MGoBBQ: Grilled Venison w/ Horseradish Cream Comment Count

GoBlueBBQ

Sent Mail-12955

-----------------------

[What this is: We yoinked Joe Pichey from MMMGoBluBBQ to share his tailgating recipes and Stubb's offered to sponsor it because their CEO is a big fan of this site, and certain tasty animals were absolutely harmed in the process of making this blog entry. Happy hunting season.]

-----------------------

IMG_6953

I'll be the first to admit that I am no hunter. While I would spend every waking minute on the water in search of that 10-pound walleye or 40-inch northern, I leave hunting to my old college roomies. They shoot it, and I cook it is our agreement. After a few failed attempts with venison in recent years (and I do mean FAILED with a capital F), I decided to take a cooking class put on by the parks and wildlife association. Money well spent!!! I can now hold my head high and say that venison backstrap no longer intimidate me. Thanks to my buddy Doug for providing the venison.

Ingredients:

    Venison backstrap (Trimmed of silver skin)
    Kosher Salt and freshly ground pepper or Stubbs Steak Rub
    3 TBS chopped herbs. (Rosermary, Thyme & Oregano combo)
    3 TBS Olive Oil


Horseradish Cream Sauce (prepare day prior for best flavor)

    1/2 cup Creme Fraiche (or Mexican Crema)
    2 TBS Freshly grated or Prepared Horseradish
    2 TBS Freshly chopped Chives
    Juice and zest of 1 lemon

[After the jump: you're gonna need some time]

Instructions:

Mix your chopped herbs and olive oil and rub on your venison straps. Refrigerate for a minimum of 4 hours or overnight if time allows. This is also a good time to mix your horseradish sauce ingredients and chill. The cream sauce flavors need some time to blend. When it's time to grill, set up for direct heat. We want a high heat on these to create some nice grill marks. I also added some wood chunks to the coals to add some smokey flavor.

IMG_6934

I let these sit out for about 40 minutes to get near room temp. I am not sure if this is necessary, but I did it anyways. This is also what I do when cooking a nice steak, so I figured it couldn't hurt. Just before throwing on the grill, I sprinkled with some salt and pepper. These are going to cook quick, so don't go far. Make sure you have a cold one handy along with a good cigar.

IMG_6941

I was looking for a good medium rare, so went to 130 degrees internally. This only took about 4 - 5 minutes per side with the high heat. The back strap and tenderloins are very lean will dry out very quickly if they are overcooked, so keep an eye on them. Just like a good steak, there are only 3 ways to cook these. Rare...Medium Rare...Ruined. Once they reach the 125 - 130 degree range, remove from the heat, tent with foil and let rest for 5 - 10 minutes. This is a very important step. This lets the juices redistribute and keeps things tender. If you cut into things now, you will have an entire cutting board covered with tasty back strap juices.

IMG_6952

Now it's time to slice. Make sure you go against the grain to keep the tenderness. Cut into 1/2 inch medallions and enjoy as is or cover with some of the horsey cream sauce. It's fantastic either way.

IMG_6957
These didn't last long. They were super tender and had a great flavor. I will definitely be doing these again if my old roomies decide the can spare more meat. I'm very interested to hear how you cook your venison and would love some new ideas. Send them to me at [email protected]. GO BLUE!

Comments

IncrediblySTIFF

November 20th, 2014 at 12:17 PM ^

I'm more of the 40" northern and 8lb Walleye hunter.  Michigan small mouth fishing can be fun (if you can find lakes that aren't overrun by speedboats and party barges) but nothing compares to the thirll of landing a northern the size of your leg.

Although, finding a school of smallies on a rice island and watching them come from the deep to hit a top water frog is a pretty spectacular thing, too.

Happy Gilmore

November 20th, 2014 at 9:37 AM ^

I grew up hunting just west off 33 between rose city and mio, never was too good after they wiped the herd down when TB was spreading but I harvested my first buck there when I was 14 -- a four and a half year old 6 point with no brow tines lol, great genetics and nutrition in those parts /s


Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

jmdblue

November 20th, 2014 at 10:07 AM ^

but I helped my bro in law drag a 9 pt out of the woods.  We often do backstraps in the manner described above and it's delicious.  We may well try this horsey sauce.  Looks awesome.

Also a quick note:  to those who cook but haven't done venison.... the pics look just like a beef tenderloin so the scale might seem a little out of whack.  The meat pictured is likely only about 3 inches in diameter, hence the short cooking time.

UMQuadz05

November 20th, 2014 at 10:08 AM ^

This is nothing earth-shattering, but I've also found that not throwing your meat on the grill when it's 4 degrees right-outta-the-fridge makes a HUGE difference. 

And hot damn, I want to buy a rifle and start driving west to get me some venison now. 

GoBlueGladstone

November 20th, 2014 at 10:57 AM ^

Few minutes from guns up in the dark. Would love to see a duck recipe if you haven't already! Question, cheesey toasts as an accoutrement? Thanks for this! I am always looking for new venison recipes, there's a lot of hit and misses.

Stephen Y

November 20th, 2014 at 12:16 PM ^

Has anyone tried Chicago style horseradish mashed potatoes? I had them at Morton's a couple weeks back. Absolutely terrible. They smelled and tasted like cigars. I never want to have horseradish again.

AZ-Blue

November 20th, 2014 at 1:40 PM ^

That's a great way to break them in - lots of other flavors in there.  That's also the purpose of the creme sauce in the post IMO.  About the only Venison I enjoy plain is the jerky a friend makes.  I rub with sea salt, pepper, garlic and then wrap with thick mollasses bacon and all the fat bubbles in with the meat on the grill.  I just haven't found a way to get the bacon to stick like it does on a filet.

maizenbluenation

November 20th, 2014 at 4:18 PM ^

Just put the raw peppers in there. If you wanted them to be super soft you could do that ahead of time but I prefer them to have a little structure left to them. I prefer poblano peppers but you could substitute green peppers for no spice or jalepenos for a little extra bite.

Julius 1977

November 20th, 2014 at 6:52 PM ^

with one of the other recipes that I think I'm going to try this.  I'm particularly intrigued by the sauce.  There is just the slightest chance I might substitute beef tenderloin for the venison.