Section 1.8

December 30th, 2018 at 2:47 AM ^

The first time I read your comment I passed over it; I thought that it was parody/sarcasm.

But you’re being serious, in your own idiotic way, aren’t you?

Bill Martin did hire St. John of Beilein, in case you had forgotten that.

 

Section 1.8

December 30th, 2018 at 6:47 PM ^

Bill Martin:

1. Hired John Beilein, as I already mentioned.

2. Brought the massive renovation of Michigan Stadium project to completion on time and on budget.

3. Donated more of his own money to that one project, and then others, than your net worth, I am guessing.

4. Oversaw the largest and most ambitious renovation of the general athletic campus than any Michigan AD short of Fielding Yost.

 

JDeanAuthor

December 30th, 2018 at 5:12 PM ^

Well, while I did not defend Rich Rod carte blanche, I did stand up for the guy for a few reasons:

1.) In some ways, he was shot down before he even coached his first game.  A lot of people were mad that he wasn't going to play "manball" and razzed on him prior to September, meaning he was behind the 8 ball in the eyes of many before facts were laid out. (Interesting that Hoke basically copied Rich Rod's zone read scheme in 2011 and actually went 11-2 with it.  Plus Meyer's scheme at OSU was essentially Rich Rod's scheme with a power option added, and Meyer has basically said as much. So those who say the zone read "doesn't work" are full of it up to their eyebrows). 

2.) The unwillingness to make allowance for Jeff Casteel also hurt him.  Now, this doesn't completely let Rich Rod off the hook for the poor defensive performances he had while here.  He kept wanting to run a 3-3-5, but was using 4-3 coaches to run it (Shafer and Greg Robinson).  That's like bringing in a monster truck driver to the Monaco GP, giving him the keys to a formula one, and expecting him to handle it just like the other expert drivers.  The 3-3-5 is not a bad scheme, contrary to what some naysayers believe. But you need somebody with a base expertise in a 3-3-5 to run it.  Neither Shafer nor Robinson knew how, but Casteel did.   But (and this was my biggest gripe against Rich Rod) when a 3-3-5 coach was not available, Rich Rod refused to let his scheme go.  I'm convinced that had he allowed Shafer and Greg Robinson to actually run a true 4-3 base more often, he probably wouldn't have had so many woes on defense, and probably would have won more games.  

3.) The "practicegate" thing was a complete joke, and the player who ratted Rich Rod out should be ashamed of himself for doing so.  Everybody knew full well that Michigan was not the only team actually doing things like that (Jim Tressell admitted as much in an interview), and this was sour grapes on the part of a player.  The NCAA investigation in 2009 actually disrupted a LOT of practice time, and John Bacon noted that the week of practice against Sparty was interrupted so badly that he believes that had a lot more to do with the loss than people may know. 

4.) Dave Brandon did nothing to help Rich Rod in 2010, and also undermined Rich Rod through things said and done with players behind Rich Rod's back.  I don't know how many of you know this, but Brandon basically told the players that Rich Rod was fired just before the Mississippi State bowl game, and that had a lot to do with the lack of effort seen from the second quarter on.  And keep in mind that the wins were going UP with Rich Rod each year (they didn't under Hoke, in case anybody forgot). 

So while I'm glad Rich Rod is no longer our coach in lieu of his perverse conduct at Arizona, and while I fully acknowledge that his bullheadednesss on the defensive front of the ball did much to seal his own fate, the opposition to his being here was not entirely innocent in their approach.  Read John Bacon's book Three and Out, which deals with the matter in a pretty fair manner.

JDeanAuthor

December 30th, 2018 at 5:17 PM ^

Ahhh... while I put Harbaugh above Rich Rod, at least you could say Rich Rod made offense exciting.

And while I love Harbaugh overall, I do get sick of the Lloyd Carr-esque schemes which doesn't know how to play uptempo and move the ball with methods other than the slow and lumbering "manball pro-style".

Remember, Urban Meyer's zone read scheme is essentially the same as Rich Rod's with some minor tweaks.  How many times did we beat Meyer since he's been at C-bus?

I'll wait for the answer...

Chicago Blue Fan

December 30th, 2018 at 12:18 AM ^

I assume if he flops it will be because Freeze didn't give him a big hug when he got to Oxford?

Or will it be because the upperclassmen didn't "buy in"?