OT- Which Ann Arbor High School is Best?

Submitted by SBo on

Me and my family are moving to Ann Arbor next month. I am entering my junior year of high school. Have at it

DairyQueen

July 8th, 2017 at 4:09 PM ^

High-School is garbage all around. Just get through it. And don't look back.

Don't "peak" in college either. Get as many non-classroom experiences as possible (internships, semester abroad/experiential, clubs, arts, INTERNSHIPS, etc.--see/do AS MUCH as possible, for a more informed decision/diversity of people/attitudes/lifestyles--read: the working world is HUGE, and varies wherever you go, "college" is a terrible representation of that, and it will only become more and more varied every year).

Forget prestige. Go for the experiences and who offers what.

Previous experience is what will get you the job, or at least the interview.

That being said, you can't lose at any of the Ann Arbor schools. At Community, you'll essentially be "dual-enrolled" for any sports/music/AP classes.

But like I said, all Ann Arbor schools are adequate, where you go on from there, depends solely on you.

 

DairyQueen

July 8th, 2017 at 10:39 PM ^

Haha, I guess I have a few battle-scars from this.

I used to tutor Ann Arbor high school students for quite a few years on the side, both on college applications/essays and for ACT/SAT test prep.

I ran into a TON of kids who were either pushed too much by their parents, their teachers, or themselves about "getting into" UM or _________-ivy league school, or their "dream school".

Half of those kids needed ZERO tutoring, they were already top of their class, 4.0, community service, year-round varsity athlete, music-dance-and-poetry-performing, small start-up founder, etc. etc. it was insane the lengths students are going to "look good" for the admissions department and beat out competing applicants. There was literally no "tutoring" to do most of the time. My main job was just doing damage control, showing them that they just needed to learn how to breath again, calm down, enjoy being 16 years old, and look forward to college as a fun experience no matter where you go!

I mean, by the time you're posting on a hyper-niche college sports internet forum hoping to ask ann arbor locals/high school alums about which high school is "best", you're in the 1% of 1% of 1%. So, I am making a presumption here in regards to the OP, but, it's not founded on nothing.

There are just some high school go-getters (and full-on adults) that you can just NEVER "convert", or change their mindset no matter what facts or viewpoints you present. So, seeing this poster is at minimum at leasy somewhat of a go-getter, I'm more just trying to give them straight up information.

And, forcefully drive home that you can accomplish anything at any college you end up attending, if you actually want to (and the data backs that up--but again, presenting people with reliable data and thinking that that will change their mind, is actually largely a myth).

I could ramble forever--I already have!--so I'll apologize and stop here.

 

Michifornia

July 8th, 2017 at 4:56 PM ^

Not sure what's happened since I was there.  I was there in 80s.  Bo's son Schemy was a couple years younger than me and picked up my tee after kickoffs at football games.  I aslo played soccer and we had a pretty competitive team, great rivals with Pioneer.  Our tennis teams were always good back in the day.  Football sucked when I was there but was good a few years later.  A lot of my friends went to Michigan and a lot also went Ivy League.  One of my buddies is now the Michigan Crew coach.  Another buddy is Abby Cole's dad.  Another went on to coach the US Olympic wresting team.  Another was world champion boxer.  All the schools are decent.  Loved going to school in Ann Arbor (K thru College)  Go Huron!

Joshuy

July 8th, 2017 at 5:02 PM ^

Went to Huron back in the early 90's.  Great school.  Lots of opportunity.  Got into every school I applied.  Ann Arbor Public Schools is a great system period (regardless of high school).  I took classes at the University of Michigan as a Jr and Sr in high school.  Wonderful experience.   The key is the peers you have in high school.  Find the right group.  You won't go wrong with either school.  But Huron is better!!!

bnoble

July 8th, 2017 at 10:51 PM ^

Any of the three (Pioneer, Huron, Skyline) will provide great educations for most kids. Each has particular strengths and weaknesses. My kids happen to go to Skyline, and both had great experiences there, but we probably would have been happy with any one of them. There are few enough houses in the district that I would not limit by high school. Just find a place in town you like. Saline vs. Ann Arbor: Saline has a much narrower socioeconomic band, and is correspondingly less diverse. That's not the place for us, but it might be for you. It depends on what is important to you. Finally, if you're really that concerned, send your kids to Greenhills. I'm an engineering faculty member and a number of my colleagues' kids go there. My wife and I are fans of public education so we never really considered it.

chuck bass

July 9th, 2017 at 12:47 PM ^

Yes, Greenhils (private) and Father Gabriel Richard (private Catholic) are excellent options. From what I recall, Greenhills average ACT score is 28-29, FGR's is 26-27, AAPS overall is 24-25.

FGR is $9k before aid. Greenhills is $22k before aid. Gov. Snyder sent his kids to Greenhills.

Ann Arbor area in general has a top notch cluster of high school options: AAPS, Saline, Dexter, Chelsea, South Lyon and a few privates.

Zoltanrules

July 9th, 2017 at 12:12 AM ^

Great place to raise kids. Like all the other schools mentioned IB and AP kids get into UM ( and elite private schools). Downtown is quaint fun with DQ, Cider Mill, A&W, and a real hardware store.

Solecismic

July 9th, 2017 at 3:08 AM ^

My kid had a winning number (I hope it's a winning number) in the Community lottery and will start there in the fall. I've read a lot about it, talked to a couple of teachers at different schools. It's hard to say, though, what's best. Transportation will make it difficult if he wants AP classes down the road, but I'm intrigued by their integrated (whatever subject seems relevant to the topic at hand) approach to science rather than the traditional approach. I worry that they have about 30 English electives but only a handful across all of the sciences. I probably would have kept him in the area he lives (Pioneer) if it were my choice alone. But he should keep an open mind and he may end up loving Community. It's not the same place that had the more negative reputation decades ago. In the end, though, I think it's more up to us parents and the kids themselves what they get out of school. AAPS certainly has talented teachers. We have to support that by teaching our kids that they need to prepare for class and embrace learning - wherever it takes them. Saline is excellent, too. As are Dexter and Brighton. Probably South Lyon as well. They may not "look" as diverse, but true diversity is about thought and experience and a hundred less obvious things.

Karumba

July 9th, 2017 at 10:02 PM ^

#1 Greenhills (private) -- private prep school, about 75-80 kids per grade

#2 WiHi (IB in Ypsi) - academics only - school of choice - best of the public schools

#3 Community (lottery only) - unlikely you will get in

#4 Washtenaw Technical Middle College - at WCCC - school of choice - earn college credit

#4 Gabriel Richard (catholic)

#4 Early College Alliance (at EMU) - school of choice - take classes at EMU after 1 semester

All of the big 3 HS are worse than in previous years because of larger class sizes.

#7 Huron - Most Asian kids, highest academics of big 3

#8 Skyline - Has some magnet programs, lame principal

#9 Pioneer - Best music and theatre program

#10 Rudolph Steiner HS - Only if you are already in RS schools

#11 Michigan Islamic academy

#12 Stone school/Pathways

I would not confuse SAT/ACT averages with the quality of education at any of the schools because the demographics and SES at each school is different. If you are a very high acheiver, have the money, and don't want to deal with PS issues, go to GH or GR. If you just want good academics and want to attend a free school, WiHi is your best option, followed by WTMC or ECA. Otherwise the Big 3 will be fine, but if you are a quiet kid you will probably be lost in the system, and you have to spend a lot of time advocating for yourself.

Sports are extremely competitive at the Big 3, much less so at others.

 

 

 

 

PeteM

July 10th, 2017 at 3:43 PM ^

You've got more than enough advice already but I'll jump in all the same.  I went to Huron a long time ago, and thought it was a great experience.  One of the math teachers was named best in the country.

That said, I think that your kid's high school experience will be based more on the teachers they draw, the friends they make and the activities they get involved in than the name on the building.  I have no doubt that each of the schools has some great teachers/counselors, and some that aren't so great.  There is a difference between the big school, Huron/Pioneer/Skyline experience versus the smaller Community High experience (and I imagine v. Greenhills or Gabriel Richard experience).  I liked going to a big school with lots of classes, activities, people and generally a lot of options, but I can understand why some kids and parents would prefer someplace where it's harder to get lost.

Basically, my advice is don't sweat the school choice, but wherever you choose encourage your kid to explore the different things the schools have to offer in whatever areas interest them -- music, sports, other excurriculars etc. -- as I think those experiences can make a big, overwhelming school a lot smaller.