a modicum of success like he did this year.  He outperformed in almost every way with the expectations of his current roster.  We saw this success with Hoke here when he went 11-2 and went to the Sugar Bowl and pulled a victory in 2011.  It didn't really translate as his record progressively got worse every year thereafter.

3)  He left his old job in the 11th hour after he pretty much publicly stated he wasn't going anywhere.  I would assume that type of loyalty carried over to this coming situation he will be in when other schools come calling

 

I'm pretty sure if LSU comes callin'... he gone.

1VaBlue1

November 3rd, 2021 at 3:58 PM ^

BGSU is a funny loss, but he also has them in the middle of the B1G West race with Wisconsin.  Again.  He's doing okay at football, as far as Minnesota is concerned...

Creedence Tapes

November 3rd, 2021 at 4:33 PM ^

Big bowl game victory when he won 11 games in 2019

Big deal. Like that even means anything! That was TWO whole years ago. Since 2015, Harbaugh has more wins (56) than Fleck does (53). What has he done since 2015 besides win 13 games at Western and 11 at Minnesota? I'll tell you what he did, he LOST to Harbaugh last year. End of story.

Past success only counts for our current coach, not someone that's clearly up and coming who's achieved higher success in two season already, at two different schools, with far lower ranked athletes at significantly smaller programs.

trueblueintexas

November 4th, 2021 at 1:08 PM ^

Whenever college football realignment threads start, it's always about trying to get the best teams to join the conference, but now it's not fair because the part of the conference Michigan is in is too hard? 

In 2012 Alabama played LSU during the regular season and then again in the championship. Was that the right thing? I said it wasn't at the time, but the point is, win your games and things work out.

Michigan needs to figure out how to put together a season where they don't lose a dumb game and they will get their chance. An 11-1 Michigan team with a close loss to OSU would be considered one of the top 4 teams. A 10-2 Michigan team who OSU beats by 25+ isn't considered and they shouldn't be. 

Perkis-Size Me

November 3rd, 2021 at 5:17 PM ^

You know how many more games Harbaugh would've won by now if he was in that crapshack of a division? The Big Ten West is one of the weakest in college football on a regular basis. Its the Wild West (no pun intended) because outside of Illinois literally anyone in that division can win it in any given year. We rail on Harbaugh for not getting the job done, and it’s true that he hasn’t, but he is also coaching in easily the toughest and deepest division in the sport. Three other teams in the East are either currently in the top 5 or have spent part of the season in the top 5. 

Harbaugh would be winning the Western division and would be in Indy at least every other year. 

tenerson

November 3rd, 2021 at 4:39 PM ^

As they should. I'm not a fan of the guy but he's winning at a higher clip than any has there since 1950 and while MN has some talent, it's not exactly prime recruiting ground especially when any top level guys will have southern options. 

I think he'll jump as I do a lot of those guys in those jobs but it's pretty clear that guys like him, Campbell, Fickell, etc., aren't taking the risk for a small step up. They can make a load of money doing things their way with a much lower stress level, better quality of life, and much less "input" from boosters and legacy guys. It'd be good for college football if that was a trend that stuck around for awhile. 

matt1114

November 3rd, 2021 at 7:37 PM ^

Agreed. I could see some desperate NFL team offering Campbell and Fickell and they'll take it. I could also see Ryan Day getting an offer and Fickell swooping in to get the OSU job. 

I'm surprised Fleck didn't leave after 2019 as he had gotten Minnesota to an Outback bowl win, and in my opinion the best record Minnesota will have in his tenure. He will probably finish this season with 2 loses, do something similar next year, and some school will pay a ton to get him there(FSU). 

 

SFBlue

November 3rd, 2021 at 4:58 PM ^

Gophers are a sneaky 6-2. Even if they finish out 2-2 it is Fleck's second best season (notwithstanding a loss to BGSU that is hard to understand). Grinding out wins against Nebraska, and Purdue (on the road), is harder than it looks.