The Mindfulness Primer for Michigan Football Fans

Submitted by Denard In Space on September 1st, 2021 at 12:21 PM

Greetings all, local MgoMentalHealth provider here. I’m writing today to share some perspective regarding how I survive the season as a Michigan football fan. This was inspired by Brian’s article wherein he disclosed the personal toll that his fandom has taken. I can see that distress about our program’s football lack of success permeates throughout the board. We’re very unhappy with our program and with the scope of college football in general. I have read great, supportive dialog on the board also, with a lot of healthy perspective being shared. So I thought I’d add to that with some insights about Mindfulness and how this may help Michigan football fans maintain their mental health and their perspective during the dark tumult of football season.

 

What is Mindfulness?

According to Mindful.org, “Mindfulness is the basic human ability to be fully present, aware of where we are and what we’re doing, and not overly reactive or overwhelmed by what’s going on around us.” The key feature of mindfulness is cultivating a non-judgmental awareness; this often looks like forgiving ourselves for our negative thoughts, returning to our stance as observers, and engaging with our sensations without trying to change or “do” anything to them.

 

How does this work?

Mindfulness is a skill. It is not something that we can flip a switch and turn on. By engaging in mindful practice on a regular basis, we train our minds to be present, aware, and non-judgmental. This can look like guided meditation, mindful walks, mindful cooking or cleaning, yoga, etc. Mindfulness is cultivated through habit just like any other skill.

 

How can I get started?

My favorite gateway into mindfulness is an app called Headspace that offers a free ten-session starter course. There are also numerous free mindfulness resources on Youtube. I like to start by learning body breathing, then moving on to a body scan meditation, then trying the loving kindness meditation. These three activities are an excellent starting pathway for cultivating mindful awareness. Practice for 5-10 minutes a day. Youtube is an excellent resource for further guided meditations.

 

How does this apply to Michigan football?

It can be hard to be a Michigan football fan if we rely on the outcome to determine our mood. Learning non-reactive and non-judgmental responses to disappointment can go a long way to mitigating the “BPONE” levels of depression we experience after a grisly loss. In developing such a skill set, we can learn to be happier in general without the weight of a loss on our shoulders, which in turn will lead to a generally less negative discourse between fans, and thus a less toxic fanbase.

 

What does this look like on game day?

Here is my practice on game day:

  • I regularly meditate in the evenings; on game days, I meditate in the morning as well.

  • I plan for breaks from the TV during games no matter how they go. Halftime I will go outside and stretch a little.

  • I will also plan for an alternative activity for The Game and more recently the matchup with Sparty. Something like going on a walk with a partner, a bike ride, maybe playing video games with friends, anything positive and pleasurable to give some respite if needed.

  • I am a cannabis user, so I will usually smoke a little at halftime, but less than usual for me. Be cautious with imbibing too much of anything, as being inebriated is kind of the opposite of mindful awareness. I mention this because I know it’s really common to drink beers and be merry during a game. Keep in mind that alcohol is a depressant, and can have negative effects on our decision making especially in a bad mood.

  • This is the most serious part: if the game is going badly and I start to have more severe negative thoughts, I turn it off.

    • This is serious. I have jokingly said things like “well I’m gonna go jump off a bridge” or some such. This is not healthy. Negative self-talk, self-harming thoughts, and suicidal ideation of any kind is a warning sign that we are crossing a boundary. Turn the game off. Choose one of your pre-planned positive activities, and engage with that. Football is a game, and mental health is the furthest thing from a game.

  • Engaging with community...at the right time. Snowflake threads can be cathartic, but beware, as they are the definition of wallowing. If you need to commiserate, try to give it time. If you feel that you need to vent, try doing so in person with friends. If you can’t wait, set a time limit for yourself. Honestly my recommendation is just don’t check the boards until Monday if you can. Maybe skip the game column too.

  • Focus on what’s awesome and beautiful about the University of Michigan and its football team. We have unparalleled history, the best uniforms, and a world-class education that almost every other college football program would envy if they weren’t just professional training programs for football. We have a real history of giving incredible opportunities to under-heralded players; every year it seems we put 3-star recruits into the NFL. I think of this as the Seth mindset.

 

Folks, the bottom line is that we won’t ever be able to enjoy life to the fullest if we don’t allow ourselves to experience things as they are, rather than as we want them to be. Rather than an admission of defeat or inferiority, I view this as an opportunity for the real people that comprise our fanbase to find some joy in the experience of Michigan football as opposed to the outcome of Michigan football.

I for one am super excited about the season, can’t wait to see the new players and plays, and watch them play their asses off. I will try to answer questions as I can if they come up, though I do have real-life patients today so bear with me.

GO BLUE!!! 

Further Resources: 

"The Miracle of Mindfulness" by Thich Nhat Hanh
"Wherever You Go, There You Are" by Jon Kabat-Zinn

Comments

Forsakenprole

September 1st, 2021 at 4:19 PM ^

This is really good stuff. Really appreciate the emphasis on mental health; people are often mocked for caring so much about a game, but it’s not just a game for many of us. It’s a tradition and a lifestyle that links us to family, our past selves, etc…

My struggle is in thinking that in order to enjoy the highs - whenever they may come - I must have been there to suffer the lows.

Kind of like how a post recently stated that the depth of our suffering also increases our potential for joy.

Ive gotten trapped in the - likely errant - thinking that I must suffer with the team to enjoy the highest highs; that anything short would make me a fair weather fan.

And yet your post shares wisdom on why this line of thinking is erroneous. 

Thanks for sharing. I think we can apply these wise words to many facets of this strange new world we’ve been thrust into.

Be well, MGo community.

 

Denard In Space

September 1st, 2021 at 5:46 PM ^

Thanks for sharing your perspective -- I can understand the "ride or die" mentality. I view it as a process of triaging my needs, knowing that there are far greater stressors in my life and that they don't need help from a football game. But there are also tolerances, which are different for everyone. For whatever reason I really only get to a point where I need to shut the game off for my own mental health when we go against sparty or osu.  Part of the benefit of developing mindful awareness is that we can gain greater insight into those tolerances, knowing our limits better. All that to say there is no one right path, but there are ways to find one that's right for you! 

rc90

September 1st, 2021 at 5:11 PM ^

On the one hand, as someone who has dabbled in the Kwan Um School of Zen, I think this is very well done. You have done your homework, and have provided a gateway for what can be an effective way of introducing a sense of balance, I guess, to sports fandom.

OTOH, OMG Harbaugh really needs to beat tOSU like a fucking drum this year.

BuddhaBlue

September 1st, 2021 at 8:43 PM ^

I feel obligated to post here lol. There's a lot here, thanks for that. I hope it helps people understand that mindfulness isn't anything mystical, but something we all already have. We just need to cultivate it and use it more. Not being mindful, being reactive and letting your emotions go where they want to, that lets the trolls in, lets the losses cut deep. Instead, you lead your emotions, you lead your thoughts

Namaste and go blue

tubauberalles

September 1st, 2021 at 11:02 PM ^

Thank you for this post - tracks well with my personal "growth" as a Michigan fan.  In my household, I'm the only person who really cares about Michigan sports, so my mood swings depending on outcomes used to be something noted by one and all.  I've utilized many of the same approaches you share to help make sure I remain balanced and in the moment and not overly-wrapped up in the outcome of an experience that is really meant to be fun and transitory.

I do care and hope for Michigan victories - dominant, crushing victories over our rivals - but I have learned to take more care for the experience of the game as it unfolds and remember that I'm just an observer and a fan and have my Michigan degree and memories regardless of any single game's outcome.

As an aside, my wife is in the middle of a meditative practices training program, which she is melding with her creative arts practice, which emphasizes mindfulness and the creative process instead of the creative product.  Can be very powerful, even when just utilizing common and cheap materials - which helps break the over-focus on what might result from the creative inputs, and instead supports deeper connections to the creative process.  A freeing of the mind and unleashing of the creative spirit.  Which can be translated beyond visual arts, to business, community-building, social healing and, at least in my mind, to the endeavors of a team to collaborate toward a common goal (ideally turning the tide vs OSU).

Ezeh-E

September 2nd, 2021 at 10:43 AM ^

I second this. I watch 11 games a year now and plan an activity for the OSU game. In 2018 I went to another college football game with friends. In 2019 I went bowling with my kid.

I caught snippets of the game and score updates, but generally stayed present and away from it. I had pretty good days. If UM had been leading late, I might have turned on the TV. Either way I had it recorded so I could watch if we won. And I would have savored every moment of watching the recording, even knowing the outcome.

I think if we get back to "even" or close to it with OSU, I'll start watching The Game again live. But until then it just feels like an exercise in pain and frustration.

Seth

September 2nd, 2021 at 3:30 PM ^

One of my good friends created a mindfulness app as well: www.aplanforliving.com. For him it was necessary; he is bipolar. But this stuff really is valuable for dealing with people online. The kind of shit that gets thrown my way being just a tinpot "celebrity" is insane, and I used to lose hours of productivity because someone wanted to tweak me and I wasn't prepared to handle it.

Denard In Space

September 2nd, 2021 at 6:06 PM ^

I'd also recommend the book "The Four Agreements" for dealing with online discourse. One of the agreements is "Don't take anything personally," and goes on to elaborate in a really insightful and helpful way. I will check out this app as well, anything that could be useful for my clients is worthwhile to look into, so thank you! Feel free to reach out with any other ways I could be helpful!