College Game Day - Week 9 - Where?

Submitted by GRRBlue on October 18th, 2021 at 4:43 PM

UM @ MSU would seem to be the logical choice if UM takes care of business v NW.  If so, I am sure Sparty (Papa Doc) would have nothing witty or original in the sign department.  

A check on that slate of weekend games:

PSU @ OSU

UM@ MSU

Ole Miss @ Auburn

TrueBlue2003

October 18th, 2021 at 5:12 PM ^

That's like the 8th best reason it'll be in Columbus.  He'd have plenty of time to fly from EL to Columbus between noon and 730 and he does that all the time.  But it's not even a question that it'll be in Columbus because:

1) OSU-PSU is a bigger game in terms of national audience appeal

2) It's objectively a "better" matchup in terms of team quality: the 5th v 7th ranked teams compared to the 6th and 9th.

3) it's being broadcast on a Disney channel so given the above, of course Gameday is going to promote that game

FB Dive

October 18th, 2021 at 5:15 PM ^

Just saying, GameDay doesn't always go to the game Herbstreit is calling, and they usually just try to pick the best game, regardless of which network has it. Just this year, GameDay has gone to UGA-Kentucky and Wisco-ND, neither of which was on ESPN. There are plenty of examples from every year.

They will pass on the "best" game if Herbstreit wouldn't have time to fly to the game he's set to call (which is why Penn State-Iowa wasn't Gameday -- the Red River Game was set to kick at noon ET, so GameDay had to be there if Herbstreit was going to call it). They'll also choose a second-tier game if the GameDay game would be directly competing with one of ESPN's premier games (ie at the same time).

So while it's certainly possible GameDay will choose OSU-Penn State, it's not a sure thing. Our game and that game are at different times so they're not competing with each other, and Herbstreit has plenty of time to fly from East Lansing to Columbus. 

stephenrjking

October 18th, 2021 at 7:26 PM ^

Responding to both you and TrueBlue:

Gameday does not only attend games that Herbie is calling. You've given a couple of examples here, and there are many others. When there is a clear best game of the day and it's not on an ESPN network, Gameday goes, because it's a college football show. This has been immensely good for the entire sport for over 25 years now and they have earned respect and plaudits for it.

However: They do have a bit of a network bias. It's just logistically easier for a number of reasons if Gameday is at a game that is already being broadcast on their network. 

PSU and OSU both have a loss while the Michigan teams don't, but they also both have had much harder schedules to this point, and the winner of that game is the favorite to win the division. So the two games are basically even with regard to significance. Given that they're roughly equal, I'd expect PSU-OSU to get the nod. 

But if OSU loses to Indiana (or PSU loses to IllinHAHAHAHA uh nevermind on this one) they could change their mind. Obviously, it wouldn't be hard for Herbstreit to fly to Columbus in that case. 

chatster

October 18th, 2021 at 7:47 PM ^

Having ESPN’s College Game Day crew in Columbus on October 30 for the Penn State-Ohio State game would be the logical choice, but consider an extreme longshot choice – Dartmouth at Harvard.

Both teams currently are 5-0 in the Ivy League standings. If Harvard wins at Princeton (5-0) and Dartmouth beats Columbia (4-1) at home this Saturday, that would set up a noon matchup between unbeaten Ivy League teams. College Game Day hasn’t been at Harvard since November 2014 for the Harvard-Yale game. Absent weather-related issues, getting to Columbus from Boston for the Ohio State-Penn State game at 7:30 wouldn’t be a serious problem for Herbstreit.

stephenrjking

October 18th, 2021 at 7:28 PM ^

They do it a lot, because they are a college football show and they have enough integrity to recognize that they don't broadcast every important game. They've done this for decades. Literally the first on-site show ever was for Notre Dame-FSU in '93 when it was the 1-2 matchup, and that was broadcast on NBC.

The Gameday product is immensely better because of this. When you watch, you think, "they love college football," not, "they're selling me something." And college football is better for it. So, in this case, a rising tide lifts all boats. 

chatster

October 18th, 2021 at 6:55 PM ^

This weekend in Los Angeles, besides the ESPN College Game Day crew broadcasting from UCLA’s campus in Westwood ahead of the UCLA-Oregon game at the Rose Bowl in Pasadena, the NBC Sports Premier League Fan Fest crew will be up even earlier, broadcasting from the Memorial Coliseum in Los Angeles while the USC football team will be visiting Notre Dame. LINK

1VaBlue1

October 18th, 2021 at 8:35 PM ^

I dislike 'the Bear'.  I don't think he adds anything, and every time the camera cuts to him it feels contrived.  Plus, he doesn't like Michigan - I know from last week, when he asked the trivia question about the last time the Big Ten had two top 5 teams playing each other when one of them wasn't OSU.  He specifically stated that UM wasn't necessary to that question.  Fuck him...  Who cares if it was technically correct?  It was an obvious slight towards Michigan, so fuck him.

NittanyFan

October 18th, 2021 at 5:01 PM ^

Lee Corso's first ever "head-gear pick" was when GameDay was in Columbus for a PSU/OSU game in October 1996.

This is the 25th anniversary of that, so this may be a factor in this decision as well.

MH20

October 19th, 2021 at 9:02 AM ^

Mitchell is starting to become a bit polarizing not unlike Harbaugh. Wins a high percentage of games, has shown the propensity to drop one he shouldn't, and is now deep in the hole to his main rival. GV fans are getting a little antsy as it's been since 2016 that they've made a regional final, and that game was a stinging loss to, you guessed it, Ferris State.