The people we're losing were great coaches. We're about to find out their skills as managers.

Submitted by BostonWolverine on January 29th, 2024 at 2:34 PM

We often have tons of insights into the day-to-day behind being a great football coach. Those are the types of results you see on the field day in and day out during their tenures.

But let's not forget: Coaches delegate, ramp up responsibility, teach, and work with their staff to make them better and get them ready for the next steps in their careers, just like in the business world. We saw it with Harbaugh and David Shaw at Stanford. We're seeing it now with Harbaugh and Moore, as well as with Herbert and Tress. 

Each coach infuses his own philosophy into the machinations of football, but the football community writ large often loses sight of the managerial aspects of coaching, along with the fact that they're not just coaching players. They're building their tree. 

Sometimes, you see the tenets of a mentor in the philosophy of a budding coach, and it doesn't completely work. Josh McDaniels, Matt Patricia, Eric Mangini...those are perfect examples of the Belichick tree not working the way we expected to. The fact is, I didn't really have Belichick figured for much of a manager or mentor. He's much more of a Football Mind™️ than a teacher. 

This is fascinating to me, because I think in general, college is a much better arena for teaching than the NFL. Kids are learning to be better players and better adults, and the coaches are there to instill different values than you see on NFL rosters. The players traditionally haven't been making millions of dollars for their abilities, and they're at a stage of development that requires a more human, even nurturing, approach.

It's similar to how I felt at the beginning of my career as a Copywriter at an advertising agency. My first year, I spent figuring out how to write, who to talk to, how to hone my strategic chops. I had talent, but I was figuring out how to apply it. For coaches as young as Tress and Moore, that's very similar to transitioning from player to coach. The mind is there, but the big-picture conversations hadn't yet started. Their focus had been singular. As coaches, their worlds begin to expand. 

As a burgeoning copywriter, you learn from your Creative Directors, strategists, colleagues...you take in everything you can. There's a lot of emphasis on being "hungry" in advertising, making you want to move on to bigger things, do the work that takes you to the next step, and makes you great. Usually, that's a euphemism for working long hours and not getting paid. Luckily, we don't have to worry about that here. 

As a Manager of Coaches, Harbaugh has a track record of using old hands (Drevno, Warriner, etc.) when he needs something urgently, but he also brings in younger minds when he has time to develop, train, and develop. 

Sherrone Moore is a great example of this. In five years, Moore went from TE Coach to Co-OC/OL coach, to OC, and now head coach. He has been fast tracked, partially due to the untimely departure of Matt Weiss, partially due to winning two consecutive Joe Moore awards, partially due to a whole bunch of other qualities we're about to see on full display in the years to come. 

Ben Herbert is a trainer by nature. Sure, his primary medium is strength and conditioning, but he's spent the last 5 years working with Justin Tress to train his abilities as a coach. 

A lot of this comes from Harbaugh as a manager. More than anyone I can think of in the public eye, we've seen him work to help coaches to succeed. After Jedd Fisch, Biff Poggi, David Shaw, et al. have moved onward and upward to the ranks of head coaches, Jesse Minter is now an NFL DC, and Ben Herbert has grown into an NFL S&C guy (which...I guess they exist now...). Saban hired complete coaches who needed jobs: Lane Kiffin, Tommy Rees, Bill O'Brien, Steve Sarkisian...It doesn't seem like he's taught anyone since Kirby Smart, and that's debatable. 

I'd argue that Harbaugh, more than any other coach in college football, believes in management and mentorship of COACHES. He made hires not just based on output, but on potential (see: Minter), he puts them in places to succeed (giving Minter, Hart, and Moore all gameday coaching responsibilities), and then he advocates for their advancement. Harbaugh has been saying for years that Sherrone Moore is ready for the next step in his career. This was not an accident. This was motivation, it was mentorship, and it was support from a manager. Harbaugh is not gone from the program. His legacy is still in big block letters behind Moore, who takes up the mantle.

Maybe it's because I'm closer to Michigan than I am to other programs. Maybe there's really something here. But not only am I optimistic about the direction of the program, I believe this was part of what Harbaugh saw as the goal when he took over as Head Coach. The Rodriguez and Hoke eras had left the coaching tree cupboard bare, and it was Harbaugh's job to create a new lineage for Michigan coaches. 

Now, the new lineage is here. Those who stay will be champions. And the best part? Some of them already are. 

Comments

HighBeta

January 29th, 2024 at 2:58 PM ^

Time will tell if Harbaugh's succession plans and efforts produce winning coaches. Because. At the highest levels, it's about results. We can argue all we want, the records will determine success rates. I'll be watching every play of every game, reading URFs here. I'm cautiously hopeful and will leave it at that.

jdemille9

January 29th, 2024 at 5:55 PM ^

Thank you for a level-headed take on all this. A bright spot amidst all the board BPONE, immediately after we won a national championship no less.

We aren't happy when we're losing and apparently we aren't happy as national champs - some of 'us' anyway. 

Good teams lose coaches, just the nature of the beast. I am willing to give Sherrone the benefit of the doubt as he rounds out his staff. At the very least let's wait to complain after he hires someone.

To paraphrase the stoics., "we complain more in imagination than reality."

mtm

January 29th, 2024 at 6:42 PM ^

Yes, been thinking about this as well.

At some point, you have to build a culture that is somehow self-perpetuating and self-renewing, that exists apart from an individual leader, or position coach, or whatever. Hopefully, Harbaugh (re)built that culture, and Moore is the guy to keep it going. But there's no use lamenting this or that coordinator or strength coach, or whoever, leaving the program. As long as there's a culture that develops people and gives them more opportunities on the backside than they came in with, we'll be ok.

(At least we can look forward Coach McCarthy coming to resurrect the program in Harbaugh's spirit, if necessary!)

mrgate3

January 30th, 2024 at 6:07 AM ^

You make a good point about teachers. I predicted (you can ask my wife) that Rich Rod would flame out quickly at UM, because he was just a football coach, whereas Lloyd was a *college* football coach. The difference was just too great, and you can easily argue that UM is the kind of place where learning is as important as winning. After Rich Rod, there was a coach who was just plain in over his head, then UM found the perfect "teacher" of football players. Let's hope that establishment lasts; the foundation looks pretty secure from here.

bighouseinmate

January 30th, 2024 at 10:04 AM ^

Just a note on Saban’s coaching hires: I believe that they weren’t so much about trying to make splashy, headline grabbing type of hires so much as they were hired of proven/semi-proven positional and coordinator coaches who’d failed at HC jobs. Saban, for most of them he hired, reformed and redirected their focus on team building and coaching and then sent them on their way again to become HC’s. Some of them, Sarkisian and Kiffin come to mind, have then gone on to become better HC’s than they were previously. And some of his longer termed coordinators, like Smart, have become really successful head coaches. 

michengin87

January 30th, 2024 at 10:50 AM ^

I agree on the Saban comments.  Most of the Saban understudies had extensive track records but had flaws that needed correction.  In each case, Saban's teams improved under the leadership of these understudies while the understudies also grew, resolved their flaws and developed as evidenced by their later success, although they still couldn't beat the master.

Relative to Harbaugh, I also agree that he is a leader and developer of talent.  Looking forward to seeing Coach Moore continue to develop and blossom as a leader, and I'm sure that he'll still call upon his mentor occasionally to hone his skills.  That is the Michigan Difference.

OC Wolverine

January 31st, 2024 at 12:42 AM ^

I was thinking the same thing.  There was a reason some of these guys got fired at previous head coaching roles and were left to take analyst positions at Alabama.

Sark and Kiffin have had much more success post-Alabama than they ever did prior to working with Saban (Sark getting sober may be basis for much of his turnaround).

SpacemanSpiff

January 30th, 2024 at 10:42 AM ^

Thank you for putting this to words! I've had this feeling for a while but was unable to articulate it. I think we'll see some great things from people who are getting elevated within the org. It will be really interesting to see how everyone does! I feel good about our chances.

schizontastic

January 30th, 2024 at 12:05 PM ^

Thanks for putting this together. We can have the silver lining that coaching hires etc is another 'game' to follow and 'enjoy'.

Sorry 'Excessive' use of quotes for sure.  

kehnonymous

January 30th, 2024 at 12:13 PM ^

What it comes down to, for me, is that Harbaugh trusts Sherrone Moore to pick up the torch and keep moving.  You know, that same Jim Harbaugh who is infamous for being lax and not holding other people to high standards.

Moore now has the biggest challenge to date of his career.  He'll make some missteps along the way, but so did Harbaugh. So did Saban.  So has everyone.  Moore will be defined by how he rises to those challenges and responds to his failures - but if we've learned nothing else from this run, it's that nothing is promised.  The only thing you can really do (especially as a fan) is trust that you have the right people in the right positions and hope for the best.  I'm not saying we will win another championship this generation but more that I have as much faith in Sherrone Moore to do it as any other conceivable alternative and that's good enough.

It'd be better if we could've kept Herbert, and it'd also probably be better if we had a different AD. But, looking back on the last three years, I can point to any number of things that I would've preferred happened that didn't (Zinter not getting injured, or forgetting how to field punts in the Rose Bowl, or not calling the Philly special, etc.) and... we overcame those.  We'll have to overcome some more hurdles so let's not all chicken out at the first post-Harbaugh thing that doesn't go our way, because that's what soft-ass OSU fans would do.