[Patrick Barron]

Penn State 28, Michigan 21 Comment Count

Ace October 19th, 2019 at 11:58 PM

I don't know what to do with this.

Michigan fell in a 21-0 hole at Penn State and looked well on their way to yet another road debacle against a ranked opponent to add to that stat everyone mentions when Michigan goes on the road against a ranked opponent. Everything from the gameplan to the execution looked ugly. On one side, the Wolverines slammed into the PSU defensive line and dropped potential first downs; on the other, Sean Clifford started hitting shots downfield, including a slot fade to KJ Hamler, who Michigan should've recruited harder, for what looked at the time like an insurmountable three-touchdown lead. Jim Harbaugh called for a punt on fourth-and-one in PSU territory. The officials probably missed an offensive pass interference on the second PSU touchdown.

Then, in a way seemingly designed to inflict maximum emotional pain on both fanbases, Michigan clawed their way back into it. Patterson responded to the Hamler touchdown by leading an eight-play, 75-yard drive capped by a 12-yard Zach Charbonnet touchdown run—though only after an improbable Ronnie Bell snag-a-fumble-out-of-midair-and-run touchdown was negated by penalty. After a deeply bizarre sequence in which Harbaugh had Jake Moody attempt a 58-yard field goal—surprise, it was short—and James Franklin turtled with three timeouts at midfield, the teams went to the locker room with the score at 21-7, Penn State.

The defense set a different tone in the third quarter, limiting PSU to 16 yards, but it looked like the offense failed to take advantage until their final drive of the quarter, when Charbonnet accounted for 45 yards and a touchdown to pull Michigan, improbably, within seven points.

Like cats toying with prey, PSU batted the lead back up to 14 to open the fourth quarter; Hamler found himself one-on-one with Josh Metellus and Clifford made no mistake in taking advantage of a safety defending one of the country's fastest slot receivers. But Michigan fought back again; Bell took a screen 35 yards and Patterson banged in a QB sneak to make it 28-21.

Ronnie Bell's teammates comfort him on the sideline. [Barron]

The defense booted Penn State off the field in three plays, setting up a drive for the tie. While nothing came easy, Patterson looked in his element, hitting receivers on time when plays worked as designed and creating with his legs when they didn't. A crossing route to Erick All set Michigan up with first and goal, but two runs and an incomplete pass only advanced the ball to the three-yard line to set up fourth down.

Patterson niftily escaped pressure, stepped up in the pocket, and found Bell with a sliver of space over the middle. The pass slipped through Bell's hands and fell harmlessly to the turf. Following a first down run by Hamler, PSU knelt out the clock.

All I know is I feel for Bell, who was shown crying on the sideline by ABC's cameras after the drop; he'd played a hell of a game to that point. Patterson's near-heroics inspired newfound confidence, though his stat line (6.7 yards per attempt, no TDs, one INT) looked familiar. The coaching of Harbaugh and Gattis often confounded, but the second-half gameplan looked sound. The defense looked like it was going to take a 2017-style pasting until they stiffened up considerably. Michigan looked overwhelmed by a night game in White Out conditions until they turned that crowd into a collective nervous wreck.

I don't know. Michigan is clearly not winning the Big Ten, and the rest of the schedule is going to be tough, and losing stinks. This time they went down fighting. Whether that's of great comfort is up to you.

[Hit THE JUMP for the box score.]

Comments

hazardc

October 20th, 2019 at 4:23 PM ^

It's not Harbaugh, it's academic standards.

 

I don't know why there is ever any confusion here.  You have to play school at Michigan and not everyone wants to play school.  

andrewgr

October 20th, 2019 at 8:25 PM ^

There isn't any confusion.  This tired excuse has been debunked so many times.

Michigan recruits the exact same players that Ohio State does.  There aren't any players that Michigan passes on because of their character, that Ohio State takes.  Maybe there's one player every so often that can't get accepted to Michigan that makes it into Ohio State, but IIRC I don't think it's as high as one per year.  And once they're in school, Michigan athletes major in General Studies, just like athletes at other big football schools major in whatever their equivalent is.

I mean, you can spend a few minutes doing a Google search to find the numerous times people have actually put together the numbers, but this comes up over and over and over again, and it just has no basis in fact.  Whatever slight advantage Ohio State may get because of academic standards is not enough to matter.

And just in case anyone cares about the actual facts: Cardale Jones was a very good student in both High School and in College.  Ironically, the reason he got so frustrated and tweeted out that infamous remark is because he got a lower grade than he thought he deserved-- something like a B-.  It was frustration that he had put in the effort and didn't do as well as he had hoped.  And ultimately he turned down leaving early for the NFL draft in order to stay in school and graduate.  There are plenty of players that attend Ohio State on football scholarships and do the minimum to get by, never intending to graduate; Cardale Jones was not one of them.

GoWhew

October 20th, 2019 at 4:47 PM ^

We are Penn State?

 

Harbaugh era (2015 - present):

 

Average recruiting class:

UM - 11 (if you count transition year, it's 16)

PSU - 13.5

MSU - 28

 

Total 5 star recruits:

UM - 5

PSU - 5

MSU - 0

 

Overall Records:

UM - 43-16

PSU - 45-15

MSU - 36-23

 

Record on road vs ranked team:

UM - 1-7

PSU - 1-6

MSU - 5-3!!!

UofM Die Hard …

October 20th, 2019 at 4:49 PM ^

While shitty of course, they looked like the team we thought we would see for 3qtrs. They came out 2nd half and played their asses off and beat up psu. That game gave me hope for rest of season.  Yeah we ain’t winning any titles but we can still have a really great season.

 

hell with Notre dame...
 

Hail! 
 

 

BlueHills

October 20th, 2019 at 5:55 PM ^

Being an older guy, I remember the late 50s and 60s, both going with my parents for all the games as a little kid, and my own college experience.

For most of both decades, Michigan was only a middle-of-the-pack team. The idea that we ought to be “elite” wasn’t even a thing until Bo, Mo, and Carr.

Oddly enough, no one minded. If you wanted to see Michigan football, you went to games where the environment was wonderful, the atmosphere entertaining, and there weren’t constant TV breaks. Very few games were televised.

This whole ‘failure unless you make the playoffs or win a championship’ thing didn’t exist. Michigan went 4-5 my freshman year. No one seemed to mind! It was still fun to hit the stadium on a fall Saturday and experience the tradition with the other 65,000 fans who’d show up. No one cared about the 100,000 fans stadium record, we never had that many fans come to games until Bo beat OSU in that all important episode of The Game.

Michigan football was (for me) very enjoyable no matter what the outcome of those games. Different times. I don’t enjoy the games as much now. There’s always too much emphasis on the record, too many game breaks, too much pressure. It’s harder to be a fan. I kinda feel sorry for the younger guys who never got to experience the laid back atmosphere of my early days when football games were actually fun!

Alumnus93

October 20th, 2019 at 8:02 PM ^

It seems they play systemic and on script, that is until they are down 3 tds due to Browns unsound defense, which it is.   Works vs avg opponents and nobody else.   

I felt like I was watching a tape of the ND game.  

Alumnus93

October 20th, 2019 at 8:02 PM ^

It seems they play systemic and on script, that is until they are down 3 tds due to Browns unsound defense, which it is.   Works vs avg opponents and nobody else.   

I felt like I was watching a tape of the ND game.  

Alumnus93

October 20th, 2019 at 8:17 PM ^

Feel for Bell?  So he gets all the glory when plays normally, and is given endless passes when he chokes.  Ok... That is a good gig he has.  

 

Duq

October 21st, 2019 at 8:01 AM ^

Maybe next Saturday we can actually play the whole game like we did the 2nd half. Spotting 21 to any team makes it very difficult to win whether home or away.