Brindley should hear his name tonight [Bill Rapai]

Unverified Voracity Goes For It Comment Count

Brian June 28th, 2023 at 1:03 PM

RIP. Sad week for the Michigan family, as Mister Simpson and Ryan Mallett both died far too young. Mallett drowned off the Gulf Coast—apparently one of 11 people to lose their lives to rip currents in the past two weeks. Simpson's death is under investigation by the Cincinnati police department. Keep their families in your thoughts.

Toe meets leather. Warde Manuel asserts that the changed Big Ten format will not affect The Game:

“The Game will remain at noon in the regular season when we play,” Manuel said on “In the Trenches,” a podcast produced by Michigan Athletics. “We’ve had great fan enjoyment of that game, and being at noon. Great television response in terms of numbers of people who who watch that game. I think there’s no need to move it to any other time. It’s really been become a part of that series and people sort of set their calendar, set their clock to watch that game at noon on the Saturday after Thanksgiving.”

This of course sets up the unappetizing possibility of an immediate rematch for the Big Ten championship, but aside from some wacky bloggers making wacky, impossible suggestions—Seth and I are specialists in this department—I'm not sure what the alternative is.

Also note the assumption that the Game will be at noon, which is technically not guaranteed—Fox could choose another Big Ten game for their #1 overall pick—but is about as certain as anything in this crazy mixed-up world.

Math wins. There used to be a cottage industry around here: fourth-down clucking. We still mention it from time to time, but the section on the podcast that used to mention unforgivable Brady Hoke decisions has mostly been reduced to things like "ehhh… that's really close." That's because college football has gotten a lot more aggressive on fourth down. Bill Connelly provides a graph:

image

Since there are occasional correct punt decisions even in the top two categories college coaches are probably approaching optimal. I also enjoy the big spike in 2020, as the college football collective decided that nothing mattered lol. Then they were like "oh… that worked" and kept going for it.

Michigan was not on the leading edge—you probably know this—but chose its spots superbly:

Meanwhile, Michigan went for it just 21% of the time (87th) but picked its spots well and profited by 5.3 points per game (ninth). Jim Harbaugh's Wolverines converted 17 of 21 attempts (81%, second in FBS) and scored 81 points after those 17 conversions. Opponents scored only seven points after the four failures.

No decision was more important, bold, and correct than Michigan going for it on fourth and one in their own territory early in the third quarter against OSU. Meanwhile, the Buckeyes:

I imagine this is high on the list of offseason priorities in Columbus. It'll be interesting to see how that number changes this year. If it stays stubbornly low it could be a sign that Ryan Day's just a finesse kind of guy.

[After THE JUMP: yeahhhh we're just going to ignore you thanks]

The rerank. The Athletic's Max Olson re-ranks the 2019 recruiting classes. 2019 was the Dax Hill-Chris Hinton-Charbonnet-Mazi Smith class, and Michigan slides well up from their original ranking of 8th:

3. Michigan

Adjusted average: 2.85
Class rank in 2019: 8th
Four-year record: 36-11
Attrition: 44%
Top signees: DB Daxton Hill, DL Mazi Smith, LB David Ojabo, DB DJ Turner, DL Mike Morris

Jim Harbaugh and his coaches found 13 starters and eight All-Big Ten players in this class, hitting on a remarkable number of NFL-caliber defenders who helped lead the run to back-to-back Big Ten championships and College Football Playoff appearances. Smith joined Hill in becoming a first-round draft pick this spring, while Ojabo and Turner were both second-round selections. Morris and defensive lineman Mike Danna also got drafted, and D-lineman Christopher Hinton is playing in the league as well.

The Wolverines’ offensive haul in 2019 included quarterback Cade McNamara, offensive linemen Trevor Keegan and Karsen Barnhart, wide receiver Cornelius Johnson and running back Zach Charbonnet, who became the best back in the Pac-12 after transferring to UCLA.

Michigan's attrition rate is fairly standard, FWIW. Alabama had a whopping 61% attrition rate and still slid in just behind Michigan at #4. Must be nice.

FWIW, that was the class where Michigan missed on the top three kids in state, causing much panic on the Michigan internet and rejoicing in East Lansing. Not so fast, my friend: The in-state top three of Logan Brown (UW), Devontae Dobbs, and Julian Barnett (both MSU) all failed to make an impact. Mazi Smith, #4, just got drafted in the first round.

Just find one corner. Michigan's other CB slots are in excellent hands:

I don't see any OSU players on that list.

Let them enforce it. The NCAA's trying to keep the lid on NIL business, for all the good that will do:

Texas A&M's AD has directly stated they're ignoring this: "The state law is going to govern how we do business." In this new era of anything goes that's not a huge surprise; what is the NCAA going to do about it? As mentioned repeatedly around here, scholarship limits are more or less fictional. They really do not want to issue postseason bans. Does anyone care about vacated wins? No. Is a federal court going to side with the NCAA? Not likely.

This is all futile posturing by people with jobs that are rapidly becoming obsolescent.

FWIW, a bill that somewhat liberalizes Michigan's NIL law has been introduced in the state legislature. MLive's summary:

It seeks to expand Michigan’s existing NIL law for college athletes to allow colleges to partner with third-party licensees and help athletes better utilize NIL opportunities.

“The NIL legislation that we are seeking promotes fairness and equity among student-athletes,” sponsoring Rep. Angela Witwer, D-Delta Township, told the higher ed committee.

HB 4319 would also encourage colleges to offer financial literacy, brand management and life skills programming for athletes.

That's not at the level of the more aggressive state legislatures but seems like a good change.

Obligatory Berhalter take. I endorsed his return after the World Cup and nothing in the intervening six months did much to change my opinion. ESPN's Ryan O'Hanlon has a briefer version:

At the 2022 World Cup, there was a team that didn't allow a single goal from open play in the group stages. They drew with -- and outshot -- England. And they didn't lose a game in the opening round: one win and two draws.

Sure, they lost in the round of 16, but it came against the Netherlands -- a traditional world power -- and this team had almost 60% of the possession in that match, also outshooting the Dutch 17 to 11. A couple of bounces go differently, and this team is playing Lionel Messi and Argentina in the quarterfinals.

Now, this team didn't even qualify for the previous World Cup. And at the World Cup before that, this team went out in a match against Belgium that was so lopsided that the literal president of this team's country called this team's goalkeeper to congratulate him on all of the saves he'd made.

At every previous World Cup this team had qualified for, they'd rolled out the traditional international-underdog playbook: defend well, wait for set pieces and counterattacks. Supporters, who had been both pining for more modern tactics and to see their team perform at the World Cup, got it all in Qatar: this team played in a new way, and this team got results.

So, when this team announced that it was rehiring the same manager that guided this team at the World Cup, everyone rejoiced ... right? You simple, silly person. This is the United States men's national team: we don't rejoice here, buddy!

The #BerhalterOUT crew on twitter—which some wag just dubbed the QSMNT—is losing their minds, but given the realistic prospects out there I'm more or less content to continue with a coach who had the US playing on the front foot with a very young team who seems to be thrilled to have him back.

TBH unless you get an extreme outlier like Klinsmann, an international manager is not really going to move the needle much. As long as Berhalter is able to smooth things over with Reyna, which is likely, there's no reason to not continue to build on what was an encouraging cycle.

Etc.: Talking with Adam Fantilli just before this year's NHL draft. Men's tennis coach bounces for Florida. Manuel talking about NIL. Fantilli endorses Gavin Brindley. Alan Bowman's going to start for Okie State.

Comments

BursleyHall82

June 28th, 2023 at 4:11 PM ^

If Alan Bowman starts for Okie State, there will be four Michigan quarterbacks starting for Power Five teams: JJ (Michigan), Cade (Iowa) and Joe (Tennessee) being the others. That's remarkable. Just need Dan Villari to switch back to QB and crack the lineup at Syracuse, as well.

Blue Vet

June 28th, 2023 at 4:35 PM ^

Is it just my imagination or is this an exceedingly calm Unverified Voracity? 

Lots of here-are-things-going-well and see-we-didn't-need-worry and so-pretty-good. 

I may have to close my window b/c I don't need to be ready to get out on the ledge. (Also, I'm in NYC, so closing it makes breathing easier.)

Autostocks

June 29th, 2023 at 9:47 AM ^

Wise to teach your children - even the Great Lakes can be dangerous.  There are many drownings from dangerous surf conditions along Lake Michigan.

However there were no rip currents present when Ryan drowned, and beach conditions were yellow flag, meaning moderate.  The reporting is, unfortunately, and like a lot of reporting these days, sensationalism.

RIP Ryan Mallett.

BKBlue94

June 28th, 2023 at 5:23 PM ^

Don’t like that The Game is always at Noon. It's just not the best time of day for a football game, especially one with that much hype. Need more time that day for build up and tailgating - would love to see it at 3:30 or wouldn’t even mind a night game. 

And with a game that big people don't really care if it happens in the dark/cold, which is clear if you've ever been to a packed night NFL playoff game. 

Edit: I often get a few negatives votes on this opinion, but no one ever says why so far. Would love to hear what makes noon games ideal. I could potentially be wrong, but I just don't see it.

michengin87

June 29th, 2023 at 5:46 PM ^

Agreed.  So many good reasons for me to like the noon kickoff.

I enjoy being the first game of the day on the last weekend of the regular season and also being The Biggest Noon Kickoff of the year.  This also ensures that The Game is played during daylight and in the relative warmth of the day when there isn't much of either by late November.

JBLPSYCHED

June 28th, 2023 at 6:34 PM ^

What's the over/under on how many years in a row M-OSU will be the B1G championship game match-up beginning in 2024? More to the point, how many times will it happen before they change something about which teams play in that game? With the CFP expanding to 12 teams, and probably more than that down the road, the conference championship games need to go the way of the dodo bird.

JBurd

June 28th, 2023 at 8:37 PM ^

I have been a long-time Mgoblog reader and a huge fan of Brian's work for ~13 years and I agree with 99.9% of his takes on anything Michigan athletics. 

With that being said he has some really terrible USMNT opinions. If you think Berhalter is a good tactical manager then you don't really understand the game of soccer. Cherry-picking random stats like "didn't allow a single goal from open play" is meaningless. They were playing Wales, Iran, and perennial underachiever England. Pretending like the Netherlands game meant nothing because they are a "traditional world power" is laughable.

The truth is that Gregg was a below-average manager with a career 39% win rate who was hired via a search conducted by his own brother wherein no other managers were interviewed. Claiming that he should come back because the players he has favored for the last couple of years want him back is asinine. Think of how much Brady Hoke was loved by his players and how many of them would've wanted him back

Here is a thread explaining the process of the Berhalter hire for those interested.  https://twitter.com/FootyMoments21/status/1600210519889018881

I think a lot of the Berhalter support comes from a lack of soccer knowledge. People watch their local MLS teams and watch their local USL teams or maybe even catch a couple European/ South American games and believe they understand what they are watching. Brian and Seth can break down the game film of a football game in a way that goes over the head of the majority of us while we're watching the games. After reading some of Brian's opinions on the USMNT it's pretty obvious that he doesn't have that same ability when it comes to soccer. Those of us who played at a high level and can appreciate the tactics of well-played soccer can see Gregg for the below-average manager he is.

If that makes me QSMNT that's fine (I don't post on twitter so I'm not sure if I qualify). I was just so surprised to finally disagree with one of Brian's opinions that I thought I'd share my .02.

ShadowStorm33

June 28th, 2023 at 9:42 PM ^

Yeah, we looked shitty in qualifying, and pretty mediocre at the World Cup. Injuries didn't help, but Berhalter made some strange roster decisions, and I've heard he has a reputation of playing favorites with those that kiss his ass, which is no bueno when he decides to sit talented players like Reyna potentially without good justification. And his tactics have never really inspired.

Now I'm sure Berhalter deserves some credit for developing the team, but I'll be honest, to my admittedly amateur eye, the performances in the two Nations League games I watched coached by the interim guy (Callaghan) were way more impressive than anything I've seen from Berhalter...

Eberwhite82

June 29th, 2023 at 9:51 AM ^

I love the idea that Twitter opinions being stupid somehow invalidates the opinions of those of us who know what we're looking at. I have nothing to do with Twitter, yet I'm not all that psyched about GGG coming back.

I've been following and analyzing US soccer since the late 80s. (Yes, I'm old.) I'm not objective (I'm a fan), but I sure can look at talent and the overall set-up of a squad and provide a critique. GGG all too often constructs rosters that leave much more talented guys off with MLS pluggers taking their place. It's not all that complicated.

And the analysis that we were a few bounces away from playing ARG in the quarterfinals is pretty close to disqualifying in terms of its simplicity. What many don't seem to grasp is that because the US roster lacked quality backups AND the trust of the manager, our midfield was completely gassed by the time we played NED. Our high press style runs our front 7-8 into the ground. You have to play your bench in the group stage so that you can compete in the knockout stages.

That's 100 percent on the manager, yet it barely gets talked about by the "experts" who talk about our performance at the WC. 

DiploMan

June 29th, 2023 at 10:59 AM ^

"It’s really been become a part of that series and people sort of set their calendar, set their clock to watch that game at noon on the Saturday after Thanksgiving.”

No, Warde.  What is traditional is that The Game is on the Saturday before Thanksgiving.  It was only in 2010 that the game got moved to the following Saturday.  To my everlasting frustration at having to wrestle time together with family with watching (or listening on the radio) the most important game on the calendar.

michengin87

June 29th, 2023 at 6:32 PM ^

As a matter of trivia I must remind everyone that there were actually several times that it was played after Thanksgiving.  Indeed, there were 6 instances since I started following my favorite school in 1972 and prior to making it permanent in 2010.  During The Ten Year War, they played each other after Thanksgiving in 1972 and 1978.  Then again in 1989, 1990, 1995, and 2001.  Of course, these were all years in which Thanksgiving was particularly early and resulted in The Game being played after Thanksgiving.

I, too, much preferred that The Game be played before Thanksgiving, but at least The Game has been preserved and that weekend is now becoming rivalry weekend throughout college football, so this is the new tradition that I am learning to enjoy.

DiploMan

June 30th, 2023 at 6:37 PM ^

Thanks for that correction.  Now that you mention it, I do remember morosely watching the 2001 game in the airport on my way back from my parents' place after a Thanksgiving visit.  I was too young to care about football in '72.  '78 and '95 I was living overseas.  And I don't remember '89 or '90 at all.

I suppose the other alternative would be to petition to have Congress change the date of Thanksgiving.

Having the CFB playoff semi-finals on New Years Eve the last two years also sucked (almost as much as the outcomes of the games).

Major college football games should be their own holidays; they shouldn't have to share with others.