OT: How does a family narrow down where to buy a Michigan summer home?

Submitted by chuck bass on May 28th, 2019 at 11:07 AM

Over the years we've spent time in most of the more popular towns. Saugatuck, Holland, Grand Haven...Charlevoix, Petoskey, Harbor Springs, Bay Harbor, Indian River...Traverse City, Torch Lake, Leelanau Peninsula, Glen Arbor...even Au Gres on Lake Huron side (not really our cup of tea). How do you narrow down where to focus on? Pretty overwhelming.

SAvoodoo

May 28th, 2019 at 11:15 AM ^

I don't know, I can understand the trouble.  Me and my beautiful wife and perfect children are really having a hard time picking where to buy our next house too.  Considering we have one in London already that covers most of Western Europe but it's just so far from there to Italy so should we get a condo there? But really who has the patience for less than 3 bedrooms, you know what I mean.  On the other hand, we really don't NEED anything on the water considering our place in Turks...so much money, it's more hassle than it's worth.

chuck bass

May 28th, 2019 at 11:33 AM ^

Oh jeez, I set myself up for that. But it's genuinely not like that. It's something we've been saving for and pondering for a while. Everyone loves their own summer spot and this state is lucky to have so many gorgeous options, so it is honestly overwhelming.

It seems certain regions of the state gravitate towards certain summer destinations, ex. Grand Rapids and Lansing families to Grand Haven, Spring Lake and Holland? And also, family ties? But very few of our extended family remain in Michigan, so that doesn't really help us narrow our focus.

DonBrownSoda

May 28th, 2019 at 6:45 PM ^

Really? It's a Michigan blog. Many people are successful after going to the greatest University in the world. Dude has a question and you shame him. 

Just because someone has more money than you doesn't mean their question is bragging. 

Clarence Beeks

May 28th, 2019 at 11:12 AM ^

The biggest problem you'll face is, quite frankly, that there is no one answer on that because it's so totally an individual "fit" question.  And that will be compounded by the fact that people aren't going to share the truly great locations, because then everyone will be there.

maize-blue

May 28th, 2019 at 11:18 AM ^

It was difficult in my case. I wanted a waterfront home with dock access for my rather large yacht, well maintained road access for my Lambo and also a private airfield for my Gulfstream.

chuck bass

May 28th, 2019 at 11:41 AM ^

I admire the humor but everyone with a summer (lake) house isn't a billionaire. Growing up I recall uncles and their colleagues that worked at Big Three assembly plants had summer cottages on now very prime land. It's been a Michigan thing for I'd guess 100 years. It's been a goal of ours for a while.

bronxblue

May 28th, 2019 at 12:02 PM ^

I think everyone is busting your balls a bit, but at the same time you listed over a half-dozen places where most people try to get summer homes.  They're all fine.  I don't really know what other evidence people can give you beyond "find a place you like that you can afford."  Like, depending on where you look and your requirements (e.g. water access, # bedrooms, etc.), you can probably get a place anywhere for around the same price.  

 

MGoStretch

May 28th, 2019 at 12:02 PM ^

Ahhh, those were the days... is it still a thing where regular middle class folks could sock away some savings and still afford a place on a lake up north? I’ve done some intermittent Zillow browsing and it seems much more slanted toward the billionaire set. Not really a problem for me financially speaking, but I just don’t see myself driving to any of those towns when I could just fly on my private jet to the Aspen cabin in the winter.  It’s also tough to top the place on Lake Zurich in the summer, ya know?

pescadero

May 28th, 2019 at 12:50 PM ^

" is it still a thing where regular middle class folks could sock away some savings and still afford a place on a lake up north? "

 

Yes.

Clare. Harrison. Gladwin. Baldwin. Etc.

Clare/Lake/Osceola/Gladwin/Missaukee/Ogemaw/Roscommon Counties...

 

The place across the street from my cottage (lake view, lake access at community beach) just sold for $25K. 1200 square foot house with new well and septic.  Needed a lot of decor updates, but structurally sound.

 

crg

May 28th, 2019 at 12:22 PM ^

It wasn't called "Generous Motors" for decades without good reason.  I worked at a Delphi facility for a while ~15 years or so after they split from GM.  It was interesting hearing from the former GM people about how much money that company used to throw around (and was their unsubtle way of complaining about the lack thereof at Delphi).

drjaws

May 28th, 2019 at 11:22 AM ^

I mean, aside from "choose the area with the most options ion your price range" this is such a personal question it's impossible for any of us to help you.

Also, I don't see this going well for you OP.

NittanyFan

May 28th, 2019 at 11:23 AM ^

I mean - you've been to most of them, as you said.  So just choose one.

If I ever got a Northern Michigan 2nd home (and I aspire to), the biggest differentiators to me would be (1) are you going to own a boat, or just want to look at a lake?, (2) proximity to interests (wineries, fishing, sand dunes, golfing, winter snowmobiling, etc), (3) do you want to be around people to some extent, or completely away from it all?, (4) and ease of travel.

My ideal spot winds up being the Lake Michigan stretch from Manistee to Arcadia.  But that's just me.

NittanyFan

May 28th, 2019 at 12:14 PM ^

Beautiful.  Great spot.

You should probably neg-bomb me though --- I need to keep that area "secret."  :-) 

I do think it's setting up for a bit of a "boom" in the next 10-20 years.  Frontier used to fly Milwaukee-Manistee in the early 2010s and I've heard rumors that Delta is looking into Detroit-Manistee (it is a "essential air service" airport so carriers into Manistee would be eligible for federal subsidies).  Those flights would open the region up a bit.