Thursday Recruitin' Explores The South Comment Count

Ace

McDowell Lines Up Officials


Malik McDowell (#67) relaxes before playing Farmington (Bryan Fuller)

Southfield top-50 DL Malik McDowell has been quiet throughout the recruiting process to the point that I'm not entirely sure this is breaking news; regardless, Josh Helmholdt posted McDowell's official visit plans in his Around The Midwest column, and this is the time I've seen five schools lined up for visits ($):

While the Wolverines and fellow in-state Big Ten program Michigan State are strong contenders for McDowell's signature, the nation's No. 40-ranked prospect will take all of his official visits out of state. All will take place after his senior season. The five schools he has tabbed for those official visits are Alabama, Florida, Florida State, LSU and Ohio State.

Michigan and MSU won't get officials because McDowell has seen each school multiple times and can easily make his way to games if he wishes. The Wolverines are in the driver's seat of McDowell's recruitment and I don't think the official visit schedule changes that; while that's a who's-who list of top programs, depending on how far Southfield goes in the playoffs, McDowell's season could extend into November, limiting his options for visiting on actual game days—the visits that tend to have the biggest effect on a recruitment. McDowell is so familiar with the Michigan program at this point that it's hard to see him winding up elsewhere.

Cole: "They're All Even"

2015 Saginaw Heritage ATH Brian Cole's recruitment has already taken a couple twists and turns—first Michigan looked to be in command, then MSU, and now the Wolverines again as Saginaw natives haven't appreciated MSU's (lack of) usage of De'Anthony Arnett—and for now, Cole says there isn't a leader at all, per Sam Webb ($):

“(I like) Michigan, Michigan State, Ohio State, Tennessee, Alabama, Wisconsin, Indiana, and a couple more schools,” Cole said.  “They’re all even. They’re all about the same. They all treat me nice. I’m not committing anywhere yet.”

I'd expect this still comes down to an in-state battle—one that'll be hotly contested—though some schools on there (OSU, Alabama) cause more concern than others (Indiana? Word?). Michigan is recruiting Cole as a receiver, though he could also play defensive back at the next level.

[Hit THE JUMP for evaluations of Da'Shawn Hand, Lawrence Marshall, Jared Wangler, Erik Swenson, and Kyle Kearns, plus updates on a couple underclassmen.]

Hand Stonewalls Jackson

Scout's Ultimate 300, in which they put three classes in the same rankings, raised a few eyebrows when they placed 2015 DT Tim Settle at #5, ten spots above his 2014 friend and fellow lineman Da'Shawn Hand. Hand's Woodbridge squad took on Settle's Stonewall Jackson team last weekend, and according to Rivals's Adam Friedman, the on-field comparison heavily favored the senior ($):

1. DE Da'Shawn Hand, Woodbridge (Va.) Woodbridge Senior
The nation's top prospect sure played like it on Friday night. Hand had 10 tackles, three for a loss, and topped it off with a blocked punt. His explosiveness at the snap was too much for the Stonewall Jackson offensive line to handle. Hand could do an inside rush, outside rush, split the double team and pretty much anything else he wanted. What's even more impressive is that Stonewall Jackson ran away from his side nearly every time.

Friedman put Settle down at #8 on his top performers list; while he also tallied three TFLs, he failed to show the consistency and high motor necessary to make an impact on every down.

TomVH has a free article detailing the mentorship/friendship between Hand and Settle, and now all I can think about is Prince Fielder:

[Settle] prides himself on his athleticism and how well he moves for a big man. To prove that point he talks about how he played basketball and tried to play baseball as well. He laughs as he describes himself playing in the outfield and striking out at nearly ever at bat.

“A 300-pound dude playing baseball isn’t really normal,” he says laughing. “My freshman year I didn’t know how to slide so I would just run through the bases.

I'd hate to be the catcher having to make that play at the plate.

More Evals

Scout's Allen Trieu caught Southfield's game against Oak Park last Friday and came away very impressed with Lawrence Marshall ($):

Southfield senior defensive end Lawrence Marshall, a four-star Michigan commit, had a strong game. He is long, athletic, and plays with a good motor. He has great speed and ability in pursuit and tracked down a couple ball carriers when Oak Park tried to run away from him. He still has to continue to add weight and get stronger, which he has been doing, but he's putting together a great season.

I'm pretty sure The Wolverine has found a way to clone Tim Sullivan, who's been taking in games all around the country at a remarkable pace. He checked out Jared Wangler in De La Salle's last-second loss to Brother Rice last weekend ($):

Focusing on the negative, however, overshadows the positive game that he had. Although he's not expected to play safety at the next level, he plays a deep-half for De La Salle, displaying impressive athleticism that he should maintain when he adds weight to play linebacker at Michigan. His physical play coming up in run support (and in the secondary) is a better example of what will translate to the next level.

Notably, Wangler committed a critical pass interference penalty and misjudged Brother Rice's Hail Mary winner; he also was a standout on offense, according to Sullivan.

Tim also made it to Illinois to scout 2016 blue chip tackle—and strong Michigan lean—Erik Swenson, who lived up to lofty expectations ($):

Impressively, Swenson is equally adept at run blocking and pass blocking. He drives very well when the ball is run behind him (the game-winning touchdown run features him caving half the Morton defense, allowing some of his fellow blockers to clean up the remaining Morton players), and has a solid pass set without overextending himself.

Tim pegged Swenson at 6'6", 290 lbs., so he already has college-level size; the all-important pad level is noted as an area for improvement. This is pretty representative of the game film:

JPTTA.

247's Clint Brewster has a free breakdown of 2015 CA four-star QB Kyle Kearns, who could be next in line for an offer whenever Michigan decides to move on from Josh Rosen, who's expressed zero interest in the Wolverines.

Etc.

2015 top-50 consensus linebacker Malik Jefferson told Steve Lorenz that while he can't make it from Texas to Michigan for a visit this season, the Wolverines would "definitely" be one of his five official visits if he had to choose right now ($).

Scout's new 2014 team rankings has Michigan at #11, second in the Big Ten behind #5 Ohio State.

Yahoo's Pat Forde takes a look at how the current top ten put their teams together; yes, it's more positive stuff on the Buckeyes.

SBNation's Bud Elliott breaks down the major ramifications from the NCAA walking back the scholarship reductions at Penn State; Bill O'Brien already has surpassed any reasonable expectation for recruiting under the sanctions, and having a full 85 scholarships at his disposal for 2016 makes PSU a serious contender moving forward.

Comments

Yinka Double Dare

September 26th, 2013 at 2:09 PM ^

As someone who went to school in Morton's conference, let me tell you that they are almost always really really terrible, so a huge dude like Swenson trucking a bunch of guys on that team sounds more impressive than it probably is.  Despite having like 8,000 students between the Morton schools (they play as one for sports), the demographics and interests of the student body lead to a lousy football team without a lot of big dudes on it.  

JClay

September 26th, 2013 at 2:09 PM ^

Malik McDowell looks like a golden Adonis and is undoubtedly the greatest recruit in the history of recruits, except for all our other recruits!

ThoseWhoStayUofM

September 27th, 2013 at 3:48 AM ^

Would anybody mind explaning this to me?  What are you implying when you say, "He looks exactly 17 or 18 years old"?  If you aren't implying anything, then couldn't you have equally said that he looks exactly like a human being?  You could have said he looks exactly like an American citizen.  I mean... did you have a point in saying that?

dahblue

September 26th, 2013 at 2:10 PM ^

I wonder if the East/West split of the B1G would have been different if it were sorted out after the PSU penalty reduction.  The East is going to be a monster, especially compared to the "who cares" division in the West.  Sorry, Sparty.

One Inch Woody…

September 26th, 2013 at 2:16 PM ^

Scheduling official visits to those 5 schools in particular is going to be a great time for him. There are a lot of rumors about the wonderful hospitality such schools show to their recruits during official weekends and, unfortunately, Michigan doesn't really compare in all that they have to offer to recruits as opposed to those schools. With the weather, the hostesses, the academic support, the great football tradition, and the giving spirit of the school, you can be absolutely sure that on each subsequent visit, each school will up the ante for the recruit.

bdsisme

September 26th, 2013 at 2:19 PM ^

In all due respect (and I know that is something one writes when they are about to offend), but when is Ace going to get back to writing stuff that matters?  He's a top-notch writer, but it's just GIF after recruiting roundup after GIF after roundup after GIF.  It's like taking Jack Nicholson and restricting him to romantic comedies.

Toasted Yosties

September 26th, 2013 at 2:50 PM ^

He's obviously serious about seeing other programs, and I could see most any recruit being swept off his feet walking into Alabama's new facilities with Nick Saban in his ear.  Could the Michigan awe wear off after so many visits?  His dad has spoken very highly of Michigan, which leads me to believe he ends up a Wolverine, but you never know.  I'm not sure what it is McDowell is looking for, but I sure hope proximity to family is high up on his list.

gwkrlghl

September 26th, 2013 at 10:12 PM ^

but I always thought Diamond was the original "lock" who was always sooooo close to committing or something. Then it was Treadwell, no Westphal, maybe McDowell? Maybe Drake Harris now.

It's always concerning when a guy is on campus 5, 6, 7 times and still doesn't pull the trigger. Always looks like a case of looking for something better. Heck, we did it to MSU with Lawrence Marshall

Toasted Yosties

September 26th, 2013 at 3:14 PM ^

I just don't understand the high level of certainty in landing him, considering how he's played his cards so close to the chest.

"McDowell is so familiar with the Michigan program at this point that it's hard to see him winding up elsewhere."

Visiting a bunch of teams that have won multiple National Championships in the last decade bumps the chances up exponentially, in my book, especially when he's visiting their warm campuses in November or December when Michigan becomes the cold realm of the dead, dark, and gray, loathed by most anyone who's grown up in Michigan.

UMaD

September 26th, 2013 at 3:09 PM ^

Did you read above that it's "it's hard to see him winding up elsewhere"? 

Familiarity is all that matters. Not taking an official visit - that's actually a good thing.  Nevermind the significant number of highly regarded in-state prospects that were intimately familiar with Michigan but ended up elsewhere.  Nevermind the annual examples of commit-on-the-late-visit.  McDowell is a Michigan lock.  Especially since he never talks to anyone - that's a dead give-away.

 

bronxblue

September 26th, 2013 at 4:31 PM ^

As others have noted, these "perfect fit" guys always seem to to fall through the cracks.  I've always thought that if a guy hasn't signed up after half-dozen visits, something is up.  He may still wind up at UM, but there is at least some factor that makes the decision tougher than some people think it is.  I wish him luck in this choice because I can only imagine how difficult it has to be for a teenager to figure out which high-profile school he wants to pledge his allegiance to, but this pounding sense of uncertainty is a big reason I don't really follow recruiting very much until NSD.

razor93

September 26th, 2013 at 3:08 PM ^

anyone who was at the De La Salle Brother Rice game knows that pass interference penalty against Wangler was a joke and complete BS. The refs wanted Rice to win and that was confirmed on the second to last play which was a sack and intentional grounding that was not called.

m83econ

September 26th, 2013 at 4:30 PM ^

The last Brother Rice drive was a comedy of homer calls - non-PI, slow clock operators, lack of intentional grounding.  Hard to beat a team that is averaging almost 1 official assist per play. 

That said, the Hail Mary was a nice throw from Malzone.  Although not sure he's Michigan caliber.

razor93

September 26th, 2013 at 5:58 PM ^

is the perfect way to state it.  I do give Malzone credit on the throw it was pretty nice.  He took advantage of the dozen extra opportunities(and the 12 men on the field that was not called) given to his team by the refs and the homer clock operation.  I guess Al Fracassa is being willed by the MHSAA to go out undefeated in his last season.

alum96

September 26th, 2013 at 9:50 PM ^

From the Pat Forde article re: Alabama - "Sixteen of 23 starters are from the signing classes of 2010 and ’11."   I believe for Michigan it would be 10 if you include Avery.  If not 9 as Jake Ryan and Beyer overlap in position.  Unless you move Beyer to either DE in which case he overlaps with Clark and Heitzman.  So it is still 9 (+1) with Avery... and that includes Dileo who as much we love him, on a traditional UM team would be receiver #4 or #5.   So 41-45% of UM's starters are 10s and 11s depending on how you count Avery, and for Alabama its 73%.  Yep, hello dead horse.