Three-peat [Patrick Barron]

Michigan 26, Iowa 0 - B1G Champions Comment Count

Alex.Drain December 3rd, 2023 at 1:37 AM

Michigan agreed to meet Iowa on their proverbial turf and play a nasty game with little offense, where field position has precedence and turnovers/special teams are crucial. Michigan played this Iowa game and in turn, out Iowa'd Iowa. The Wolverines came up with all three takeaways, netting 10 points off of them, and broke off the most consequential special teams play of the game, leading to another touchdown. Michigan beat Iowa at their own game in Indianapolis and thus claimed their third consecutive Big Ten Football Championship, the 45th in school history. 

Sing it again, Freddie. 

-----

The game itself was rather boring, a vintage Iowa slog. Michigan won the opening coin toss and deferred to the second half, giving Iowa possession, who promptly went three-and-out. Deacon Hill delivered a decent throw on 3rd down under pressure, but Junior Colson broke it up. Michigan them embarked on a plodding 13 play, 52 yard drive that saw them convert one 4th down (a JJ McCarthy strike to Cornelius Johnson) but opt to kick a field goal on the second 4th down situation. An injury to center Drake Nugent the play before was likely a key reason for kicking on 4th & short, as Michigan decided to let James Turner bang through a 35 yard field goal to open the scoring. 3-0 Michigan. 

Iowa's second drive saw them pick up their first first down of the game, a run by Leshon Williams on a 3rd & short, but they punted four plays later. A false start had backed them up and calling a reverse on 3rd & 12 amounted to waving the white flag. Iowa put star punter Tory Taylor on the field and he launched a booming punt, backing Michigan returner Semaj Morgan back inside his own 10. Morgan caught it, sidestepped two quick tackle attempts, made one cut back, and then found an open seam. Morgan put on the jets and was gone, dusting every Hawkeye until he began to run out of gas some 70 yards later. An Iowa player pushed him out inside the Hawkeye 10, but the 87 yard(!) punt return was the longest in B1G Championship Game history. Set up at the Iowa five, Michigan ran Corum twice and punched it in. 10-0 Wolverines. 

The putrid Iowa offense was now in a seemingly insurmountable hole and nearly gave Michigan the ball right back, as Mike Sainristil read Deacon Hill's third down pass intended for Kaleb Brown perfectly. Sainristil dove for the ball, but was unable to come up with it. Alas, Iowa punted and Michigan got the ball back. This drive was a solid one, several productive passes by JJ McCarthy got Michigan marching down the field, but a completion to AJ Barner on the run was called back due to a rather borderline holding penalty on Trente Jones. Set behind the sticks, Michigan's offensive line began to struggle against the ferocity of Iowa's pass rush. Deontae Craig sacked McCarthy and Michigan punted. 

[Patrick Barron]

Iowa continued to be completely incompetent on offense. They went three-and-out again, a PBU by Ja'Den McBurrows ending the next drive, and punted it back to Michigan. The Wolverines' offense was equally stuck in the mud during this period, the Iowa front seven imposing itself and another sack forced a quick Michigan punt (this sack by Max Llewellyn). Tommy Doman's ensuing punt was a poor one, taking a bad hop around midfield and setting the Hawkeyes up with excellent field position, starting at the Wolverine 38. 

This seemed to be the moment for Iowa to get back in the game, being given the plus field position their offense desperately needed to get on the board. After an eight yard gain on first down, a throwaway brought up 3rd & 2 from the Michigan 30. Deacon Hill completed a play-action dump-off to Jaziun Patterson behind the sticks. Patterson turned his body up the field, took a step and made a football move, when Mike Sainristil punched the ball free, recovered by Michigan's Kris Jenkins. The game's first takeaway ended a key opportunity for Iowa and as it turned out, they'd never get deeper into Michigan territory again. 

At this point the game reached Peak Iowa status, quick stops and punting wars. Michigan went three-and-out again, a tough ball for Colston Loveland incomplete on 3rd & short, and Tommy Doman drilled a punt that pinned Iowa at their own 9. Predictably, Iowa responded with a three-and-out of their own, Tory Taylor uncorking his own masterful punt enabled by Morgan not catching it in the air. The ball bounced closer to midfield and then rolled some 30 yards before being downed at the Michigan 19, a 67 yard bomb(!). The next Michigan drive went alright, moving out past the Michigan 35 when JJ McCarthy found Colston Loveland running wide open over the middle of the field. JJ delivered a perfect ball, hitting Loveland in the hands in stride. If Loveland catches the ball, it is a huge gain deep into Iowa territory... unfortunately, Loveland did not catch it and Michigan punted. 

[Patrick Barron]

Time was now ticking down in the half, under a minute to go. Iowa couldn't muster a two-minute drill, a prompt defensive stop from the Wolverines slamming the door, but Taylor's strong punt flipped the field again. Set back on their own 26 with only 16 seconds left, Michigan was in an uphill climb to get points before halftime. Donovan Edwards broke a long run to get them out to the 43, but McCarthy was sacked again and the Wolverines headed into halftime up 10-0. Not great, but a seemingly insurmountable (indeed it was) lead having been built up. 

Michigan got the ball out of halftime and started to get a bit of offensive rhythm before a holding call on Roman Wilson set them back. The senior receiver made up for it, however, when McCarthy delivered him a fine ball on 3rd & 10 to get into Iowa territory. For the first time all game, Michigan decided to spruce it up on offense and dialed up a reverse to Cornelius Johnson, which was perfectly called, two blockers for two defenders with Johnson running behind. Loveland and Drake Nugent were the two blockers, but neither blocked anyone and the play was stuffed. On the next play, McCarthy nearly threw an interception, dropped by Iowa LB Nick Jackson, and the third down play was merely a meek swing pass to Donovan Edwards. Michigan punted and Doman pinned Iowa at their own 6. 

That field position ended up being hugely consequential when a blitzing Mike Sainristil hit Deacon Hill as he was getting ready to throw and the bar was jarred free. At the time, it was thought to be a pass attempt (nearly intercepted by Michigan's Kenneth Grant), dropping onto the ground incomplete. However, upon further review, it was determined to be a fumble, with a clear recovery by Michigan's Josh Wallace, who wisely scooped up the ball while all other players thought the play was over. Iowa offensive coordinator and college football court jester Brian Ferentz erupted in fury at the replay decision, being given an unsportsmanlike conduct penalty. The takeaway + penalty set Michigan up at the Iowa six yard line and on their first opportunity, Blake Corum carried it into the end zone for a touchdown. 17-0 Wolverines. 

 

[Patrick Barron]

With a three score lead in hand and the depravity of the Iowa offense opposing them, Michigan had the game won by this point. The Hawkeyes would put together their first drive that notched two first downs on the next possession, getting into Michigan territory, but Deacon Hill's 4th & 1 sneak was stuffed at the Michigan 44. The Wolverines took the ball and drove into Iowa territory, JJ McCarthy's legs featuring for the first time, but the drive stalled inside the Iowa 30. They sent James Turner back out there and he converted on a 46 yard field goal attempt. 20-0 Michigan. 

The rest of the game was just the same as what had happened beforehand. Iowa continued to be inept on offense, Michigan continued to be vanilla and moderately disappointing on offense. Michigan's defense forced another turnover when Braiden McGregor strip-sacked Deacon Hill, recovered by Kenneth Grant. The Wolverine offense didn't make much of that opportunity due to another brutal drop by a TE, this time AJ Barner at the Iowa five yard line, and James Turner made his third field goal. 

Iowa drove into Michigan territory for their second time all game, but again failed on 4th down (this time on another PBU by McBurrows). Michigan began to insert backups on the offensive line as Blake Corum rushed them into Iowa territory, setting up a forth and final Turner field goal. This was his most impressive, a 50 yarder that split the uprights and made the final score 26-0. A 4th down sack by Derrick Moore finished off the final Hawkeye drive and Michigan then did the kneel downs. For as iffy as the offense looked, the Wolverines had won by 26, covered the spread, and won a Big Ten Championship. Not too bad. 

[AFTER THE JUMP: takes and rankings debate]

[Patrick Barron]

It's difficult to know exactly what to make of this game, other than that Iowa's offense is indeed wretched and their defense is indeed excellent. The Hawkeyes were as advertised and Michigan won by a margin many predicted pre-game. Still, there were a number of things to clean up for Michigan's offense, the most notable of which being drops by the tight ends. Michigan could have scored well into the 30s if Loveland and Barner catch two balls that they normally bring in. Not much else to say there, other than flukey results. The offensive line's effort was concerning, but it seemed to be the regular starters getting abused, not the injury replacements. Ohio State has an excellent defensive front and Michigan fared much better up front in that one. Therefore, I'm not exactly sure what to say. 

McCarthy was rock solid but didn't take many chances. I wrote in my scouting pieces before the game that Michigan would need to pepper in deception and trickery to crack the Iowa offense opened but they largely opted not to, presumably keeping their best plays in the bag for more competitive games. Putting Peyton O'Leary on the field for several snaps at WR early on seemed to suggest that Michigan wasn't taking this game too seriously. I can't blame them, but it is a reason why the offensive effort looked sluggish. 213 yards on 3.3 YPP is by far the worst offensive output of the season. 

On the flip side, the defense was as dominant as you'd expect against an offense as bad as Iowa. They held Iowa to 155 yards on 56 plays, for a 2.8 YPP clip. They forced three turnovers, one when the Hawkeyes were in scoring position for what turned out to be the only time all game, the other two deep in Iowa territory that resulted in 10 points. The defensive line dominated Iowa's offensive line (3 sacks, held Iowa to 1.5 YPC) and the secondary dominated Iowa's passing game (Deacon Hill was 18/32 at 3.8 Y/A). Every single player on the defense played well and Michigan pitched their second shutout of the season in the process.

 

[Patrick Barron]

On special teams James Turner was yet again fantastic. After making three FGs last week, he made four tonight, several of them challenging kicks. Tommy Doman averaged 42 yards per punt and pinned Iowa inside the 10 twice. One shank was unfortunate, but he was good. Similarly, Semaj Morgan's electric return will be remembered for the ages, but his decision not to catch the Taylor punt in the first half possibly cost the Wolverines some points via the field position change. As always, there are things to work on. 

Michigan is now 13-0 for the second consecutive season and were 12-1 at this point two years ago. They have won 25 consecutive B1G games (regular season and B1G title games) and are the B1G Champions for the third consecutive season. This is the first time Michigan has won three titles in a row since 1988-1992 under Bo Schembechler and Gary Moeller. The program has reached heights not touched in several decades, but still has one more goal to reach. 

The trophy presentation after the game merits brief discussion. Jim Harbaugh, back on the sideline after his B1G-imposed suspension, was put face-to-face with the man who suspended him, conference commissioner Tony Petitti. Petitti handed the trophy to the injured Zak Zinter, as Harbaugh wanted, but then quickly slinked into the background before Harbaugh stepped forward. It was a cowardly moment that will certainly be widely discussed in the coming days, painfully on brand for the man who suspended Harbaugh by leaking the story to ESPN before notifying the coach himself, then doing so while the team was on a plane, less than 24 hours before a game. Petitti's performance tonight only confirmed that he is a feckless, weak, and petty commissioner, nothing but an empty suit unprepared and incapable of handling the difficult business of running the conference. 

[Patrick Barron]

At 13-0 and the B1G Champions, the Michigan Wolverines will be in the College Football Playoff. As will the 13-0 Washington Huskies, who defeated Oregon last night. Both of these teams were top 3 in last week's rankings and will be when the rankings are unveiled tomorrow morning. The remaining two spots are up for grabs in what is the most fascinating debate in College Football Playoff history, the four-team field going out in its most controversial fashion. Florida State, ranked 4th this past week, won the ACC Championship Game with their third string QB starting thanks to suffocating defense over a top 15 Louisville team. They are 13-0 and everything about how the CFP has operated to date suggests they will be in. 

It is possible the 'Noles could be left out, but it is more likely that they will be in and the last spot will come down to 12-1 Texas, the Big 12 champions, and 12-1 Alabama, the SEC champions. Despite the excellent seasons that 12-1 Georgia and 11-1 Ohio State had, both will be going to irrelevant New Year's Six games. Texas seemingly holds the edge on Alabama by having the head-to-head win, in Tuscaloosa by two scores, back in September. They have led Alabama in the rankings all season and did what they had to today, blowing a top 25 Oklahoma State team out of the water. Alabama, on the contrary, notched a huge upset win over Georgia, the previous #1 team. The argument for Texas getting in is that the games matter and they have a H2H road win over the team they're competing against, having looked excellent the last three weeks down the stretch. The argument for Alabama is that the SEC is the best conference (don't check their non-conference record this year) and they beat Georgia, who hadn't lost in two calendar years. 

Most people on this site, your author included, believe that Texas and FSU should be in and Alabama, and therefore the SEC, should be left out. Whether the committee has the guts to do so, remains to be seen. Michigan's matchup for the College Football Playoff is thus up in the air at this point in time. They will be either #1 or #2, more likely #1 but I do think that Washington has a strong case for the top spot based on their resume. The Huskies will take the other spot of the top two, and then #3 and #4 will be two of those three teams I mentioned. Michigan is more likely than not to play in the Rose Bowl on New Year's Day, but the Sugar Bowl is a possibility if Washington gets the top spot in the rankings. Who it will be against is anyone's guess... and we've got until noon EST to wait. 

Comments

slimj091

December 3rd, 2023 at 1:42 AM ^

If Iowa had even a slightly good offense with that defense they would build a monument to Kirk Ferentz in Iowa City that would be so tall that you could see it from Chicago.

rym

December 3rd, 2023 at 3:47 AM ^

As it stands, Iowa needs to find the self-respect to fire both Ferentzes. We just watched Iowa hit its ceiling. Can you imagine rooting for a team that is so unimaginably boring and doomed to perpetual mediocrity because, to take the latest reason, it prioritizes the Coach’s son’s feelings over fielding even an Indiana/Northwestern/Rutgers/MSU-level offense?

J. Redux

December 3rd, 2023 at 1:50 AM ^

If you put Texas in to the exclusion of Alabama, you eliminate the last vestige of hope that anyone will ever schedule a meaningful out of conference game again.  If Alabama had played Texas State instead of Texas, they clearly would have won, and nobody would suggest they shouldn’t be in the playoff.  Punishing them for playing Texas seems misguided, even though they lost.

If Texas absolutely has to be ahead of Alabama, then the only thing you can do is drop FSU as not being one of the “best four” teams without Jordan Travis (note that the committee has never tried to define what “best four” means).  I don’t like the idea of an undefeated power conference team being left out, but it’s better than leaving out the SEC champ due to the vagaries of a loss in September.

I like the idea of the SEC sitting home for the holidays as much as the next guy, but it’s simply not realistic.  The SEC is the best conference in the country until proven otherwise, and a one-loss conference champion is not going to be knocked out by a one-loss champion of a lesser conference, head-to-head results be damned.

And, finally, UW’s strength of schedule is no better than Michigan’s — Oregon is significantly worse than OSU, and if Friday night is any indication, they may be worse than PSU also.  There’s simply no justification for Michigan to be anything but the #1 seed.

Dayday

December 3rd, 2023 at 2:18 AM ^

If you can leave out the pac 12 or the big 12, like has happened in years past, then the sec shouldn't be immune to being left out either. The sec gets too much credit for the bottom feeders in the sec. I don't know how the year ended up,  someone please look up the sec's record out of conference please, but I remember at least a couple weeks to begin the season they were not doing so well as a conference. You shouldn't get in on the conference's performance from years past but from the performance of this year. Texas beat Alabama FSU is undefeated. The sec should be out. Will they be? No,  but they absolutely should be. Enough of the, "the sec needs to be in the playoffs because they are the sec," b.s. That's sec marketing and propaganda. 

GoBlueTal

December 3rd, 2023 at 2:26 AM ^

it's 12 teams next season, so to, "eliminate the last vestige of hope that anyone will schedule a meaningful OOC game again" argument leaves something to be desired.  To counter your hyperbole, putting Bama in over Texas eliminates the last vestige of hope that anyone will ever take the regular season seriously again...  Texas went to Bama and won going away.  Whether in September or November is irrelevant.  Schedule quality will be a factor, and a good loss against a great team will be worth much more in a 12-team format than any win over a cupcake.  

I assume FSU will be sat in what is a travesty.  Control what's in front of you, win your games, the end.  They did, ugly or pretty, they did in fact win. And, since we only have the idiotic playoff so that the season ends with a game instead of a vote, the message is clear, winning uber alles.  

What right has the SEC to a spot?  Because Georgia was #1?  They lost, winning uber alles.  Bama beat them?  Bama lost to Texas at Tuscaloosa, winning uber alles.  We heard arguments during the game that Georgia should be in, if they do, every league should sit out and end the NCAA altogether.  Full stop.  

We have a playoff so that the championship is decided _on the field_ nothing else.  So dropping subjective arguments is against the entire intent of having the playoff.  Win. Your. Games.  

Sam1863

December 3rd, 2023 at 5:53 AM ^

Punishing (Alabama) for playing Texas seems misguided, even though they lost.

If we accept this argument as support of your contention that no one will ever schedule a significant OOC game again, then the reverse has to be true as well. You can't punish Texas for scheduling that kind of big OOC game - on the road, no less - and then winning it.

UMForLife

December 3rd, 2023 at 7:30 AM ^

It can go the other way if you don't schedule good non conference game. OSU got in few years ago even though they lost a OOC game early in the season. Imagine Bama losing to Georgia but beating Texas. Texas doesn't lose any game except to Bama. In that scenario, everyone will be clamoring for two SEC teams.

So your logic of why anyone would schedule a good OOC game is short sighted.

Champ Kind

December 3rd, 2023 at 8:43 AM ^

It’s an entirely different format after this year, so we have no idea what the impact of scheduling these games will be in the future. Texas and Florida State both scheduled tough out of conference games and won. Alabama lost at home. Alabama thought they’d need a tough OOC win because they might lose an SEC game. However, the SEC was bad this year so the bigger challenge was the OOC game. That’s the risk/reward. Going forward, who knows?

maquih

December 3rd, 2023 at 9:03 AM ^

> The SEC is the best conference in the country until proven otherwise

Alabama lost to Texas and LSU got blow out by FSU.  Like what does it mean "until proven otherwise??"

And maybe they're still the best conference but don't have a top four team, they just have more teams ranked 5-25 than any other conference. 

Does that mean we dont pick the four best teams out of respect for SEC being a good conference??

Wado

December 3rd, 2023 at 10:15 AM ^

You're getting a lot of downvotes for a realistic take. The CFP committee has said they are not obligated to take "the most deserving teams". And they have said that player availability is a criteria. We hate those aspects of the CFP, but they are there.

Now, there is a chance they will do the right thing and leave out the SEC, but how many of us think they will do that?

I think they will put FSU in a NY6 bowl against a top 10 team that is very likely to beat them, such as Georgia or OSU for vaguely "I told you so" reasons. It sucks, it doesn't offer a compelling argument against "why do we play the games, then?", but I think that's what will happen.

I've been wrong before though.

Zopak

December 3rd, 2023 at 1:59 AM ^

BET. Watched this game with my grandmother who is slowly starting to fade. This team has been a source of many great memories, which I'll hold very close. Can't wait for tomorrow

Class of 1817

December 3rd, 2023 at 2:04 AM ^

BWAHAHAHAHA!!!! I’m straight up pasting this for those of you who didn’t read it multiple times:

"The trophy presentation after the game merits brief discussion. Jim Harbaugh, back on the sideline after his B1G-imposed suspension, was put face-to-face with the man who suspended him, conference commissioner Tony Petitti. Petitti handed the trophy to the injured Zak Zinter, as Harbaugh wanted, but then quickly slinked into the background before Harbaugh stepped forward. It was a cowardly moment that will certainly be widely discussed in the coming days, painfully on brand for the man who suspended Harbaugh by leaking the story to ESPN before notifying the coach himself, then doing so while the team was on a plane, less than 24 hours before a game. Petitti's performance tonight only confirmed that he is a feckless, weak, and petty commissioner, nothing but an empty suit unprepared and incapable of handling the difficult business of running the conference.”

GO MGOBLOG!

stephenrjking

December 3rd, 2023 at 2:06 AM ^

Three Big Ten Championships in a row. 

I remember 1997 very well, and it is, as Lloyd Carr told the team, a legacy against which every team that follows is judged.

This team doesn't have Woodson, but it has a team of great players, all-time Michigan greats. This team has a better offense, but like 1997 it has relied upon its defense in the last month to win games.

I want Michigan to win two more. Let's face it: a lot of us felt uncomfortable for large parts of the game tonight, and it wasn't because we every thought Michigan was in danger of losing. It was because we want Michigan to win the national championship. This is the year. And we want the team to *look* like a team that will win the national championship.

After all, no team who struggles with mediocre teams has a chance, do they? If you play a flawed team, you should look like worldbeaters every time you face them

Or not. 

I can think of any number of reasons why Michigan's 26-point spread-beating victory over Iowa wasn't as impressive as I wanted, but in the end, it doesn't matter one little bit.

Because this Michigan team has won all the games it played so far. They have lost a total of 3 times since the humiliating 2020 season ended and I called for Harbaugh to be fired, and they have done so with three different guys calling plays, multiple acting head coaches, and two defensive coordinators.

It doesn't matter whether I think they look good enough to win it all or not. They have won. They will get to prove it on the field. 

Because, in at least one sense, this is very much like 1997. I remember the thrill of my first in-person Ohio State game, my first time in the student section, freshly turned 18 and flush with birthday money to scalp a ticket. The greatest game experience I've ever had at the Stadium. The crowd pushing me forward as Woodson ran that punt back into the opposite corner of the field. The incredible noise as Brian Griese knelt the ball to finish the last two minutes of the game. The crowd rushing the field.

And then heading home to watch the second half of Florida vs Florida State, with Spurrier rotating QBs every play. And, somehow, beating a Florida State team that was at the top of the polls. And running through the rooms of the house as that game ended, already hoarse from the incredible game earlier that day, now buoyed by a further boost. Running, yelling. One finger held aloft. Like 1997, this year, with all to play for, with a Rose Bowl beckoning:

We're Number One.

jackw8542

December 3rd, 2023 at 8:33 AM ^

It was a good, if boring, game plan that effectively eliminated any chance of an Iowa victory. We covered the spread, and the defense was amazing. We are #1, and we have shown it on the field, week after week. Was there any game other than Maryland where we did not cover the spread? Even in this slogfest, we covered the spread and with a couple of balls being caught that were, instead, dropped, it could have been a good bit more. Go Blue!

Goggles Paisano

December 3rd, 2023 at 5:53 AM ^

The disparity between Iowa's offense and defense is an all-timer.  I was listening to the Iowa radio broadcast during the 2nd qtr on my way home last night.  They were constantly talking about punting and flipping field position with the hopes of getting into FG range.  That's the mentality.  

As far as the playoff goes, the consensus amongst the talking heads is that FSU is out.  I can't get my head around being 13-0 and being left out.  All week long everyone was saying, "win and fsu is in".  Welp, here is where the rubber meets the road, and I think they get left out.  Fuck the SEC.  

 

Don

December 3rd, 2023 at 11:52 AM ^

I can't get my head around being 13-0 and being left out. 
 

The idiots who concocted this 4-team playoff guaranteed that they’d put themselves in this spot eventually. The common sense solution would have been to have an 8-team playoff comprised of the five P5 champions and three at large teams. That would yield Michigan, UW, FSU, TX, Alabama, Oregon, OSU, and Georgia. No controversy.

xgojim

December 3rd, 2023 at 6:35 AM ^

This was the wierdest lop-sided non-blowout blowout ever!  How fabulous!  Beat the huge point-spread with a defense that played like an offense and an offense that played like a defense.  The defense/special teams handed the offense 23 points and the offense scored only 3 via drives longer than a few yards.  M scored as many rushing touchdowns against Iowa as Iowa had given up in its 12 games -- on two "drives" of less than ten yards!  Yet the offense controlled the ball for 36 minutes, keeping Iowa off the field!  What a great defense!  Go Blue!!

Kewaga.

December 3rd, 2023 at 7:28 AM ^

"This is the first time Michigan has won three titles in a row since 1988-1992 under Bo Schembechler and Gary Moeller. The program has reached heights not touched in several decades, but still has one more goal to reach"

...few (not several) decades.

 

 

victors2000

December 3rd, 2023 at 7:36 AM ^

Tip of the hat to Iowa; now we know how they won ten games. I thought the Michigan coaches could have done a better job at getting the team in a position to score touchdowns by running trick plays. It was probably best not to use them; they might want to keep those bullets chambered for down the road when they really might need them. JJ could have played a smarter game; at times he held on to the ball too long waiting for something to develop and inevitably ended up being sacked. There were several instances he had Donovan open in or near 'the flat', but chose to keep looking for more. Our defense played lights out; to 'out-Iowa', Iowa, that is pretty impressive.

Oh well, 26-0 is a good outcome against this Iowa team, nothing to be ashamed of. 

 

UMForLife

December 3rd, 2023 at 7:56 AM ^

It was annoying yesterday when they kept showing SEC Top 25 wins rather than Top 10 wins. It is the distorted statistics to fit your narrative and ranking some SEC teams to strengthen the conference rubs me the wrong way. I have no idea why Fox is touting SEC as someone pointed out to me that Fox has no skin in the game. May be everyone thinks SEC is the best.

Regardless, leaving out a Power 5 conference champion with no loss is contrary to everything CFP committee said in the past. Between Texas and Bama, Texas Beat Bama. It doesn't make sense to reward Bama but not Texas.

If the final four is not UM, Washington, FSU and Texas, all objectivity is lost. I say Texas four because of its loss. Again, objectivity. But I don't trust the suits to do the right thing. And the media and annoying commentators won't do the right thing either.

DennisFranklinDaMan

December 3rd, 2023 at 8:27 AM ^

Of course, that's not "objective." It is, quite literally, your opinion. Describing it as "objective" doesn't make it so. 

This is by nature a subjective decision, in that there are no controlling criteria here the Committee has to follow. It doesn't seem, in my opinion, irrational for someone to believe that Alabama (or Georgia, frankly), is one of the four best teams in America. I personally think FSU should get in over them, but ... that's just my opinion.

WestQuad

December 3rd, 2023 at 9:25 AM ^

There is criteria that includes the team’s record and head to head wins and losses. The SEC objectively didn’t meet those criteria over Texas.

I would rather beat Alabama or Georgia as they have dominated over the past 10-[15] years, and are very good teams, but I don’t see any evidence that they are better than the other teams beyond opinion.  The only objective ding is that FSU isn’t as good without their QB which is in the criteria, but FSU won their championship game without their first or second string QB. 

Amaznbluedoc

December 3rd, 2023 at 8:09 AM ^

“Still, there were a number of things to clean up for Michigan's offense, the most notable of which being drops by the tight ends. Michigan could have scored well into the 30s if Loveland and Barner catch two balls that they normally bring in. Not much else to say there, other than flukey results. The offensive line's effort was concerning, but it seemed to be the regular starters getting abused, not the injury replacements. Ohio State has an excellent defensive front and Michigan fared much better up front in that one. Therefore, I'm not exactly sure what to say.”

Two disparate points.  The dropped balls by otherwise sure handed receives were concerning though credit Iowa’s defense on the disruption.  The o-line has been concerning all year (first with run blocking and then pass protection) and I think there is a fair amount to say.  The loss of Zinter was huge for many reasons not only for his ability but as a captain and leader.  Likewise, Nugent being banged up and leaving the game had an impact.  

Calling M’s o scheme “vanilla” was an understatement.  Iowa has a terrific d which is highly disciplined and mechanical.  We needed to adjust our scheme and the few times we did, there was a modicum of success.  The way one beats a d like this is using some motion, counters, slants, and quick out routes to dissect it apart.  The couple of times we did that, we saw some gains (CJ’s grab, Edward’s longest run come to mind) but we were unable to sustain this for the game.  

Whether Jim was toying with everyone or not, injuries were a factor, we were experiencing a bit of post ohio let down, or Iowa’s defense were “all that”, is largely irrelevant to me.  Instead, the team hung together, the D played lights out with 3 turnovers, held Iowa to a hair over 100 yards of total O, our FG kicking is strong, and the future is incredibly bright.  Yes this win was Coyote Ugly but by any measure this was a great win, we’re 13-0 and headed for the CFB playoffs!  

Anyone who has watched this team knows these kids are decent, are truly representative of this school and program, and are incredibly special.  I think the world of these players and am so proud for them, the coaches, and the fans.  Now it’s time to heal up, get back to work, and move forward.  Who’s got it better than us?   Noooo-body!  Go Blue!