Iowa Snowflakes - The Offense

Submitted by LSAClassOf2000 on October 5th, 2019 at 11:30 PM

This will be your thread for snowflakes and hot takes regarding the offense in our game against Iowa. 

DonBrownsMustache

October 5th, 2019 at 3:32 PM ^

Look y'all, I'm happy with a win, but the offense is absolutely atrocious.  Seems we are allergic to what works - QB reads and passing the ball to our good WRs.  Let's be honest, this game should have been 30-3 with a semi-competent offense.  Nothing but wasted talent.

AnuckSudicki

October 5th, 2019 at 6:20 PM ^

30-3 but in favor of Iowa. Don't know what game you were watching but what UM trotted out there today they will be lucky to score 30 points the rest of the year. The defense saved the offense today plain and simple. Look how many times Iowa was inside the 40 compared the the offensive juggernaut that is Michigan. Defense and only the defense won this game. The offense had absolutely nothing to do with it.

stephenrjking

October 5th, 2019 at 3:33 PM ^

Obviously the O is terrible. There are some coaching problems, IMO; Gattis is a big disappointment. 

But the biggest problem is at QB. And putting in a new QB won’t fix it, because he has the same coach. 

Harbaugh ruins his QBs. 

stephenrjking

October 5th, 2019 at 3:41 PM ^

The only guy who has worked out is Rudock, and perhaps Shea improves the way he did late in the season. 

His other QBs: Speight, the worker. OKorn, who was good as a freshman. Peters, McCaffrey, and Milton, all highly rated guys he recruited. And Patterson, a 5-star. 

Not every QB pans out. But all of Harbaugh’s guys, except Rudock, have been actively underwhelming and in most cases actively regressed. I don’t know how or what, but something in the way Harbaugh manages and teaches them makes them bad. They aren’t comfortable beating zones, they are nervous in their reads, and they get worse over time as their mistakes compound and they grow afraid of making more. 

AlbanyBlue

October 5th, 2019 at 4:24 PM ^

I've said it before and I'll stick to it. All of JH's QBs have had it drilled into them not to make a mistake. I'm sure it's done so often that they lose the ability to just play. Then we get hesitancy, never throwing to a spot, second-guess, ball pat, third-guess, ball-pat, happy feet, ok now throw. That's why most throws, especially against zone, have bad timing. Everything is "should I? should I? OK, go....." So the longer they're in the system, the worse they get. Rudock "could" be an outlier since he seemed more NFL-caliber and more able to deal with the risk-averse messages and still use his natural ability. But he STILL had a shit game at Iowa 2016. So don't say the last half of 2016 was continual improvement.

And that to the extra problem, which is Shea's seeming inability to survey the whole field, and we have what we have.

I have no clue and no inside information, but based on results, I think this is pretty right on here.

stephenrjking

October 5th, 2019 at 5:07 PM ^

There is information we will never get. But I wonder how Harbaugh trains the QBs to make reads. I remember when he was in SF reading an article explaining how he designs plays with easy reads for his QBs, but other than that, what evidence is there that he is coaching them well? If he, with his scattershot speaking/thinking style, not great at communicating his thoughts on QBing to the players? Does he load them up with detail information rather than encourage them to master concepts first followed by nuance? Does he ONLY deal with basic concepts and expect them to swim on their own?

We don't know and we never will. We can only judge by results. But the results are bad. 

Magnum P.I.

October 5th, 2019 at 3:33 PM ^

The key to this whole offense was made abundantly clear on the drive where we started with passes to Collins, DPJ, and Black. First down, first down, first down. 

And then, wouldn't you know it: the running game opened up and we gained chunk yardage for the only time the whole game.

Then, of course, we didn't do this again the rest of the game.

Those first few sets of downs are what our whole offense should look like all the time. Throw it to our three NFL receivers. That established, run. 

Ham

October 5th, 2019 at 3:34 PM ^

Offense scored 10 points in the first 6:30 (3 courtesy of the defense giving the offense the ball deep in Iowa territory before the offense went 3-and-out. 

0 the final 53:30. 

Pathetic.

shags

October 5th, 2019 at 3:38 PM ^

Just a reminder that Michigan is never, ever beating Ohio State again.  I have a 8 year nephew, and he, his children, and his grandchildren will never see Michigan beat Ohio State.  And I might be underselling that.

Michigan will get beat by Penn State, likely badly, but they can compete with Notre Dame and Michigan State, especially at home.

It's a win.  Enjoy it.

Blue 4 Life

October 5th, 2019 at 3:34 PM ^

I'm a lot of bit drunk but it seems like we should be able to appeal Shea Patterson's eligibility. I'm pretty sure he should have sat out a year after transferring from Ole Miss. 

It doesn't seem fair.