B1G West Scenarios: A Tangled Ball of Mediocrity
The Big Ten West is a big, beautiful, shining mess of mediocrity this year, and I find it fascinating. So I dug into scenarios for the division title.
With two weeks remaining there are still five (!!!) teams in the running.
Two teams have been eliminated:
-Northwestern (1-7) with 1 win and 2 games left can't catch any of the teams that already have 4 wins total
-Nebraska (2-4): Because Iowa and Minnesota play each other, Nebraska pulling off upsets against Wisconsin and Iowa the next two weeks, wouldn't be able to catch the winner of the Floyd of Rosedale.
Situation for the contenders
Purdue (4-3)
Remaining Games: Northwestern, @IU
Tiebreakers: Illinois, Minnesota
Prediction: Win, Win (6-3)
Illinois (4-3)
Remaining Games: @Michigan, @Northwestern
Tiebreakers: Minnesota, Wisconsin, Iowa
Prediction: Loss, Win (5-4)
Iowa (4-3)
Remaining Games: @Minnesota, Nebraska
Tiebreakers: Wisconsin, Purdue
Prediction: Toss-up, Win (5-4, or 6-3)
Minnesota (4-3)
Remaining Games: Iowa, @ Wisconsin
Tiebreakers: (none)
Prediction: Toss-up, Toss-up (4-5, 5-4, or 6-3)
Wisconsin (3-4)
Remaining Games: @Nebraska, Minnesota
Tiebreakers (none)
Prediction: Win, Toss-up (4-5, or 5-4)
Scenarios to get to B1G Championship Game:
Purdue:
- Win against both Northwestern and Indiana
- Iowa loses to Minnesota or Nebraska
- Lose to one of Northwestern or Indiana
- Iowa loses to both Minnesota and Nebraska
- Minnesota loses to Wisconsin
- Illinois loses to Michigan or Northwestern
Illinois:
- Win against both Michigan and Northwestern
- Purdue loses to either Northwestern or Indiana
- Loss to one of Michigan or Northwestern
- Purdue loses to both Northwestern and Indiana
- Iowa loses to either Minnesota or Nebraska
Iowa:
- Win both remaining games
- Illinois loses to Michigan or Northwestern
- Win against Minnesota, Loss to Nebraska:
- Illinois loses both games
- Purdue loses a game
Minnesota:
- Win against both Iowa and Wisconsin
- Illinois loses to Michigan or Northwestern
- Purdue loses to Indiana or Northwestern
- Win against Iowa, loss to Wisconsin:
- Wisconsin loses to Nebraska
- Illinois loses to both Michigan and Northwestern
- Purdue loses to both Northwestern and Indiana
Wisconsin:
- Win against both Nebraska and Minnesota
- Iowa loses to Nebraska
- Illinois loses to both Michigan and Northwestern
- Purdue loses to both Northwestern and Indiana
No team controls their own destiny
The snake is eating its tail, and oh is it tasty. Because of tiebreakers being dealt out evenly, no team can win out and go to Indy without help, which is incredibly hilarious.
Let's filter out some very unlikely scenarios to get down to what could happen
Wisconsin, while still alive, really needs a tear in the fabric of spacetime. While each are possible, Northwestern beating both Purdue and Illinois along with Iowa losing to Nebraska is extremely unlikely.
Minnesota can't lose a game. Nebraska beating Wisconsin, and Northwestern winning out against Illinois and Purdue is extremely unlikely.
Iowa probably can't lose a a game. Illinois losing to Northwestern and Purdue losing to Northwestern or IU is not likely.
Pretty unlikely: All you had to do was beat Michigan State!
Illinois is probably out of it.
They will need to break a 2-game skid and pull off a big upset against Michigan to have a somewhat realistic shot. In addition to that, Purdue would need to drop a game to either Northwestern or Indiana. They are inconsistent, but will be favored in both games, so adding that to an upset at the Big House, seems pretty unlikely.
A likely loss to Michigan requires Purdue to lose to both Northwestern and IU, which is also very unlikely.
It seems to come down to a pivotal game
Iowa @ Minnesota next week is the likely decider of this all.
Iowa winning means they are 5-3 and only need to beat Nebraska and Illinois to lose to Michigan to lock in an Indy trip.
If Minnesota wins, it puts Purdue in the driver seat and they just need to beat Northwestern and Indiana, games in which they will likely be favored.
Minnesota is seriously in the mix too
Minnesota winning the Floyd of Rosedale means they need Michigan to win next week, and Purdue to get upset by either Northwestern or Indiana.
Michigan's rooting interest
East scenarios are clear now: the winner of The Game is in, no matter what else happens.
None of these teams are terrifying, but it seems like Purdue is the most dangerous team to play at this point due to the potency potential of their offense. That means root for a Minnesota win when they host Iowa next week, or for Purdue to lose against IU in the last week of the regular season.
I personally, would prefer to see Minnesota. If you're with me, we want Minnesota to beat Iowa next week and for Purdue to drop a game.
None of these scenarios seem like a lock
While the Big Ten is likely to shake things up in the near future with the B1G Championship game always going to the East winner (so far) and USC & UCLA joining the conference, who can deny the fun this brings? I truly can't tell you what's going to happen. Bust out your popcorn!
November 13th, 2022 at 12:39 AM ^
Thank you for doing the legwork on this so that we can just gape at this monstrosity
November 13th, 2022 at 8:58 AM ^
I can’t imagine that it’s mathematically true that no team controls it’s own destiny. If you go below the first couple tiebreaker layers, some team must meet some archaic criteria for the lead.
November 13th, 2022 at 12:37 PM ^
There’s a scenario where Purdue wins out, Illinois wins out, and Iowa wins out that goes to the tiebreaker of record of crossover teams. That likely has Iowa winning since they played both Michigan and Ohio State.
[EDIT: this is wrong. Purdue has a worse in-division record than Iowa and Illinois, which is a criteria before cross-division opponent record. So Purdue would drop out and the edge would go to Illinois holding the head-to-head over Iowa]
That would be the closest to controlling their own destiny but they still need help. Because tiebreakers are spread around evenly, no one is completely in control.
November 13th, 2022 at 3:02 PM ^
So the universe could actually implode because of this mathematical paradox?
November 13th, 2022 at 8:55 PM ^
It's not a mathematical paradox. It's a Schrodinger's Division.
November 13th, 2022 at 5:32 PM ^
SP+ odds of winning the division mostly verify your conclusions (except that Illinois seems to have a bit better chance than you give them):
- Purdue 44%
- Iowa 30%
- Illinois 14%
- Minnesota 11%
- Wisconsin 0.2%
November 14th, 2022 at 8:48 AM ^
Wisconsin it is then
November 13th, 2022 at 6:44 AM ^
The big ten west is so broken. Poor damn indiana for having to face osu, um, msu, and psu every year while Purdue has this much more manageable schedule
November 13th, 2022 at 7:14 AM ^
Or one might say the division is a skein of excellence.
But only if one wanted to use the word “skein.”
The only excellence here, dankbro, is your extended analysis of the Big Ten Worst.
Thanks for digging in the muck so we didn’t have to. (Poor damn Indiana.)
November 13th, 2022 at 7:28 AM ^
Thank your for doing this.
The Iowa fans are having a real crisis - they know they have to revamp their offense, but if they win the BigTen West, they also know it guarantees years of Ferentz the younger as OC.
Minnesota winning it seems plausible - they have a strong need to beat Iowa, and Purdue can be upset.
November 13th, 2022 at 8:29 AM ^
Iowa winning the division and showing up to the BTT game again would be an epic 'barrassment for the conference.
November 13th, 2022 at 8:56 PM ^
Playing Iowa three times in two years? How exciting.
November 13th, 2022 at 7:51 AM ^
You're a masochist of the highest order, dankbrogoblue. Excellent work.
November 13th, 2022 at 7:58 AM ^
Facing Iowa or Minnesota would definitely be preferable to facing Purdue. Although Minnesota may or may not have Tanner Morgan back, they do have Mo Ibrahim and a physical OL, along with a very solid defense, so I'd rather play Iowa again.
Beat Bert, beat Bucks, beat whoever. Let's go.
November 13th, 2022 at 7:58 AM ^
You almost lost me at "Big10 West". Kidding. Heckuva writeup and analysis.
November 13th, 2022 at 8:25 AM ^
As much I think I'd like to see us play Purdue since I think we'd mash them into a gooey paste, I'm kind of hoping for Minnesota. I want the Mother Of All Jug games.
November 13th, 2022 at 8:48 AM ^
My thought exactly on Minnesota winning the west. Want to crush them and loft the jug!
November 13th, 2022 at 8:58 PM ^
What is the rule here? Is the championship game counted or not counted for rivalry trophies?
November 13th, 2022 at 10:42 PM ^
It's got to count. It's Michigan-Minnesota!
November 14th, 2022 at 7:13 AM ^
That rule is just after the “double secret probation “ codicil.
November 13th, 2022 at 9:05 AM ^
With two games left, NO ONE CONTROLS THEIR OWN DESTINY. It never occurred to that such a circumstance was possible. Yes, I am a probability and stats guy so if you asked me if it was possible, I would have said yes but the question never came up in 50 years of fandom.
November 13th, 2022 at 10:59 AM ^
Your user name doesn’t make it look like you’re a probability or stats guy
November 13th, 2022 at 5:15 PM ^
Industrial Engineering uses probability and statistics to make decisions. 11+ statistics and probability classes. Hardest part in the real world is asking the right question.
November 13th, 2022 at 8:22 PM ^
Like, is a hot dog a sandwich?
November 13th, 2022 at 9:56 PM ^
The really tough question is "hot dog or not hot dog".
November 14th, 2022 at 8:47 AM ^
If Illinois had beaten MSU or Purdue, they were probably getting a 2 week head start on buying B1G Championship tickets.
If UM beats OSU, UM fans will start buying tickets at 3:30pm. The West winner probably won't be determined until 7pm, giving us a 3.5 hour head start.
November 14th, 2022 at 1:24 PM ^
Bring.
The.
Jug.
To.
Indy.
November 15th, 2022 at 1:34 PM ^
What happens in case of the following scenario?
- Illinois loses to Michigan, wins at Northwestern.
- Wisconsin wins at Nebraska, beats Minnesota at home.
- Minnesota beats Iowa at home, loses at Wisconsin.
- Iowa loses at Minnesota, beats Nebraska at home.
- Purdue beats Northwestern at home, loses at Indiana.
This scenario results in a 5-way tie at 5-4.
I think Purdue wins it, but my interpretation of the Big Ten tiebreaker procedure is probably wrong.
Comments