Not A. Toomer

April 30th, 2018 at 3:20 PM ^

Love that google search in his commitment picture. The best players in Michigan do go to Michigan!

Bluey

April 30th, 2018 at 3:28 PM ^

I believe Barnhart is being recruited for center. He has really good mobility, reminds me of Mason Cole. Solid pickup. 

Bluey

April 30th, 2018 at 3:41 PM ^

He has a great frame and can move, so being a pulling guard definitely isn't out of the question. I expect it will take some time for him to add weight, but he looks like he could play at 315 lbs with ease.

FatGuyTouchdown

April 30th, 2018 at 3:57 PM ^

Don't overlook the fact that he played Tight End as a Junior, after playing on the interior line as a freshman and sophomore. I don't live in Michigan anymore, so I have no clue what position he's going to play as a senior. He also plays basketball. But to me that shows not only does he have great athleticism, but he's underscouted and underdeveloped as an interior lineman. He performed alright at camps, but he just didnt have the technique or size to beat elite level DL consistently and got put on his ass a couple times. I'd imagine Barnhart is a definite, no doubt redshirt, but I could see him developing very quickly. 

Magnus

April 30th, 2018 at 8:31 PM ^

It's not so much that I liked Rumler more at C than OG, but I did say that he doesn't really have the athleticism for tackle. I have heard that the coaching staff wants him primarily for center. Center and guard are pretty similar spots. Rumler is more of a drive blocker than a puller.

Watching From Afar

May 1st, 2018 at 9:44 AM ^

What?

You leave early if you're an OL that is like All-American level good. Jake Long had to make a decision to come back for his senior year because he was the best OT in the country. Lewan didn't even have that big of a decision to make and he was also a top 5 OT in the country as a junior.

Neither Bredeson or Onwenu have proven to be that yet. Onwenu wasn't even a starter all of last season. If either of those guys leave early, it would be the most out the blue thing I've seen in a while. Like Donovan Warren leaving early type weird, and even then he was a Freshman All-American/All-Big Ten first team guy.

JonnyHintz

April 30th, 2018 at 7:19 PM ^

Eh I wouldn’t be so sure. He’ll be coming in as a freshman when’s Ruiz is entering his Junior year. It’s almost certain that he would redshirt, meaning he’d only be a redshirt freshman when’s Ruiz is a Senior, and that’s assuming Ruiz doesn’t leave early.

goblue16

April 30th, 2018 at 6:35 PM ^

Not necessarily. Now I’m gonna use some big words so read slowly please. If harbaugh can match Dantonio that would make him 9-2 against his rival, 3 big ten titles and 1 playoff appearance with a couple bowl wins. Yes he did go 3-9 after a PLAYOFF APPEARANCE and then followed it up with a 10-3 season with wins against his RIVAL and PSU. Now fast forward 3 after harbaugh. What exactly are u expecting in the next 7 years that would put him above Dantonios last 10 years. If he can match that I would be more than happy

BigBlue02

April 30th, 2018 at 7:23 PM ^

Yay, another long post about how amazing Dantonio is. I was actually joking about what a shitshow MSU was when they went 3-9, but ok, let’s do this. If Harbaugh matches Dantonio’s accomplishments on the field, does that also mean he matches the off field accomplishments? Does that mean Harbaugh will have multiple football players attend multiple group beatings, one happening in a dorm and one in the middle of a yard? Does one of Harbaugh’s players give one of our own hockey players brain damage, do time in jail, and then get picked up and driven straight to football practice? Does Harbaugh recruit a bunch of rapists to the team, one of which had a rape-y high school past that caused other schools to back off his recruitment? Does Harbaugh get to kick a senior captain off the team right before the bowl game for steroids? Look, I get that Dantonio is a good in-game football coach and this board goes out of their way to blow him at any chance they get. He beat the shit out of two really shitty coaches at Michigan and has had a lot of success. Great. But I have zero desire for Michigan to look anything like MSU in any way imaginable. Harbaugh has outcoached Dantonio twice out of three games (I has a sad that we are only 1-2 against him in those three games), but you can keep Dantonio and the entire MSU football team and culture as far away from Ann Arbor as possible. Fuck Dantonio-he coaches at a shit infested school with a bunch of thug football players and I don’t want Harbaugh to match anything about that horrible program

goblue16

April 30th, 2018 at 8:21 PM ^

Why is it so difficult for morons like you to admit Dantonios done a great job he is the equivalent to John Beilein on the field/court. Your just like the idiot MSU fans who refuse to give Beilein the credit he deserves. No one is talking about off field issues I’m not sure how that is relevant to this argument. I’ve never seen such a stupid post

BigBlue02

April 30th, 2018 at 9:45 PM ^

I’m not like MSU fans as I can see what a shithole East Lansing is and how much better Ann Arbor is. I am also not like MSU fans because I can see Dantonio is a shitty human being who trades character of football player for wins on the football field. Also, I said Dantonio is a good coach and has won a lot. So to answer your question, it isn’t difficult at all for people like me to admit that as I already did. Good for him. The off field issues are relevant when you compare coaches. You know, like we are doing. I would rather have Beilein than Izzo because he is a shitty person. I would rather have Beilein than coach Cal because he is a shitty person. Both those coaches have more wins and I don’t want either at Michigan because I actually care about my school and not just getting wins. Also also, I’m not a moron, I just dislike Dantonio because I think he is morally bankrupt and it is impossible to mention how good a coach is and completely ignore the shitty people he is coaching. I am completely fine having to worry about multiple people on our team gang raping Michigan students.. I know it’s crazy, but it is possible to think a coach is good and still not want our coach to be anything like him. I don’t want Harbaugh to recruit assholes just to win, which is what Dantonio does. Urban Meyer is a good coach and I wouldn’t want him anywhere near AA because he sleeps with cords and tells you will never coach again, then takes another coaching job after his heart apparently gets better. So you can fuck right off with the name calling and go root for Dantonio for all I care. And it’s “you’re,” not your. You can fuck off with your bad grammar as well

JonnyHintz

April 30th, 2018 at 7:25 PM ^

Dantonio’s first three years he was 22-17. Harbaugh is 28-11. It’s asinine that you’re holding a coach that just finished his third year to the same results as a coach who just finished his 10th. Harbaugh is ahead of where Dantonio was at the same point in their tenure. Let’s not forget it takes time to build a program. Harbaugh took over a team that was 5-7 and 46-42 over the previous 7 years. Harbaugh inherited a program in disarray and a roster (while it had some talent) that was filled with holes and lack of scholarship players at key spots.

goblue16

April 30th, 2018 at 8:23 PM ^

Um Dantonio took over for John L smith so I wouldn’t make excuses. I’m not comparing the first few seasons I’m looking at a 10 year stretch. If harbaugh can match Dantonio I think that would be great. What more can you ask for at this point? Why is it shameful to make this statement?

Alumnus93

April 30th, 2018 at 3:29 PM ^

Someone send out the Magnus bat signal.. Magnus, where is Barnhart slated to play, and whats your educated opinion of him ?

FatGuyTouchdown

April 30th, 2018 at 3:32 PM ^

but I do remember Magnus was pretty damn high on Barnhart and I think he liked him a lot more than Stewart. Hope I'm not putting words into his mouth though.

My opinion, Kid is tough and mean as hell. He's athletic and definitely got the athleticism for tackle, but he may not have the pure size. Personally I think he's a guard, and I think he has a very high ceiling for a prospect in his rating range. 

BoCanHam15

April 30th, 2018 at 4:09 PM ^

As to who he thought was better between Stewart and Barnhart. “Barnhart was his choice!” It makes me feel like the o-line coaches have now settled in on one scheme. Thus, the decided eye test will become the norm more less now with recruiting! Can this kid do what we are trying to accomplish? Yes! Well we will take him. I know that we are headed in the right direction all of these kids will mirror our coach! It’s a great time to be a Michigan Wolverine!

FatGuyTouchdown

April 30th, 2018 at 4:42 PM ^

a trend of the coaches going after underscouted and underdeveloped two sport athletes. I'm not saying the coaches aren't attempting to reel in the big fish, but I feel like with Barnhart, Velasquez, Jack Stewart, Gabe Newburg, Ronnie Bell, Michael Barrett, and Luke Schoonmaker are all very underrecruited dudes that excelled in multiple sports. Guys that play multiple sports can sometimes be underrecruited and underdeveloped because they don't spend as much time at recruiting camps and on the recruiting circuit. 

Magnus

April 30th, 2018 at 8:35 PM ^

I think the coaches like him more at guard, but he's a guy who can play all five spots. I think he's a lot like Mason Cole, but he's not as polished yet, because he's a tight end in a run-heavy offense. Cole had some of the best technique of any OL coming to Michigan during the time I've been following recruiting.

I like Barnhart. I don't think he's going to turn into a 1st round draft pick or anything, but I think he's going to be a very solid player. If we can find a Mason Cole-like player within the state of Michigan, I think that would make most of us pretty happy.