Your 2015 Harbaugh Staff Comment Count

Brian

WELP. You know, you schedule a thing in Cleveland right after OSU loses to Virginia Tech and you think two things: 1) OSU is definitely not going to be winning the national title that night and 2) Michigan's not going to be finalizing its assistant coaches after hiring Jim Freakin' Harbaugh. I've been playing catchup this week.

BUT ANYWAY. Your assistant coaches.

OFFENSIVE COORDINATOR/OFFENSIVE LINE

ncf_a_tim-drevno_mb_600x600[1]

TIM DREVNO. I'm mostly through his hello post. Upshot: Harbaugh vet with OC experience under him at San Diego who coached TEs and OL at Stanford (yes please) before following Harbaugh to San Francisco, where the OL's performance was highly variable. Drevno left last year to go to USC, where he had excellent results with an extremely young (as in three true freshman starters) Trojan line.

Drevno's a good fit with Harbaugh specifically and appears to be the most qualified OL coach Michigan's had in forever. USC fans were super pissed about losing him.

QUESTIONS. Is OC/OL too much for one plate? How are his recruiting chops?

SOMEWHAT UNFAIR GRADE. A-. Lack of big-time OC experience the one drawback; tons to offset that.

RUNNING BACKS

TYRONE WHEATLEY. You know Wheat. Even if you are a pup, there is Wolverine Historian for you. Michigan legend, quick-riser once he hung up the spurs, driven to be a head coach. Should be a killer recruiter and guy who tells guys to run at the holes.

QUESTIONS. Is there enough of a difference in RB coaches to matter, or is vision un-salvageable?

SOMEWHAT UNFAIR GRADE. A. Excellent trajectory, is Ty Freaking Wheately.

WIDE RECEIVERS

011311-NFL-Seahawks-Jedd-Fisch-PI_20110113141821167_660_320[1]

JEDD FISCH. Former OC at Minnesota, Miami, and with the Jaguars was dumped after two years in Jacksonville during which he was provided not much talent and a ton of rookies. Two-year tenure at Miami was highly encouraging, featuring a big turnaround from Jacory Harris and the development of pretty-good Stephen Morris.

Fisch's WR experience is somewhat limited. He didn't play football and hasn't had a WR job since 2008.

QUESTIONS. What exactly will he do as a passing coordinator? How much does his relative lack of WR background hurt?

SOMEWHAT UNFAIR GRADE. B+. Recruiting questions due to his relatively short tenure in college, awkward fit at WR, but also a position coach who is 38 with 5 years of OC experience behind him.

TIGHT ENDS

KIM-JAY[1]

woo! suck it, dad! via MGoVideo

JAY HARBAUGH, son of Jim. Yeah, nepotism hire. The younger Harbaugh at least resisted the call when it was offered to him earlier:

With a coaching vacancy to fill this offseason, 49ers coach Jim Harbaugh zeroed in on a promising young member of his brother John's Baltimore Ravens staff. John reluctantly granted permission, and Jim proceeded to woo the up-and-comer.

But his pitch wasn't good enough -- not this time, at least.

"It's a dream to one day work for my dad, and hopefully the opportunity will come," said Harbaugh's son, Jay. "He understood where I was coming from."

Jay is the first Michigan coach who's appallingly younger than me—25—and should have Michigan on the cutting edge of the Facebooks and Instagrams and swipe-right-to-commit websites; he necessarily has zero track record.

I'd rather have a guy with one of those, but if that's the cost of Harbaugh whatever man. Also, let's look back that the Harbaugh coaching tree… okay. I mean:

"One time, I asked, 'Do guys give you a hard time about working for your uncle, automatically look at that as the reason you got the job?' His response was: 'It's my responsibility to not give them the opportunity to confirm that suspicion.'"

QUESTIONS. Is he actually a good coach? Will having a 25-year-old on staff help with the insta-twitter-snap-tinder-cruiting?

SOMEWHAT UNFAIR GRADE. C. Zero track record. Shades of JayPa, but Harbaugh isn't the OC. Harbaugh name rescues it—there is obviously a heritage there.

DEFENSIVE COORDINATOR/LINEBACKERS

HWPQEWOQMTVDJNN.20131113183704[1]

DJ DURKIN. Mattison/Harbaugh/Muschamp protégé has experienced meteoric rise in the coaching profession, to the point where he's taking his second DC job at a prestige program at the tender age of 37. (It's his birthday. Happy birthday.) Called plays for Florida's kickass D the past two years, has three years of Harbaugh experience as the DE coach at Stanford.

Should be a dynamic recruiter both in Florida, where he has four years of experience, and in Ohio, where he grew up and played college football at Bowling Green. Was pursued heavily by A&M and UNC, the former of which "settled" for throwing a walrus of money at LSU DC John Chavis.

QUESTIONS. How much of the Florida D was Muschamp and how much was him? How long will he stick around before getting a head coach gig? Does he know Mike Judge and can he get him my movie script?

SOMEWHAT UNFAIR GRADE. A. An up-and-comer with a terrific track record who immediately piqued the interest of a half-dozen recruits in SEC territory when he took the job.

DEFENSIVE LINE

6196187473_8eee53333e_z

[Eric Upchurch]

GREG MATTISON. Michigan retained its DC as a position coach, and he was pretty good to excellent as  defensive coordinator. Also, he's regarded as a terrific recruiter and provides continuity to help ease transition costs and prevent too many transfers. Pretty pretty good. Good fit, as well—Mattison's known various Harbaughs for 40 years and had Durkin as a GA when both were at Notre Dame. He's not going to butt heads with Michigan's new DC, but rather help him ease into being the man in charge of his own D.

Yeah, he's expensive for a position coach, but that contract was already signed.

QUESTIONS. How long does he stick around?

SOMEWHAT UNFAIR GRADE. A. Or five swag Mattisons.

CORNERBACKS(?)

MIKE ZORDICH. Twelve-year NFL vet has a decade-long coaching career that is mostly on lower levels save for a short stint with the Eagles. Should know everything about coverages given playing experience; Youngstown dude who went to Penn State should be able to hit Ohio and Pittsburgh hard.

QUESTIONS. Can he recruit at a big-time level? What happened with Philly and why did he get stuck at YSU?

SOMEWHAT UNFAIR GRADE: B-. NFL pedigree is nice, track record lacking, does bring a presumed set of recruiting chops that should be highly useful in PA.

SAFETIES

635568479949566418-Untitled-1[1]

GREG JACKSON. Another guy with a decade-plus career as an NFL safety; hooked on with Harbaugh after a few years at small schools and one at Wisconsin, whereupon his DBs were statistically lights-out. LSU alum who will likely focus on recruiting the south.

QUESTIONS. Was he a driving force behind the kickass 49ers DBs or was that either a statistical fluke or just a fortunate confluence of talent? Can he overcome the extreme gravitational pull of the South—and especially Louisiana—in recruiting?

SOMEWHAT UNFAIR GRADE: A-. Track record a little short, but dang man.

SPECIAL TEAMS

JOHN BAXTER. Thirteen-year career at Fresno State saw Bulldogs block a stunning 84 punts and kicks and return a bunch of the unblocked ones for touchdowns; upon his hire at USC was an immediate success with the Trojans. Left out after Kiffin firing when Sarkisian brought in his own guys, took a year off, was pursued by Texas and Pac-12 schools this time around and chose Michigan.

Also has 15 years of experience as an associate head coach and touts his "Academic Gameplan," which helped drag Fresno State out of the depths of schoolwork purgatory.

QUESTIONS. Spread punts?!?!?!?! (Yes.) How's his recruiting?

SOMEWHAT UNFAIR GRADE. A. Should be a massive upgrade on Michigan's dismal Hoke-era special teams.

A BRIEF COMPARISON TO THE PREVIOUS STAFF(s)

As in how good of an idea they seemed like when hired, not now. Otherwise these grades would be worse.

Borges: C. Had been out of football, not much success since first year at Auburn. Did have a good year with Lindley in second year at SDSU.
Doug Nussmeier. B+. Pretty clear he was getting chased from 'Bama so Lane Kiffin could enter, but a guy with an impressive track record who's still respected enough to get the Florida OC job even after last year.

Fred Jackson: C. Had been losing his fastball for a while. In-state recruiting successes offset by wildly inaccurate talent evaluations, and how hard is it for Michigan to recruit in-state anyway?
Jeff Hecklinski: B. Long time Hoke assistant did do a nice job with SDSU WRs, both of whom went in the third round after Heck's departure for M.
Darrell Funk: C. Pre-Hoke experience topped out as OL coach at Colorado State. Seemed plausible as an up-and-comer.
Dan Ferrigno: D. Had bombed out of college coaching in 2008 and was back in HS when Hoke picked him up; aging; no thought of upward mobility.

Greg Mattison: A. Big time college coordinator coming straight from the NFL.

Jerry Montgomery. B. Iowa alum and up-and-comer who Michigan yoinked away from Indiana mere weeks after he agreed to move there. Trajectory was borne out when Oklahoma came in with a big offer and stole him away.
Mark Smith: D. Had been with Hoke forever after moving from Indiana State, failed DC at Ball State, no track record of success recruiting or coaching. Also no thought of upward mobility.
Roy Manning (CB): C. Awkward fit in secondary, but young go-getter good on the trail. Would have been a grade higher if left in the defensive front seven.
Curt Mallory: C. Longtime DBs coach who had bounced around the Big Ten for a while; was coming off three years as Illinois co-DC and one as Akron's DC, albeit with little success.

----------------------------

All you have to do to measure relative attractiveness of Hoke's last staff is where they're landing. Borges and Ferrigno are supposedly headed to San Jose State; Jackson retired; Mallory went to Wyoming. Nussmeier is the exception, and he was only around for one year. Nobody else has an announced destination yet, and it's hard to see anyone other than Manning and Hecklinski getting a good Power 5 job—and even that's somewhat doubtful.

Notably, the biggest jobs many of Hoke's assistants had before coming into Hoke's orbit were not real big. A hypothetical Hoke-Harbaugh "impressive job not related to you or Michigan" challenge starts out with a couple of pushes and then is a blowout:

HOKE COACH PRIOR CEILING HARBAUGH COACH PRIOR CEILING
Mattison Ravens DC Mattison Ravens DC
Borges Auburn OC Durkin Florida DC
Hecklinski Arizona QB/pass game Fisch Jaguars OC
Mallory Illinois co-DC Drevno USC OL/run game
Ferrigno Oregon WR G. Jackson Wisconsin DB
Smith Indiana State DC Baxter USC ST
F. Jackson Vandy RB Zordich Eagles DB
Funk Colorado State OL Wheatley Bills RB
Manning Cincinnati RB Harbaugh Ravens QC

[Fred Jackson is a weird outlier, admittedly.]

Calibrate your preference between Borges and Durkin as you will; to me there's no question which guy I'd rather have at the time they were hired. Ditto Ferrigno versus Jackson since Jackson had been very impressive with Harbaugh. And this staff is very, very young. By my reckoning everyone on it save Baxter, Zordich, and Mattison is hungry to move up—and capable of doing so. I'm not sure you could say that about anyone on Hoke's staff.

Hooray, then? I think so.

Comments

jerasaurus

January 15th, 2015 at 1:27 PM ^

That Wheatley tribute video is well worth14 minutes of your day.  How long did he play at Michigan anyway, a decade?  There are like 50 jaw-droppng highlights.  

Ty Isaac brings that combination of size and speed.  Here's hoping he has something approaching a Ty Wheatley career.

Champeen

January 15th, 2015 at 2:01 PM ^

I am personally extremely excited to see Isaac behind an OL with 1 more year of experience, and coaches bent on successfully running it down opponents throats.  Actually, we have an crazy amount of talent in the backfield next year.  No reason not to have a breakout run game, and it should make up for our questionable returning pass game.

schreibee

January 15th, 2015 at 2:33 PM ^

Where did Isaac finish in the state sprint final? Because if memory serves, Wheatley WON!?

Not to take anything from Ty, cuz I'm glad he decided to transfer, but guys like TW don't come along too often. Like Ezekial type speed and power, a very rare combo. Look at that tape and see both runs where he blasts thru tacklers at the line, and more impressively, beats guys who look like they have an angle on him to the zone.

I loved him at the time - I bet (foolishly) that he'd have a better pro career than Marshall Faulk - but I didn't fully recall or appreciate how impressive he was.

M-Dog

January 15th, 2015 at 11:21 PM ^

His best, most meaningful game was the '92 season Rose Bowl.  

It was one of my favorite Michigan games ever.  We won in a shootout which was very un-Michigan at the time.  We typically relied on holding teams to less than 20 points.  If they scored more, we were not built to keep up.

But every time Wasshington punched, we counter-punched, back and forth until we got the knockout.  The same thing happened the year before, but in that case, we could not keep up and lost in a blowout.  

To see us learn from our mistakes, get a second chance, and prevail this time was truly inspiring.  It was a fun win.

DrMantisToboggan

January 15th, 2015 at 1:30 PM ^

Who will be Jim's Recruiting Coordinator?? Seems like an awfully important post right now to not have filled. I'd hope he at least considered Manning for the spot. Awfully disappointed that he was let go, if only for his recruiting prowess (especially in NJ where 2 top 10 players in 2016 at positions of need hail from). 

michgoblue

January 15th, 2015 at 1:32 PM ^

So here is my question regarding Fisch:  How is a guy who has never played competitive football going to teach WR how to play the position?  Serious question. 

My understanding was that actual playing experience was not important for the HC, DC and OC spots, where being a student of the game is arguably more important than knowing every intricacy of technique.  But, at the position coach level, it is important to really know the techniques.  Little things like making sure that the WR knows when to turn his hips or how to best bate the CB into making contact to draw as PI call. 

Having never played organized football myself, perhaps my concern is completely unfounded, but I am curious as to what others think about this point.

note:  if this is our biggest and only area of concern for the entire staff, then we truly have "first world problems."

PapabearBlue

January 15th, 2015 at 1:43 PM ^

Capable people learn from the previous experiences of other capable people. Intracacies can be learned and not everyone needs to experience the 'why? ' to understand and teach it.

BlueinOK

January 15th, 2015 at 1:37 PM ^

The Hoke staff had some obvious holes and dead weight. That's not the case with Harbaugh. He's got great guys at every position. Some are unproven at recruiting, but they seem like guys that would hit the ground running. There's a lot of youth and energy in the group. 

alum96

January 15th, 2015 at 1:45 PM ^

Huge upgrade everywhere except TE coach, which hey if someone had said you need to pay Harbaugh $10M and he is bringing 3 kids to coach, I'd say ok fine.

Baxter and Drevno are my 2 favorites based on track record; Durkin looks promising of course - just want to see how much was Muschamp, but for intangibles of age/energy/recruiting an A+.  Greg Jackson may be the dark horse, especially if he can recruit LA and surrounding areas and make our worst position group over the past 10? 12? years better.

maize-blue

January 15th, 2015 at 1:50 PM ^

I agree with Brian in that there are several of these guys that will looking to move up in the future. It's a great coaching staff but I don't see it remaining intact for more than a couple of seasons. That's not necessarily a bad thing though as that would probably mean they have had success here.

dragonchild

January 15th, 2015 at 2:04 PM ^

Jay Harbaugh and Fisch are weird fits.  I consider Drevno a bit unproven as an autonomous OC, but he won't be autonomous under Harbaugh.  Durkin WILL be autonomous after working under Muschamp but the hype on that guy is insane.  Zordich is kind of enigmatic; either he peaked early or he's a 20th-level NPC disguised as a hermit.  I'm not sold on hiring Wheatley just because he's Wheatley (that reeks of "legacy hire") but what I've heard is that 2014 Wheatley is definitely a RB coach, and we need a RB coach.  And don't forget Tolbert.  I would've preferred Turley of course; Tolbert is less of a sure thing, but nothing on his record indicates Michigan will regress.  So while the pessimist in me is all "let's wait and see" after years of crushed hopes, the ceiling is super-high for Durkin, Zordich, Wheatley and Tolbert.  My only real worry is that our WR play last season was disappointing and neither of the guys in charge of the ball-catchers have significant experience coaching receivers.  Who's going to coach technique??

From there, though. . . hoo boy.  Hee hee hee hee hee.  Mattison took a demotion to position coach.  Jackson's SF secondaries were insanely good.  Baxter is probably the best college ST coach in the country.  And of course we have Jim Harbaugh the HC, Jim Harbaugh the OC, and Jim Harbaugh the QB coach.

schreibee

January 15th, 2015 at 2:58 PM ^

dragonchild - Jedd Fisch is SO gonna force choke you for dissing he & young Harbaugh!

Also, people keep citing their preference for Turley over Tolbert - but since this was clearly also JH's preference, isn't is reasonable to speculate that some of those advanced techniques we were so enamored of will be adapted and employed by the S&C staff we did get?!

dragonchild

January 15th, 2015 at 3:52 PM ^

"Jedd Fisch is SO gonna force choke you for dissing he & young Harbaugh!"

I'm relishing the thought of it.  Crow pie would never taste so sweet.

"isn't is reasonable to speculate that some of those advanced techniques we were so enamored of will be adapted and employed by the S&C staff we did get?!"

Sure, but I think "let's see" is a valid position as well.  Tolbert worked under Turley so it's reasonble to expect he has similar knowledge, but S&C coaches all tend to have their chosen methods so it's likely Tolbert deferred to Turley and will implement his own program at Michigan.  That makes him less of a sure thing to me, but that said, Tolbert is NOT an unknown to Harbaugh, so while I'm going "let's wait and see", it's strictly from a fan standpoint.  I'm not questioning Harbaugh's judgement here.

Wave83

January 15th, 2015 at 2:04 PM ^

Brian, I know that your road trip down to Cleveland to speak to the local alumni association came at a busy time for you, but I wanted you to know how much we appreciated your effort.  Everyone enjoyed your talk (and as well as the discussion of the entire panel).  Thank you so much for taking the time to come down!  Thanks also for bringing Seth and Bacon down with you.  Adding Muransky and Cannivino to the group made the evening unbelievably great.

Thanks also for taking a little bit of the sting out of having to endure the Buckeyes winning the NC game.  Wolverine fans and UM alums living in Ohio have to put up with a lot.  It was nice making the evening about Michigan and what we hope will be a bright future.

DonAZ

January 15th, 2015 at 2:15 PM ^

Yeah, the hiring of his 25-year-old son to coach TE made me cock my head a bit.

But three things:

  1. My guess is the WR and OL coaches will work with Jay H. some
  2. My guess is Jim H. himself is going to keep an eye on the TEs a bit as well
  3. I can't imagine a scenario where Jim H. would jeopardize the success of the team just to plant his son as a coach.  It runs totally counter to everything Harbaugh preaches.

There's a method to this madness ... we just don't see it yet.

(Or maybe it truly is just a pure nepotism hire ... in which case I'd be very surprised.  There are lots of roles he could have hired his son to do.  A relatively high profile offensive position coach didn't have to be one of them.  Again, see #3 above.)