JJ McCarthy and Donovan Edwards at the Battle of Isandlwana

Submitted by Desmond Was Tripped on November 27th, 2022 at 9:08 AM

War is not football, and football is not war, but having done both, they sometimes look like one another.

 

In 1879 the British Empire was nearing the zenith of its Victorian greatness. For most of the 19th Century the British Army had walked through most of its wars, having the occasional scare to be sure, but never staring down the specter of defeat. 

In January of that year the Empire decided it wanted to expand its holdings in southern Africa, and that meant an invasion of the Zulu. To say the Zulus were warriors would be to say that water is damp, or that MSU players are of questionable civic and moral virtue. It is a vast understatement. But the British knew their own strengths and experiences, and more importantly they thought they knew the Zulus. British commander Lord Chelmsford assumed the Zulu army was a slow and plodding mass, undisciplined, and with limited advanced weapons. He assumed that if he advanced fast enough and engaged the Zulus while they were in their villages for the harvest, he could bring his superior European firepower to bear and destroy the helpess Zulus with their stabbing spears and cowhide shields. Chelmsford was born into his position, and didn't quite appreciate the mistakes he was making. The Zulu impi had advanced over 50 miles in five days, while Chelmsford had only advanced slightly over 10 in double that time.

Ryan Day, but with better facial hair. 

In his arrogance Chelmsford neglected common sense tactics when in enemy territory. Like digging defensive positions when in camp, keeping his army concentrated so various wings could support one another, or even ensuring the enemy he divided his force to chase was actually the enemy's main effort. He was so certain that the Zulu could only do one thing, he chased full speed after the first Zulus he saw, leaving behind just over a thousand soldiers to guard the supplies at Isandlwana. It was a feint. They are Zulus, it is always a feint. The Zulu scouts pulled the core of the British infantry away from the camp, and at a full speed run (Zulus loved to run to battle) the Zulu main body was able to totally reverse their battle formation on the move, and attack the thousand British soldiers and native help Chelmsford left alone. Approximately 20,000 Zulu warriors rose up in a place the British least expected them, moving at a speed the British barely believed possible. Zulu king Cetshwayo's orders had been simple "March slowly, attack at dawn and eat up the red soldiers."

Zulu Warriors and their king... absolutely not to be messed with

The 6 companies of the British 24th Regiment of Foot Chelmsford left to guard Isandlwana were no scrubs. They were quality soldiers whose regiment existed even before Great Britain did. But Chelmsford had left them under the command of an administrative officer, who had limited game experience. 

The Zulus poured at the British Infantry and its allied Natal Native Cavalry in massive waves. The British were stretched thin, and every time the Zulus extended their line, the British were forced to match it. The British had to put every rifle at the front to merely slow the waves of onrushing Zulus. As a consequence, there were no second or third lines to push back any breakthrough. And break through the Zulus eventually did. After hammering away at the British front, the Zulu warriors found a gap between the Natal Cavalry on the right flank, and the British infantry in the center and poured into it. There was no one behind the first lines to stop them. An orderly defensive action quickly became a route, and the British line collapsed. Zulus poured through the British camp, slaughtering the helpless British who by now were nearly out of ammunition with the very weapons Lord Chelmsford found to be antiquated and obsolete. Over a thousand British soldiers fell at Isandlwana, and by the time Chelmsford returned with his main body, having never made contact with the Zulus, the camp was a smoking ruin and the Zulus had already moved on, to a place called Rorke's Drift. 

45-23

Michigan is a running team. Michigan loves to run. Michigan fans love watching the run. Michigan has turned the run game into part science and part art. Ryan Day looked at Michigan and tried to take away Michigan's strength. He neglected to plan for Michigan knowing this about themselves, and he refused to look at the Illinois game as a lesson. We all watched Indiana run crossing routes all over the field in 2018 and thought "boy I sure hope we get this sorted out by next week" the same way we looked at the run game sans Corum and Edwards last week and thought "pass or die". It appears that even though MGoBlog doesn't cover fucked, Michigan does indeed practice it. It appears the only ones who didn't see that warning was Ohio State. 

Ohio State looked at the Michigan formation and said "Blake Corum will not beat us". Which is a fine strategy. Except he played one drive and OSU didn't bother to adapt. Their full out attack won them the first half and in their arrogance, they just assumed they could count on JJ McCarthy being John O'Korn. He had to do something he had struggled to do all season. Something Ryan Day was betting his job he couldn't accomplish. JJ McCarthy didn't have to be amazing, he just had to hit the targets that Ohio State blundered into giving him. Wide open relievers on busted coverages for giant body blows that began to stretch the Ohio State defense, and once they started to stretch, Donovan Edwards broke them. The Ohio State defense was so broken it shattered the aura of invincibility Ohio State felt in their beloved Horseshoe. As the combination of JJ and Donovan began to pour it on the Ohio State defense, their offense began to panic, and the red uniformed route was on. 

Despite JJ not having the best passer rating of a Michigan player on the day (Kalel…..cough….Mullings…) and Edwards playing playing with a mitt on, both young men led their team. They led them into a place Michigan hadn't won since before they were born, and absolutely ate the red soldiers so thoroughly that their coach was on the verge of tears in his press conference.

This is the Michigan we have waited since… checks notes… forever… to see. Explosive in both phases of Offense, dominant on defense, and as the Pax Specialista Era draws to a close, with two of best offensive weapons in the country sharing the backfield with our Heisman Trophy candidate running back. It is great to be a Michigan Wolverine. 

The Horseshoe

Comments

dragonchild

November 27th, 2022 at 10:56 AM ^

Out of context for the game, it's amazing the sheer number of battles that were lost because of racism.  Then again, a lot of battles could've been avoided if not for racism.

OSU obviously respected Michigan far more than England respected Zulu, but like Victorian England, they showed up not for security or ideology, but for material comfort.

We basically posted the same diary, told different ways, at the same time :D

BlueHills

November 27th, 2022 at 11:17 AM ^

I loved this history lesson.

However, I don't think OSU was likely to win regardless of their second half defensive scheme. This game wasn't about OSU's defense, it was about our defense.

Michigan's D held OSU to only three second half points. OSU would have had to prevent all TDs and limit M to only one field goal to even send the game into overtime. That wasn't going to happen.

Granted, the blowout nature of our second half offense made this a game for the ages, but the bottom line is that M needed only one second half TD, or a couple of field goals, to win.

All year M's O-line has dominated opponents in the second half. So if OSU had concentrated more on the pass, eventually we'd have gotten a rushing TD.

Seems to me that OSU's second half plan was rational. It simply didn't work. This game was won by our defensive play.

Denard In Space

November 27th, 2022 at 11:32 AM ^

Awesome. I always say to myself I'm gonna read these diaries, then forget. This was the first one I read all the way through, well worth the wait!

Hope you keep writing these, or at least three more times this year.  

MIdocHI

November 27th, 2022 at 12:20 PM ^

“Michigan fans love watching the run.” citation needed 

JK.  Although to read the comments around here, it is clear that many want JJ to be released into full gunslinger/air raid mode. 
 

I enjoy these vignettes. Keep up the good work. 

treetown

November 27th, 2022 at 12:22 PM ^

For those who are interested in learning more about the battles of Isandlwana and the subsequent defense of Rorke's Drift, take a look at Ian Beckett's recent book, Rorke's Drift & Isandlwana. This is part of a series from Oxford University Press that looks at battles (mostly British) and looks at their long term impact on society - the works on Alamein, Agincourt, Waterloo, Battle of Britain, and Gallipoli are all excellent and if you are looking for a reasonable price holiday gift from someone interested in military history but with a new take, these are worth searching out.

It covers the battles but goes into depth into the longer term ramifications. Like Custer's Last Stand, the Zulu war created a deep impact on society - both British and Zulu.

The Zulu chief, Cetshwayo became a celebrity for a time and he actually visited England during July- August 1882 during a period when he was out of power, and had an audience with Queen Victoria. Ironically he was seeking British help in re-establishing himself to his throne - proving that politics can lead to some strange relationships. He also appears as a character in George Bernard Shaw ("Pygmalion" aka My Fair Lady) play Admirable Bashville in 1901. 

The use of the word Zulu also entered general usage and a soccer team played in 1879 under the name "Brewers and Rolling's Original Zulus" - later called the Sheffield Holmes Zulus. The appearance of the word "zulu" in the NATO alphabet and radio lingo for zee or zed may also be one more lasting effect.

Blueroller

November 27th, 2022 at 2:10 PM ^

Fascinating and enlightening, as usual. Michigan always leads the nation in quantity and especially quality of words written about it, and it's really nice see the team reaching the same level.

BananaRepublic

November 27th, 2022 at 3:03 PM ^

This is the first battle during colonial times in Africa that I've read about where the British actually suffered comparable losses to the Zulu. At the end, it's noted that the Zulu continued on to Rorke's Drift. The battle of Rorke's drift resulted in over 800 casualties for the Zulu, while the British suffered about 30. A small regiment of about 150 British soldiers defeated this band of nearly 4,000 Zulu warriors. Wild times

AlbanyBlue

November 27th, 2022 at 6:38 PM ^

A fantastic job yet again. An anthology of these pieces is book-worthy, and it's a book I would buy on the first day of release. 

As for The Game, one could argue that it was CJ's breaking two tackles and going the distance in the first half that set the tone for our offense. That assuredly gave JJ some confidence, and it probably gave the coaches confidence too. That led to the deep-ball touchdown to CJ and we were off and running.

Once again, thanks for the great work all season!