WTKA Roundtable 10/6/2022: Mildly Annoyed With Paranthropus Boisei Comment Count

Seth October 6th, 2022 at 10:38 AM

Things discussed:

  • Craig opens the door for Seth to go off on stuff you can read about on the John Hawks blog.
  • Iowa's offense isn't caveman, it's an Australopithecus that evolved in a different direction.
  • It's ugly football, but Michigan was correct to turtle into 1950s football and run out the clock.
  • Seth: Makes a big difference that they scored some touchdowns. The first time Iowa walked down and tried to sell out against something they get gutted by the Ronnie Bell end-around. They were playing soft and conservative, Michigan ground them down like they did Washington last year.
  • Worry about Colson spot dropping—it's about getting a feel for route combinations and where they next guy is coming from. Colson's still a true sophomore. Meanwhile Barrett was AGGRESSIVE! Iowa got some yards by using fullbacks against our smaller dudes but how many teams even have a fullback?
  • Biggest concern? JJ McCarthy getting the deep ball back, Trente Jones's weird pass protection biffs, and linebacker depth: after Mullings had a bad week Rolder played as much as he did.
  • Pass rush: Morris was great—he's very developed. Eyabi Okie: only out there for passing downs but !!!! and when those were runs he actually did his job.
  • Mazi Smith: Hit a ceiling, isn't a great finisher (Seth calls it Karlaftis Disease) and shouldn't play every snap but not many teams are going to be heavy personnel to put Graham Mason on the field instead of backing up Smith.
  • Indiana: What happened? Bad year on offense and they cleaned house and went full Walt Bell, who's all about speed in space and needed new players. Offense is all transfers, slot receiver is the scary guy but he's hurt. Might be a good matchup for Michigan because they want to attack Sainristil and Moore, get their RB singled up in an athletic contest with Colson/Barrett. Uh…
  • Hockeytalk: Just as talented as they were last year, going to love seeing Samo on the top line.

[Hit the JUMP for the player, and video and stuff]

You can catch the entire episode on Michigan Insider's podcast stream.

It's all one segment this week. You can watch the video here:

The Usual Links:

If Iowa week isn't the right time to dive into Neanderthal introgression to the modern human genome, what is?

Comments

1VaBlue1

October 6th, 2022 at 10:57 AM ^

Paleolithic offenses...  Mentions of Australopithecus...

Seriously, how many other college football blogs are talking about paleontology and human evolution as much as MGoBlog?  The Michigan Difference?!!?

Bo Harbaugh

October 6th, 2022 at 12:01 PM ^

These would be better without Brian.

Dude, if you don't want to be there or don't feel well, sit it out.

Rest of the guys are funny and upbeat.

Do you, it's your blog - but no reason to show up if the entire episode can't even put a smile on your face once.

dragonchild

October 6th, 2022 at 12:18 PM ^

Roundtable probably has some contractual obligation with WTKA, and with Sam out I think it would've been tough to do the show with just two regulars.  (Imagine the digressions if it was only Seth and Craig!)  So, Brian probably decided to be a good soldier and report for duty.

And while Seth upthread said it's a cold, I've had some just-a-colds that enveloped my brain in soupy fog and make gravity feel like Earth swapped places with a neutron star.  It looks like Brian was trying to tough out a real slobberknocker of a bug.

DiploMan

October 6th, 2022 at 12:32 PM ^

I wonder if Wisconsin firing Chryst early was an attempt to play both sides of the Leonhard-Liepold coin.  If Leonhard does well with his audition as interim, they can keep him on, and if not they can join the auction for Liepold at the end of the season.  Firing Chryst now gives them more data on whom to pursue.

Wallaby Court

October 6th, 2022 at 1:14 PM ^

I think that Wisconsin had a number of reasons to fire Chryst so early. First and foremost, his teams' performance has progressively and noticeably declined over the last three seasons. The Solid Verbal described Wisconsin as a B student with B+/A- grades because they always showed up and did the little things right. That allowed Wisconsin to dominate teams with similar or lesser talent levels and at least make a respectable showing against more talented teams. But the little things have started to fall off for Chryst's most recent teams. You could see it when Illinois flipped the script and "out-executed" Wisconsin at its own game.

Second, I think Wisconsin's athletic department had the unexpected foresight to realize that the traditional coaching search cycle has completely changed. Teams are not waiting until November or December to fire coaches. Everyone has taken their cues from USC's and LSU's approaches last season. Fire your coach early and get a head start on the search for your new coach. These searches have turned into musical chairs and you do not want to be looking for a seat at the end of the track.

That new paradigm and the specific jobs available put Wisconsin in a precarious position because they already have a prime head coaching candidate on staff. Someone will hire Leonhard as a head coach this cycle. If Chryst is not the answer and Leonhard leaves, then Wisconsin will either have to keep Chryst as a lame duck for another one season or jump into a coaching search after the best candidates have accepted other jobs.

Ultimately, I do not think Wisconsin will take a run at Leipold. The last time that Wisconsin looked outside the Alvarez coaching tree, they hired Gary Andersen, which went poorly for everyone. Leipold may be a geographic match, but he has almost no professional ties to Wisconsin.* He spent two or three seasons at Wisconsin as a graduate assistant. My best guess is that, absent a total meltdown, Wisconsin will conduct a nominal coaching search, but in the end will hire Leonhard as its next head coach.

*Yes, he grew up an hour away from Madison and developed his reputation as the head coach of Wisconsin-Whitewater. That's a geographic connection. Wisconsin and Wisconsin-Whitewater are very different schools with different athletic cultures.

acs236

October 7th, 2022 at 5:13 AM ^

MRE and Wolpoff references.  Fantastic!

 

His Human Evolution class was eye opening to me.  It's when I feel like I first appreciated the politics and rivalry in academia.