Boo. (Peter South's Phone)

Michigan Hockey Game #38: Michigan State 5, Michigan 4 (OT) Comment Count

David March 24th, 2024 at 12:05 AM

CLICK HERE for Game Recap from Kristy McNeil and other pertinent information and HERE for current Pairwise Rankings.

What just happened (TL;DR): Michigan and Michigan State played a back and forth game all evening, exchanging leads throughout. Michigan held leads of 1-0 and 3-2; MSU had leads of 2-1 and 4-3. While neither goalie was outstanding, Trey Augustine was better than Jacob Barczewski, and that proved to be the difference. There were a couple of controversial goal calls (or wave offs), making it a peak Big Ten game in the final Big Ten game of the season. Both teams were very good as it took almost 75 minutes to decide the final. I don’t hate either teams chances next weekend in NCAA Regionals.

FINAL CORSI NUMBERS (www.collegehockeynews.com)

 

Total Attempts

Even Strength

Power Play

Close (within 1)

Even Strength %

Michigan State

71

61

10

58

50%

Michigan

69

61

8

61

50%

Forward Notes.

-Michigan started the game with a bang, scoring a goal bright and early. They followed that up with another goal that was waved off goal goalie interference (a debatable decision). The Wolverines continued the onslaught peppering Spartan goalie Trey Augustine when not killing a penalty. Only getting that one goal to count early seemed to change the flow of the game, as MSU played better as the game moved along…with Michigan seemingly feeling a bit fortunate to get to overtime. Overtime was rather even with one goalie making one more save that the other. In the end, the game was about as close as it could be.

-Frank Nazar got his line on the scoresheet a couple of times at Munn on Saturday night. He finished off a very nice backhanded pass from Josh Eernisse from the boards. Nazar raced to the front of the net and elevated the centering pass over Trey Augustine to open the scoring. In the third, down a goal, Dylan Duke fired a shot from the point that Nazar was able to redirect into the net with his back skate. It was a bit of a fortunate bounce, but Frank had to get his foot in the right place originally. 

-The top line scored to make it 2-0, right after the first Nazar goal. Rutger McGroarty found and open Gavin Brindley in the slot who beat Trey Augustine. The goal was waved off due to Garrett Schifsky sending a defenseman into Augustine before the shot. It was reviewed and hotly debated if it was a shove or a position battle. Unfortunately for Michigan, it was ruled a shove and goaltender interference.

-More on this goal in the next section, but Philippe Lapointe made a very nice pass across the ice to Marshall Warren to set up his goal. Lapointe chipping in backs up the fourth line’s great offensive play last weekend in Minneapolis. He also had a very nice backhanded assist to Luca Fantilli on a goal that was waved off for offsides. Good to see Lapointe making a difference in the offensive zone down the stretch.

Defense Notes.

-Overall, I didn’t think the defense was bad at all. They faded a little bit in the third period and then in overtime, as the game kept going, forcing Barczewski to bail them out more than he had to in the first couple of periods. However, other than the first goal, it was hard to fault them for any of the goals. It would have been nice if someone had stepped out into Matt Basgall’s buzzer-beating rocket…but that seemed like a frustrated mental error after the absurdity of the third goal being reviewed and given. That’s slightly understandable.

-The one bad DZTO did come from Luca Fantilli. That was the first real scoring chance that MSU got all evening…over ten minutes into the game. He may have played after that, but I did not see him or notice him. (When college hockey has a naturalstattrick website that I can check TOI and shift times, let me know!) Luca has had an up and down season. He’s flashed some puck moving potential, but has also had his own gaffes in the defensive zone. He still seems a summer away from strong, consistent contributions.

-Marshall Warren had a Cale Makar-esque finish on the third Michigan goal. He reached out to catch the Lapointe pass. Then, he went forehand, backhand and ROOFED the shot over Augustine! Even Seamus Casey must have been like “Wha??” Warren has finally turned into the defenseman that Michigan had hoped he would be all season. He’s been very solid in his zone, on the puck, and is starting to finish some plays. That bodes really well going into Regionals.

 

Dylan Duke got the power play tally on Saturday (Bill Rapai)

 

SPECIAL TEAMS CHART

 

PP Opportunities

PP Corsi For

PP Shots/Minute

Michigan State

0/2

8

.5 (2/4)

Michigan

1/3

10

1.56 (7/4.5)

Power Play. After a couple of lackluster power plays, Michigan’s third power play hit the jackpot. Seamus Casey made a nice move at the blue line, carried down the side of the House, backhanded a slick pass to Rutger McGroarty’s tape. Rutger fired a shot into Trey Augustine, who leaked the puck as he was moving across the crease. Dylan Duke was where he normally is for the rebound: at the top of the crease. The thing about power plays is that you don’t need to be great on every one. If you are awesome on a couple and finish one, that’s all that matters. The Wolverines did that on Saturday night.

Penalty Kill. The Wolverines took the first two penalties of the game. They then proceeded to rather easily kill of both Spartan power plays. While MSU did garner some zone time, they didn’t get a shot on net until the second opportunity…and neither were overly dangerous. Michigan’s penalty kill resurrection has been a sight to behold. It’s gone from “AHH!!!” to “eh” in a matter on months. Major point for the coaching staff.

 

 

After keeping them in it, Jake Barczewski couldn’t get the last one (Bill Rapai)

GOALTENDING CHART

 

Michigan Shots Faced (House)

Michigan State Shots Faced (House)

First Period

6

14

Second Period

9

10

Third Period

14

7

Overtime

6

6

TOTAL

35

37

Notes. Jake Barczewski started in net on Saturday night. He had a very nice stretch of play later on in the game, but did not have his best performance overall. While there was very little he could do on the first goal, he gave up a big rebound on the second goal that allowed Daniel Russell to find Isaac Howard for an open net goal. It may have been a tricky shot, but the rebound was very costly. The third goal should not have counted, but he did loose the puck in himself (to some degree) that did allow Jeremy Davidson to jam it in, post-whistle or not. The buzzer beater goal was also not great. It was a rocket, but it looked like he was just beaten. Then, the final goal he got the glove up and just missed it. To his credit though, Barczewski did play really, really well in the third period when Michigan wasn’t generating much. He made a number of unbelievable saves that kept the game going. He also made 2-3 Hero saves on cross-crease plays and on a breakaway. In the end, Michigan needed just bit better of a goalie performance to hoist a trophy.

ODD MAN RUSH CHART

Defense

Rushes

Advs

Escape%

Offense

Rushes

Advs

Scoring%

1st Period

1

1v0

100%

 

1

3v1

0%

2nd Period

n/a

n/a

n/a

 

2

1v0, 2v1

0%

3rd Period

2

3v2 x2

100%

 

1

3v2

0%

OT

n/a

n/a

n/a

 

n/a

n/a

n/a

Total

3

1v0, 3v2 x2

100%

 

4

1v0, 3v1, 2v1, 3v2

0%

Notes. Michigan State got an early breakaway after a botched end of power play by Jacob Truscott. Barczewski made a great save to deny the Spartans best rush chance. MSU also generated two more 3v2s in the third period, but neither came to much of a chance. Overall, Michigan was pretty good positionally all even to defense MSU’s rush chances.

The Wolverines did create a few chances in transition as well. After their first 3v1 was mismanaged, Josh Eernisse got a breakaway in the second period, but could not be Augustine. That was the best look Michigan got, as their final two OMRs were pretty nullified by the defenders protecting the House very well.

FINAL THOUGHTS

Michigan definitely played well enough to win on Saturday night. If the Brindley goal counts, they probably do win. If the third State goal doesn’t count, they probably win. If the fourth State goal is a second later, they could easily win. However, none of those things happened, and they could not over come them. They needed better in net. They certainly will if they’re to win any games next weekend. Right now, it looks like they’ll be the #3 seed playing the North Dakota Fighting Sioux. Will they be in St Louis, MO or Springfield, MA? Probably St Louis, but it could be either. Their #1 seed looks like it will be either the Boston University Terriers or the same MSU Spartans. Tune in Sunday evening at 6:30pm on ESPNU/ESPN+ to find out for sure.

Comments

Mr. Robot

March 24th, 2024 at 12:33 AM ^

I'm just done with getting fucked on goal reviews in every big game we have. The assholes on the ice making these decisions need to start defending them publicly instead of hiding behind "judgement calls". I hope they burned in an East Lansing couch fire after the game and can never skate again.

Honker Burger

March 24th, 2024 at 9:59 AM ^

Sparty's 3rd 'goal' was unfathomable. I've NEVER seen that be called a goal, when the original call on the ice was no goal.

1. The puck was under Barzo for several seconds. This should have been blown dead. Refs sometimes let play continue, so this one is the only part of the play that can be debated.

2. The whistle was blown before the puck crossed the line. The whistle being blown is not the definitive end, the rule specifically states the play is dead 'when the ref intends to blow the whistle.' Even so, on replay, it's clear the whistle blows the play dead prior to the puck crossing the line- or at worst, you can't see where the puck is.

3. You cannot push a goalie's pad that is covering the puck into the goal resulting in a goal.

Bad calls happen, it's sports. But this one is the biggest home cooking bullshit in a long time. It's a shame because that was a really exciting hockey game between two really good teams. Why in 2024, are reviews not centralized to the B1G office? It would still probably suck, but at least there would be one person consistently calling the shots, compared to different officials trying to make sense of a review in-arena, on a tiny screen.

lhglrkwg

March 24th, 2024 at 11:50 AM ^

Bad calls that happen live are understandable. A bad video review that overturned the call on the ice is insane. How do you make that call. The puck was under Barzo's pad AND the whistle had blown? It's so bad that I can't even go Spartan Bob about it. The Big Ten officials are just that bad and it happens week in and week out

Packer487

March 24th, 2024 at 3:18 PM ^

The only thing I could think of was that they had an angle that showed the initial shot in the net when Barzo moved his legs back. But then they gave the goal to the guy who crashed the net and poked it in after the whistle, so, no. 

Now the only explanation I can come up with is that they reviewed it solely for "was the puck in the net" and didn't consider "Hey I blew the whistle. Did I blow the whistle before the puck went in?" and Nar would have needed to challenge that. Which would be stupid, but knowing this conference I wouldn't put it past em. 

It's also sweet that that was an automatic review, but ours would have required a challenge a minute into the game, which would have meant that we couldn't challenge any of the other Big Ten BS the rest of the game without risking a penalty. 

AWAS

March 24th, 2024 at 1:11 AM ^

Giving up 4 goals on 15 shots won't get it done. We never recovered from that awful goal at the end if the second period. 

bronxblue

March 24th, 2024 at 6:53 AM ^

Yeah, Barzo wasn't great but I thought he played equal to Augustine.  He officially gave up 5 goals but as we've noted here 1 has never been allowed according to any rules of hockey ever played, and even the one with under a second to play was a bit wonky and could have easily been overturned.  Augustine gave up 4 and it should have been 5, and he's supposed to be one of the best goalies in the country.

UM needs better goaltending in general but tonight he gave at least as good a performance as Augustine and if the refs called the game correctly UM wins going away.

I said this in the live thread but I can't wait for UM to play games not officiated by the shitty refs in this league.  I'm sure they suck elsewhere but this has been just a banner year of stupidity for this conference and these past couple weekends we've seen UM be on the wrong end of some terrible calls that could have/did cost them games.

Packer487

March 24th, 2024 at 3:16 PM ^

Augustine gets way too much love for his actual performance this season. He has an insanely high ceiling, he's going to be a stud for them next year, and he definitely won some games for them this year, but he has like a 3.53 goals against vs tournament teams this year. I think Barzo is like 3.37.

He got most outstanding player in the BTT for beating a mid OSU team and getting kind of shelled by us? It's a little weird. 

smotheringD

March 24th, 2024 at 6:53 AM ^

When my son played AAA, the officiating was blatantly biased when we traveled to Chicago to play Team Illinois.  It got so bad one year, that to stay in the League, TI had to bring in referees from out of state to officiate their games.

ShoelacesFlapp…

March 24th, 2024 at 7:57 AM ^

We’re stuck with the Big 10 in football, but I would love for us to ditch them in hockey and join the NCHC. The conference clearly hates us and tries to screw us at every possible opportunity. 

lhglrkwg

March 24th, 2024 at 8:36 AM ^

idk. I was invested in the game after it, but the absolutely incompetent refs calling MSUs 3rd “goal” a good one after *video review* really just made me feel like what are we doing here when the officials are this bad. Michigan should be on the phone with the league office but they wont do anything about it because its the Big Ten

Stuntrooster

March 24th, 2024 at 8:54 AM ^

I try pretty hard not to point my finger at the refs, but after seeing yesterdays game, and some of the bs calls going on in the NCAA hoops tournament, it’s really getting frustrating to see so many missed calls that are easily observable for me sitting and watching on the couch.

DennisFranklinDaMan

March 24th, 2024 at 9:25 AM ^

Eh. Every fan base in the world complains about calls and insists that the referees conspire against them when their team loses. (See also: Ohio State on the Roman Wilson TD this year). It's absurd to believe that a team that's won back-to-back Big Ten Championships and lost the third in OT on the road is playing against a stacked deck.

The breaks definitely went against Michigan in this game (though I have no idea why Naurato didn't challenge the goalie interference call), but we also had real chances to win it. Seemed to me that MSU had more energy and was playing with a lot more fire down the stretch (as the shots-on-goal reflect) — that's a hell of a team.

Onwards. Let's meet them again in the Frozen Four and crush them. :-)

ChampsoftheWest

March 24th, 2024 at 10:14 AM ^

Is it just me, or does it seem like our team doesn’t try to block shots with their body? Sparty did this several times throughout the game, where I seemed to notice on a few occasions that we just tried for a stick breakup. Call it “toughness” or whatever, but I’m curious if this is just the way we’ve been playing all year.

Blueisgood

March 24th, 2024 at 11:59 AM ^

Michigan never seems to recruit "that" goalie. One that a team can put on his back. Almost always they have the firepower to outscore any one, or a pretty good defense, but not a goalie who can steal the show night in and night out. I'm not saying they've never had it, but it seems to be rare.

sambora114

March 24th, 2024 at 12:43 PM ^

Outstanding game

Transition year for Michigan hockey and they played great down the stretch. 10 spot in Pairwise feels about right for the team. Less injuries and some puck luck and they could content for Big Ten regular season title and 1 seed.

Hope they find a way to get to the Frozen Four and BU, BC, Denver, and Michigan State do not. That's a lot of luck needed but Michigan almost certainly will need to beat one of the aforementioned to make it to Minneapolis.

Thanks David for the coverage

Don

March 24th, 2024 at 1:03 PM ^

There can’t be another program in the country that has lost as many big games in OT as Michigan has, going back to 1977. The ways we’ve lost are various and sundry, but It’s fucking painful nevertheless.

Bando Calrissian

March 25th, 2024 at 11:21 AM ^

I was thinking about this yesterday: Since UM won two (very overdue) championships in three years more than a quarter century ago, it feels like every single thing in both the cosmic universe and college hockey has conspired against that ever happening again.

Looking at the bracket and seeing NoDak followed by that potential MSU quarterfinal, as The Giant once said, "it is happening again."