Seth Davis posts pre-draft evaluations of top 50 NBA prospects on The Athletic this morning

Submitted by mGrowOld on June 17th, 2019 at 12:28 PM

For those of you who dont follow him every year Seth Davis posts evaluations of the top 50 NBA draft prospects via "Finch".  Finch is an anonymous amalgam of 6 NBA scouts and 6 different NBA front office executives all rolled up into one.   Let's just say Finch is not a big fan of the three Michigan players leaving early this year to say the least.

Ignas Brazdeikis, 6-7 forward, Michigan, 20. “I’m not a huge fan. He measured smaller than I thought. He’s not all that athletic. I don’t think he can guard a 4, and right now doesn’t have the ability to play the 3. I don’t like drafting Michigan players because I think John Beilein takes average players and makes them look terrific. His guys get drafted high but don’t do much in our league. Lateral quickness is a question. He was terrific the first month of the season, but I don’t know what happened to him. He did not shoot the ball well in the workout I saw. What does he do to really stand out on an NBA floor? He’s a streaky shooter but not a bad one.”

Charles Matthews, 6-6 guard, Michigan, 22. “Breaks my heart that the kid just tore his ACL. He was borderline before the injury. Now I can’t imagine who would draft him. I don’t see anything there. If you’re a wing in our league you have to be able to shoot, and he doesn’t have that yet. He’s more of a two-way guy who you develop. When you don’t improve your jumper after playing for Beilein, that’s a troubling sign. He’s going to have to make it defensively.”

Jordan Poole, 6-5 guard, Michigan, 19. “He should have stayed in school. Doesn’t handle the ball in terms of being to attack off the dribble. He’s going to have to take the long route to the NBA, probably through the G League. Not a fan. Good size but not a great athlete. I’m not convinced he loves basketball. Smooth as heck. Can really pass it. I think he can be a point guard if he gets stronger. Needs to get better as a defender but he’s good. He’s smaller than I thought, really lean and thin. Toughness is his biggest question. I question his decision-making. I thought he was good at times, but at other times I thought Michigan lost games because he was a train wreck.”

JamieH

June 17th, 2019 at 6:02 PM ^

Yeah, none of this is surprising.  Neither Iggy nor Poole had any business going.  It probably will not end well for them.  

CaliforniaNobody

June 17th, 2019 at 6:47 PM ^

Hard to say he’s wrong. Iggy doesn’t stand out in any way. I love CM but the shooting is a major issue, though I think people underrate his defense. Poole, as he said, just came out way too early. Probable G league to overseas route in his future unfortunately, and just a horrible decision to declare early IMO.

Matte Kudasai

June 17th, 2019 at 9:21 PM ^

Iggy's abundant ego and Poole's delusional misguidance are the story here.  Neither kid should have come out.  Even Matthews realistically could have improved his offense with another year.

nowicki2005

June 17th, 2019 at 9:41 PM ^

I'm definitely not thrilled that Poole decided to enter the draft but I never blame a kid for trying to get to his dream even if it be a tad bit early. I'm most worried for him though.

 

I don't think he is mentally strong enough to endure a bad showing in say, the summer league. I look at him more as a streaky shooter as to a pure shooter because he would miss bad sometimes, like really bad. He just seems like if he gets it handed to him in the summer league he is just going to spiral downward. It's a hard road that he's probably going to have to take. You go from being around your friends and having teammates to basically having to do it all by yourself.

 

Mathews, I wonder if beilien would draft him just so he can get a g league contract with the Cavs and get medical treatment 

JTP

June 17th, 2019 at 11:04 PM ^

I remember talking to a guy in 2011 he said a guy related to him who coached a guy at a California school suggested the Pistons draft a guy by the name of Leonard! I think his first name was Kawhi? Too bad they didn’t! Oh that guy who suggested that was an assistant at Michigan at one time.

uofmchris1

June 18th, 2019 at 12:19 AM ^

But seriously. Who's advice did JP and Iggy take when declaring for the draft? At best, they will be mid to late second rounders.

I am guessing only one of them will actually get drafted.

Maybe there was a soft promise by an NBA team?