Indy Pete - Go Blue

February 13th, 2021 at 12:38 AM ^

? it took urban Meyer less than one week to find his first scandal. To his credit, he has not even tried to blame this one on the cyst (always good to have that in the back pocket for his next misstep)

BlockM

February 13th, 2021 at 1:26 PM ^

In my experience, which consists of spending my entire life in the CRC, Calvinists are very good at applying this standard to themselves ("I'm saved, I truly believe") but not great at applying to others ("They did something I don't like, they couldn't possibly truly believe"). 

That's not unique to Calvinists obviously, but it always rubs me the wrong way when these valid conversations about someone's questionable decisions veer into discussions about someone's eternal soul, especially when it's an uninvolved 3rd party. 

Eli

February 13th, 2021 at 2:58 PM ^

Block,

The whole point is Grace through Faith and if you do truly believe and have that Faith, the Holy Spirit will change you and you will be Christ-Like.

Being Christ-Like will mean that you follow God's word as much as possible. If you say you truly believe, but you are still doing things that you shouldn't according to the word, then you don't truly believe. Hence the "Narrow Gate". Many say they believe, but do they really? 

It is a bit complicated, but there are some good Preachers that lay it out for us. I hope that helps. 

BlockM

February 13th, 2021 at 3:29 PM ^

I have heard those sermons countless times, from many preachers I respect greatly. I understand the concept.

I do not, however, think it's appropriate to debate someone else's salvation or lack thereof. It's not productive, and it assumes things about their inner self that no one else will ever and can ever know. No one wins except for the fleeting sense of superiority or judging someone else.

Just my opinion, of course.

MMBbones

February 13th, 2021 at 5:24 PM ^

Wow. Never expected anything here to go this far. I am a total POS, way too prone to drunkenness, like the rest of the MMB trombone section (hopefully the rest of you outgrew said affliction), and way too tending toward proclivity toward vice. I did have the privilege of doing some devotionals for the football team during Lloyd's tenure, in spite of myself. And it went well. Michigan recruits such outstanding men. Not 100%, but yeah, they are a great group overall vis-a-vis anyone else you would like to set up as a control group.

Yeah, responding to the above,  I am too fat to make it through the "narrow gate" if judged by works. Calvinists are people who recognize they suck. Include me in the aforementioned group of those who suck. And in any way in which you might suck too, I will be uncompromisingly sympathetic. I will be delighted to buy anyone on this board a drink if given the opportunity to further discuss, when we meet in A^2. 

blueheron

February 13th, 2021 at 9:10 AM ^

"He didn't learn anything from the scandal with his wife beating, ball lifting WR coach."

Huh? Over the years he's "learned" that he can get away with plenty of shit if he wins games and is plenty smoove when visiting the parents of recruits (and subtly trashing Harbaugh and Michigan so "smoovely" that the parents get his upspoken message even when consciously thinking that he's praising Harbaugh and Michigan).

It's nice to see a teflon creature like Urban get some shit. He's getting beaten pretty badly about Doyle.

I'm far from sold on Harbaugh's performance since 2014, but Urban is a good example of why Ohio State is on another cultural tier (a lower one) from Michigan.

UM85

February 13th, 2021 at 9:21 AM ^

A month or two back, when Jim H's job was in doubt, the question was floated about on the board would we want Urban as head coach at Michigan. We all know it would never happen but it was a slow news-day.  A surprising number said give us Urban and the W's.  I wonder if any of those individuals are now rethinking their position (or more correctly, actually thinking for the first time about their position). 

1VaBlue1

February 13th, 2021 at 9:49 AM ^

No.  However, they will mention how deplorable he is in this conversation.  But again, the next time that question is floated, they will - again - say they'd take him for the W's.  And the next scandal in his name will - again - cause them to say what a schmuck he is.  Rinse and repeat...

clarkiefromcanada

February 13th, 2021 at 12:56 PM ^

@UM85

At some point it's probably worth accounting that each of us is going to have failings (Sark, Urban, ex-Iowa S/C coach, Pruitt et al. among them). At a certain point "consequences" will occur from those actions that may or may not satisfy the ever moving goalposts of those who might judge. In Meyer's case, he is not coaching tOSU (I'm reluctant to believe the cyst rationale) and in this S/C coach he is apparently unemployable. Sark, on the other hand, new job at Texas. Pruitt, time will tell where new McDonald's bags may appear.

The question is, if people land on the opposite side of our societal judgment (see: Twitter mobs on one side or another) are they beyond redemption, forever? Have we inherently moved on from forgiveness or a culture that supports second chances? What flagellation would we ask of Meyer before he would have joined at Michigan? How can this ex-Iowa S/C coach be redeemed? Is it possible? If not where are we as a society that once supported a culture of redemption, second chances and renewal?

Personally, I believe in redemption and that humans, while fallible, are also redeemable. If Meyer were to admit his past transgressions and a desire to make things right I'd be open to him (although at this point he'd be Bruce Arians aged by the time that happened).  

MGlobules

February 13th, 2021 at 6:11 AM ^

That's one extremely tone-deaf move right there, bwoy. But. . . a welter of VERY interesting issues that go with a hire to probably the most conservative franchise in what is sometimes asserted to be the most conservative city in the United States. . . The question of whether Black players want to buy what white coaches and franchises are selling them is going to loom ever larger. 

Some real potential for this Urban hire to fail in explosive fashion. The NFL AND college football are large and changing animals, and a guy with Urban's record is going to be placed under the microscope. Break out the popcorn.