?Vaccine or Negative Test Required to Attend UM Games Starting 1/1/22

Submitted by Kilgore Trout on December 29th, 2021 at 12:34 PM

Looks like you will be required to prove vaccination or a negative test within 72 hours to attend games starting next week. Not much in the way of details on how it is going to be enforced. I don't think I really have an opinion on this one way or the other, but god speed to the ushers and ticket takers who will be tasked with verifying this for 12k people on 1/8 for the MSU game. 

BlueGoM

December 29th, 2021 at 12:59 PM ^

I find it curious they didn't require this during the football season.

The university wouldn't hold in-person career fairs during that time but 110k people crammed in like sardines was somehow OK.

CDC caving to airlines and reducing to 5 day period is equally eyebrow raising.

 

blueheron

December 29th, 2021 at 1:48 PM ^

Fluid dynamics is a tough field for most people. A nickel for every person I've seen who's perfectly OK seven feet from someone with a coughing fit in a restaurant ("It's cool ... we're socially distanced.") but nervous when three feet from someone outside on a windy day. This unfortunately includes upper management at my employer.

MRunner73

December 29th, 2021 at 2:04 PM ^

I don't know about any mask requirements in the suites. 

If you have some stats whereas there was a spike in COVID cases after a Michigan football home game, I'd like to know. That in itself is impossible to trace but it is safe to assume there may have been a few cases but not an outbreak.

Any blame should be put on the university and athletic department for allowing capacity crowds this past fall. Just say'in.

JamieH

December 29th, 2021 at 2:04 PM ^

Being packed in shoulder to shoulder certainly doesn't help, but outdoor transmission of the virus does not happen very often.  The dilution of the air means that it isn't likely you will breathe in enough of the virus to get it.  Obviously if the person directly behind you is spitting all over you, then your chances go up.  

It may be worse now with Omicron since it is more contagious.  I'd still take being outdoors over any other scenario.  

JamieH

December 29th, 2021 at 2:08 PM ^

Indy is "indoor" but it is huge.  If they have decent air filtration/air circulation it should be mostly ok.

It's all about amount of virus x time breathing it in.   So if they circulate the air well and have filtration on it, it should be fine.  That's why (up till Omicron) very few people were getting sick on airplanes---they filter the air very rapidly.   The amount of dilution provided by the huge stadium should be similar to being outside IF the air isn't too stagnant.  

 

blue in dc

December 29th, 2021 at 1:26 PM ^

Caving to airlines is not requiring vaccines to fly.    Changing the quarantine period from 10 to 5 days is just recognizing that particularly if you are vaccinated, you are not likely to be spreading the various further into your course of covid.

RickSnow

December 29th, 2021 at 1:03 PM ^

Good. Other venues (e.g., the Chase Center in SF) have been doing this for months with bigger crowds, so it’s totally doable. I’ll take the negs from the sad MAGAs. 

sdogg1m

December 29th, 2021 at 1:11 PM ^

Fully vaccinated here and I dont give two craps about sitting next to someone who is unvaccinated and if I did I wouldn't be at the game.

Omicron has brought us to the point of realizing that discrimating and creating two classes of citizens (the vaccinated amd unvaccinated) is fruitless.

blue in dc

December 29th, 2021 at 1:23 PM ^

Unvaccinated are more likely to get Covid and if they pass it along to spread covid.   They are also significantly more likely to need hospitalization,  Until we get to the point that we don’t have to worry about overcrowded hospitals unvaccinated people pose a significantly greater health risk to society than vaccinated.

If people want to actively contribute to the potential to overwhelm our medical system it doesn’t seem unreasonable to make them have to take a painless test.   If it makes them realize it would just be easier to get vaccinated, so much the better.

sdogg1m

December 29th, 2021 at 1:34 PM ^

The problem with "more likely" is that no concrete assurance is given. You are not anyway near bullet proof if you are vaccinated, you are just "safer." Safer most likely means you will avoid the hospital but it could also mean your Colin Powell. Currently, its fair to conclude you will eventually get sick and you can spread the virus. If this were not the case then a push to get a booster shot would not exist.

You can still get the virus and you can still spread it and that is why policies like the one presented will end in failure. Honestly the University would be better suited to empty the arena for the games again.

blue in dc

December 29th, 2021 at 3:50 PM ^

Generally public health policy focuses on society as a whole rather than individual outcomes.   While we would like to eliminate all death, we are balancing other societal needs.   We aren’t going to eliminate covid deaths or hospitalizations.   The goal is to limit them to the point they don’t overwhelm our hospitals.

Very few public policies fully eliminate the problem they are aimed at, but good ones reduce it without introducing other more significant costs.    This is a policy designed to reduce, not eliminate the spread of covid.

MGoStrength

December 29th, 2021 at 10:36 PM ^

Unvaccinated are more likely to get Covid and if they pass it along to spread covid.

I'm not sure we have the data with omicron to say what percentage unvaccinated people are more likely to test positive than vaccinated folks.  It certainly seems quite a bit less than previous strains.

They are also significantly more likely to need hospitalization

Some people being more likely to be hospitalized based on their choices is nothing new.  Obese people are a lot more likely to get hospitalized too.  In fact, I bet one could create a compelling argument that physical fitness is more protective than vaccines at preventing hospitalization from Covid, but we aren't requiring anyone to be fit.  We let people do unhealthy things all the time that strain the medical system.

Until we get to the point that we don’t have to worry about overcrowded hospitals unvaccinated people pose a significantly greater health risk to society than vaccinated.

One, the goal posts are always moving as to when it's over.  When do we accept this is where we are and get rid of all the restrictions and let people live again?  At one point the promise was when there was a vaccine.  That didn't happen.  You're saying when hospitals are not overcrowded.  What exactly does that mean?  How do when know when we've reached it?  If the hospitals are fine in my state, county, city, etc can we stop worrying about who's vaccinated?  Or does everyone nationwide need to get there?  Two, I think that's a misrepresentation of the data.  Healthy people under the age of 60ish don't pose a high risk of hospitalization with or without vaccination.  This is a serious disease of the sick and the elderly.  For the vast majority of everyone else it is a mild sickness.  The harder, more ethical question has always been do people at low risk have an obligation to get vaccination based on the assumed benefit to those at higher risk.  There are no easy answers to that one.

blue in dc

December 30th, 2021 at 9:48 AM ^

Unfortunately omicron seems worse for kids:

“CNN)A five-fold increase in pediatric admissions in New York City this month. Close to double the numbers admitted in Washington, DC. And nationwide, on average, pediatric hospitalizations are up 48% in just the past week.

The highly transmissible Omicron variant is teaming up with the busy holiday season to infect more children across the United States than ever before, and children's hospitals are bracing for it to get even worse.

"I think we are going to see more numbers now than we have ever seen," Dr. Stanley Spinner, who is chief medical officer and vice president at Texas Children's Pediatrics & Urgent Care in Houston, told CNN.

"Cases are continuing to rise between Christmas gatherings and we're going to continue to see more numbers this week from that," Spinner said in a telephone interview.

US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention data released Tuesday showed that on average, 305 children have been in the hospital with Covid-19 on any given day over the week that ended Dec. 26. 

This is a more than 48% increase from the previous week, and just 10.7% lower than the peak average of 342 children in the hospital that was seen at the end of August and early September.”

With regards to “healthy” people getting vaccinated, it is definitely much more of a value judgment, but from everything I have seen, I think that you are undertating covid risks even for healthy and overstating vaccine risks.  

Macenblu

December 29th, 2021 at 1:33 PM ^

Tell that to all of the people in Ohio who have had their surgeries postponed because there isn't room in hospitals due to hyper-admissions from unvaccinated people.  Look, in many walks of life people can absolutely choose to do what they want to do but the numbers are simply too damning with this issue.  The overwhelming majority of people who are in the hospital requiring a significant amount of medical care are unvaccinated and/or non-boosted people.  Therefore, if you're going to put yourself in a position to have a greater chance of being infected as a non-vaccinated person then you are not only potentially harming yourself (again, that's your call) but also someone else.

https://spectrumnews1.com/oh/columbus/news/2021/12/03/ohio-hospital-sys…

https://spectrumnews1.com/oh/columbus/news/2021/12/03/ohio-hospital-systems-postpone-elective-surgeries-amid-covid

sdogg1m

December 29th, 2021 at 1:52 PM ^

I am sure they are aware that current policies have created the unecessary layoffs and retirement of medical professionals at a time when demand for services are at an all time high; not very wise. 

We were heading that way regardless due to the aging boomer population but covid gave it that extra push. 

CRISPed in the DIAG

December 29th, 2021 at 1:42 PM ^

You were required to upload a picture of your vacc card to a phone app and answer questions (whether you recently had covid or symptoms, etc). Once the vacc card was loaded, I received a text from Duke athletics department which navigated me to screen that I presented at the security line. I think it was a QR code, but I don't remember. I attached what is left of the text msg link:

el segundo

December 29th, 2021 at 1:55 PM ^

As you may have noticed, these days, "LGB" has multiple meanings, some of which inspire or are associated with, how to put it . . . strong feelings. Some of those feelings are even stronger (and sometimes more controversial) than support for the University of Michigan. I tried a certain kind of joke, which, I now realize, is not well suited for this kind of format.

Darker Blue

December 29th, 2021 at 1:31 PM ^

I don't understand why people have to jump in and argue on threads such as this.

If you want the vaccine by all means please go get it.

If you don't want it then don't get it.

Just please shut up about it.