Even after the flips today Michigan holds the #10 recruiting class in the nation

Submitted by mGrowOld on December 16th, 2020 at 5:27 PM

https://www.cbssports.com/college-football/news/college-football-recruiting-rankings-2020-top-classes-emerge-during-early-national-signing-day/

Given the uncertainty at the top of our coaching staff and certainly on the defensive side of the ball (allegedly) finishing up at #10 is not that bad.  Could've been worse, way, way worse (just ask a Purdue fan).  The entire B1G as follows:

#2   OSU

#10 Michigan

#16 Wisconsin

#19 Maryland

#21 Penn State

#22 Iowa

#23 Nebraska

#27 Minnesota

#33 Michigan State

#40 Rutgers

#58 Northwestern

#61 Indiana

#76 Illinois 

#79 Purdue

 

rob f

December 16th, 2020 at 5:58 PM ^

While I'm not at all satisfied with the trajectory of Michigan Football under Harbaugh over the last few seasons, I hope this forever silences the idea I've seen from some (not so much lately, though) that Jeff Brohm would be an attractive candidate to take over the reigns at Michigan.

Purdue is a difficult but not impossible place to build a winner. Brohm's recruiting woes aren't helping his cause. 

bronxblue

December 16th, 2020 at 10:10 PM ^

Yeah, I've noticed way fewer "Michigan should get somebody like Brohm, Fleck, etc." around these parts recently.  At least with Fleck he can still sorta point at recruiting (though 38th ain't great considering the bulk of it was built off last year's success), but Brohm's classes at Purdue have gotten progressively worse (though this year's class only being 14 players may be part of the reason for the low ranking; on a per-player average it's a bit more middle-of-the-pack) and his teams have not been good on the field.  

MS3

December 16th, 2020 at 5:42 PM ^

Yep, as polarized as we the fans are regarding the coaching staff, credit must be given when it's due. But that doesn't absolve them from the cluster that was this season. Salvaging the recruiting class today is a good first step, but they need to get some combination of Jaden McBurrows, Jaydon Hood, Ceyair Wright, George Rooks, Rayshaun Benny or the depth on defense will be worse than it was this year.

Mike Damone

December 16th, 2020 at 5:46 PM ^

Awesome job by Coach Harbaugh and his assistants during a challenging 2020.

Really hope the good folks on this blog can recognize this and be happy and positive - at least until tomorrow when the bitching likely to recommence.

crg

December 16th, 2020 at 5:49 PM ^

Notice that the loudest voices doing the complaining are the ones on here the least (either "newer" accounts or old accounts that rarely post).  The bloggers that are active day-in and day-out on these boards have a bit more understanding and awareness of things.

CC_MFan

December 16th, 2020 at 7:47 PM ^

I don't think that is true.  I think everyone understands the situationg.  We all feel good about the recruiting class, but with reservations about a few positions being thin.  The main issues of roster management, player retention and player development have not been addressed.  If cleaning house on the D coaches is the answer we will all be happy.  Bottom line is it looks like JH is getting another chance deservedly or not.

Hail to the Vi…

December 16th, 2020 at 8:09 PM ^

And reality is they are never not going to. Credit to the coaches for signing a talented class, but in my opinion closing the gap with OSU is going to be done in the film room and game planning sessions during the week. OSU is also eating our lunch there as well right now and that needs to change. Michigan just isn't going to recruit at that level to match the on-field talent on a consistent basis. Not that they couldn't do it, they just aren't going to do what it takes to get to that level.

We'll have to get better at preparing the element of surprise and self-scouting our own tendencies in order to starting winning a few here and there in the rivalry

Bo Harbaugh

December 16th, 2020 at 5:48 PM ^

Agreed.  The skill and speed brought in on the offensive side of the ball over the past 2 seasons give Harbaugh a chance -even if slim- to rewrite the narrative of his Michigan tenure.

He better pray the new defensive staff can coach these guys up, get some transfers on the D-Line, and teach and rotate scheme. 

OwenGoBlue

December 16th, 2020 at 6:52 PM ^

I have the obvious preference for known guys with stars like Benny or Wright but sleeper guys could be more interesting than in most years.

With all the camps/games/visits cancelled it seems pretty likely that big schools and the rankings industry will miss on more talented guys than usual this cycle. 

stephenrjking

December 16th, 2020 at 5:52 PM ^

Thing is, our recruiting has never been awful.

It's the roster management, the development, the Xs and Os. Michigan's recruiting has not been organized well and we have gaping holes at key positions. And we're not recruiting well enough to equal OSU.

But OSU is one game a year. And if Michigan were going 11-1 every year we'd get more interest from recruits, retain the guys we have better, and things wouldn't be a mess.

I'm glad that our offensive talent looks good. I'd be a lot happier if I had any real confidence that we could hang on to all of these guys. But at least there is talent there on the chance that Harbaugh miraculously turns the corner, or alternatively the chance that we get a solid offensive coach in 2022. Better to have supplies in the cupboard than not. 

1VaBlue1

December 16th, 2020 at 7:42 PM ^

This...  There is plenty of talent on the team (save for DT), but it hasn't been used well, at all - especially offensively.  I have my doubts that these guys will be used well.

But, you know what?  Since it appears that Harbaugh will stick around, then I'll support him and hope for the best.  He needs to prove he can get it done better than the last 4 years have shown, but I'll be pulling for him.

True Blue Grit

December 16th, 2020 at 6:08 PM ^

Poor defensive line recruiting the last several years is completely unacceptable given how successful Michigan has been at other positions.  Michigan can't compete at a high level unless this improves.  I think it comes down to the defensive coaches responsible for recruiting the DT and DE positions.  Michigan needs to upgrade.  

andrewgr

December 16th, 2020 at 8:55 PM ^

To be a first round picky, you either need to be in the top sixteen-ish of eligible players at any position, or else in the 17-ish to 50-ish range while matching a position of immediate need for a team selecting in the bottom half of the first round.

JJ is playing a position that only one person plays at, meaning in any given year, there's a limited number of teams that are willing to spend a first round pick.  He'll need to be top 2-4 at his position the year he comes out.  It's possible, but there's no reason to expect that to be the case, particularly with how QBs have been developed under Harbaugh at Michigan.

Edwards is in any even worse situation.  He plays RB, the position with the shortest career in the NFL (meaning, a team is really minimizing their return on the investment of a high pick if they select a RB, as opposed to, say, an OL who plays for 16 years).  NFL teams have been shying away from first round RB selections to a dramatic degree recently, as a replacement level RB is not so much of a step down from an All-NFL RB as it is at most other positions.

Worthy isn't even in the conversation for top 5 WRs in this recruiting year.  Maybe he's top 10, depending on rating service.  Unless you have some secret knowledge not available to the rest of us, there's simply no reason to predict that he'll pass much more highly ranked WRs that are ahead of him, many of whom are joining teams with much more prolific offenses than UM's.  It could happen, of course, and one can hope for it to happen-- but to expect it to happen seems irrational.

Michigan's haul on the offensive side of the ball would have them finishing in the top 10, maybe top 8, if it is duplicated year after year.  A fan can always hope to catch lightning in a bottle with a couple of players, or with a new OC, or with a generational QB; if that happens, it could be a top 4 offense in any given year, with this sort of recruiting.  So depending on expectations, that could be very satisfying.

Let's not talk about defensive recruiting.

Blue Middle

December 16th, 2020 at 5:55 PM ^

It's pretty much all offense.  From another thread:

Is this the best overall offensive class we've had in Harbaugh's tenure?  Four top -100 players along with four more in the top 275.  Dunlap, Bounds, and Anthony look like potential gems.

I know there a lot of negativity out there right now--and much of it is deserved--but damn, this looks like an amazing offensive class.

Congrats to the offensive staff and recruiters as a whole.

That said...yes, there are some significant holes on the other side of the ball...

True Blue 9

December 16th, 2020 at 5:58 PM ^

Really interesting to see how far down there Indiana is. 12th in Recruiting in the Big Ten is big yikes....Tom Allen clearly has a knack for getting everything out of the talent he gets but recruiting top talent is clearly not their forte.