rps

Gardner is one of the great what-ifs [Patrick Barron]

Assuming each player is healthy, coached by a competent OC and behind a competent OL, which Michigan QB would you choose: Tate Forcier, Devin Gardner or Shea Patterson? 

Bonus question: where does John Navarre fit in?

This is a tremendous question. None of these guys except Navarre had the luxury of a career where they got to stay at the same place and play the same position. Forcier bombed out after two years; Gardner got moved to WR for an offseason and half a season; Patterson transferred from Ole Miss after two years.