Has anyone intentionally toned down their fanhood in order to improve their well being/mental health?

Submitted by go16blue on

Sorry in advance for what I'm sure is one of the more laughably depressing threads we've had after a loss, but it's a serious question. Mods if this is just too much, kill it. I was talking with a guy yesterday who intentionally stopped being a sports fan because it was too much stress and too distressing for him. I'm a generally happy person, but after a loss like that I can be depressed for days, and to be perfectly honest I feel like it might just be healthier for me to tune out a little bit. Much as I love Michigan and football, the fact that one of the biggest causes of distress in my life is sports is just not healthy.

Thoughts? Talk me off the ledge?

HAIL-YEA

October 13th, 2013 at 12:41 PM ^

way. I put way too much of myself into things I have no control of. I was in a situation where I should have been having a great time, but I was miserable last night. It's not healthy.

YoungGeezy

October 13th, 2013 at 12:43 PM ^

Before this season I would sacrifice anything on Saturdays to see every second of every game... Even during the RR years.

Since Akron, I've been trying to just passivley consume the games (even miss quarters) in order to keep my sanity. Unfortunatley, it hasn't worked all that well.

At least we have BBall......

Lucky Socks

October 13th, 2013 at 12:44 PM ^

I went to U of M from 07-11 so I endured "The Horror" (my first home sporting event as a student), the Oregon blowout, and all the frustrations of the RichRod era.  Not to mention the Josh Gasser bankshot buzzer beater (my last home sporting event as a student).  It got really tiring being so invested in the outcome and having my Saturday's ruined by something I have no control over.  And having the disappointment spill over into the week while worrying about the next game.

I'm still a rabid Michigan fan.  Haven't missed a single football or basketball game as a Grad Student elsewhere (thanks DVR!).  I love it when we win.  I love watching Michigan play.  I check this blog daily.  I hate to lose, but I don't let it bother me anymore.

Grant me the serenity to accept the things I can change...and the wisdom to know the difference.  Not trying to get religious, but seriously.  Hoke and the team probably feel pretty awful about losing.  I'll trust them to deal with it.  Is my anxiety or fury going to make any difference?  Nope, I'd rather just watch the Tigers and get a good night sleep.  

Go Blue.  It'll all be OK.

 

BlueUPer

October 13th, 2013 at 12:54 PM ^

So well said. I couldn't sleep last night. Like so many I thought this was the dawning of an age of dominance for UM. The horror of last night's game was worse for me than the horror itself. Why do I care so much? I couldn't talk to my kids after the game. I need a shrink. I need to get away from this blog, away from all thing UM for a while. M

bluebyyou

October 13th, 2013 at 12:44 PM ^

I'm backing off a bit.  

I got way too invested in that loss yesterday.  Had trouble falling asleep and when I woke up, I realized that the nightmare was real.

I have put way too much energy in being a Michigan football fan for way too long.  I will still watch the games and go to the home games, but with way less involvement emotionally.

Crime Reporter

October 13th, 2013 at 12:51 PM ^

It's a game and I can't do anything to change the outcome. I didn't lose money on it and I don't know any of the players or coaches personally. I didn't attend UM but I was born into the culture. That being said, I'm still upset about the loss. I know I shouldn't but I'm taking it very hard. I was sulking at church this morning and it didn't help that I sit by a Penn State couple. I am still shocked by the the improbability of Penn State's win and all the wasted opportunities. I'm pissed we repeatedly ran into a brick wall on first and second down to get behind the chains. I'm pissed the refs didn't overturn that horrible spot on Gallon's catch when it was clear he had a first down. I'm furious we let a freshmen QB march down the field in 20-some seconds to tie the score. I didn't like that Hoke punted instead of seizing the win by the balls and going for it. I look forward to watching Michigan every week but this one really hurt. I've stressed myself way too much this season, and I don't need the extra stress. I might find something else to do next Saturday.

1974

October 13th, 2013 at 12:46 PM ^

Unless I can be there in person (couple of times a year), I avoid watching games in real time on TV unless I can do it in the company of many others. (Haven't done that in a while here in Chicago ... hurts my aging ears.) Just not worth it ... there are too many other interesting things to do on a weekend. I check the score a half-hour or so after the game should be ending. Aside: I really miss those "every offensive/defensive snap" videos.

I think it's a good strategy for my mental health. May not work for everyone ... to each his/her own.

MMB 82

October 13th, 2013 at 3:23 PM ^

DVR is your friend. Maybe I am becoming an ADHD fan, but I have gotten into the habit of DVRing a game, and begin watching it about 90 minutes after the start. Part of the angst is waiting for something to happen, and now I can FF thru all the commercials, half-times, studio updates, under further reviews, extra points scored by opposing teams, etc.; it just removes a lot of the dead time that allows your emotions to otherwise boil over. 

90 minutes is about right for catching the end of the 4th quarter in real time. Living outside the midwest also helps. The only games I watch completely live anymore are OSU and bowl games.

I have tried being less of a fan. It doesn't work, I bleed blue and have done so for decades.

M Fanfare

October 13th, 2013 at 12:47 PM ^

I used to, but during the Rodriguez years I developed a sociopathic ability to detach my negative emotions from reality when the team played poorly. I remember laughing through the 2008 OSU game because at that point it was just hilarious that we were so terrible. I usually do a little venting, but I try to channel it into humor instead of anger, which in turn makes losses much easier to cope with.

Engin77

October 13th, 2013 at 1:24 PM ^

Started off well with Stevie Brown's interception of Terrel Pryor, but other than Brandon Minor's 2nd quarter TD there wasn't much to cheer about.  At least the non-shutout streak was maintained, the loss of which was my biggest fear going into that game in Columbus.

Victor Hale II

October 13th, 2013 at 12:48 PM ^

In many of the Carr years, they would lose some bad games early, and I'd boycott the team for a while and go bowhunting every weekend. By the time I was done, they'd have put together a nice winning streak just in time to make the OSU game seem important. Then I'd jump back in front of the TV only to have Tressel and his boys kick me in the sack. Being a fan can be hell. I think I need to start bowhunting again. Soon.

Bando Calrissian

October 13th, 2013 at 12:49 PM ^

I thought I had gotten over the kind of anger, rage, unmitigated sadness, and completely pissed-offness that I was capable of in the pre-RR era when Michigan did what we did last night.  I really did. I thought that part of me was gone. Then last night happened.

I guess that's what an acid flashback feels like?

joegeo

October 13th, 2013 at 12:55 PM ^

If it's ruining nights, then step away. The reason all of us got into this is because it's supposed to fun. Unfortunately, for many, it seems only to be fun when Michigan plays perfectly. However, it is quite possible to be a big fan and not let your mood be tanked by poor play or poor decisions or any of the other negative things that happen when a bunch of people play a game. I can't say I had a big smile on my face at the end of the PSU game, but I was able to turn off the game once it was over and enjoy the rest of my weekend.

I know that people make these comments regularly and typically people are quite defensive in response. I'll just surmise by saying that placing your emotional state in the hands of something so far beyond your control is unwise.

Oscar Goldman

October 13th, 2013 at 1:02 PM ^

The only season that really went well (til the end anyways) was 06.  Then, well ya we don't need a recap (11 was good but lost to staee).  The losses always make me miserable for a bit.  Particulary because the past five yrs have had a distressing pattern: the fact we always seem to hire a coordinator who makes things worse.  Between GERG and Al, it has been too many years of being completely baffled by the way things are done.  That being said, I still love seeing the players compete, the winged helmet, the memories... and the sense that one day the ship will get back on course. Go Blue.

UMxWolverines

October 13th, 2013 at 1:05 PM ^

Yes. I still screamed and yelled at what an idiot Borges is and that Hoke is channeling his Lloyd Carr after that punt and it would come back to bite us in the ass. 

But I used to be depressed for a while after losses, but once the 2nd overtime came I realized I didn't really care anymore. We haven't won a B1G title since 04 and that's not changing this season. We just don't have elite coaching and I hate to admit it, but it is what it is. OSU has rolled us for a decade because they have elite coaching. 

BornInAA

October 13th, 2013 at 1:05 PM ^

With Llord as coach, with 5 big ten champs, 5 rose bowls and a NC, I alway believed we could be at the Rose Bowl again every year.

Since then, my expectations and fanhood and been lowered. Michigan doesn't really scare anyone anymore. Michigan football is like the toothless bumble abominable snowman from Rudolf, once a year we might get to put a star on the tree (like a Notre Dame or Suger Bowl win) but that's it.

 

go16blue

October 13th, 2013 at 1:07 PM ^

Wow, I expected to be laughed at and run off with this post... looks like I'm not alone with this though. If anyone has had any successful techniques at staying happy when Michigan wins but coping better with losses, I'd love to hear them. Otherwise, I might not be too crazy for just tuning out a bit. 

B1G_Fan

October 13th, 2013 at 1:07 PM ^

 I was surprised it only ruined about an hour of my night but the Notre Dame game last year ruined my entire night. I should probably step back. I tried to pull for other teams in college sports but cant get involved even the tiniest amount. I wasn't a "fire the coach" kind of guy until Richrod unfortunately it carried over into the Hoke era.

JimBobTressel

October 13th, 2013 at 1:14 PM ^

Yes.

OP you are not alone in any way. After going to school for the RR years and the past few seasons I simply no longer live and die with michigan football. Actually I wouldn't say I lived and died with it, but now I have quiet resignation.

I've reguarly started to speculate what my fandom would have been like had I gone to an SEC school like originally planned. That's not good

M-Dog

October 13th, 2013 at 1:09 PM ^

Yes.

I have three bruises on my hand from hitting it hard against a wall in anger during OT.  My kids are afraid to talk to me.

Time to dial it back.

 

Geaux_Blue

October 13th, 2013 at 1:11 PM ^

Noted it to my wife. I'd have been awful to be around until Weds or so about 3-5 yrs ago. I locked in on Tigers, read over absurd vitriol on this board, played Madden til 3 am and took wife+baby to brunch. I'm completely over it and eager to beat Mr Brady this afternoon and see a gem from Scherzer. To be honest, I'm prob representative of the demo D Brandon has to prevent "losing"

Onas

October 13th, 2013 at 1:12 PM ^

You have to love the game, the players, the atmosphere, the fact that college football is this precious and natural spectacle still relatively uninfluenced by corporate milquetoasts. I love Michigan and even in the worst defeats take comfort in the fact that I never wish I was anything other than a Michigan Wolverine.

dearbornpeds

October 13th, 2013 at 1:15 PM ^

I've had this conversation with my adult sons over the past few years and we all agree with the idea behind this post.  i attended u-m from 71-78 and have remained a devoted fan since that time.  i find myself feeling worse about losses as i get older and not deriving as much pleasure from the wins.  (akron and ucon were actually worse for me than psu)

i have trouble sleeping on saturdays regardless of the outcome of the game.  i have endured many donkey punches over the years but i keep returning for more.  i thought rr would bring us to a new level of glory and we know what happend-i had my doubts about the current regime and now i feel anger over what i see as a lack of progress.  people can talk about systems and lack of experience but we are simply not very good right now.

the job of the coaching staff is to prepare players and put them in a positon when they can possibly win.  our coaches are playing not to lose.  going forward, my biggest fear is how it will affect recruiting which is our only salvation at this time

UMfan21

October 13th, 2013 at 1:15 PM ^

I was blessed with two children during the RR years. The combination of fatherhood and on field performance definitely put things into a new perspective. I am no less of a fan, but When the clock hits 0:00, regardless of outcome, I am able to take a breath and go play with my kids.

You have to keep things in perspective and if sports, a relationship, substance a use, or anything else causes you to lose perspective on life, then it's time to step away and re calibrate.

Danwillhor

October 13th, 2013 at 1:17 PM ^

I had to do this last year but it was more forced, unintentionally. Had a family member have surgery at Motts and that along with seeing everything/everyone else I literally thought to myself "football is not as important as you make it". Seeing that block M everywhere in a place not associated with football but real life did it. I'm glad it did. I still get jacked for games. I love wins. Losses cause distress but while I used to also get bothered for days I now pretty much am over it by the next day. Games like last night will maybe take longer but it's more a case of WTF than depression or the like. Incredulity. More than the game I find myself bothered by staff/player execution after a loss. Stupid decisions by guys making a lot of money and innocently wishing a ball wasn't dropped, punt didn't go into end zone, etc.

no joke its hoke

October 13th, 2013 at 1:21 PM ^

the last 5 years or so I have cared less and less. I still like watching the games but it doesn't ruin my week anymore. I was over last nights loss before the game had ended. I'll always root for Michigan but the landscape of college sports has changed, and so has my passion.

Danwillhor

October 13th, 2013 at 1:29 PM ^

I LOATHE the spread offense and that's all football is now. I look back at games from being a kid 80s-90s and miss seeing teams just line it up. The spread alone dropped my overall love/concern of cfb a bit. Not to mention the ESS EE SEE bs. The game isn't the same so even with a loss last night was kind of refreshing. Teams can't play defense anymore, etc. I care but am very GOML about football since about 2004.

imdeng

October 13th, 2013 at 1:25 PM ^

Yes I have conciously decided to tone down my involvement. Last night I kept waking up with the deep throw to Robinson (one with Stribling guarding him) playing in my head. This level of distress over something I have no control over is clearly unhealthy. So I have made a simple decision - I will still be involved in Michigan atheletics - but I will not watch live. I will record all games and will make a decision post-result whether I want to watch it. I hope this will lead to a more calmer association with Michigan sports.

Knight

October 13th, 2013 at 1:26 PM ^

I use to get so frustrated when my favorite teams lost as a kid/teen but now I try to keep things in perspective. Life is about so much more than whether MY team won a game. I love my teams, follow every move they make, and get nervous/excited watching them play, but if they lose it is not the end of the world just because I can't be happy about my team but the opposing fans can be. If we win, great! If we lose, it is tough, but there is always another game to look forward to.

JeanClaudeVanD…

October 13th, 2013 at 1:30 PM ^

As in, a loss would cause me to retreat to my room and poke my voodoo dolls kinda hard core. But it seems these last few years have been disappointment after disappointment. After the second over time I just started laughing because good lord it's second overtime against a bunch of "run ons"