OT: Thoughtful Denhollander interview on Nassar tragedy

Submitted by StephenRKass on

I am putting in a link to a long interview article with Rachael Denhollander, the first woman to go public with charges about Dr. Larry Nassar. I labeled this "OT" because the article comes from Christianity Today, and digs much deeper into Denhollander's perspective as an articulate Christian. Please truly view this as OT, and read something else. Unless you are really interested in the whole topic, as I am.

LINK:  My Larry Nassar testimony went viral. But there's more to the Gospel than Forgiveness.

This is an excellent article looking at the relationship of justice to forgiveness. It is written from a Christian perspective, and highlights the failure of many churches to do well with such charges when they happen in their own church. Many of you know I am a Christian. I appreciate the bright light Denhollander applies to the church. It is needed. For those readers who believe differently, truly feel free to neg away and mock and ridicule. The reality is this mockery is often deserved, including towards me.

However, there is also relevance to how the Univ. of Michigan deals with things. It is always easier to be outraged when things are happening elsewhere, and not to your own organization.

That leaves me with the question: What happens when it’s a trusted person [in their own organization?] What happens when it’s a trusted person in [related organizations?] The extent that one is willing to speak out against their own community is the bright line test for how much they care and how much they understand.

This is why Brian's front page posts/articles about Michigan are so critical. We can and should criticize PSU and MSU. But we also have to shine as bright a light as possible internally at Michigan. I hope that this tragedy helps administrators at Michigan shine that light brightly in our own community.

I hope this tragedy continues to be taken very seriously. Denhollander writes

The damage never has to be anywhere near as extensive as it gets. Never. The research has shown that the average pedophile is reported approximately seven times before he’s finally caught. The average number of victims a pedophile has is about 250. We don’t need to get there. We never needed to get there.

I especially appreciated the nuance Denhollander brings to discussions of punishment, accountability, justice, and forgiveness. Too often, forgiveness is cheap. She adds,

Repentance is a full and complete acknowledgment of the depravity of what someone has done in comparison with God’s holy standard. And I do believe that entails an acknowledgment of that, and a going in the opposite direction. It means you have repented to those you have harmed and seek to restore those you have hurt.

One last thing. Yes, there needs to be justice, and punishment. But there also needs to be wisdom, and compassion. This morning, I heard from my daughter. She was sexually harassed by the Command Master Chief on her ship in the Navy. (thankfully never raped or abused.) The CMC was court martialed, and was separated from the Navy in the Fall. Yesterday evening, his wife came home to find he had hung himself. That is also a tragedy, which I wish never would have happened. So sad.

I believe Nassar's punishment is just. But I still don't want to see him tortured, or abused, or brought to suicide. Better for him to spend the rest of his days reflecting on his choices. And hopefully, truly repenting.

kehnonymous

February 1st, 2018 at 3:11 PM ^

For those readers who believe differently, truly feel free to neg away and mock and ridicule

Readers who believe differently - don't do that.  It just makes you look like a small-minded ass.  And I say that as someone who's agnostic.

StephenRKass

February 1st, 2018 at 3:23 PM ^

Thank you for your kind words. I do believe the concepts of justice and forgiveness and repentance are relevant and needed, regardless of one's beliefs or lack thereof in a God or gods or mother nature or something else.

If you read the article, the church is certainly richly deserving of ridicule and mockery and anger and opprobrium. My heart grieves for the many people who hate religion and hate God or hate the idea of God because of deep wounds they have suffered within the church. Such things should not be. I'm merely acknowledging that this criticism (of the church) is often deserved. It absolutely infuriates me that sexual abuse happens in the church, and that it is covered up. This is wrong, and just makes me mad. The church should not be a "good old boys" club that just protects its own. Ok, I'll get down from my soapbox.

kehnonymous

February 1st, 2018 at 3:37 PM ^

There’s a great quote by Gandhi(?) that's always resonated with me about how God makes religion easy while man makes it hard.  As much as somone who didn't grow up with religion can, I think I get that.  There's a lot to say about the intersection of organized religion and civic society that's um... beyond the scope of an MGoPost.  The church, like many other instutions, is comprised of fallible individuals.  It has its share of institutional failures just like almost literally anything else and those can be in part sourced to the lesser aspects of human nature.  But just as scriptures were misapplied in many cases to shame victims of sexual assault, they were clearly also a source of strength and moral certainty for people like Denhollander and her sister survivors so while you can criticize many aspects of the church you also have have to respect how that same faith helped her navigate her horrific experience.

Njia

February 1st, 2018 at 3:56 PM ^

Gandhi was very careful to separate faith from religion. In essence, he said that "faith" was God's creation; whereas man, being imperfect, created religion.

 

All faiths are a gift of God, but partake of human imperfection, as they pass through the medium of humanity. God-given religion is beyond all speech. Imperfect men put it into such language as they can command, and their words are interpreted by other men equally imperfect.

andrewG

February 1st, 2018 at 3:24 PM ^

sorry for the small squabbles but...
"The average number of victims a pedophile has is about 250."

I just have a really hard time believing that's anywhere remotely true. Which then make me question the validity of anything else being said.

andrewG

February 1st, 2018 at 3:32 PM ^

Right, I saw the link. But that link doesn't provide any source for their list of "facts", which quickly and clearly delve into opinions labeled as facts. I don't necessarily disagree with the opinions, but if that's fact, it need to be supported.

The very next page from the website provides sourced statistics (http://riseaboveabuse.org/child-sex-abuse-statistics/), which doesn't include that outrageous number.

Everyone Murders

February 1st, 2018 at 6:37 PM ^

I suppose if you count pedophiles' instances of viewing child pornography as sexual assault (which some do), you could get to 250 pretty quickly.

If the numbers are based on number of assaults without regard to the number of victims, I can see that number being possible.  Multiple assaults on a victim seem to be more normal for pedophiles than single assaults.

If the numbers are based on the pedophile's personal interactions with distinct individual victims, I think you're right - 250 sounds untenable.  Very untenable.

SC Wolverine

February 1st, 2018 at 3:36 PM ^

As a fellow Christian, I have known of the situation she addresses in this article and have had personal interaction with some of the people alluded to.  One point of connection between MSU and the church situation she mentions (though Denhollander was not assaulted in the church, nor have the pastors against whom she was speaking been accused of sexual assault) is the calloused treatment of victims in order to protect  leaders who failed.  Her conflict with her church was over its support for a famous pastor who had allegedly failed to respond properly to accusations of sexual abuse (sound familiar?).  Christians around the country were enthralled by Rachael Denhollander's message to Larry Nasser in court, both in its truth and its grace.  This article in Christianity Today is a timely reminder that Christians and churches must also attend to our own sins and failures.  

Just like in the sports world, accomplished church leaders are highly valued, bring in a lot of resources, and warrant a certain measure of protection due to the high demands placed on them.  But just like in the sports world, protecting leaders should never be an excuse for irresponsible handling of sex abuse accusations or neglectful treatment of victims.   The "good old boy" network that protects abusers of all kinds reflects a sinful byproduct of the admiration that leaders acquire.  This tendency needs to be systematically excluded, especially in the church, for the protection of innocents and the accountability of all leaders.  

Both in college athletics and in the church, how we define success makes all the difference.  If we care only for wins and losses (of whatever kind), without considering the victories in the growth and care of precious lives, this kind of failure is bound to continue.  As a Michigan man, I am grateful that Jim Harbaugh has so far held a high standard of this integrity both as a Christian and as a coach.  

 

Reader71

February 1st, 2018 at 4:25 PM ^

Does he? I spent some time with him years ago, and he never mentioned religion at all. I found that refreshing at the time, since a lot of other coaches did. My parents had a lot of icons in the house, and everyone seemed to think they were clever when they brought up religion, unprompted.

bringthewood

February 1st, 2018 at 8:18 PM ^

http://www.gospelherald.com/articles/60993/20151229/college-football-pl… Dantonio was raised in a devout Roman Catholic family and lives his life based on those Christian principles. His faith and devotion to Christ are an important part of his coaching philosophy. Dantonio spoke openly about his faith in a 2013 interview with USA Today, saying his Christian walk is reflected in his role as a coach, recruiter, and mentor. "You can talk about your faith, or you can live your faith," he said. "You can talk about this program's culture, or you can be in this culture, live this culture," Dantonio said. "There's a difference there. Is it smoke or is it real?"

MottledMaizeandBlue

February 1st, 2018 at 3:38 PM ^

Thanks for posting SRK, this was lovely to see. I agree wholeheartedly with your last paragraph (and broadly with the rest). In a different context, obviously, Booker T. Washington said that you can’t hold a man down in the ditch without staying down there with him. He also said “I shall allow no man to belittle my soul by making me hate him.”

JamesBondHerpesMeds

February 1st, 2018 at 4:27 PM ^

"It is with deep regret that I say the church is one of the worst places to go for help."

I spent nearly a decade in the evangelical community, and what saddened me was how much I agree with this statement.

mgobleu

February 1st, 2018 at 5:00 PM ^

Tis a very broad brush being wielded, but unfortunately you're right about many many many churches. Don't forget who the church is: a bunch of broken people. I'm sorry that people have hurt you and that this is the experience of so many. Christians can be the absolute worst at walking the walk of which they talk so much. But for me it still doesn't diminish the goodness or divinity of God, and I hope it doesn't for you either. It's like the old saw about marriage that so many of them end in divorce, as if the culprit was the marriage itself and not the people bound by it. I know many Christians who are so legalistic they'd much rather turn someone away from the church than invite that person and their sin inside the doors, but I also know many righteous people who have held the hand of an addict they had just met, through night after night while they detoxed. People who took an aids infected, pregnant rape victim into their home to help raise the child, indefinitely. There are practicers and there are pretenders in churches, just like everywhere else. I hope someday you find a place that accepts you like Jesus would. Of course he cares about our sin, but he's much more concerned about just having a relationship with us first.

stephenrjking

February 1st, 2018 at 4:44 PM ^

Denhollander discusses something important that is true for any large group. It is something I was trying (perhaps unsuccessfully) to get at with posts like this one during the Sandusky scandal, and an idea that informs a lot of my opinion and commentary about these sorts of issues.

The issue is this: It is really easy to demonize and dehumanize people who inadvertendly or otherwise allow the perpetuation of abuse, but much harder to detect our own vulnerability to such grievous errors.

The Culture of Outrage that inevitably arises when something like this happens has its uses, but it also allows people to become so enraged and so tribal toward those on the wrong side that they imagine the guilty parties to be so unconscionably wicked that no person in their right mind could ever do such a thing.

But the reality is a lot messier than that: Often these abuses are perpetuated, not by people who make a conscious decision to allow someone else's evil to continue, but by people who have never truly considered the danger of the decisions they are making. Perhaps they think they have done "enough." Perhaps they can't believe that someone who they respect would do such a thing. Perhaps the whirlwind of law enforcement and legal issues is so daunting that they convince themselves they probably didn't see anything.

And it's much easier to pass the buck. 

When I assumed my current pastoral role I was already aware of abuses in various secular and religious groups, and I am thankful for mentoring that guided me to have a strong position to protect both vulnerable people and our own people from situations that could be abused or construed as abusive. And I mandatorily report; I have had to call authorities about things on occasion, even things that turned out to be nothing.

It's easy to get angry at someone else that we neither know nor could ever know. It's harder to look at our own situations and explore how we could be exposed to a similar situation, and ensure that we do the right thing. 

Hard-Baughlls

February 1st, 2018 at 4:57 PM ^

No way I could ever believe in a specific religion, scripture, etc., but given the knowledge of my own insignificance, I would never knock others beliefs or ridicule their faith, as I recognize there is far too much we don't know or understand about the universe.

That said, while I can't find a "god", there is plenty of evidence for the existance of devils...IE, Nassar himself.

 

Qseverus

February 1st, 2018 at 5:08 PM ^

USA Gymnastics & MSU inaction in this matter reminds me of the Cardinal Law priest pedophile situation in Boston. The very last thing those in charge think about is the well-being of those being abused.

Suggested reading: “Betrayal: The Crisis in the Catholic Church” by the investigative staff of the Boston Globe. An eye-openning account where the children who were abused were often not believed because the abuser was a respected priest. And the families of those who fought back were forced to sign non-disclosure agreements to keep the abuse secret. Help for the children was largely ignored.

Jonesy

February 1st, 2018 at 5:58 PM ^

My takeaway: the church is worse than MSU and still hiding shit.

 

Religion is the worst, half that article was like another nonsensical language.

blue in dc

February 1st, 2018 at 6:37 PM ^

I really appreciate you Brian (and others) who are tryng to nudge people to think at least as much about how we can make sure these things don’t happen in our own organizations as we do about what happened at MSU. If we want to live up to the standards of being “the leaders and best”, that is what we need to do. It would be great if Michigan were considered both a model school at dealing with sexual assualt and also a leader at helping other schools. I’m not sure what the rules, programs, trainings etc are that are needed to reduce this problem, but I wish I felt that U of M were more at the forefront in trying to find them then I sense it is and that it was also leading a charge to help other institutions (possibly starting with the big ten) in instituting those best practices.

xtramelanin

February 1st, 2018 at 7:20 PM ^

that sinful man is reminded that we are 'blind guides who would swallow a camel and strain out a gnat'.  second time today that i have mentioned this under the MSU umbrella.  i appreciate very much your perspective on these topics.  it seems that others have as well. 

StephenRKass

February 1st, 2018 at 8:52 PM ^

I am rereading The Screwtape Letters by C.S. Lewis. In the book, he has to come up with an image that portrays Hell and evil, and I think Lewis hits the nail on the head. He settles on "Bureaucracy" as a modern picture of evil. Lewis wrote,

I live in the Managerial Age, in a world of "Admin." The greatest evil is not now done in those sordid "dens of iniquity" that Dickens loved to paint. It is not done even in concentration camps and labour camps. In those we see its final result. But it is conceived and ordered (moved, seconded, carried, and minuted) in clean, carpeted, warmed and well-lighted offices, by quiet men with white collars and clipped fingernails and smooth-shaven cheeks who do not need to raise their voice. Hence, naturally enough, my symbol for Hell is something like the bureaucracy of a police state or the offices of a thoroughly nasty business concern.

I like this picture of what allowed Nassar to get away with such despicable evil. Nassar was the end result of this. But it was enabled by an army of bureaucrats and functionaries both at MSU and USA Gymnastics.

Texagander

February 1st, 2018 at 10:54 PM ^

Thank you. Such a sorrowing story. But I do greatly appreciate her words on justice and forgiveness and repentance. The pity she has for Nassar too in not experiencing joy was also astounding. What a great way to illustrate what’s missed out when one falls to their own depravity.

Thank you for being brave enough to link this here.