Brandon Peters
Like a slave in orbit, he's beaten 'til he's tame. All for a moment's glory and it's a dirty, rotten shame. [Eric Upchurch]

Exit Brandon Peters Comment Count

Seth May 4th, 2019 at 11:55 AM

The least surprising departure of this offseason is finally quasi-official. Former starting quarterback Brandon Peters, who graduated from Michigan yesterday, has entered the trasnfer portal with two years of eligibility remaining, and Purdue the most likely destination.

Peters was the guy this site fell in love with after Ace and David took in a high school game of his in Indiana. Concerns about his lack of arm strength morphed into excitement over his ability to float a perfectly catchable ball with impeccable accuracy. Peters redshirted in 2016 and entered 2017 trailing Hoke/Borges leftover Wilton Speight and Houston transfer John O'Korn for the starting gig. But Speight was injured in the Big Ten opener that season, and after a pair of disastrous road starts against Indiana and Penn State, a nice easy home date with Rutgers seemed the natural launching point for Harbaugh's first true quarterback recruit at Michigan. Peters clearly had the training wheels on, but looked reasonably functional. A perfect wheel to running back/classmate/fellow Hoosier Chris Evans caused QB coach Pep Hamilton—and in fact the entire Michigan fanbase—to exclaim "The Brandon Peters era has begun."

The Peters Era would last only a few weeks. A week before The Game, Wisconsin's front seven turned Michigan's Drevno-constructed OL into swiss cheese; by the time Peters was knocked out of the rest of the regular season with a concussion, the freshman quarterback had already lost all semblance of composure. Michigan nearly beat Ohio State the following week but couldn't overcome O'Korn's terrible performance. Peters returned to start the bowl game against South Carolina, but looked extremely skittish and unconfident. Meanwhile, dismissible rumors leaked from the program that Peters didn't have the take-charge, devil-may-care attitude of a high-level quarterback. These were not helped by the Peters portion of Amazon's yearlong look inside the Michigan program, in which the presumptive starter came across as a generally passive, normal college kid.

Michigan pursued former 2016 five-star Shea Patterson to start in 2018. By the following spring, it was redshirt freshman Dylan McCaffrey, not Peters, challenging Shea for the starting job, and early enrollee Joe Milton got as much hype as the returning starter. It seemed a fait accompli by that point that Peters would seek a transfer. Already three years into his education, his choices were to lose the year of eligibility by transferring somewhere immediately, or stick around a few more semesters, get his degree, and have the freedom to transfer and play immediately wherever he liked.

It's impossible to tell if it was Pep Hamilton's overly long-developing route trees, Drevno's overly complicated offensive line calls, Brandon's own makeup, or what combination of the above, led to Peters not coming close to his potential at Michigan. There are probably 30 ways his career could have worked out differently.

Like Shane Morris and Alex Malzone before him, Peters demonstrates why the grad transfer rule is good thing for Michigan and its players. Peters leaves with a Michigan degree and more value than he had as a freshman. He offers immediate eligibility, three years of Harbaugh coaching, starting experience against Big Ten and SEC opponents, two years left to play to any school with a good graduate program that needs a starter. While Peters has the option to shop, a rising Purdue program near home and in dire need of an established QB is probably harder to pass up than the chance to coach Louisville was for Jeff Brohm.

Comments

dpeslis

May 4th, 2019 at 12:01 PM ^

Best of luck, BP!

 

Wish it would have worked out differently, loved this kid coming out of high school, but hope he finds a good fit now!

You Only Live Twice

May 4th, 2019 at 12:55 PM ^

Congrats on earning your Michigan degree Brandon, you will do good things wherever you go.

El Jeffe

May 4th, 2019 at 1:06 PM ^

Seems like a moderately likely scenario is that he'll be a mid- to late-round selection, spend 2-10 years as a backup in the NFL, and walk away with two post-secondary degrees from highly-ranked universities, millions in his bank account, and his brain intact.

Not too shabby!

WestQuad

May 4th, 2019 at 1:47 PM ^

Good luck Mr. Peters!

Really like BP coming out of highschool and even after he got his crack at starting.  2017 was an awful year on offense and I'm not sure if anyone would have done well.  Like Wilton Speight, I'll be a Brandon Peters fan going forward and hope he kicks ass at Purdue or wherever else he ends up.

Brhino

May 4th, 2019 at 1:49 PM ^

So officially how many quarterbacks has the Michigan Offensive line broken since the start of the Richrod era now?  Half a dozen?

Tr'Net

May 5th, 2019 at 1:02 AM ^

McCaffrey's injury was on a run past the line of scrimmage and had nothing to do with the protection of the o-line. Plus it was in garbage time and he was not the starter. It's lame to list him with the others. Also, Rudock's shoulder injury never sidelined him for a full game. 

stephenrjking

May 4th, 2019 at 2:42 PM ^

Peters waited behind two QBs that were not great, came in when they got hurt, did a serviceable job as a game manager, showed flashes of real promise at Wisconsin, got badly hurt, flailed in a bowl game... and got totally passed up and forgotten last year.

All of this past season there wasn't a single hint of dissension or difficulty. No highlights of Peters sulking on the sideline, no proxies airing grievances on message boards or to sympathetic media pot-stirrers. He went to practice, he participated in his drills, he came in and tried gamely in spot garbage duty. He graduated in three years.

It didn't work out in on-the-field terms, but otherwise he was everything we want a guy who comes to Michigan to be. 

I'd love to see him get a start against Wisconsin and win.

Go wreck the B1G West, young man. 

Marvin

May 4th, 2019 at 2:52 PM ^

If Peters transfers to Purdue, I wonder if he will really want to play well against Michigan, of if he will be torn about it since he was here for three years and likely has a strong allegiance to the team and coaches. Interesting food for thought on a rainy Saturday here in the deep south. 

stephenrjking

May 4th, 2019 at 2:55 PM ^

The only game on the schedule is in 2020, homecoming in Ann Arbor.

I would expect him to aim to play the best game he has ever played. Whether he has warm feelings or not, Purdue would be his team, and he would give it his all. 

I would expect nothing less. 

JPC

May 4th, 2019 at 2:53 PM ^

I hope he has a chance to show what he can do somewhere else - unless he's playing Michigan. 

ERdocLSA2004

May 4th, 2019 at 3:03 PM ^

Best of luck to him!  I hope he succeeds wherever he goes.

its amazing the number of quarterbacks our OL, OL coaching, and OL recruiting have left bloodied and broken over the last 10 years. Certainly we need more top notch recruits but I couldn’t be more relieved now that we have Warriner.

m1jjb00

May 4th, 2019 at 3:04 PM ^

I heard John Thompson say this on the radio once, and it perfectly sums it up for me.  I wish you well, just not at my expense.

Brian Griese

May 4th, 2019 at 4:13 PM ^

Kind of ironic this post blames Peters himself, Drevno and possibly Pep for things not working out, but makes no mention of the person that employed them and had the final say in recruiting Peters...

JPC

May 4th, 2019 at 7:31 PM ^

When Peters stopped short of the first down, I figured he'd never get off the bench so long as Harbaugh was coach. Harbaugh seems to value "toughness" above most other features of a player.

Harbaugh is the guy who did pushups until he puked to prove a point, and he seems to require that from his QB as well. Peters was never that guy, and it was a bad fit from the start. Even so, Peters never complained publicly, so kudos to him. 

BassDude138

May 6th, 2019 at 9:02 AM ^

Of the top 15 pro-style QB recruits in the 2016 class, one was just drafted and four are still at the school that they originally committed to. The other 10 have all transferred at least once, and that is just one recruiting class. This is what college football is now, it isn't a Harbaugh thing.

BassDude138

May 6th, 2019 at 4:16 PM ^

Or it just didn't work out for Peters at Michigan, so he moved on. Does there really need to be an investigation into who should get what percentage of blame? The best teams and coaches in the game don't hit on every QB prospect they bring in. OSU, Bama, and Clemson have all had 5 star, can't miss QB's flame out and transfer without even playing a down. But you have a burning need for Harbaugh to be crucified for having better QB options on the roster than Brandon Peters?

Albatross

May 6th, 2019 at 12:29 PM ^

You know what else is a college thing and not a Harbaugh thing? Winning conference titles and making the playoffs, since only a handful of college teams have done either of those things since 2016.

Harbaugh wasn't brought in for the status quo. You don't pay someone that type of money to be average. You can get that done with a lot smaller investment.

It's time for Harbaugh to live up to his paycheck.