OT: Talkin' 'Murican Cars

Submitted by JeepinBen on

A day late with the holiday, but no matter. It's a simple question for today, the day after the 4th: What's the single greatest American car ever made?

Is it the Model T? which allowed everyday Americans to afford these new horseless carraiges? The Corvette? Mustang? Hellcat and/or Demon? Pickup trucks that can tow 30,000lbs that you can buy at a regular dealership and need a special driver's licesnse to use all that capability? The invention of the Minivan? The invention of the ORV (which became the SUV)? The Tesla Model S? (this is wrong)

What's your favorite red, white, and blue automobile? What's your greatest American Made car story?

socalwolverine1

July 5th, 2017 at 1:20 PM ^

Missing on the Motor Trend list... 

But I agree the Tesla S should be there, as it arguably the most admired American car throughout the world, and has taken a big bite out of the earnings of its European and Asian luxury market competitors.    

MaizeAndBlueWahoo

July 5th, 2017 at 2:59 PM ^

has taken a big bite out of the earnings of its European and Asian luxury market competitors.

Has it? I very much doubt it. Lincoln put more cars on the road last year than Tesla has sold Model S's in its lifetime.  That would be Lincoln, not the really big fish like Lexus, Mercedes, and BMW.  That would also be Lincoln's US sales, not including Canada or China or any other market.

Last year, Tesla sold about 30,000 Model S's in the US and Canada.  Last month, BMW sold about 33,000 cars in the US and Canada.

Truthfully speaking, none of the current luxury automakers' earnings reports really notice the presence of Tesla.  They may start to, if the Model 3 is a success.  But for all the attention, the size of Tesla's niche in the US car market currently lies somewhere between Fiat and Smart.

MaizeAndBlueWahoo

July 6th, 2017 at 8:22 AM ^

I mean, that's true, but the original point is about whether the Model S by itself has dented the profits of big luxury automakers, so really, Model S vs. the entire lineup of BMW (and vs. the entire lineup of Mercedes and Lexus and so on) is the original comparison, not mine.

Yes, the Model S has done pretty well against similarly-priced competitor models; no, it has not taken any kind of a bite out of the profits of those competitors.

oriental andrew

July 5th, 2017 at 1:34 PM ^

Most iconic? Definitely have to think about the Jeep, Corvette, and Mustang

Most commercially impactful? Possibly the Model T (assembly line! First pickup ever!) and the first Chrysler minivan

Most innovative? Tesla has to be right up there

Walter Sobchak

July 5th, 2017 at 5:26 PM ^

One of two makes: Chevrolet Corvette. The American sports car. Chevrolet suburban. The longest running nameplate and American through and through. I've got two of each.

Wendyk5

July 5th, 2017 at 5:38 PM ^

I've only had two American cars: a Camaro z-28 and a Jeep Wrangler. I've had almost every other readily available car nationality: British (Mini), German (VW, Audi). Swedish (Saab), Italian (Alfa Romeo), and Japanese (Acura, Subaru). A day after Independence Day, I can safely say German is my favorite, though I did love my Z-28. 

South TX MFan

July 5th, 2017 at 6:54 PM ^

For me it's the Mustang. An instant hit with buyers and the best selling American "sports car" (even though yes it's technically a "pony car") of all time. From regular coupes up to the iconic Shelby and everything in between. The pinnacle for me is the 1969 Boss 429. A car that had to be shipped from Ford to Kar Kraft to be modified just so the engine could fit. It doesn't get more 'Merica than that. Pristine examples go for as much as $500,000 now. My ultimate American machine.

Vasav

July 5th, 2017 at 7:23 PM ^

I read an excellent book once called "Engines of Change," which talked about 15 cars that shaped American driving. It concluded that the Model T is far and away the most important car in American history, and the real question was what's second. I agree with that - the Model T isn't only the most important car in American history, the only car that compares in automotive history is Karl Benz's first ever practical automobile. Nothing else changed American society as much, and the subsequently caused worldwide changes in infrastructure and transportation.

As for 2nd, I find the Jeep a compelling arguement while also pointing out there were quite a lot of things that helped us win WWII. So I'd like to make the case for the Ferrarri killing Ford GT - the win at Le Mans was the greatest moment in American motorsports history. I don't think that compares to being a major driver in the bloodiest conflict in human history that still shapes the world we live in today and allowed the triumph of democracy across Europe and East Asia...but it's still pretty awesome. Okay Jeep definitely gets #2 in my book.

But until something changes our driving habits as much as the T did by inventing our driving habits, the Model T has got to be king. So...the question will one day be the Model T or the first practical, affordable and widely distributed self-driving car?

MaizeAndBlueWahoo

July 6th, 2017 at 12:48 PM ^

Still Model T.  I predict there won't be a single, seminal game-changer in the world of self-drivers.  For hybrids, you'd definitely have to say the Prius, and basically every automaker in the world, as well as all sorts of companies that don't even make cars, are all too keenly aware of that.  Now there's a huge race on, not so much to be the Model T or Prius of automation, but not to fall behind.

If there's to be any big winner of that race (which may not be the case at all), I think it'll be after some consolidation of technologies, and if any standard appears, it'll be more like a VHF/Betamax, or Blu-Ray/HD-DVD fight, than one company developing the big winner and everyone else going "uhhhh crap, we gotta start doing that."

wolverinebutt

July 5th, 2017 at 7:33 PM ^

I mentioned last week I love the early Chevy II/Nova, but Mustangs are the best overall.

In high school I saw Steve McQueen in the movie Bullitt with the 1968 GT fastback.  It was love at first sight.