[Zoey Holmstrom]

High Arc Comment Count

Brian March 21st, 2022 at 11:41 AM

[Shirt? Shirt!]

3/17/2022 – Michigan 75, Colorado State 63 – 18-14, 11-9 Big Ten, Round of 32.
3/19/2022 – Michigan 76, Tennessee 68 – 19-14, 11-9 Big Ten, Sweet 16.

This year played out like a message board hypothetical. You know, the one where a guy posts something like "would you trade a win over OSU and Big Ten championship in football for a disappointing bubble season from the #4 ranked basketball team?" You're like "ehhhhh… okay" because the universe doesn't work like that. And then maybe the universe does work like that.

Perhaps there is a maximum amount of swag to go around and whatever barrels football tapped as they pumped it up this fall came from Michigan's strategic reserve. Or maybe we've got Zavier Simpson in a basement with tubes sprouting from him like so many spring clovers.

I will walk away from this particular Omelas in three weeks, tops. Promise.

----------------------

As a person who lives in Ann Arbor and gets asked "what do you do for a living" with some frequency, I have a lot of experience with people being weird or dismissive about sports. Ann Arbor is the archetype of a liberal college town, of course, so anyone who doesn't already know who I am is almost certain to fall on the Sportsball Continuum. On the nice end of this continuum are people who apologize to me for not knowing anything about sports; on the not so nice end are people who actually deploy the world "sportsball." I have had many interactions with people who are puzzled or irritated that I am a guy who does the sports liking.

Sometimes I have tried to explain myself, or at least thought about what I would say if anyone seemed interested in an explanation. (For reasons likely related to cultural ubiquity, Sportsball Continuum people evince a profound lack of interest in why anyone would be off the continuum.) What I've come up with is this: sports aren't just numbers adding up over a set period of time. They are story machines.

One of the great delights of college sports is that the timeframes are generally long enough to see a player become what they're going to become and short enough that there is always someone new to see develop. The pros are more static, with colossi (Brady, Lebron, Baseball Man) bestriding the sport for a decade or more. In college whenever someone hits that they're gone and you've got to see what the freshman with dreadlocks might be up to. The stories are more than Who Is The Goatest, Skip?

These stories exist on various levels: players. Seasons. Programs. This game wrote down some history on all of these levels. It provided the definitive Eli Brooks Game for the longest-serving player in program history. It rewrote this disappointing season, at least somewhat. It reinforced the vibe around Michigan basketball—and unfortunately for Tennessee fans, reinforced the vibe around their program as well. This Jonathan Wilson passage I referenced after the USA-Algeria World Cup game always floats up at times like these:

Perhaps some of the Europeans there – certainly the French journalist opposite – were driven by anti-German feeling, perhaps some were instinctive Slavophiles, but when the three locals at the MTN (South Africa-based mobile telecommunications company) desk reacted to the final whistle with a group hug and collective dance, the appeal of Serbia's inner turmoil becomes difficult to deny. Unless they'd had a bet, I suppose, but when asked one said he'd decided to support Serbia because "they seemed to be trying to lose".

This is an intimately familiar feeling for any basketball fan, but it must be completely unintelligible to the Sportsball Continuum people. Explaining is difficult. Maybe it's less difficult now?

Now I can just say "Imagine that a fifth-year player everyone wanted to run off campus because he seemed terrified of basketball appropriated the delightfully weird shot a previous player—one denied a career culmination by covid—had painstakingly developed over the course of a few years; imagine that this one-time wilting flower of a player would uncork an audacious hook shot at a crucial juncture to defeat a heavily favored opponent, thus writing himself into annals of program history. If you were invested in this sort of thing, watching the maturation and development of this young man would not just be a guy hitting a shot, but the climax of a character arc. It's like Game of Thrones except the source material never runs out. Once you have the context that gives the numbers meaning the drama outstrips any planned fiction. Joy and pathos intermingle. We reach down into the vast beating heart of human striving and drink deeply of its nectar.

"Also sometimes Wisconsin shoots 9% from three."

This would not work because the other person would wander away and talk to someone else about organic hummus brands, but I could do it.

[After THE JUMP: Bullets]

----------------------

BULLETS


Big Ten Championship on December 4, 2021.
(Zoey Holmstrom)

[Holmstrom]

A coin flip. Michigan's win was not a fluke but neither did it feel ordained, so this measure of shot quality landing on a knife edge feels about right:

Tennessee should have hit a couple more threes, particularly during that second-half stretch where Michigan hedging was leaving guys wide open in the right corner, but also how many midrange jumpers did the #315 team in other twos hit? From your author's in-game perspective, a billion too many. It felt like about half of Tennessee's three attempts were not good—30 footers or contested shots—and most of the ones that were good were coming from a guy who's a 32% shooter. He hit zero of six.

But yeah where the Colorado State game felt like Michigan catching up and passing a team they were likely to reel in, this one felt like every bucket was the dagger until one actually was.


Big Ten Championship on December 4, 2021.
(Zoey Holmstrom)

[Holmstrom]

Mr. Inside-Outside. Hunter Dickinson had two phases in this game. In the first half he was frequently in pick-and-pop situations and Michigan did not put him on the block much. It looked like Michigan wanted to use Diabate as the main inside threat; this should have worked out better than it actually did, with Diabate bogglingly missing a couple of bunnies and having a couple of Tennessee non-shooting fouls wipe out what would otherwise have been additional (possibly missed) bunnies.

The second half started with a left block Dickinson post-up and it was clear Michigan's focus had changed. Dickinson did have a late clock flash to the elbow and another three, but IIRC all of his other second-half attempts were out of the post. This may have been spurred by Diabate having a bit of an off game, or may have been the plan from the start—unleash Dickinson post ups after halftime, when the opposition doesn't get to have a long break to decide how to best combat them.

Pregame assertions in these parts that John Fulkerson's post defense just could not have been that good turned out to be accurate: Tennessee went with many more Uros Plavsic minutes than usual and Fulkerson got put under the basket a couple times when UT tried him out against Dickinson.


Big Ten Championship on December 4, 2021.
(Zoey Holmstrom)

[Holmstrom]

Frankie does some things. Collins had just two points and two assists in this game to go with two turnovers but that stat line badly understates his performance. He had a Kobe assist to Dickinson on one of his misses and set Caleb Houstan up for three catch and shoot triples, none of which went down. He had another coulda-shoulda assist fail to occur because Tennessee got called for a blocking foul. He broke Tennessee ball pressure to the point where UT largely abandoned it.

Maybe more importantly, Collins was the only Michigan plyer who could consistently stay in front of Chandler and Zeigler. He had an early defensive possession against Vescovi where he nearly stole the ball three times that felt like it rattled him, and Zeigler spent the last five minutes settling for threes, barely testing Frankie's ability to stay in front of him.

He was obviously massive in the Colorado State game, going on a personal 5-0 run after Colorado State pushed it out to 28-13 late in the first half. He finished 5/5 from two and barely turned the ball over.

This weekend points towards Collins being the future at point guard even if his shot is unfathomably broken. The once and future Simpson.

Terrance Williams, junkyard dog. Williams finished this game out, acquiring two massive putback buckets in the closing minutes and calmly hitting a couple free throws. The announce team was accurate when they described him as just kind of a guy who does basketball. He goes out there and good things tend to happen.

Uh… isn't it time to dump more minutes on him? Williams is not high usage but he's shooting 53/39/77 on the season and he doesn't have a clear case of the yips. I'd much rather see him on the floor than Brandon Johns or Road Version Caleb Houstan right now. Maybe keep starting Houstan for appearances and in case he hits a couple early shots but once Houstan's 15 minutes deep into another bagel game maybe Michigan should plan on 25 Williams minutes.

A shirt I enjoyed. As per the title:

tennessee-shirt

Ian Eagle's bizarre proclamations. Perhaps you were, like me, puzzled when Ian Eagle declared that Hunter Dickinson "had a fever" and was "really exploring the space." If so you should remember that Christopher Walken's character in the More Cowbell sketch goes by "The Bruce Dickinson." I had forgotten this.

Poor damn Devante'. Devante Jones missed the Colorado State game and played only twelve minutes against Tennessee. He missed the first game because of a concussion sustained in practice; against Tennessee he suffered a cut to his hand and then got his head banged by Diabate. The latter hit looked fairly innocuous, but when you're recovering from a concussion that's relative. He has five days to get healthy, but I wonder if the two head hits in close succession mean he needs to be on the shelf for longer than that to truly recover. I wouldn't be surprised if he's unavailable.

That's a shame dot gif. Carnage Sunday in the Big Ten saw the conference lose four of five games, with only Purdue surviving to join Michigan in the Sweet 16. Aside from seeing Iowa make it—a distant dream indeed—that's a perfect first weekend of the tournament. Brad Davison trudging off the court after Wisconsin lost a virtual home game against Iowa State was a true chef's kiss moment.

Comments

M-Dog

March 21st, 2022 at 11:46 PM ^

Our own (former) President - Mark Schlissel - was on the far end of the Sportsball Continuum. 

On the AD search after Brandon was fired:

“People have been saying all kinds of things about who I’m talking to about positions and this sports stuff, and they name names of people who I have no idea who they are. I’ve really learned that this whole athletic sphere and the usual way you approach things just doesn’t work. It’s just a crazed or irrational approach that the world and the media takes to athletics decisions."

He hated the emphasis on sports at Michigan (something that five minutes of research would have told him has existed for 100+ years).

He was, however, an aficionado of organic hummus. 

ypsituckyboy

March 21st, 2022 at 12:07 PM ^

Brian, we walked past each other at the Silver Lake recreation area on an off-football Saturday last year. In that 3 seconds, I could tell that you knew that I knew who you were and that you knew I was a random local blog reader. We did not speak, merely exchanged a knowing glance.

Should our paths cross again (literally or figuratively), there's nothing more that I would like than to hear an Eli Brooks soliloquy amongst the trees of SE Michigan.

stephenrjking

March 21st, 2022 at 12:07 PM ^

I guess when your basketball team makes five straight Sweet Sixteens, you are going to see some strange variations that make it. This is probably the most surprising version, though if you had told Michigan fans in February of 2017 that Michigan would roar into the SS with a B1G tournament championship and a great win over a 2 seeded Louisville (much less after a plane crash) you would not have been well received. This is a strange mix of young-ish guys with one wily veteran of all veterans still hanging around like a 20-year old that keeps dropping by his old high school.

After Beilein's initial flirtation with Eli at the point in that early tournament where we lost to LSU, Simpson locked down the starting PG job, and Eli spent two years doing not a lot. Some people on boards like this said that he wasn't really a Big Ten level player.

That is, alas, technically true: Most Big Ten level players don't get to play in Sweet Sixteens these days. Eli has played in four of them. 

matty blue

March 21st, 2022 at 12:15 PM ^

i can't even describe how much i love when someone like eli sticks around and goes from being (unjustified) fan target to functional player, if not a team leader and critical contributor.

we tend to ascribe all sorts of personality traits to what we see on the court or field, and we almost never have the faintest idea what we're talking about.  but in this case?  of COURSE eli plays like a mature adult that has been through a lot.  i think of MAAR the same way - remember his affect stepping to the line for those free throws against maryland?  like his pulse wasn't even slightly elevated.

fiery guys like hunter dickinson and mo wagner are important, obviously, but you need those cool, calm, collected guys, too.  i'm still not sure about juwan's current and possibly future roster construction, but he seems to get that he needs both.

i think, too, of this year's ladies hoops team.  danielle rauch and emily kiser played way less than eli did through junior eligibility.  but they stuck around and became important cogs in a terrific team.  there's something to be said for that, not only in terms of team success, but also in that it harkens back to brian's reference to college sports as stories.

anyway.  what a weekend.  can't think of a single outcome i would've changed.  well, except a meteor hitting the stadium during duke vs sparty.  but hey, you can't have everything.

J. Redux

March 21st, 2022 at 12:15 PM ^

The only way that things could have gone any better would have been if (a) TCU had held on and (b) Brad Davison had fouled out of his last game, preferably while flopping, six feet away from his opponent, trying to draw a charge on a game-tying, buzzer-beating, banked-in three, with the resulting four-point play giving Wisconsin a one-point loss.

Not that I've spent a lot of time trying to come up with Brad's most humiliating exit or anything...

robpollard

March 21st, 2022 at 12:22 PM ^

Ian Eagle is awesome - funny, descriptive, gives room for his analyst gets excited but not overly so. Glad he did our games.

I really, really hope Devante Jones sits. He has had at least 3 hits to the head (one of which, in practice, caused a concussion) within the span of 9 days. For whatever reason, during his short stint against Tennessee, he had difficulty dribbling and looked a bit lost on defense. Was it the hand? Bad luck/nervousness? Additional concussion effects? I don't know. But simple observation and the report that he was "sick" indicate the latter.

Suffering multiple concussions in a short period of time is very serious, and can easily be life altering/threatening. Even before this stretch, he regularly crashed down to the ground -- it's just how he plays. Michigan either needs to sit him or be extremely prepared to answer questions of why he was in the game (I'm talking a pre-clearance by multiple, highly regarded, independent neurologists) if something, God forbid, happens against Nova.

CRISPed in the DIAG

March 21st, 2022 at 12:24 PM ^

We have to give Houstan some minutes to un-fvck his shot because tournament teams don't usually advance without someone able to shoot threes. In terms of creating space, opposing teams appear to defend him for the moment, so he's at least useful in that regard.

Otherwise, yeah, we need TWill's minutes IF Houstan is going to continue to rack empty attempts.

TrueBlue2003

March 21st, 2022 at 2:24 PM ^

What's more frustrating than missed shots, which happen, is when he tries to make something happen off the dribble.  It almost never goes well.  I'm fine with him in the game if he accepts his role as Just A Shooter and only shoots open shots.  But when he puts the ball on deck, it too frequently ends in a poor shot or turn over.

jdraman

March 21st, 2022 at 12:27 PM ^

Great write-up Brian. W/r to Ian Eagle, he said "More cowbell for Dickinson!" after HD had an and-one against Colorado State on Thursday. So, he's just going back to the same, admittedly hilarious well. 

Erik_in_Dayton

March 21st, 2022 at 12:33 PM ^

I will avoid going on too much of a rant, but looking down on people who like sports is an own goal by liberals (and I am a liberal).  

On a happier note, Frankie Collins grew up before our very eyes!  As others noted in another thread, Mitch McGary was the last Michigan player to flip the switch in the Tournament like this.  It doesn't happen often. 

zapata

March 21st, 2022 at 12:57 PM ^

You're right about that own goal. And it reveals a dramatic ignorance of the many, many sports-loving liberals, some of them iconic. I seem to remember Nelson Mandela recognizing the fascination offered by rugby and soccer. Just in my own circle, I had a professor in grad school who had to go into exile from Argentina during their military dictatorship because of his liberal ideology. He was a feminist before men called themselves such things, and he LOVED watching his fútbol. A bunch of other professors in that department would get together to watch college football and smoke cigars on fall weekends, liberals all. And then there's my family... One could go on and on.

It's just a stupid, easy way to consider oneself superior.

TrueBlue2003

March 21st, 2022 at 2:29 PM ^

Yeah, I live in Los Angeles which is far more liberal and aside from the working class or the occasional celebs that want to be seen at games for status, people care FAR LESS about sports than in Ann Arbor.

I would love to have the level of community interest in sports around me that Ann Arbor has.

TrueBlue2003

March 21st, 2022 at 5:53 PM ^

LA county is vast and has the population of the entire state of Michigan so it's not very homogenous (not saying Ann Arbor is per se), but where I live in LA is insanely liberal. 90% went for Biden in my zip code which is admittedly comparable to the blue-est parts of Ann Arbor.  I don't know that that's the right measurement since he's a moderate, the choice was binary, and those are both crazy high rates. 

But there's no question California liberalism is more liberal than Michigan liberalism which tends to be more moderate. I've lived in both states for two decades.  The whole spectrum is shifted left here.  That's why conservatives look like Arnold Schwarzenegger who are pretty liberal on a lot of social and environmental issues and the liberals are pretty far left.  I could wrong and Ann Arbor may also be that liberal, it just wasn't my experience when I lived there (obviously still very liberal).  Not sure where to find data on just how liberal a place is.

And in the context of the Sportsball Continuum, Californians are pretty much all on it, conservative or liberal.  Interest is very low here compared to Ann Arbor or the state of Michigan.

In the weeks leading up to the Super Bowl you wouldn't have even known the Rams were in it, at home no less.   No Rams gear, no flags on cars, etc (again, in Venice beach and surrounding areas).

As others have commented, and what I love about Ann Arbor (and Michigan grads) there's an appreciation for top level academia but we're not too serious as to also crap on sports.

snarling wolverine

March 21st, 2022 at 6:08 PM ^

You're moving the goal posts a lot here.  First it was LA vs Ann Arbor, then California vs Michigan, then just your zip code...

I think you have it backwards.  Angelenos are socially left but not necessarily so economically.  Ann Arborites are traditionally left in both measures (although gentrification may be gradually changing the latter).

I don't think this has much to do with sports fandom.  LA residents have a million entertainment options besides sports.  Also, the Rams are a weird curiosity over there, having been gone for so long.  The Raiders are the team with the hardcore fans.

TrueBlue2003

March 21st, 2022 at 6:29 PM ^

The initial point was where I live in Los Angeles is more liberal.  I can't live in or interact with a 10 million person city / county. We're talking about our experiences here.  So that's what I meant.

And yes, I admit (sound the alarm bells - someone on the internet is admitting to being wrong) that to say it's far more liberal than Ann Arbor was hyperbole.  It may only be marginal.

But I definitely don't have it backwards. You're very wrong about your assertion that Angelenos are not necessarily economically left.

Angelenos tolerance for high taxes in exchange for exorbitant social spending and anything else that could be considered economically liberal is pretty much unlimited. The vast majority of people here are either so rich and bleeding heart they don't mind higher taxes or they are benefitting from the services.  So any time there's a ballot measure for another tax to pay for more stuff, it passes.

My experience in Ann Arbor was that voters have a bit more fiscal restraint than voters in LA, in general (and I'm pretty sure city taxes are lower to reflect this).

Also, yes, it has to do with sports fandom.  Same thing when the Dodgers were in the World Series. Does that work for you?  Would not have even known they were in it in the majority of the city.  I used the Rams example because it was more recent.

AC1997

March 21st, 2022 at 12:45 PM ^

Good post Brian - almost sad it wasn't even longer and didn't touch on more off-the-court stuff like Sparty tears, Juwan's image reclamation project in the handshake line, Webber talking to the team (and hopefully teaching Diabate how to finish or even catch a ball), etc.

On Frankie, he's still got massive limitations and I'm glad UT didn't realize that fouling him late in the game might have been smart if they wanted to win.  But at least now we can look forward to next year without abject terror associated with our guards.  Now we can just be excessively frightened.  I think Frankie has shown enough in these two games to start trying to project him on a Simpson/Hoggard development track instead of Tum Tum Narin development track. Still a long way to go, but his defense, turnover avoidance, ability to push pace, and even glimpses of a ball-screen vision are at least something to cling to.

I agree that TWill should probably be in line for more minutes - not just at Houstan's expense but also Diabate's.  I will give Houstan credit that his defense has come a long way and TWill has his own challenges on that end of the court, but there's no reason cold Houstan needs to play 30+ minutes these days.  Meanwhile, my "Diabate sucks at jumping without a running start" narrative was boosted against UT.  He was okay otherwise, but those bunnies he missed despite being this supposed NBA athlete almost decided the game.  I really would like to see Webber take him to school in the offseason and explain how to use his physical gifts.  Villanova is a small team, so if Diabate is struggling on D or failing to convert around the rim, give some of his minutes to TWill.

Brandon Johns probably doesn't need to see the floor except in case of emergencies anymore.  Sad end to a frustrating career, but he's adding no value and does more harm than good at this point. Maybe against a smaller Nova he can help, but I'm nervous to try.  When I watch Purdue's Gillis play PF for them I picture what I hoped Johns would be.

AC1997

March 21st, 2022 at 3:52 PM ^

Me either - but I think I decided he's a better player if his only role on offense is to shoot corner threes and search for OREB.  Any Johns post up is a disaster.  I would love to see his career ORTG on post-ups....it has to be a negative number.  In some ways I think he's the rare big guy who would have been better off with Beilein than Howard as a coach.  His skills and mentality aren't suited for it.  I think Johns is the type of player that needs to do as little thinking as possible and just react - catch and shoot, attack the glass.  Any play that requires him to make a decision ends up a mess.  Beilein would have tried to turn him into Livers or DJ Wilson.  Juwan tried to turn him into Diabate.  

 

Such a weird career arc for him.  I like the kid and he's been a good program guy for four years, but just didn't work out.  

ak47

March 21st, 2022 at 12:50 PM ^

Houstan isn't going to be a 4 next year and Williams can't consistently guard threes on the defensive end. Diabate is a 4 in the NBA, if he comes back next year its to try to develop a jump shot that turns him into a lottery pick so he can play the 4 in the NBA.

NFG

March 21st, 2022 at 12:52 PM ^

GoT after the book content ran out was permissible till the end of Season 6. Season 7 was a disaster but we all were accepting it as a pass thinking Season 8 would lead us to the best conclusion in modern history of entertainment. Season 8 made us all question the very existence of film and entertainment. 

Yinka Double Dare

March 21st, 2022 at 5:24 PM ^

The guys running the series got tired of doing the series and wanted to move on to do other things, so they shortened both of the last two seasons and had to cram everything left into their artificially limited set of episodes. Which is how season 6, where most of it was past the books (although I'm pretty sure they'd had plenty of discussions with Martin on where things were going on the storylines), was still pretty good and included IMO the best episode of the series (the S6 finale), while 7 and 8 pissed everyone off. It felt rushed and things that happened unearned because it was rushed!