michgoblue

January 4th, 2017 at 10:35 AM ^

I am curious - is the film that you are referring to Peters film in which he looks awesome or McCaffrey film in which he looks sub-par. 

Either way, likely doesn't matter all that much, as one was a true freshman who redshirted and the other is still in high school.  It may be true that Peters will take over and lock down the QB spot starting in 2018 (or even 2017 if he is better than Speight / O'Korn), but it is probably too too early to make that call now.

Venom7541

January 4th, 2017 at 11:19 AM ^

From the high school film I've seen from both of them (not hightlights, but full games), Peters looked much more poised and ready for the college game. That being said, I don't know which one has the higher cielling, I just know when I watched Peters, I was amazed at the command of the game he had. With McCaffrey, I saw an athelete, but I wasn't sure how good of a quarterback he was.

I will say, it did look to me like they used McCaffrey as more than just quaterback, but had him play all over, where Peters was solely the quarterback. That could have an affect on my impressions of each and maybe affected how each developed. 

They both will be amazing in my opion tho. I just see Peters as the most likely to start once the time comes.