Unverified Voracity Enters A World Of Pain Comment Count

Brian

mark it zero 2

this is a completely normal bowling event

I honestly don't know how anyone goes bowling and doesn't get in a massive brawl. You've just spent several hours of your time flinging a ball at various inanimate objects and the objects generally win. You are losing to some smug-ass ovoid shapes. In such circumstances, it is only natural to become so irrationally angry that you start a yell-fight over the circumstances you find yourself in.

And lo, it has happened to football teams.

This makes total sense. I do enjoy how bored the cops look. Because this happens every time they're in a bowling alley.

These are unrelated, but I wish they weren't. Mo Hurst will play in the bowl game. Probably less than he has in most games, for a ton of reasons. Here's hoping he gets through it okay.

God bless Mike Leach. And God bless the reporter who absolutely nailed the zoom-out reveal midway through:

This is art on par with the raptor gif. And they said bowl season didn't mean anything.

You cannot understand the Brohm of it all. Purdue beat Arizona in an extremely entertaining game that featured one of those college-only back-to-back-to-back touchdowns in the last few minutes to swing the game to and fro. In the end Purdue's margin depended heavily on this play at the end of the first half:

That is a perfectly legal play that I've seen Auburn and Arkansas execute over the past few years. People are describing it as a "fake kneel," though, and they do have a point: Purdue had a guy lined up as the traditional we're-gonna-kneel "safety" on the play. Shame on Arizona for biting on that after Purdue got the ball back with almost a minute left...

...oh.

[/mentions fill up with "intent to deceive" outrage]

Well... you're not wrong. If a team is going to line up in a formation that causes the refs to demand the opposition stop playing they should stop playing too. One dollar says that there's a new rule covering running actual plays from a kneel-down formation next year. Which is a shame:

Most importantly, when Gus Malzahn runs this play, the call on the field is “THERE’S A SNAKE IN MY BOOT!” because the name of the fake kneel is “Woody,” it almost always involves the smallest running back on the team getting the ball, and because anytime one can take an excuse to yell “THERE’S A SNAKE IN MY BOOT!” on a football field, one should.

RIP.

Interesting Michigan-related item:

M apparently had this scouted.

Random bits from Zach Shaw. Shaw has been poking around the 24/7 database for article on various Michigan units, and has come across a number of things that look promising for next year's defense:

  • On the DL, Aubrey Solomon had a "stop rate"—tackles at or near the LOS—of just over 10%, which was on par with Hurst and Winovich. Nearly identical to both, in fact. Those guys were 10th and 11th nationally in that stat. If Solomon maintains that productivity he should be at least good and, with some extra pass rush, potentially great next year.
  • At linebacker, Khaleke Hudson and Devin Bush Jr. missed just three tackles each all year. Both guys had a ton of QB pressures but not many stops—probably because the DL was crushing so many plays before they could even get to the LBs.
  • The cornerbacks did this: "Michigan’s three cornerbacks — all first-year starters — allowed 32 of 81 passes for 478 yards, 0 touchdowns, 4 interceptions and 16 pass breakups." That is, of course, bonkers. Like having Jourdan Lewis clones coming out of your ears.
  • The safeties were good-ish. In the aftermath of a tough game for Metellus against Ohio State there have been a lot of criticisms of the safeties, and by implication departed safeties coach Brian Smith. But collectively there were middle of the pack when targeted and had an acceptable missed tackle rate—Metellus's was more acceptable than Kinnel's. The individual stats don't take into account the general lack of huge plays against M. Michigan gave up quite a few 20+ yard plays (59th) but relatively few 30+ (22nd); a lot of those longer plays were the inevitable result of Michigan's very aggressive defense cracking. The safeties mostly held down those opportunities.

If Solomon improves as much as most rising sophomores he could be only a reasonable step back from Mo Hurst, and then Michigan just has to find a linebacker from 5-6 options and a develop some DL depth to have the kind of defense that could be #1 nationally. Again.

One downer: per Football Outsiders Michigan's punting efficiency was 121st nationally, and the early shanks from Will hart didn't have much of an impact. Brad Robbins's net yardage was 121st. Shoulda got an Aussie.

Etc.: Graham Couch is at it again! If you've seen various Lars Von Trier movies the reference to him in this article will go 1% of the way towards restoring your lost time and/or sanity. Marcus Ray departs WTKA. The Blind Pig will carry on. Patterson officially in; the other two guys are officially not. Ted Janes of the Daily talks to John O'Korn. Jourdan Lewis: still good.

Comments

LKLIII

December 28th, 2017 at 1:49 PM ^

Defense should be good to great yet again. Hopefully they can sustain that excellence and consistency until we can put it together in offense.

I feel like the D is this small elite group of soldiers in an action movie valiantly holding off an unimaginably large army, waiting for reinforcements to arrive on time.

Here's hoping our story ends more like the Battle of Helms Deep as opposed to Battle of Thermopylae.

bronxblue

December 28th, 2017 at 1:52 PM ^

If it's true that the refs told Arizona players it was a kneel down, I wouldn't blame them for being angry. It was a weird time to take a knee admittedly, but for player safety you don't want someone taking unnecessary shots on a dead play. There is a contingent here that hates RR because he couldn't win, but I am always going to be pulling for him in games like this because I really like his offense and I think Purdue is beyond obnoxious right now. Also, I agree that bowling alleys are just designed for fights.

Heptarch

December 28th, 2017 at 6:20 PM ^

You know what else is a disservice to our children?  Raising them to believe that the world is black and white instead of infinite shades.  Teaching them to shut down debate with those who disagree with them or that those people deserve only scorn instead of honest, critical dialogue.

This world needs MORE people who can think critically and disagree without insulting each other, not fewer.

AA Forever

December 29th, 2017 at 10:04 AM ^

Teaching them that all opinions are equally valid. Teaching them that just because something is someone's "opinion" that it deserves to be taken seriously, and to be treated with respect and deference. Teaching them that decades or centuries of thought and debate on issues doesn't get us any closer to the truth. Teaching them than opinions are more important than evidence and logical arguments.

gbdub

December 28th, 2017 at 2:10 PM ^

Meh, I think a fake kneel is a dirty play. It's basically attacking under a flag of truce. You're taking advantage of the fact that the other team is easing up to avoid hurting somebody in a dead play. I hope the next time Purdue goes to kneel the QB gets knocked on his ass.

CRISPed in the DIAG

December 28th, 2017 at 2:25 PM ^

I'm too lazy to grind this out of a rule book, but once the runner 'gives himself up' he's considered down (eg, quarterback slide or taking a knee). The simple act of faking like you're downing the ball is the same as giving yourself up, IMHO. 

That said, just tell the defense to pay attention and there's no deception.

gbdub

December 28th, 2017 at 3:34 PM ^

The closest thing might be faking a fair catch call - if you make any motion at all to signal, the ref is going to blow the play dead when you catch it (and penalize the other team if they hit you). Faking a kneel down should really be the same thing. The other team has to ease up, or risk penalty. You shouldn't be able to exploit that safety rule.

gbdub

December 28th, 2017 at 3:29 PM ^

So when a UofM QB takes a shot to a head in a kneel down situation because of this play, you're okay with that?

It's like faking a slide to take advantage of the rule that punishes defenders for hitting you there, causing them to ease up. The UofA players can't play all out because if they do they are likely to take an unnecessary roughness call (especially if the refs told them to ease up). Taking advantage of that is bush league.

And you know Brohm would be the first to bitch if the UofA nose tackle had just clobbered the center on this play and it was an actual kneel down.

bklein09

December 28th, 2017 at 4:28 PM ^

Didn’t this happen to Henne (or maybe Navarre) against MSU? He took a while to kneel in order to run time off the clock and got nailed. I think they called a personal foul on the defender.

Problem is, you can’t have it both ways. I don’t think it should be illegal to fake a kneel down, but if that’s the case, you’d better be ok with defensive players jumping over the line and/or wrecking your offensive lineman.

At the end of the day, if it’s a football play (which it is) then the fake should be allowed, as should the defensive response. The refs obviously have to stay out of it though.

If we want to make kneel downs a non-football play, then just remove the snap altogether and let teams “sacrifice” downs for 40 seconds a piece.

SlickNick

December 28th, 2017 at 2:31 PM ^

I know it was against a RichRod Defense, but Sindelar impressed me in the game last night...dude has a cannon. Aside from their douchebag DC I'm hoping Brohm stays around and makes Purdue into a exciting program. 

ST3

December 28th, 2017 at 3:03 PM ^

Is just another example of the "Survivor-ification" of America. I blame Richard Hatch. Back in the day, sports and sportsmanship were synonymous. Then, Al Davis and his, "Just win, baby," ethos took root. That spread from the NFL to daily life with the establishment of Survivor ethics. Basically - it's just a game so it's OK if I lie, cheat, and steal. I'm calling bullshit on that.

Hatch was rewarded with $1M for outwitting (lying) outlasting (cheating) and outplaying (backstabbing.) At some point in America, we lost our way. What happened to respecting your opponent? Playing fair? Being honest? Purdue, the piece of shit program we all lambasted for their horrible facilities and late hits the week after we played them is now being defended for playing to win at all costs? Gimme a break.

/getoffmylawn

Rabbit21

December 28th, 2017 at 3:36 PM ^

I didn't read Brian's comments as defending it.  I read his comments as saying it's not cool that the referee's told the Arizona players not to rush.

I think the arguments goes fake kneel downs are fine as long as the refs don't interfere, if the refs interfere and you run the fake anyway that's a problem. 

Agree it's bad sportsmanship to take advantage of a situation in which another team is being told to stand down and it will only lead to dangerous play and injuries.  Purdue is an interesting team, but they seem to be taking a very Spartan-like approach to the rulebook and that's a shame.

As far as the Richard Hatch thing, I think you're giving him a little too much credit.  He basically took a look at the strategy needed to win a game show and took advantage of the fact that none of the other contestants really knew what they were doing out there.  Subsequent versions of Survivor have shown aggressive gameplay, but people just as often get punished for it as rewarded for it, just like the way the world has worked, ever since Rarrgghhh the caveman invented fire and said, "Yeah! Now I can see naked women in the dark!"  

gbdub

December 28th, 2017 at 3:38 PM ^

I didn't like this play either, but we're blaming lying in Survivor for ruining America now? Do you want to outlaw bluffing in poker? There's a difference between cheating and gamesmanship in a game where deception and diplomacy is kind of the point.

ST3

December 28th, 2017 at 4:16 PM ^

I was being facetious with that comment. I do think that the lying and backstabbing you often see on Survivor is emblematic of the "win at all costs" ethos that has probably always been with us. It just seems more egregious recently. Look no further than hall of fame coach Rick Pitino. It could be argued that Wooden was also dirty. Perhaps the human condition has not changed, we only have more media and means to expose the scoundrels. But we should not defend them or heap praise upon them because they are more willing to stretch the rules. Bluffing in poker is an expected part of the game. Faking a kneel down to take advantage of someone and norms of sportsmanship is a douchebag move.

Don

December 28th, 2017 at 4:11 PM ^

In 1946 Brooklyn Dodgers manager Leo Durocher said "The nice guys are all over there, in seventh place" about the 1946 New York Giants, who were in last place at the time. This statement was shortened by a sportswriter of the time to "Nice guys finish last."

And I'd bet you a box of money that Yost, Crisler, Rockne, Bryant, Schembechler, Saban, Carr, Meyer, McKay, Devaney, Osborne, Switzer, Johnson, and every other successful head coach or manager has essentially said the same thing more than once.

ST3

December 28th, 2017 at 5:09 PM ^

He may have said nice guys finish last, but he also said a whole bunch about integrity, and people remembered him more for that than a win-at-all-costs mentality.

...recently retired ABC announcer Keith Jackson said, ""I would like you to know Bo Schembechler epitomized integrity. That he tried very hard to do always what he said he would do, and if he couldn't, he would be the first to tell you. That was his basic strength. That was why he was easy to like. He valued values, and he lived by them." Time, energy, love, and integrity - don't cost a dime, pay priceless dividends forever.

https://review-mag.com/article/tribute-appreciating-bo-schembechler-a-s…

Bando Calrissian

December 28th, 2017 at 5:59 PM ^

How much do you know about the ways Yost and Crisler coached football? Seems like you would have been one of those guys saying "how dare that Yost throw those forward passes, putting the ball over the head of those defenders where they can't get to it..." or "how dare Crisler try to platoon his players, not letting his same 11 players get too tired after an offensive series..."

UMHX1992

December 28th, 2017 at 4:46 PM ^

In 2016-17 we all are getting a good look at what it means to live in a win-at-all-cost culture, in which defeating the adversary is the only end, even if that means ignoring or subverting decades (or centuries) of institutional protocol.

BlueDragon

December 28th, 2017 at 5:28 PM ^

There had better be a new rule covering that kind of cheap shit next year, otherwise everyone's going to go full Tampa Bay Buccaneers on kneeldowns - just to be safe.

Enjoy your richly deserved W, Purdue, while it lasts.

 

Michigan4Life

December 28th, 2017 at 6:21 PM ^

from them taking awful angle that allowed big plays.  See Saquon Barkley's first play of the game on a zone read where Metellus took an awful angle that turned from a 1st down to a TD in a hurry. That doesn't show up on the tackling rate stats.